Phantom of Hogwarts
Good_Witch1,533 Reviews | 7.33/10 (1,533 Ratings, 0 Likes, 788 Favorites )
*NOW COMPLETE* How in the world does Hogwarts come to be doing a performance of The Phantom of the Opera? And just why is Snape so pissed about it?
Start ReadingChapters (84)
About Good_Witch
Author
Good_Witch
Member Since 2005 | 17 Stories | Favorited by 360 | 32 Reviews Written | 2,096 Review Responses
I have completed my Master's of Science degree in Marriage and Family Therapy and want to focus on serving the LGBTQIA community and the Alt/Kink/Poly communities in my work. I used to be a poker tournament director and floorperson at the world famous Binion's Gambling Hall in downtown Las Vegas. Before that, I was high school Spanish and Theatre teacher. I am happily married and (thankfully) have NO kids. I have an original short story published here: http://www.elm-books.com/ProductDetails.asp?ProductCode=R01%2DChristmasBadGirls under my penname, Jess Alynn. Thanks for taking a chance and reading my stories! :)
Oh, and check out the "trailer" for Phantom of Hogwarts that xtahsee made for me on youtube! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k63yCE9sslY
Reviews for Phantom of Hogwarts
Let me begin by apologizing for not reviewing the previous chapters, but I must tell you that "Phantom of Hogwarts" is such a compelling love story that I could not stop myself from racing from one chapter to the next since I began reading! Nearly every minute that I could spend has been devoted to catching up. I wish I could remember who it was that recommended your story so that I could thank them.I love everything about your tale, and your description of the growing love between Severus and Hermione has touched my heart. Witnessing the evolution of Severus Snape, bat of the dungeons, to Severus Snape, consummate lover, has been a delightful journey. I look forward to this continuing story of discovery. I was very happy when Severus finally came to the point that he bloody well didn't give a tinker's damn what Dumbledore might think if he found out about his love for Hermione. Well done, Good_Witch! I'll be waiting for the next update with eager anticipation!!!Regards, Beth
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
*blink blink* Wow! *beams* You just made my day! *sniffle* It warms the cockles of my heart to see that someone enjoys my labour of love so much. Thank you so much for your kind words. :)
Dear Lord, you did it again. Another cliffie! I loved this chapter. Very hot. I really liked how Hermione confronted Severus on his double standards, and his reaction. And I really hope you're going to finish this in the next chapter. You can't just leave me hanging like that!
Alright, back to foaming at the mouth while waiting for an update.
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
Yes, it was another cliffie, but not nearly as evil as the last one! LOL As for Hermione confronting him on double standards, it just seems to me like a REALLY Hermione thing to do. The next chapter will pick up right where this one left off, so don't worry! *snicker* Glad you enjoyed this chapter too, and thanks so much for reviewing! :)
Yay! Very good chapter, enjoyed it muchos! Can't wait for the next one to find out what happens when Snape finds Hermionie... 
Post the next chapter ASAP!
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
Aww, thanks! *beams* Yeah, it should be rather a shock for him to find her that way... *snerk* Thanks so much for reviewing! :)
I know I've told you this before, but I really do love this story! Are there not other apothacaries in Britain that Severus could apply to, or could he and Hermione set up their own? I can't wait til the actual performances. Are you going to fully describe the Beauxbatons and Durmstrang performances too? Do you not think that Les Mis could also be done at Hogwarts, but as a HG/SS tragedy with Hermione as Eponine, although admittedly the other characters would not suit the HP characters a well. Sorry, too many questions! I really hope you update soon. C
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
*blush* Awww, you make me happy! I don't think I'll inflict the excruciating details of the other performances on everyone. We're over half a million words already. LOL!! I'm glad you're enjoying it so much, and thanks again for reviewing :)
Wonderful as always, dear. I know I've forgotten to review the last couple of chapters, for which I heartily apologise (I blame my brain). I love your detailed descriptions of the sets and the acting as much as the character-based stuff, so I particularly liked this chapter.I also really liked the fact that Hermione is uncomfortable with alcohol - I'm in my early twenties and I don't drink, and I sometimes get the impression that my friends think I'm a prude or something, just because I want to have fun without being off my head. Thank you for giving the message that alcohol doesn't have to be a part of life, if you know what I mean. ;)
So, yes, lovely chapter, evil cliffie, looking forward to the next installment!
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
Yeah, that was my personal agenda creeping in there. I am in my 30s and I can't stand alcohol. And, like I said in a reply to a previous review, I'm tired of alcohol being used as a tool to incite action or lower inhibitions. *shrug* I used to be REALLY vehement about it, and would get almost sick with stress if I was around it, but as I grew up, I managed to get that knee-jerk reaction under control and accept that everyone can make their own choices. Considering my feelings on the subject, it was actually kind of hard writing the scene with Snape and the firewhisky! LOL
As for the rest of the chapter: I'm glad I managed to get through several days this time. LOL!! And I'm glad you're still enjoying it. Thanks as always for reviewing! :)
I have read up to this chapter and thought I would leave you another reveiw. I can't stop reading this story. I only have so much time everyday and I have to get my fix. This is beautifully written story and I will be recommending it to several of my friends who are also SS/HG shippers. I can't wait to see what happens next. Will Severus be able to keep a level head around Hermione or will she tempt him too much?Thank you for writing this story.
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
*blush* Wow! I'm so glad you're enjoying it. *beams* And reccing it to others? Thank you!!! :D Thanks so much for reviewing! :)
I hope more is coming very soon! I was so hoping he would incorporate his proposal into the play! I can't wait to read more!
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
Was working on it again just last night, actually. :) Over 9000 words in now. Glad you enjoyed it, and thanks as always for reviewing! ;)
Response from Merlina Thalia (Reviewer)
Ooooh. That's enough, post the chapter! lol jk
You can't stop there! lolCan someone (eg Ginny) just take Colin away and have a quiet word... or alternatively borrow Snape's fireball thing 
I love it!
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
LOL!! Well, as of right now, Ron's the only one who witnessed the whole Colin thing (witnessed, hell, more like spurred it on! *sigh* Poor oblivious Ron), so Ginny doesn't know to step in and play bodyguard. *has images of Ginny weilding that pike through Hogwarts halls, and prolly enjoying it far too much* Glad you're enjoying it, and thanks so much for reviewing! :)
A wonderful chapter! Fern was a delight. Those two working together would be quite entertaining! LOL I felt sorry for Hermione's mum ... she didn't realize she had gone a bit over the top (or a lot) when it came to Snape. Hermione almost tipped her hand with her anger, though. I'm sure her reaction will come back to mind when their relationship goes public. Durmstrang looks like competition. I love how you had McGonagall be the one looking for rule breakers and Severus being the voice of reason by reminding them to focus on their own performance. In fanfic, we usually see it the other way 'round. I look forward to more--your updates are always worth the wait!
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
I daresay a LOT of things will come rushing back to a lot of people when they finally go public. And much will suddenly make sense. *snerk* Glad you enjoyed it, and thanks as always for reviewing! :)
Just thought I'd drop by and leave my two Knuts...enjoying as always! Eager for more, but you already knew that! :)~HR
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
Aww, thank you darlin! *hugs and chocolate* I'm actually off tomorrow, so I MIGHT be able to try the next chapter (work has been BUSY this week!) :)
oh, now that's a surprise that'll give our poor sevy heart failure. with any luck he'll take it as it is and not as an affront to his masculinity. 
you're updates never fail to bring a smile, and we wait on pins and needles for the next installment. good job with your story.
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
*splutter* "poor sevy" indeed! ROFL!!!!! Awww, you're sweet. I'm glad you're still enjoying it, and thanks so much for reviewing! :)
OMG.....I LOVE IT!!!! WOW IS HE IN FOR A SURPRISE WHEN HE GETS TO HER ROOM!!! Great chapter!!!! And my goodness what has Colin got up his sleeve?? He is trouble with a capital T.......Can't wait for the next chapter!!!
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
Ah, I knew it wouldn't be long before I saw a post from you, my dear
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
. *beams* LOL Yeah, it'll be... interesting... when Snape arrives this time. And Colin is still trying my patience. Ah well, we'll see what happens! Thanks as always for reviewing. :)
I really like this story - I've never seen Phantom but you obviously know it very well. I am though a bit concerned about Hermione's character - she's still a virgin at eighteen and is intending to keep her virginity for the man she intends to spend the rest of her life with. She also has problems with nudity, her sexuality and has a very odd attitude to drink - was her father an alcoholic? With her background she would have been brought up in a house where wine on the table would be an everyday occurrance. I find her prudery very strange and rather disturbing. I find myself asking if she is mature enough for a relationship with Severus as an equal or is she looking for a father figure. All that aside, I'm looking forward to some on stage snogging in the near future.
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
"Onstage snogging"--LOL!!! As for Hermione, she's growing up, in pretty much every aspect. As for the alcohol, I admit, that's my own agenda. I was tired of seeing stories where teenagers drink (even though they're "adults") and where alcohol is used as a tool to further actions between a couple. As for her intending to keep her viriginity--she's been pushing the envelope, but Snape's been the one stopping. :) We're going to see a lot of topics discussed soon, not the least of which is her emerging sexuality. Thank you so much for such a thoughtful review. I love those! :)
Response from melusin (Reviewer)
Thanks for your reply. I agree that alcohol is far too convenient a plot device to get two people together and underage binge drinking in Britain (under 18 that is) is a big problem. However, I just had this vision of Severus taking her out to dinner after she leaves school and asking 'what about some champagne' and Hermione replying 'no thanks I'd rather have a chocolate milkshake.' He's going to feel like a child molester.
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
And that's why I wanted the issue to come up early, so that wouldn't happen. Now that he knows she wouldn't want it, there's no need to even ask. I'm 31, and I've hated alcohol all my life, and my friends and loved ones know that. So, they're very considerate around me: knowing there's no point in offering, and not going overboard around me. It's not like I'm going to go off on a diatribe if my husband wants a beer every once in a while--I know everyone makes their own choices--but he knows that I wouldn't be into going to an event or anything where the sole purpose is to get drunk (which, unfortunately, seems to be the case at so many parties/clubs). I got lucky in that he doesn't care to "get drunk" or be around people who are doing so either. :) I'm so glad you replied, as I welcome the chance to address why I write what I do. Thank you so much for a great opportunity! :)
Response from melusin (Reviewer)
Thanks for making your views clear. It makes sense now why the characters are acting the way they do.
Oh, my! Evil cliffie... And they finally got some "quality time" (not that I think they should have done earlier, your timeline is very good)I love it! 
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
Yeah, those evil cliffies just seem to keep popping up. *snerk* As for my timeline... I seriously have a calendar marked with what happens when, so I can keep track of things and try to aim for plausibility (I know I'm already stretching the suspension of disbelief with the premise to begin with, LOL). So glad you enjoyed it, and thanks for reviewing! :)
I started reading this a few nights ago and have finally caught up, what a fantastic story and this is from someone who can't stand musicals! Looking forward to your next update.
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
LOL!! I'm so glad you've enjoyed it so far. Thank you so much for reviweing! :)
*argh!* Don't kill you? DON'T KILL YOU??!!
ROFL! Aw, come on...type fast!!
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
*snicker* I'm working on it, really! I'm already 11 pages into the next chapter, ask Lotm! Thanks for reviewing! :)
Oh my! That's a masterpiece :D
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
*beams* Why, thank you! I'm glad you enjoyed it. Thanks so much for reviewing! :)
Severus and a shower. Never fails to get my juices flowing! I'll bet Sev was fairly wetting himself when Minerva called to see him. Silly old bat! If she'd have been more into potions she would have smelled Hermione all over him! Looking forward to the next installment. Thanks for the ride.....xxx
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
*snigger* Yes, well, he may be venturing into new things, so why not a new scent? (At least that's how he could explain anything to McG... LOL) Thanks so much for reviewing! :)
Okay, I've gotten used to waiting your chapters at least a month so this took me by surprise to see a new chappy here. Anyway...What are those two? Rabbits? They already had an exhausting night together and they'd be ready for round 2 already in the morning. Phew. Wow! Minerva comes to rescue! Good witch that Minerva. Really looking forward what will happen.
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
ROFL!! Haven't you ever been in that we-can't-shag-enough-or-get-enough-of-each-other stage in a relationship? I remember it quite well with my hubby. *wicked grin* Hey, I write what I know from experience as much as possible... *snerk* As for Minerva, I'm sure Snape will use her as an ally for as long as he can. Thanks as always for reviewing! :)
Woo!!!!! I've been gone for so long, and what a great chapter to come back and find in my in-box! Thank you so much! You are forgiven for the mildly evil ending.
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
LOL *whew* I'm glad at least someone forgives me. ;) Thanks so much for reviewing! :)
The perfect timing for the proposal with all that had gone before and the similarities between their "RL" characters and stage personae. :)
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
*beams* I'm glad you enjoyed it. Thanks so much for reviewing! :)
What a way to propose. I must say your right about ending the chapter there. I think this is where Dumbledore needs to 'prove it'.
I look forward to more.
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
*nods sagely* I think you're right *shifty eyes* LOL Thanks so much for reviewing! :)
YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
*blink blink* Um, darlin? Let me introduce you to this new-fangled contraption called a spacebar... ;)
Response from serenifly_phantom (Reviewer)
where's the fun in that?
I get very excited whenever I see a new chapter of this story. Thanks.
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
*blush* Awww, thank you! I'm glad you enjoy it. Thanks so much for reviewing! :)
Oooh! Steamily snogging Snape on the stone floor, felling him with her fervidness... such an inspiring story. Makes me want to go write...
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
ROFL!!! Well then, succumb to the inspiration and go write, woman! :D I do hope that means you're still enjoying it... Thanks for reviewing, and for making me a validated author, and for putting my fic up on your Featured Stories, and oh, for having this awesome site! :)
notsosaintly's response: But OF COURSE I am still enjoying the story!! And you are welcome, although I should be thanking you. It is great authors like you who help make this site what it is.