Phantom of Hogwarts
Good_Witch1,533 Reviews | 7.33/10 (1,533 Ratings, 0 Likes, 788 Favorites )
*NOW COMPLETE* How in the world does Hogwarts come to be doing a performance of The Phantom of the Opera? And just why is Snape so pissed about it?
Start ReadingChapters (84)
About Good_Witch
Author
Good_Witch
Member Since 2005 | 17 Stories | Favorited by 360 | 32 Reviews Written | 2,096 Review Responses
I have completed my Master's of Science degree in Marriage and Family Therapy and want to focus on serving the LGBTQIA community and the Alt/Kink/Poly communities in my work. I used to be a poker tournament director and floorperson at the world famous Binion's Gambling Hall in downtown Las Vegas. Before that, I was high school Spanish and Theatre teacher. I am happily married and (thankfully) have NO kids. I have an original short story published here: http://www.elm-books.com/ProductDetails.asp?ProductCode=R01%2DChristmasBadGirls under my penname, Jess Alynn. Thanks for taking a chance and reading my stories! :)
Oh, and check out the "trailer" for Phantom of Hogwarts that xtahsee made for me on youtube! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k63yCE9sslY
Reviews for Phantom of Hogwarts
WOW you just made me fall in LURV all over again. Now there is a new reason to love the phantom. as always my dear you did a wonderful job.
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
*blush* Aww, you're so sweet. Glad you're still enjoying it. And thanks as always for reviewing! :)
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
*blush* Aww, you're so sweet. Glad you're still enjoying it. And thanks as always for reviewing! :)
It always feels like christmas when i see a new chapter!
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
LOL!! You always make me feel so happy with such lovely reviews! Thanks for the continued support! :)
Response from chyara (Reviewer)
I dearly love this fic. Any idea on how many chapters are left?hugs to you and your muse. (slipping your muse some chocolate to keep her happy)
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
Not a clue. However many it ends up needing to finish the journey (I'm not being intentionally obstructive, I swear!), but I daresay we're closer to the end than the middle. LOL Thanks for the hugs and chocolate! ;)
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
LOL!! You always make me feel so happy with such lovely reviews! Thanks for the continued support! :)
Response from chyara (Reviewer)
I dearly love this fic. Any idea on how many chapters are left?hugs to you and your muse. (slipping your muse some chocolate to keep her happy)
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
Not a clue. However many it ends up needing to finish the journey (I'm not being intentionally obstructive, I swear!), but I daresay we're closer to the end than the middle. LOL Thanks for the hugs and chocolate! ;)
Wow. I bet you feel relieved now after having the final performance huh? Lol. Of course you do. It was phenomenal, emotional and I can't tell you how much I love this story. Each chapter is a treasure. I'm really enjoying the way you're progressing Hermione and Snape's relationship and how you're making it plausible for them to be out in the open one day and actually accepted. Brilliant work.
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
Of course I do! LOL It makes me so happy that not only are you enjoying it, but you find the build-up and progress of their relationship plausible. I strive so much to keep things believable. Thank you for such a lovely review! :)
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
Of course I do! LOL It makes me so happy that not only are you enjoying it, but you find the build-up and progress of their relationship plausible. I strive so much to keep things believable. Thank you for such a lovely review! :)
As usual I am trilled to see an update to this marvellous story. Your description of their performance makes me want to look for plane-tickets to London, they are showing the "Phantom of the Opera" there:-)Absolutely excellent work!!!!
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
You and me both, darlin. *wishes for tickets to London and to PotO there* Glad you liked it, and thanks so much for reviewing! :)
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
You and me both, darlin. *wishes for tickets to London and to PotO there* Glad you liked it, and thanks so much for reviewing! :)
*sighs* So brilliant. So utterly, fucking brilliant. What a performance! I relived watching it. Are they gonna win, then? Is it gonna be a happy ending, then? Yeah, I know. Colour me curious.
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
LOL!! You're curious, indeed. But remember, I'm a sucker for happy endings, no matter how angsty things get along the way. *snerk* I'm so glad the "performance of a lifetime" came through and wasn't repetitive, considering how many times I've detailed scenes in rehearsals already! *rolls eyes* Thanks as always for reviewing! :)
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
LOL!! You're curious, indeed. But remember, I'm a sucker for happy endings, no matter how angsty things get along the way. *snerk* I'm so glad the "performance of a lifetime" came through and wasn't repetitive, considering how many times I've detailed scenes in rehearsals already! *rolls eyes* Thanks as always for reviewing! :)
*purrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrpurrpurrpurrpurrkneadkneadpurrrrrrrrrrrrrr...*~Lotm
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
*grin*
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
*grin*
That was brilliant! Thanks so much. I absolutely love this story; it's made me love the Phantom of the Opera so much more and inspired me to go see it live in London. I can't wait for more, especially everybody's reactions when Hermione and Severus relationship is revealed. Keep up the good work. Zoë
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
*sucks in an envious breath* You saw it in London? Lucky, lucky you! *turns delicate shade of green* I'm glad you're enjoying it, and thanks so much for reviewing! :)
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
*sucks in an envious breath* You saw it in London? Lucky, lucky you! *turns delicate shade of green* I'm glad you're enjoying it, and thanks so much for reviewing! :)
This story is one of my favorites; seeing that there was a new chapter made my day! Looking forward to seeing what happens next.
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
Aww, thank you! Glad you're still enjoying it, and thanks so much for reviewing! :)
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
Aww, thank you! Glad you're still enjoying it, and thanks so much for reviewing! :)
oh my gosh . . . oh my gosh . . . did they forget to remove their little display of affection during intermission? ack!
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
*huge grin* Deep breaths... ;) All will be revealed (unless we do'nt want things to be revealed, in which case, all will be kept under wraps). LOL Thanks so much for reviewing! :)
You know what's crazy? I had been thinking of writing a fic featuring Hogwarts performing a musical . . . I was trying to decide between Phantom and Les Miserables . . . I'm sure you would do a much better job at it than me, so I'm glad I stumbled across it. I look forward to reading it.
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
LOL!! Guess it wasn't such a crazy idea, eh? (Great minds think alike!) I do hope you enjoy it, and thanks for reviewing! :)
Eeep! Just came back from watching OotP... and here I find and update! Love the little moments when Hermione and Snape get carried away. Really well done!
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
*beams* Hiya! Glad to contribute to a hopefully fun-filled evening. LOL Thanks as always for reviewing! :)
OMG! This is adorable! It's really great fic, i can say you like a person, who'd read a lot of fics not only in English, but also in Russian . Yer idea is very interesting and yer style is terrific!
I know, that i've already asked you about it, but i'm doing it once again: could i ask yer permission to translate this fic into Russian? Please, give me yer answer, even if it would be negative!
Thank you for yer "Phantom" once again!
Julia
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
I'm glad you enjoyed it so much! If you want to translate something this long into Russian, I only ask that you send me the links to where you're posting it, and that you include my name and the links to my original postings in your posts on Russian sites. I know a couple of folks who already know Russian, so it would be fun to see how directly it can be translated! LOL Thanks so much for reviewing! :)
that was a beautifully written chapter! they couldn't have reacted anyway else. thanks so much
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
*blush* Aww, you just made my night! Glad you enjoyed it, and thanks so much for reviewing! :)
Another wonderful addition.I especially like how you are allowing Albus to see his mistakes rather than enacting retribution. I find the realization of a mistake through brutal but truthful communication more realistic and human than vengeance. So many stories go for some sort of, unrealistic, hurtful, and ultimately meaningless revenge. It's nice to see things handled as they are in the real world.Elen
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
*beams* I agree. The guilt and heaviness of spirit that one feels when they have internalized the fact that they have truly hurt someone they care about is often punishment/revenge enough. Thank you for such a great review! :)
Oh my, definitely worth the years and such an awesome epi for our couple!!! Thanks for sticking to it - I'd give you a standing ovation any day!!! *stands up clapping, hooting, whistling & hollerin'*
Seriously, you're on my faves list so I'll be looking out if you start another fic - but no pressure - I'm sure it's a relief to be out from under this one. Love your work!!!
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
*blush* Awww, you're so sweet! I'm so glad you enjoyed it all this time. Thank you, as always, for reviewing! :)
ABSOLUTELY FABULOUS!! rather hoping they would have had children :< but c'est la vie! bridal dress looks awesome, and described beautifully. i'm going to miss this story! T^T
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
*beams* Glad you liked the dress; I went looking for what I saw in my head and that was the closest I could find. LOL As for kids... well, I had to follow my heart on that score. I'm gonna miss writing this story too! Thanks for all your continued support all this time! :)
Good on the ol' cat for giving The Bearded Bastard a sound hissing at! I can't wait to see what happens next! 
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
ROFL!! Guess she's no "pussy"... *cringes* Sorry, that was a bad pun. ;) Glad you liked it, and thanks as always for reviewing! :)
Anonymous
Go Minerva!!! Woo hoo! She really told Dumbledore off! he is really being a git lately! Can't wait for your next update!! As always, 5 stars!!
Author's Response: *beams* Aww, you're so sweet! McGonagall is really getting a fan club now... LOL Thanks as always for reviewing! :)
Iam reallly eangoy read this chapter , and I can t stop smile at . This is verry veryy nise one.
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
*beams* I'm so glad you're enjoying it. Thanks so much for revieiwng! :)
yayness.....i is content.....C.U.N.T!!!!
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
*beams* Well, as long as you're content... *snerk* :)
YAY!!!!UPDATE!!!!! gonna read it now.....and i have your money ready but i probably wont see you till tuesday....reading time!!!
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
LOL NP Can't wait till Tuesday night!!! *flail* ;) What time do you figure your group will be getting there? :)
such a poetic ending...
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
*beams* I had hoped it would be a fitting close to the chapter. Thanks so much for reviewing! :)
Response from cflower (Reviewer)
Your welcome, but thank you for writing such a fabulous long story. My apologizes for not reviewing, I must admit to being bad at clicking the button. But I am always looking for updates, and love your story. I really enjoy the fact that the story has a plot without Voldemort. It really has a romantic feel, but is not PWP. In addition I enjoy your portrayal of a Hermione/Snape relationship. It is not overly mushy, and a good alternate universe piece; your Snape without the Voldemort. There are some many good Pre-final battle stories but it is always nice to read something lighter, but still real. (there is still angst and drama, but there is a focus on the lovely romance) I also love The Phantom of the Opera by the way. It was interesting because I always wanted to read the book, but never did till I started your story. I read several chapters and then I decided to read the Phantom before continuing. It was amazing (one of my favorites); I wish to see the play one day. Happy writing, and thank you for another sublime chapter; part of me wishes the story would never end.Best to youCarolyn
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
*blink blink* Wow. You just made me choke up. It warms the cockles of my heart to hear that my work has been such a positive to someone. *beams* I hope I don't let you down. :)
Wow, you must have ESP -- I just was looking at my "faves" (which, of course, PoH is on) and looking for a new chappy on the 4th! Amazing update, thank you!!!
I also think In Annulo could replace DH - easily - if JKR takes our beloved PM to a sour place! Although, depending on how it turns out I think PoH might take over that 7th year title! Yes, I love it that much - so far.
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
*jaw drops* Wow. Um, gee, I guess I better not drop the ball then, or I run the risk of losing being your fave. ;) So glad you're still enjoying it, and thanks so much for reviewing! :)
I wanted to read up till now before leaving a review and I must say: WOW!
This story is just awsome!
Characterisation is perfect.
The relationship, its progress and its problems are realistic.
It's funny and highly erotic!
And The Phantom of the Opera! The scene with Point of no return, and the one before, hmm.
And here I thought the movie was steamy! But then again there's no Snape in it, isn't it? 
At the beginning you had me wondering if Dumbledore wasn't trying to push them together. Now I'm not so sure.
I just hope they won't get caught before Graduation. Both of them deserve it to be brought into the open on their own terms and not because they were caught in flagranti (or how far they got anyway 
). Snape's too much the spy still for that to happen, I hope.
Anyway keep up the good work and don't make us contemplate violence till your next update! 
bye
Shal
P.S. I think I'm going to blow an artery at the thought that this is your first story.
I'm trying to post my first (archive-worthy) story here on PP but it's nowhere near as good as yours.
P.P.S. Oh, how I love those emoticons! Can you tell?
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
um... WOW! *gasp, falls over, iz ded* LOL My smug beta-git is sitting by me laughing as I read this. She says she agrees with you, but I think she's biased. *snerk* Anyway, THANK YOU! for such praise and compliments. I'm overwhelmed. (But it made me grin REALLLLL big.) So glad you are enjoying it, and I AM working on it (the beta-git can vouch for that), although I have been more along the lines of scribbling notes than TYPING since she's been here... yeah, that's it, blame her... JUST KIDDING!!!!!!!! Lotm has even been working while she's been here, so I have to take the blame myself. *self-flagellates* ..... or not.
Anyway, thanks for such an awesome review! :)
Response from shalimar1981 (Reviewer)
You're welcome!
And you better believe your beta and me because your story is fabulous! 
Oh dear, the scribbled notes! I'm color-coding my 22 note-pads at the moment to make sense of them (but they're tiny).
Typing is way better and quicker. *hint, hint*
So, I'm waiting....
Shal
I love it.
Response from Good_Witch (Author of Phantom of Hogwarts)
LOL!! This was definitely one of my favourite chapters to write. ;) Thanks for reviewing! :)