New Chapter for Death's Dominion
Death's Dominion
MMADfan559 Reviews | 6.1/10 (559 Ratings, 0 Likes, 207 Favorites )
Severus Snape’s life was changed when he was hit by an errant spell, and he comes to a decision that defies Dumbledore’s wishes. Even the fate of the wizarding world is altered by this one ill-cast curse and Snape’s subsequent resolve. Long after the spell itself has dissipated, its effects continue echoing in the lives of Severus, Albus, Minerva, and Hermione, and they bring with them a shadowy figure whom Snape does not trust and whose motivations and influence on Minerva are murky. Conspiracies and schemes swirl around Severus as he continues on his path of deception to his final confrontation with the Dark Lord.
Canon-divergent post-July 1996 in the HP universe. Not DH-compliant. (Partially HBP-compliant.)
A “Light” fic of love, loyalty, and redemption.
Pertinent warnings in individual chapter summaries.
Voted First Place, Gen Fic: Best Legacy Story, in the HP Fanfic Fan Poll Awards for Spring/Summer 2013.
Chapters (34)
About MMADfan
Author
MMADfan
41 Stories | Favorited by 312 | 127 Reviews Written | 4,741 Review Responses
Note 10 December 2015: I've been unable to write fanfic the last couple years, but I haven't abandoned my works-in-progress!
Many of my completed fics are available for download in ebook format through my blog and LJ.
Perfect Imagination accredited beta. PI:7311261659.
More about me here.
Reviews for Death's Dominion
Aesop's fables for passwords? I can just picture Severus rolling his eyes everytime he had to give the password when it was "ass." lol. Here, Minerva doesn't seem so stand offish with Severus, which I like. I also like the fact that she reminds him that he is worthy. Of course, he doesn't believe her and he makes that statement about "her and her shadow," but she still seems to humor him even though he keeps beating himself up. Grrr.This chapter made me feel better about Minerva, she wasn't so disant as she has been. YAY! I am still suspicious of Robbie, I also thought it was odd about his wife leaving him and such. Very interesting. The plot is getting thicker, time to stir the pot. I am also beginning to wonder about Severus' motives in all this. He is not following the plan, according to Minerva, yet he wants her to trust him. Hmm, I may have to revisit a few chapters. Alas, I must also go to bed. I look forward to the next chapters.Cheers, Stef
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
Yes, Minerva has eased up on Severus here. She certainly is in a good mood.Severus is just being Severus, whatever that may be! And he did get a nice pep talk from Minerva in this chapter, didn't he?Thanks for reviewing! I hope you enjoy the coming chapters!TTFN!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
Yes, Minerva has eased up on Severus here. She certainly is in a good mood.Severus is just being Severus, whatever that may be! And he did get a nice pep talk from Minerva in this chapter, didn't he?Thanks for reviewing! I hope you enjoy the coming chapters!TTFN!
I am very surprised that Severus told Hermione all that he did. There has to be a point to it. I found it nice that they were both so comfortable in each others presence. Almost too comfortable.It is so very rare for Severus and Moody to agree on ANYTHING! But they are both suspicious of Robbie? Go figure. I thought it was awfully nice how Robbie takes care of Minerva, with the tea and everything.Then in the library, GREAT MERLIN'S GHOST! What the... ? Even though I know this is Severus' POV, it does seem that Minerva accepts Robbie's advances. And then she calls out Albus' name? Goodness! Something is going on... something isn't right about Robbie. I guess I share my suspicions with Moody and Severus but probably for different reasons.,Stef
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
Yeah, not good to identify with Moody and Severus in this particular instance -- though you are not wrong to be suspicious!Severus and Hermione are comfy with each other, aren't they? Particularly Hermione. Probably left over from their being "co-conspirators" in An Act of Love -- that changed a lot of things. And what Severus told Hermione was more than had been planned on for her to know at that time, and he was fairly communicative with her, but he didn't reveal very much of himself here, really. Just a little.Thanks! (And I like your little pom-pom girls!)
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
Yeah, not good to identify with Moody and Severus in this particular instance -- though you are not wrong to be suspicious!Severus and Hermione are comfy with each other, aren't they? Particularly Hermione. Probably left over from their being "co-conspirators" in An Act of Love -- that changed a lot of things. And what Severus told Hermione was more than had been planned on for her to know at that time, and he was fairly communicative with her, but he didn't reveal very much of himself here, really. Just a little.Thanks! (And I like your little pom-pom girls!)
Great conversation at the start of the chapter between Minerva & Severus. And I think Minerva can be more ruthless than he thinks. As ruthless as she must be. I think she fully understands how difficult it is to bring death and suffering to others and still bear the full emotional burden of knowing herself responsible. Yes, she definitely has mettle.Your Poppy has officially won my heart. So often she is portrayed as a stereotype - the shrill, bossy, overbearing nurse, kicking visitors out of the hospital wing and spoiling people's fun. But this Poppy is able to be both strong and caring, balancing professional distance with compassion, and putting the suffering of others before her own needs.I was really puzzled by Severus' exchange with Remus, as he had begun to see beyond his own prejudices and had stopped being needlessly nasty. But his subsequent reflections on his own father and the burdens a werewolf's child will have to bear switched on the light for me. Well done, you manipulative author, you!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
Well done, you manipulative author, you!Heheheheh! Er, I mean, .I am very glad you like my Poppy. Thank you! That scene, to me, is one of the essential ones, and not so much for any particular plot point it reveals as for its portrayal of the characters and the ties among people. Way back in RaM, you'll remember that Minerva's mother's seal had the motto, "To Comfort Enough to Bring Forth Healing," and Minerva scoffs slightly at the motto, but her mother says that true healing does require compassion, or something of the sort. Anyway, this is a bit of that theme.As for Minerva, I think you are right and that she can be as ruthless as she needs to be, and quite self-aware as she is, whatever Severus may think. Severus recognizes her mettle here when they talk about maintaining a cool facade in the face of something horrific -- and this is progress from his view of her at the beginning of the story, where he felt that she could allow her emotions to sway her too much -- so he is beginning to recognize more of her depths and strengths now that she must exercise them and he is in a position to see them. Severus saw himself as straightening Remus out -- you see that in his conversation with Minerva. He simply doesn't have much experience in doing that in anything other than a nasty way, not to mention his own emotional reaction to drunkenness and drunken fathers.Thanks for reviewing! I'm glad you enjoyed the chapter!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
Well done, you manipulative author, you!Heheheheh! Er, I mean, .I am very glad you like my Poppy. Thank you! That scene, to me, is one of the essential ones, and not so much for any particular plot point it reveals as for its portrayal of the characters and the ties among people. Way back in RaM, you'll remember that Minerva's mother's seal had the motto, "To Comfort Enough to Bring Forth Healing," and Minerva scoffs slightly at the motto, but her mother says that true healing does require compassion, or something of the sort. Anyway, this is a bit of that theme.As for Minerva, I think you are right and that she can be as ruthless as she needs to be, and quite self-aware as she is, whatever Severus may think. Severus recognizes her mettle here when they talk about maintaining a cool facade in the face of something horrific -- and this is progress from his view of her at the beginning of the story, where he felt that she could allow her emotions to sway her too much -- so he is beginning to recognize more of her depths and strengths now that she must exercise them and he is in a position to see them. Severus saw himself as straightening Remus out -- you see that in his conversation with Minerva. He simply doesn't have much experience in doing that in anything other than a nasty way, not to mention his own emotional reaction to drunkenness and drunken fathers.Thanks for reviewing! I'm glad you enjoyed the chapter!
Goodness, that was a rollercoaster ride of a chapter! I didn't know whether to laugh or cry at Severus' hysterics, then intoxicated goofiness. And I'm so pleased that Harry is showing some maturity, able to recognise a different sort of courage than mere recklessness, and to wish to emulate it. I wasn't entirely clear, but was Severus able to do as Gareth suggested, and find forgiveness for Moody? I hope so.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
He didn't find forgiveness for Moody -- and remember what Gareth said about forgiveness, that he couldn't forgive certain things, but that he could accept an apology and move on, and maybe come to find that he managed to forgive somewhere along the way. Severus didn't even *quite* manage to accept the apology, but he came as close to it as possible: he restrained his vindictiveness and desire for revenge, and he's going to try to let Moody go on from there and prove himself better than he was in the moment in which he cursed him; at the same time, Severus did manage to rise above himself and his usual habitual reactions. He restrained himself and felt the desire to be more and better.I thought the Peaced-out Severus provided a little light relief for the reader as well as for poor Severus. It is poignant -- and both amusing and sad, simultaneously.Harry has come a long way in a year. Coming to certain realizations about himself and his presumed fate have helped him.I'm glad you liked the chapter! Thanks for the review!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
He didn't find forgiveness for Moody -- and remember what Gareth said about forgiveness, that he couldn't forgive certain things, but that he could accept an apology and move on, and maybe come to find that he managed to forgive somewhere along the way. Severus didn't even *quite* manage to accept the apology, but he came as close to it as possible: he restrained his vindictiveness and desire for revenge, and he's going to try to let Moody go on from there and prove himself better than he was in the moment in which he cursed him; at the same time, Severus did manage to rise above himself and his usual habitual reactions. He restrained himself and felt the desire to be more and better.I thought the Peaced-out Severus provided a little light relief for the reader as well as for poor Severus. It is poignant -- and both amusing and sad, simultaneously.Harry has come a long way in a year. Coming to certain realizations about himself and his presumed fate have helped him.I'm glad you liked the chapter! Thanks for the review!
Okay, this is Stef in angry mob form... Malcolm is dead???? And Gertie is permanently injured... by Severus? I don't know about this. Robbie does make me think of Gertie in his mannerisms, too. I can see what you said about Minerva's treatment of Severus. And I got this creepy feeling when Severus realized he was the Death Eater Robbie was talking about. I am thinking he doesn't know Severus was the one. That could be bad.I realized that they used the fact that Harry doesn't trust Severus to drive him away from the school. I believe, Harry may think Severus was giving him detention to appease a request from the Dark Lord. Or is that too far fetched? I do like how you are keeping elements of DH in the story as well. I am going to be brave and continue, though I am worried, I trust you. Constant Vigilance! heh.Cheers,Stef
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
Yes, trust me! And Malcolm is my absolutely all-time favorite RaM character -- you have no idea the anguish I went through before I bit the bullet and let him have his heroic death in the first war.Oh, yes, Robert knows it was Severus. And Severus knows that Robert knows that it was he. And Robert knows Severus knows that Robert knows -- and so forth!Harry can just as easily believe that Severus is just being a nasty git. Harry isn't very subtle. Just have faith in Chapter Six! Do not lose faith in MMADfan or in MMADfan's depiction of Minerva! Remember POV is vital!Thanks for the review!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
Yes, trust me! And Malcolm is my absolutely all-time favorite RaM character -- you have no idea the anguish I went through before I bit the bullet and let him have his heroic death in the first war.Oh, yes, Robert knows it was Severus. And Severus knows that Robert knows that it was he. And Robert knows Severus knows that Robert knows -- and so forth!Harry can just as easily believe that Severus is just being a nasty git. Harry isn't very subtle. Just have faith in Chapter Six! Do not lose faith in MMADfan or in MMADfan's depiction of Minerva! Remember POV is vital!Thanks for the review!
I really like Poppy. Her no-nonsense approach and caring without overt pitying or smothering Severus with her sympathy seems to be exactly what he needs right now. I'm very curious about the prophecy - can't wait to see what, if anything, comes from that. (It could be a red herring, I suppose - in any case, most intriguing.)
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
I'm glad you like Poppy here!No red herrings here! *grin* In fact, I don't tend to use red herrings. I have certain bits of ambiguity, of course, and I have characters who may lie to or mislead other characters, and a character's p.o.v. is important to take into account, but something like the prophecy . . . not a red herring.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
I'm glad you like Poppy here!No red herrings here! *grin* In fact, I don't tend to use red herrings. I have certain bits of ambiguity, of course, and I have characters who may lie to or mislead other characters, and a character's p.o.v. is important to take into account, but something like the prophecy . . . not a red herring.
poor severus...if only he understood how many people really care about him. i liked how sev talked some sense (hopefully!) into remus. thanks so much for the update of this incrediblly dense story.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
Thank you! I'm glad you enjoyed it!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
Thank you! I'm glad you enjoyed it!
I cried through the entirety of the massage scene, it was very poignant; his tears felt like a small step towards a turning point for Snape, though far from evicting himself from his current state (which probably wouldn't be possible until the end of Voldemort, regardless; the living will never be easy, but perhaps it can be eased, if he were to live).
I really enjoy this story and look forward to reading more.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
Thank you very much! I am very glad that you found the massage scene so moving. Severus needed to cry, and the massage let his body process his pain and his tears in a way that he hadn't allowed himself, and he felt what it was like to be taken care of, too, and by someone who didn't find his tears remarkable but just let him be, which was what he needed.Thank you very much for your review! It made my afternoon!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
Thank you very much! I am very glad that you found the massage scene so moving. Severus needed to cry, and the massage let his body process his pain and his tears in a way that he hadn't allowed himself, and he felt what it was like to be taken care of, too, and by someone who didn't find his tears remarkable but just let him be, which was what he needed.Thank you very much for your review! It made my afternoon!
I can feel the unbearable tension in this chapter. Snape is so tightly wound, he seems ready to snap. He seems so desperate.It was kind of Poppy to give him a massage and an outlet for his feelings. Honestly, the way that you write him makes me want to just sit with him and hold his hand.You managed to fit wussy Lupin into this - good job! Poor Buckbeak. There's another one trapped and desperately in need of being freed.Erm. I had to look up "suspires". Interesting prophecy. Why do I have a feeling that there's a plot twist coming?
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
Why do I have a feeling that there's a plot twist coming?Gee, why do you? I'm glad you liked Poppy's massage. It helped Severus process his emotions physically, and helped him to keep going. I'm glad you want to sit and hold his hand!I'm glad you liked my version of wussy Lupin! Thanks for reviewing!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
Why do I have a feeling that there's a plot twist coming?Gee, why do you? I'm glad you liked Poppy's massage. It helped Severus process his emotions physically, and helped him to keep going. I'm glad you want to sit and hold his hand!I'm glad you liked my version of wussy Lupin! Thanks for reviewing!
Wow. So much in this chapter. Excellent. And so very unhappy. I'm glad they sorted Moody out though. Thanks.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
Yeah, Moody really needed sorting out, didn't he? I'm glad you liked the chapter! Thanks! :-)
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
Yeah, Moody really needed sorting out, didn't he? I'm glad you liked the chapter! Thanks! :-)
I really liked Poppy's treatment of Severus and his response to her. You wrote that really well. My heart is heavy as I read and anticipate the raid on Hogwarts. I am curious, too, about Sybil's latest prophecy and what, if anything, it means. Great writing as usual.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
Thank you very much! I'm glad you liked Poppy's treatment of Severus. I appreciate your review!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
Thank you very much! I'm glad you liked Poppy's treatment of Severus. I appreciate your review!
I don't want to go to work, waaahhhhh! *clears throat* Excuse me I was having a moment. I really want to see what happens in the next chapter, this is intriguing. Knowing Severus had to come up with a way to get Harry to leave the school seems fitting. Though I am surprised he didn't protest that a month's worth of detentions was too much. But it seemed to work. And we see the soft spot he has growing for Hermione, aww.In this chapter I couldn't help feeling that Minerva was a bit detached. She keeps referring to Albus as 'The Headmaster.' Is she doing that in an effort to shield herself from the pain? Or is she changed somehow? Though I don't doubt, losing the man you have loved for a lifetime would leave you altered. I did notice when she seemed to falter. But, atm, she just seems so robot like, like she is just getting through the motions. hmm.And here is Robbie again. He seems to be in on eveything and I am wondering when he came into the picture to begin with. It is plain that Severus doesn't like him much, but then, there aren't many people Severus likes. But Minerva trusts him and he is a family member, or seems to be. Oh, yeah! I am also curious when Alroy will enter a scene. I can't wait for that. Is Quin going to be in this story?Yipes, I gotta go or I am gonna be late for work. I have lots of things to ponder until tonight. TTFN!Cheers,Stef
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
Hope you aren't late for work!Severus was able to use his nasty-git-ness to irk Harry enough to drive him from the school -- can't go "gallivanting" if you have detention every night! haha!Minerva is being coolly detached from Severus, as you will see later, and her role has changed drastically, as well.Robbie. Heheheh. Yeah, Severus doesn't like him much here, does he?Thank you for the review!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
Hope you aren't late for work!Severus was able to use his nasty-git-ness to irk Harry enough to drive him from the school -- can't go "gallivanting" if you have detention every night! haha!Minerva is being coolly detached from Severus, as you will see later, and her role has changed drastically, as well.Robbie. Heheheh. Yeah, Severus doesn't like him much here, does he?Thank you for the review!
Okay, this was a change up! I am beginning to feel like I'm in some odd rendition of Pulp Fiction. But I love that movie so it's all good. The differences between this and RaM are interesting. In Ram everything was sequential but here it seems we are going back and forth. I am following and not complaining, it's all good. *insert big toothy grin here*Definitely different from DH, as far as getting Harry to safety. It was good she had to change into her animagus for him to know it was her. And Melina, too? YAY! I wonder how many of the characters we saw in RaM are going to show up here. But I am afraid I am not familiar with Robbie . . . hmm, I may have to go back to RaM and do some poking around to find him.I liked the fact that Petunia and Dudley were with Harry and against Vernon. His character always got on my nerves. Dudley was even... nice. WOW! Lol, and Harry threw up on Vernon? Classic, heh, heh.I also liked the fact that Minerva didn't want to look at Harry looking like Dudley, lol. After that last chapter I liked that this was a bit lighter. Though the end was sad and I was sad for Harry. He seemed more approachable in this chapter than he was in the previous one. But then, he has had a little time to adjust to the changes.I may have time for one more before work. But I do need coffee. We shall see. I wonder what will happen next? Great chapter!Cheers,Stef
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
Yep, the first several chapters are in chronological order, though the first couple chapters are prior to the events of the prologue, the next few follow the events of the prologue. It is fairly nonlinear, though, and the early chapters don't follow one another closely, but as things draw closer to the end, the timeline grows tighter, unlike in RaM and AAoL, which follow events very closely, practically one day after the other. So you're right -- it's very different from RaM.Robert Crouch is Gertie's son by Reginald Crouch -- Minerva first met him at the Gamps. Remember that Minerva's mother was helping him and Thea with Thea's medical problem? There will be several characters whom you will recognise from RaM, or who are related to RaM characters, so that should be fun for you!I loved having Harry throw up on Vernon. He sure deserved it! haha!Glad you liked the chapter! Thanks for reviewing!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
Yep, the first several chapters are in chronological order, though the first couple chapters are prior to the events of the prologue, the next few follow the events of the prologue. It is fairly nonlinear, though, and the early chapters don't follow one another closely, but as things draw closer to the end, the timeline grows tighter, unlike in RaM and AAoL, which follow events very closely, practically one day after the other. So you're right -- it's very different from RaM.Robert Crouch is Gertie's son by Reginald Crouch -- Minerva first met him at the Gamps. Remember that Minerva's mother was helping him and Thea with Thea's medical problem? There will be several characters whom you will recognise from RaM, or who are related to RaM characters, so that should be fun for you!I loved having Harry throw up on Vernon. He sure deserved it! haha!Glad you liked the chapter! Thanks for reviewing!
LET'S DO A HAPPY DANCE!!! IT'S AN UPDATE! What an emotional chapter in so many ways.
The confrontation between Snape and Minerva after the raid was tense and very powerful. I could easily see Minerva reacting to what happened in just the way you described. And I don't think Snape withheld that information on purpose. I, like Minerva, believe it was merely a lapse in judgment.
The scene with Poppy and Snape where she's putting the potion on his back was very moving. It shows a side of him we don't normally get to see and I'm sure the Adfectus curse helped to open up his mind and heart to experience more emotions than before.
Feeding Buckbeak and then remembering to tell Minerva that he should be moved was another transformation, in a small way, for Snape. And showing so much concern, in his own way, for Tonks and Remus's unborn child was a new step for him as well. I'm glad he told Minerva so that maybe she could help prevent another orphan in the series.
Thanks so much for updating. This is a great story and I am loving the way you're putting a twist on the events that JKR botched so royally!!!
Cheers,
GLM
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
Yep, an update! I'm glad to give you a happy dance in the middle of the week!Severus has shown some growth here, even if it's reluctant and grudging sometimes. I'm glad you like my take on the events leading up to the final confrontation! It's not as full of action and adventure, of course -- I'm just letting Harry & Co. do most of their thing off-screen, so to speak -- but I like this side of the story, and the twists I've made, myself. (Well, guess I'd have to since I am writing it! haha!) And there's no camping . . . sorry about that to anyone who enjoyed the camping aspect! I'm bad this morning!Thanks for reviewing! I hope you're having a great summer!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
Yep, an update! I'm glad to give you a happy dance in the middle of the week!Severus has shown some growth here, even if it's reluctant and grudging sometimes. I'm glad you like my take on the events leading up to the final confrontation! It's not as full of action and adventure, of course -- I'm just letting Harry & Co. do most of their thing off-screen, so to speak -- but I like this side of the story, and the twists I've made, myself. (Well, guess I'd have to since I am writing it! haha!) And there's no camping . . . sorry about that to anyone who enjoyed the camping aspect! I'm bad this morning!Thanks for reviewing! I hope you're having a great summer!
Hi there! I'm back for more, heh!HOLY MACKEREL!!! What an emotional chapter! *Sniff, sniff* Excuse me for a moment while I go get a tissue... Alright, I'm back. I felt so bad for both of them in this chapter. I can only imagine how hard it was for Severus to tell Minerva about the Vow and Albus' plan for him to kill him.I am still wondering why Albus didn't tell her himself. That is just, just - so wrong! Oh, knowing how hard they worked during RaM to overcome things like this just makes me angry at Albus for Minerva. She must be feeling so betrayed.However, I am sure the fact that Severus took the Vow not knowing what it entailed doesn't set well either. Given his nature, though, it does not surprise me that he did it, and I don't believe it should have surprised Minerva either, even if he has made progress in his emotions and feelings. But he did take it before that stray spell anyway. And now Minerva knows she helped him overcome the spell, giving more of herself than anyone could or should have asked, and they both had not informed her about the Vow or Albus even knowing about it back then? She is showing a GREAT DEAL of control! Severus is lucky a shocked hand was all he got. How horrible!Oh, dear! I wonder how the conversation between Albus and Minerva is going to pan out. Atm I just want to cry.Heart-wrenching chapter (but in a good way). . . I'm on to more before work.Cheers!Stef
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
Yup, this was a hard chapter all around for both Severus and Minerva. She will confront Albus about it (of course), but it will be a while before we see that.I'm glad you found it heart-wrenching in a good way!Thanks for the review!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
Yup, this was a hard chapter all around for both Severus and Minerva. She will confront Albus about it (of course), but it will be a while before we see that.I'm glad you found it heart-wrenching in a good way!Thanks for the review!
I do so love Severus. I like how the spell and his meetings with Minerva have worked to soften him some. I got a little scared when Albus got so angry. And while I am glad they are meeting and she is helping him, I am worried about how she will react when he tells her about the Vow.And Albus being Albus, he is taking everything onto his shoulders, grrr. I wonder why he doesn't want Minerva to know? I don't think it is because he doesn't want to hurt her. I mean, his death will hurt her anyway. Hmmm...And now I want to keep going but I can't concentrate with this awful fan buzzing! The fan for our mother board is struggling for life, the poor thing. So, against my wishes, I am signing off for now. But I'll be back!Cheers!Stef
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
Erg, your poor overheated motherboard! How annoying, too!I'm glad you like Severus here! Albus didn't stay angry long, fortunately. You'll learn in a future chapter why Albus is keeping it from her. Cheers! Thanks for reviwing!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
Erg, your poor overheated motherboard! How annoying, too!I'm glad you like Severus here! Albus didn't stay angry long, fortunately. You'll learn in a future chapter why Albus is keeping it from her. Cheers! Thanks for reviwing!
Okay, I have started. I must say, this is a rather sad way to start, but I am keeping what you said in mind, as well as your cheerleader. lol. Btw, I love that Filius set the white flames to his tomb, sniff.Severus certainly kept his form with Harry, if it were me, I would have let him have it, the git! Sigh, and you know how I feel about Severus. Poor Minerva *sticks lip out* she is holding up well. Though I noticed the fade to a whisper at the end of her speech, waaah! I am very interested in where this will go.Alright, on to the next chapter. Cheers,Stef =o)
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
Yes, it is a sad start. As I've occasionally described it, the prologue here is kind of like the hub of the wheel of the story, and the other chapters are spokes.I can guess which "cheerleader" that might have been! Yup, listen to her. Hope you enjoy the ride!There's lots more Severus to come, and sometimes he holds himself in check, and sometimes not so much . . .Thanks for reviewing!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
Yes, it is a sad start. As I've occasionally described it, the prologue here is kind of like the hub of the wheel of the story, and the other chapters are spokes.I can guess which "cheerleader" that might have been! Yup, listen to her. Hope you enjoy the ride!There's lots more Severus to come, and sometimes he holds himself in check, and sometimes not so much . . .Thanks for reviewing!
The tension everywhere is almost unbearable, but I think I'm going to stop here so I'll have two chapters to read when you post the next one. Congratulations on writing such a captivating story.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
I'm glad you are enjoying it so well! It's always nice to have a chunk left to read when the new chapter is posted.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
I'm glad you are enjoying it so well! It's always nice to have a chunk left to read when the new chapter is posted.
An engrossing chapter that.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
Thanks! Glad you liked it!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
Thanks! Glad you liked it!
A good chapter but a busy one. A lot of information was thrown at us. You did a very good job showing things from Severus's POV and his emotional state.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
The next chapter is very full, too, as things crank up. You can look at as a chapter containing mini-chapters. ;-)Glad you liked Severus's POV here.Thanks for reviewing!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
The next chapter is very full, too, as things crank up. You can look at as a chapter containing mini-chapters. ;-)Glad you liked Severus's POV here.Thanks for reviewing!
What a sad chapter, I actually cried. Excellent writing and drawing me into your story.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
Thank you! I am glad that the story is drawing you in so much and that you were moved by the chapter. Thanks for reviewing!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
Thank you! I am glad that the story is drawing you in so much and that you were moved by the chapter. Thanks for reviewing!
“It would have to be a very superficial examination, Severus,” Minerva said. “That is not as simple as Transfiguring an actual corpse into something else. I don’t think I’m capable of it.”[Esoterica arches an eyebrow. Albus always did think that Minerva underestimated her abilities....and at the moment I'm tending to agree. <g>]" We will bear the guilt with you. It may not ease your own, but it is what I can do for you.” Does Severus fully appreciate the ways in which Minerva and Robbie are reaching out to him in this chapter, trying to bear his burdens with him? Watching Severus and Gareth in the first parts of the chapter, w/ the sandwiches, I am reminded of the distinction you drew between Albus and Minerva in the very first chapter of RaM...that Albus would change things to suit him but Minerva would take things as she found them. Snape seems to be very much like the younger Minerva in this respect; perhaps it's one reason they get along well. It's also interesting that in DD Albus and Minerva seem to have reversed regarding this trait...it is Albus who simply reacts to what he believes is fated to be, while, once she learns of his situation, Minerva is extremely proactive in changing things radically to try to force a better outcome. You do not write static characters <understatement!>. Another interesting thing is the parallels you've made btwn Albus and Snape. In DD both of them walk down paths where they are sure they will be dead w/in weeks but feel they can do nothing else b/c of their obligations and roles. Both of them feel themselves being eaten away from the inside--Albus literally by the curse, Snape by his despair and layers of loathing. Death's dominion. Yet Albus approaches death w/ his characteristic good humour, and Snape w/ his characteristic gloom, even though it's shot through w/ occasional bits of other emotions now. Both men feel doomed, but in Albus's case both Snape and Minerva want him to live, while in Snape's case Albus and Minerva want him to live. I guess we'll have to wait several more chapters to see if either hope is fulfilled! Dylan Thomas, depite being a depressive Welshman himself, would counsel hope, I do believe....hope, and trusting in Gryffindor witches!- - - -"Severus looked at the cover, but only the letters “abd” were legible."Robbie seems to be thoroughly familiar w/ Albus's personal library! Interesting that Albus would have taken such careful notes on such a crafty, lethal potion, especially since he was never the sort to be plotting out and out murders--though I'm sure, like Robbie, he felt responsible for many deaths. Or perhaps the transcription is Robbie's, but still, it's interesting that Albus had such a book and that Robbie could find it quickly, and find the most useful potion in it.I love love love this scene between Robbie and Severus:"Severus looked down at the book, not seeing it. “I am capable of brewing it.” “I have no doubt you are, but I will do this. I can do none of the rest for you, but this, I can do. It is also Minerva’s wish.” Severus looked back up at Crouch. “Have you ever killed a person?” “I have attempted to avoid it. However, I have been responsible for more deaths than I care to discuss. I am sure you can understand that sentiment.” “Mm. You fought Grindelwald.” “Yes. It was a long time ago, though, another lifetime.” [Interesting choice of phrase, Robbie, most interesting!] “Did you poison people then?” Crouch shook his head. Severus closed his eyes. He felt on the edge of collapse, but he could not, not yet. He only had to last one second past the Dark Lord’s decision to kill him. Then he would be dead and he could collapse. [I am sure the late Albus could relate to how Severus is feeling now, especially as he grew sicker.] “Dumbledore said you were a competent Potions Master,” Severus said, opening his eyes. “I would like to believe that I am at least competent." "- - - I think the way Robbie and Minerva are trying to help Severus avoid further blotches on his soul as much as they can, and to bear the burden w/ him when he must do heinous stuff, is quite moving. They really are trying to help him find his salvation and to see himself as more than the condemned black-souled Death Eater he once was. I hope he recognizes what they're doing, even though he doesn't articulate it. Letting Robbie brew the potion when a screw-up could get him killed STAT shows how much Severus has grown in his appreciation and trust of Robbie and I think also shows that on some level he does 'get' and accept what Robbie and Minerva are trying to do for him.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
“It would have to be a very superficial examination, Severus,” Minerva said. “That is not as simple as Transfiguring an actual corpse into something else. I don’t think I’m capable of it.”[Esoterica arches an eyebrow. Albus always did think that Minerva underestimated her abilities....and at the moment I'm tending to agree. <g>]Hmmm . . . wonder why Minerva would underestimate her abilities to Severus . . . hmmmm . . . As far as Severus's appreciation, I think he has some sense of it, but he's so (understandably) bound up in his own situation, he can't completely appreciate very much, even that. It's also in his nature to be more focussed on himself than on others, and that's a trait that's been reinforced by his abnormal life. As far as Albus & Minerva -- you are correct in a sense. Albus did accept his fate, but that was because he, despite his genius for changing things to suit him, could not see any way to change anything that wouldn't make things worse for others even if they were better for himself. With Minerva, it's not as though she was incapable of changing circumstances to suit herself, of course, but here, her talent for taking what was dealt her actually was an advantage. The changes that Albus considered when he tried to think of other options were not of the sort that Minerva could consider. Not only was Minerva able to take her own participation into account and what she was able to do in the situation, but she was able to look at it and say, "We can't change what's dealth us, but how can we use it -- have it remain the same but have it serve us to our advantage?" So while she creates change, she does it in ways that Albus wouldn't think to.Just FYI, the "abd" really was "abd," not "a__bd." It's the beginning of a word on the cover, and although you are correct that it was one of Albus's books, he obtained it many years before and he did not copy it himself. (He would have regularized the spelling. haha!) Also, Severus would have recognized Albus's handwriting.WRT the conversation between Robbie and Severus and Robbie's careful choice of words, when Robbie and Minerva -- and Gareth -- can avoid out-and-out lying to Severus, they do. (Like Gareth's answer when Severus asked if others lived on the island. An answer, truthful, and yet ambiguous.)Severus has grown in his trust of Robbie, and he gets that they are trying to help him even if he still feels entirely alone.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
And because I forgot to say it, thank you for your review!(It's also gratifying when you see some of the parallels and such that I've set up -- the basic story here is fairly simple, even the part that is only gradually being revealed -- but its construction and writing haven't been so simple. Thanks!)
Response from esoterica1693 (Reviewer)
I see what you mean about A and M also still following their original characters. All of your Gryffindors are really Gryffyclaws, compared to the stereotype one sometimes gets from canon of Gryffindors simply being foolhardy brave jocks, and Severus's equal stereotyping of them, even though he clearly has a thing for Gryffy witches! Minerva and her rellies and Albus are all notable for their brains and wisdom first, and their bravery second. And if Robbie had ever been sorted <g>, I think he'd come out Gryffyclaw too--the Gryffy part is clear from the dangerous exploit Albus had to rescue him from as a teen! Severus was so sure (and understandably so) that when he told Minerva of Albus's plan he would lose his last tie to human friendship. But now 12-18 mos later, he has more friends than he's possibly ever had: Minerva, Robbie, Gareth in a way, and Hermione. And all of them are truly going out of their way to befriend him. Hopefully he'll continue to absorb this and take hope from it.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
Whoa! This is one long review thread!Anyway, Minerva & her relatives do tend to be bright. Even Morgan, who we never see (though we have heard of) is very bright. He's a Hufflepuff and a homebody, though. Murdoch and Gareth are both Ravenclaws, though neither of them is a wuss. Gareth certainly isn't. Of course, in canon, we are told about very bright Gryffies -- in addition to Hermione, both James and Lily were supposed to have been very smart and gotten top marks. Pettigrew always puzzled me -- he's a Gryffy, but the only Gryffy thing that we see him do is turn on his friends and join Voldemort -- that would take guts, even if it's a really terrible thing to do.And yup, Severus has a thing for Gryffy witches! Smart Gryffy witches.Severus is very gloom-and-doom when it comes to his future. If he was wrong about that -- and yet he did what he thought was the right thing despite that belief -- what else might he be wrong about?
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
“It would have to be a very superficial examination, Severus,” Minerva said. “That is not as simple as Transfiguring an actual corpse into something else. I don’t think I’m capable of it.”[Esoterica arches an eyebrow. Albus always did think that Minerva underestimated her abilities....and at the moment I'm tending to agree. <g>]Hmmm . . . wonder why Minerva would underestimate her abilities to Severus . . . hmmmm . . . As far as Severus's appreciation, I think he has some sense of it, but he's so (understandably) bound up in his own situation, he can't completely appreciate very much, even that. It's also in his nature to be more focussed on himself than on others, and that's a trait that's been reinforced by his abnormal life. As far as Albus & Minerva -- you are correct in a sense. Albus did accept his fate, but that was because he, despite his genius for changing things to suit him, could not see any way to change anything that wouldn't make things worse for others even if they were better for himself. With Minerva, it's not as though she was incapable of changing circumstances to suit herself, of course, but here, her talent for taking what was dealt her actually was an advantage. The changes that Albus considered when he tried to think of other options were not of the sort that Minerva could consider. Not only was Minerva able to take her own participation into account and what she was able to do in the situation, but she was able to look at it and say, "We can't change what's dealth us, but how can we use it -- have it remain the same but have it serve us to our advantage?" So while she creates change, she does it in ways that Albus wouldn't think to.Just FYI, the "abd" really was "abd," not "a__bd." It's the beginning of a word on the cover, and although you are correct that it was one of Albus's books, he obtained it many years before and he did not copy it himself. (He would have regularized the spelling. haha!) Also, Severus would have recognized Albus's handwriting.WRT the conversation between Robbie and Severus and Robbie's careful choice of words, when Robbie and Minerva -- and Gareth -- can avoid out-and-out lying to Severus, they do. (Like Gareth's answer when Severus asked if others lived on the island. An answer, truthful, and yet ambiguous.)Severus has grown in his trust of Robbie, and he gets that they are trying to help him even if he still feels entirely alone.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
And because I forgot to say it, thank you for your review!(It's also gratifying when you see some of the parallels and such that I've set up -- the basic story here is fairly simple, even the part that is only gradually being revealed -- but its construction and writing haven't been so simple. Thanks!)
Response from esoterica1693 (Reviewer)
I see what you mean about A and M also still following their original characters. All of your Gryffindors are really Gryffyclaws, compared to the stereotype one sometimes gets from canon of Gryffindors simply being foolhardy brave jocks, and Severus's equal stereotyping of them, even though he clearly has a thing for Gryffy witches! Minerva and her rellies and Albus are all notable for their brains and wisdom first, and their bravery second. And if Robbie had ever been sorted <g>, I think he'd come out Gryffyclaw too--the Gryffy part is clear from the dangerous exploit Albus had to rescue him from as a teen! Severus was so sure (and understandably so) that when he told Minerva of Albus's plan he would lose his last tie to human friendship. But now 12-18 mos later, he has more friends than he's possibly ever had: Minerva, Robbie, Gareth in a way, and Hermione. And all of them are truly going out of their way to befriend him. Hopefully he'll continue to absorb this and take hope from it.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
Whoa! This is one long review thread!Anyway, Minerva & her relatives do tend to be bright. Even Morgan, who we never see (though we have heard of) is very bright. He's a Hufflepuff and a homebody, though. Murdoch and Gareth are both Ravenclaws, though neither of them is a wuss. Gareth certainly isn't. Of course, in canon, we are told about very bright Gryffies -- in addition to Hermione, both James and Lily were supposed to have been very smart and gotten top marks. Pettigrew always puzzled me -- he's a Gryffy, but the only Gryffy thing that we see him do is turn on his friends and join Voldemort -- that would take guts, even if it's a really terrible thing to do.And yup, Severus has a thing for Gryffy witches! Smart Gryffy witches.Severus is very gloom-and-doom when it comes to his future. If he was wrong about that -- and yet he did what he thought was the right thing despite that belief -- what else might he be wrong about?
I understand that Snape has to be exactly what he is in order to function and stay alive, constantly walking a tightrope. It still makes me so sad that he dare not accept any kindness at face value lest it crack his false face that he must hold in place for Voldemort. That being said, I really love this story. I feel like I'm there in the room. Good story!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
I'm glad you are loving it! Thanks for letting me know! There are more than a few chapters remaining, but we are getting closer to the inevitable final confrontations with V.I hope you continue to enjoy it.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
I'm glad you are loving it! Thanks for letting me know! There are more than a few chapters remaining, but we are getting closer to the inevitable final confrontations with V.I hope you continue to enjoy it.
Gareth would make a very good nurse, with his sympathetic but take-no-sh** bedside manner and not quite endless patience. I'm thinking he could prepare my bath for me anytime he liked. In other words, he's quite grown on me. The roast beef sandwich scene was especially amusing. I'm surprised Gareth was able to keep a straight face.
I'm also pleased that Slytherin House is divided, unlike that other book I won't name.And Severus's internal pep-talk during bath-time was both touching and funny. Not that I've ever been a double-agent super spy facing my own imminent death, but I've had to give myself my own bathtime pep talks during times when sinking under the bubbles seemed easier than moving forward.Another excellent chapter, and I'm so glad you're updating regularly, even if I have to stay up way past bedtime to catch up!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
He could prepare my bath and help me take it. Gareth might have gone into Potions or Healing if his education hadn't been quite so unconventional -- in other words, if he'd been able to take his Potions NEWT. It runs through the family on Minerva's mother's side.Gareth was finding Severus rather cute and amusing with the sandwiches, but knew that Severus would misinterpret any laughing. Severus has not yet developed a very good ability to laugh at himself unless he is being derisive. He has a hard time understanding laughing at someone without derision -- though he feels something like it when he talks to Hermione and she displays such supreme and artless self-confidence.There wre so many things in that Book-Which-Shall-Not-Be-Named that I found disappointing, and that was one of them. The lack of depth and some kind of salvation for Severus was another -- we learned more about his motivation in turning to Dumbledore years before (which most of us had already guessed at during HBP at least, if not before), but I think that motivation took the place of depth, and "balancing the scales" through his sacrifice took the place of salvation, if you know what I mean. I think of Seversu as a complex character, even more complex than he realizes, and while it remains important for him to remember his initial motivation for turning away from V -- Albus says something like that to him, not to forget that, not to forget why he came to him originally and why he has been at Hogwarts all those years -- but there is more to him than just that.Glad you liked his little self-pep-talk! The greatest Slytherin in the history of Slytherin! (And in some respects, he might be right, too.) And don't we all have those moments when we think, oh, to shut off the world! I'm glad you liked the chapter! I am trying to update at least every 10 - 14 days. The chapter with the Heads of House took longer to write. I had to put it aside after each scene and go do something else, then it took me a long time to be happy with it after I'd polished and repolished. RL is also not terrific right now . . . Thanks for the review!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
He could prepare my bath and help me take it. Gareth might have gone into Potions or Healing if his education hadn't been quite so unconventional -- in other words, if he'd been able to take his Potions NEWT. It runs through the family on Minerva's mother's side.Gareth was finding Severus rather cute and amusing with the sandwiches, but knew that Severus would misinterpret any laughing. Severus has not yet developed a very good ability to laugh at himself unless he is being derisive. He has a hard time understanding laughing at someone without derision -- though he feels something like it when he talks to Hermione and she displays such supreme and artless self-confidence.There wre so many things in that Book-Which-Shall-Not-Be-Named that I found disappointing, and that was one of them. The lack of depth and some kind of salvation for Severus was another -- we learned more about his motivation in turning to Dumbledore years before (which most of us had already guessed at during HBP at least, if not before), but I think that motivation took the place of depth, and "balancing the scales" through his sacrifice took the place of salvation, if you know what I mean. I think of Seversu as a complex character, even more complex than he realizes, and while it remains important for him to remember his initial motivation for turning away from V -- Albus says something like that to him, not to forget that, not to forget why he came to him originally and why he has been at Hogwarts all those years -- but there is more to him than just that.Glad you liked his little self-pep-talk! The greatest Slytherin in the history of Slytherin! (And in some respects, he might be right, too.) And don't we all have those moments when we think, oh, to shut off the world! I'm glad you liked the chapter! I am trying to update at least every 10 - 14 days. The chapter with the Heads of House took longer to write. I had to put it aside after each scene and go do something else, then it took me a long time to be happy with it after I'd polished and repolished. RL is also not terrific right now . . . Thanks for the review!
The scene with the four heads of house was beautifully written; it had me in tears. The affection and tenderness which they all seem to have for each other was touching to read, and it makes Severus's tightly controlled emotions stand out even more by contrast. The little detail of the way he clenched the watch in his hand was exquisite. The moment alone with Albus was heartbreaking. I wonder how it must hurt Severus that not only is the sacrifice of his life for Albus's refused, but that even his potions are refused. And I wonder how much it must hurt Albus to have to do so, and to refuse Severus the comfort of understanding why it must be so.
And what a contrast with the scene with Harry! Poor, clueless, self-absorbed Harry, who seems only able to interpret the world as it revolves around himself. But also fairly typical, I think, of a teenager. Or would it be typical of a teen who has already experienced so much loss? I'm not sure, but I hope we see his character have the opportunity to grow and mature, too, as we are with some of the others.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
I'm glad that you liked that scene with the Heads of House. I am sure that it hurt Albus to see Severus upset. The gift for Severus was the easiest for Albus to decide on because it was, to Albus, the most natural and perfect thing to give him. He wanted Severus to know that apart from all else in their lives, that he was important to him, like a son, and he loved him. The knowledge that what they are doing will hurt and upset people bothers both Albus and Minerva, but they see it as necessary. Melina tells Minerva that a lot of people will be upseet when it's over, and Minerva tells her that's true, but it will be over, and that is what the two are trying to focus on -- getting it over, doing what they can to ensure that Harry has the best possible opportunity to defeat Voldemort.Harry will grow, and there will be a few hints of that, but since I'm focussing on the folks left back at Hogwarts rather than Harry and his crew, we won't see a lot of him. There will be a few scenes, though, that will show some of the growth he's undergone after leaving Hogwarts, and which I think you'll find interesting.Thanks very much for the review! I appreciate it!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Death's Dominion)
I'm glad that you liked that scene with the Heads of House. I am sure that it hurt Albus to see Severus upset. The gift for Severus was the easiest for Albus to decide on because it was, to Albus, the most natural and perfect thing to give him. He wanted Severus to know that apart from all else in their lives, that he was important to him, like a son, and he loved him. The knowledge that what they are doing will hurt and upset people bothers both Albus and Minerva, but they see it as necessary. Melina tells Minerva that a lot of people will be upseet when it's over, and Minerva tells her that's true, but it will be over, and that is what the two are trying to focus on -- getting it over, doing what they can to ensure that Harry has the best possible opportunity to defeat Voldemort.Harry will grow, and there will be a few hints of that, but since I'm focussing on the folks left back at Hogwarts rather than Harry and his crew, we won't see a lot of him. There will be a few scenes, though, that will show some of the growth he's undergone after leaving Hogwarts, and which I think you'll find interesting.Thanks very much for the review! I appreciate it!