New Chapter for Resolving a Misunderstanding
Resolving a Misunderstanding
MMADfan954 Reviews | 6.45/10 (954 Ratings, 0 Likes, 108 Favorites )
Minerva has just finished her first term teaching. A series of misunderstandings leads to an embarrassing moment, injured feelings, regret, growing understanding, then resolution. A Minerva McGonagall fic set in 1957, with forays into the past. More than a Romance; stories within stories. Features Minerva, Albus, and Poppy, with appearances by Slughorn, Grubbly-Plank, Hagrid, Flitwick, Moody, Riddle, Grindelwald, and other canon characters. Not DH-compliant. Disregards DH.
Nineteen Parts.
Most content T-rated, but ratings rise to M and MA for several later chapters. Overall M rating reflects later content.
Pertinent warnings in individual chapter summaries.
Voted First Place, Minerva McGonagall: Legacy Fic, in the HP Fanfiction Fan Poll Awards Spring/Summer 2013.
Chapters (141)
About MMADfan
Author
MMADfan
41 Stories | Favorited by 312 | 127 Reviews Written | 4,741 Review Responses
Note 10 December 2015: I've been unable to write fanfic the last couple years, but I haven't abandoned my works-in-progress!
Many of my completed fics are available for download in ebook format through my blog and LJ.
Perfect Imagination accredited beta. PI:7311261659.
More about me here.
Reviews for Resolving a Misunderstanding
I can think of a way Minerva could get Albus to bed on time.Of course, there might not be any sleeping going on for a while. But I'm sure he'd have a really good night's sleep after.These two really are the last to figure it all out, aren't they? Given that JKR continually changes canon due to her own bad math or inability to keep track of the facts she gives out about her characters, I think ff authors are entitled to pick and choose what works for them.A very nice update!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Heeheehee!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
, I like your thoughts about getting Albus to bed on time!
It does seem as though those who are close to them -- Gertie, Wilspy (and by extension, Blampa), Merwyn, Egeria, and, of course, Quin, all know and are trying to do something about it. And Poppy has some inkling, but isn't entirely sure how correct she is. But Albus and Minerva are too wrapped up in their own feelings and fighting them to see very clearly . . .
I agree -- it does seem that JKR changes "canon" somewhat willy-nilly. I know that just for this fanfic I've had to make charts and timelines in order to keep facts straight. It seems pretty elementary to do that for a real series of novels. Especially for the very basic facts -- the bones -- of the stories. Details can change and events might turn out a bit differently than originally planned and subsequent scenes adjusted to reflect that, but to change really fundamental facts, such as birthdates and so forth . . . sigh! I have a chronology for RaM on my LJ (no spoilers in it), if anyone is interested in it. It includes a detailed chronology for the month of July 1957.
I'm working on a sequel to AAoL which will be non-DH compliant (obviously, since it's an AAoL sequel, which is a sort-of sequel to RaM), and I'm having fun playing with some DH stuff in that, despite it not being at all DH-compliant. Sort of a DH-twister.
Thanks for reviewing!
Response from Hypnobarb (Reviewer)
You know, JKR is supposed to be one of the wealthiest people on the planet. She could have hired somebody to keep timelines and lexicon for her. Some poor unemployed English major could have done charts of plot lines and given her a check-off sheet to follow.Urgh.Fortunately, we have fanfiction to set things right.I shall anxiously await your AAoL sequel!Snicker.
Love this chapter, especially Minerva's parents (her dad is adorable). I'm with you on the confusion regarding the "new birthday" thing for Albus, but I decided not to bother with the updated year. I wonder what made JKR change her mind 41-years worth!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Who knows what JKR was thinking! She also put his death year as 1996. If he died in 1996, then Severus wouldn't have had to kill him in 1997, well, he couldn't have, could he? I think she was trying to reconcile that with the witch's age from that early chapter of DH, but there are ways to explain away what the witch says. But then, JKR just could be so bad at addition and subtraction that she can't even estimate without being 40+ years off. It was a weird and unnecessary change, IMO.
Anyway, I'm glad you enjoyed the chapter and Minerva's parents!
Response from dmf1984 (Reviewer)
Maybe since JKR is now "famouser even than Captain Kangaroo" she has other people do her math for her?!!Of course she probably dinna expect so many picky people to read her stuff! Ennnnny-way; still love her stuff (even if she tried to sink the ADMM ship). *pff*
This is becoming quite amusing, how everyone around Minerva and Albus know how they feel about each other, but those two remain obtuse. It has been, and will continue to be, great fun watching them finally figure it out for themselves. :-) The banter between Minverva and each of her parents regarding Albus is quite entertaining, and well written. I like Minerva's perspective on Albus' beard and hair, and the reasons they suit him so well. I am as curious as Minerva about the wands, I look forward to learning more!Another wonderful chapter, thank you for posting. I am glad you are feeling better.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Thanks very much! I am hoping that things will remain stable enough in RL so that I can post the next chapter next weekend.
Glad the chapter amused you. Thank you again for reviewing.
Response from stardragon (Reviewer)
oops! Sorry, I don't know how I managed to repost my review twice!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Don't worry about it -- the lovely admins will take care of the duplicates! It may happen if you accidentally refreshed the page that pops up after you have submitted the review. It happens!
Her father's having a hard time dancing around the Albus-and-Minerva issue. She's very prickly about it, so no one seems able to come right out and talk about it. It's like everyone knows and approves but her and Albus.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Well, certainly a handful of those closest to them either know, guess, or have a vague suspicion about it. But as neither of them would admit it, it is a difficult subject to broach. Thanks for reviewing!
First off, I am sorry you are sick, and hope you are feeling better soon.I am rereading this, as I read it quickly the first time. I'm catching a lot more, not surprisingly. Like how it was Albus was able to write that letter to Minerva for Carson, and understand how he felt.I am weeping again. This is so sad, and so human. The depth to your characters and their emotions and experiences is amazing. Take care.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Thank you! I am feeling better today and hope to get some writing done.
I am glad you are enjoying rereading the story. That part with Carson was actually difficult for me to write, and I am glad that it is moving for you.
I appreciate your review and kind words! Thanks very much!
“I would treat you well, if you were mine . . . if you were my wizard . . . .” She's not talking about as a cat, Albus!!! Have a little more cognac, both of you. Keep talking.Drat. They came close, but didn't quite get there.You are taking the art of almost to a whole new level.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
I love it when I take things to whole new levels! Haha! Glad you enjoyed that little exchange. ;D Thanks for reviewing!
I forgot to say on my earlier review--congrats on the 100th chapter!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Thanks! It felt like some kind of milestone when I had a single Roman numeral for the first time since "L"! *grin*
(And if this review confuses anyone, I am posting RaM on ffnet, as well, and some of the very short early chapters were combined when I polished them for the moderated archives, therefore RaM is up to chapter 100 on ffnet, which is the same as chapter 81 over here.)
Lights in the headmaster's tower, eh? How much should I bet that Albus was watching their goodbye at the gate? *cough* Anyway, thank you for yet another lovely chapter!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
You're welcome! Glad you enjoyed i! :D Thanks for reviewing. (And no hints forthcoming! *wink*)
Response from HermioneDancr (Reviewer)
I wouldn't expect them, really. I just enjoy speculating!
Quin is awfully likeable, and I hope he's going to be persistent enough to push Minerva to admit her feelings for Albus. I liked the idea of the Ministry's laws being so convoluted that you can't manufacture the same items for muggles and wizards, that their crazy system would doom the wizarding world to financial collapse if some smart individuals didn't work around the system to prop it up. That seems in keeping with the Ministry as presented by JKR.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
I think Quin is a pretty persistent fellow, and he's practically gotten her to admit it already, so it's just a matter of the "correct time and place" -- and I'm sure he will arrange that if she doesn't! *grin* Glad you like my bit of idiotic Ministry laws! Thanks very much for reviewing!
What a good friend Quin has turned out to be. He's intelligent, charming, intuitive, successful. If Minerva doesn't want him, I'm single.What a horrifying death for Gertie's husband and for the people who loved him to have to sit by, helpless. With Quin wishing her well, surely Minerva will have a breakthrough in her relationship with Albus?Thank you for giving me a new chapter of Resolving a Misunderstanding and making my whole evening better.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
You're welcome! I'm glad the chapter brightened your evening.
See why Albus keeps saying he's "a catch"? *grin* And why he thought Gertie had brought Minerva down to the Gamps for he purpose of introducing them?
Thanks very much for the review!
Clever use of a Jarvey. They are one of JKR's more interesting creations, but too many authors give them human like intelligence. Rather like the old Lassie television show where Lassie seemed capable of planning and making decisions about how best to rescue Timmy from whatever dangerous situation he was in. Your Jarvey is more like an enhanced parrot and more believable.Albus and Minerva are about to have another misunderstanding, aren't they? Heavy sigh.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Glad you liked the Jarvey. Seemed amusing to have it like a sort of extra-clever and very rude parrot. *grin* And Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them definitely said they weren't intelligent -- although I think it could be funny to have an intelligent Jarvey in a story, too. I only wish they had given examples of their insults! And that I'd had a drunken Auror around! Haha!
Don't worry too much about our couple. Remember that Albus sent her off on a date -- with a rather inappropriate person, but, hey! -- and the date didn't separate them.
Thanks for reviewing!
Alright, I've read this entire story in a little over... lets see, 13 hours. I have literally sat and done nothing else. It was fantastic, and I enjoyed it immensly. I cannot wait for the next chapter!!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
OMG! *clunk* <falls over in a faint at the thought!>
Wow, that is both impressive and immensely flattering! I am very glad you enjoyed it so much! (And I can't imagine how exhausted you must be!)
The next chapter should be up in the next day or so, so check back soon.
Thanks so much for letting me know you are enjoying the story. I'm very glad it entertained you and sustained your interest for 13 straight hours! I hope it continues to entertain you!
The first paragraph seems to be missing a sentence or two. It doesn't make sense.Perhaps sometime Albus will come home and find a cat curled up in the middle of his four poster? Here it is that Albus offered to assist - offered to do anything to assist and Minerva didn't take full advantage. Foolish girl! Her back probably could have used a good scrubbing.You are becoming most proficient at putting the two of them in situations where they almost but not quite have their moment of truth.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
It was missing more than a sentence or two, and I can't figure out how that happened, as the doc that I cut and pasted from is complete. D'oh! Anyway, there are now a few more paragraphs, if you'd like to go back and get the full flavor of it! (I recommend that!)
Response from Hypnobarb (Reviewer)
Oh yes, it does make much more sense now. What a rude awakening from a very pleasant dream. Talk about a wet blanket!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Thank you! both for the review and for pointing out the weird deletion. There must have been something highlighted accidentally and somehow it got deleted. *shrug* Thanks again!
Oh, this is killing me! Out of curiousity, how many chapters do you have planned? I can't wait for them to get together, although I hope you don't end it right there. I'd like to read about them more as a couple too.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
It's hard to say how many chapters it will be, even though it is all outlined. Each section of the outline may be more than one chapter, depending on how things break out. I would say we are between two-thirds and three-quarters of the way through. There are a few more big events to come, so there's lots of "story" left in the story!
Don't worry, the story won't end with the moment they finally recognise the mutuality of their feelings, and there will be romance and fluffiness in those chapters as a reward for the characters and the readers for making it through! *grin* And there very well may be a sequel.
Thanks very much for the review!
I can't help but wonder if there is magical significance to come in the little shrine Minerva is building to Albus?Fantasies can be good. Now they need to start mentally rehearsing what to say to reveal their feelings. That way, when the moment of blurt arises, they'll have something worked out. Or they could go for something completely spontaneous.Honestly, any way they can manage it would be acceptable. They just keep moping, mooning, and pining. If she thinks too much about the sympathy between their magic, she's going to convince herself he's all fatherly about her and they'll just keep going in circles.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Hmm, what to say in response . . . well, I can say that they will manage it. As for the rest, those are all interesting thoughts to consider!
Thanks very much for the review! Next chapter is "Meeting Morag." I think it may make you smile.
oh,so close!they are so stubborn but it feels like they will get together soon,please?!this story has me hooked and im starting to quite like this pairing so well done and cant wait until the next update :)
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
There is more "story" between now and then, which may or may not be a good thing, if you are hooked! *grin* I'm glad you like the pairing, and I hope it continues to entertain! Thanks for reviewing!
Today was a very good one for Minerva. She solidified her relationship with her coworkers, thought through a few issues, and very nearly kissed Albus.It feels like the moment of blurt is close at hand!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
The Moment of Blurt! *grin* Glad you enjoyed it. Thanks for reviewing!
Another misunderstanding and more heartache. It is wonderful to see them talk it through and resolve the issue before the two of them get caught up in a cycle of frustration caused by filling in the blanks with wrong answers.What a romantic moment right there at the end. Sigh...
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Thank you. The two of them are making some progress, and Minerva certainly made quite a bit herself.
I'm glad you liked the little romantic moment at the end.
I'm really behind reading Looking for Magic, BTW, three chapters, I think. I hope to have some time this week, but I'm also beta-reading, and you know how RL can also demand some attention! LOL!
Thanks for the review!
For the sake of Albus' health, he should recognize that Minerva can help him ward off parasites and buffet strong winds.Not many girlfriends could do that for a guy. A foot rub on occasion, maybe, but not warding off parasites.Snicker.Johannes had better not make those regards to Rudolf too warm.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
I know -- and those parasites, they can be pesky things, so he's quite the lucky guy! ;-)
Thanks for the review!
Well. Unlike the couple in question, Quin can put one plus one together and come up with two. He figured out the identity of the mystery man right quick."He settled the tray on the table with nary a ripple in the coffee." With the way it looked with the font and not having my reading glasses on, I thought it read "nary a nipple in the coffee". I couldn't for the life of me figure out what in the world you were getting at. I spent a moment or two trying to figure out if that was a wizarding treat like a Hershey's Kiss? Or was it some sort of British slang I'd never heard of? I busted out laughing when I realized I had misread it.That was a lovely ending; a truly romantic moment. Now, if they could accidently apparate into a locked supply closet for a few hours, I'm sure it could be all sorted out nicely. They would certainly figure out something to do with themselves.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Oh, my, that gave me quite a nice laugh! And amusing to think that you would assume that I'd meant something by it! (And I know all about the travails of reading glasses! And progressive lenses -- which are not all they're cracked up to be, IMO.)
Glad you liked the ending. There are some nice romantic moments to come, as well . . . and they still remain clueless. Of course, there are some bumps, a slip, a fall . . .
We get to see more of Quin again fairly soon. He is a very bright boy! *grin* But he'll wait for Minerva to confirm it before giving her much more advice.
Thanks for reviewing!
What's the saying "Denial isn't just a river in Egypt"? It was so thoughtful of Poppy to say such encouraging things to Albus. Doing a bit of matchmaking on the side?That was very thoughtful of Albus to arrange such a nice date for Minerva. It was very thoughtful of Minerva to enjoy Filius' company so much that she wants to set him up with one of her friends. It was thoughtful of Minerva to come bid Albus goodnight even though she was tipsy. It was thoughtful of Albus to escort her down the stairs and to be charming enough to warrant a kiss on the cheek.The minute these two get a clue, they are going to explode. And you're going to be there writing it all down, aren't you?Why do I have the feeling that Albus wouldn't mind peeing bright purple all the time? The man does have a thing for color.A very bright and cheerful chapter.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Your review had me smiling!
They truly are clueless about each other, aren't they, despite their intelligence!
You bet I'll be there writing it all down! I'm more of a voyeur than Minerva, who closed her eyes during most of her visit to Hagrid's vegetable garden. Not that I blame her there! haha!
He will probably find it quite amusing to pee purple! Hee! And be disappointed when it fades away. *grin*
And Poppy has an inkling about Minerva's feelings, though neither of them has addressed it directly. She's not completely sure about Albus, but figures a little more time together, and something nice might happen for them, if it's meant to!
Thanks very much for your review!
Minnie and Flitwick? What was Albus smoking? At least Minnie's tongue was loosened by the alcohol and she was a bit more bold. I also liked Poppy trying to get Albus to spend more time with Minnie to get her to have fun. Good work!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Well, did you ever consider that maybe he subconsciously didn't really want it to work out -- even though both Minerva and Flitwick are friends of his? Minerva didn't even guess that he was trying to set them up, the idea was so far out there. *grin* Poppy's trying to be a good friend to Minerva, even if she's not 100% sure what's going on with Minerva.
Yay, another little breakthrough! Good for both of them. The dessert sounds positively yummy and I wish I could possibly find a pastry shop that would make it.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Thanks! Glad you enjoyed the description of the dessert. :D And they keep getting closer, despite themselves.
That was a date.Those two can call it anything they like, but it looks, walks, and quacks like a date.A guy who goes to town and gets his lady love a dessert like that knows how to go courting. Any minute now, something is going to happen and they are going to end up in each other's arms. I wish I had access to Madam Puddifoots. Your description of that black forrest torte sounds heavenly. I am getting up right now to get into my stash of chocolate and it is all your fault.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Got your mouth watering, did I? *grin*
Actually, one of the upcoming chapters is titled, "If This Were a Date . . ." So there are more non-date dates to come! And yes, that was very date-like. I love writing romantic scenes while they're both still in denial . . . it's so much fun! And Albus certainly does know how to court a lady, you're right about that!
The next chapter is called "A Date for Minerva," and Albus has a "brilliant" idea. Well, not so brilliant, maybe, but it works out nicely, anyway!
Go eat your chocolate and dream of Madam Puddifoots! And thank you for reviewing!