New Chapter for Resolving a Misunderstanding
Resolving a Misunderstanding
MMADfan954 Reviews | 6.45/10 (954 Ratings, 0 Likes, 108 Favorites )
Minerva has just finished her first term teaching. A series of misunderstandings leads to an embarrassing moment, injured feelings, regret, growing understanding, then resolution. A Minerva McGonagall fic set in 1957, with forays into the past. More than a Romance; stories within stories. Features Minerva, Albus, and Poppy, with appearances by Slughorn, Grubbly-Plank, Hagrid, Flitwick, Moody, Riddle, Grindelwald, and other canon characters. Not DH-compliant. Disregards DH.
Nineteen Parts.
Most content T-rated, but ratings rise to M and MA for several later chapters. Overall M rating reflects later content.
Pertinent warnings in individual chapter summaries.
Voted First Place, Minerva McGonagall: Legacy Fic, in the HP Fanfiction Fan Poll Awards Spring/Summer 2013.
Chapters (141)
About MMADfan
Author
MMADfan
41 Stories | Favorited by 312 | 127 Reviews Written | 4,741 Review Responses
Note 10 December 2015: I've been unable to write fanfic the last couple years, but I haven't abandoned my works-in-progress!
Many of my completed fics are available for download in ebook format through my blog and LJ.
Perfect Imagination accredited beta. PI:7311261659.
More about me here.
Reviews for Resolving a Misunderstanding
Minerva's parents are truly lovely - and I love the dynamic between them in the dialogues you write. I am looking forward to finding out how Albus will react...
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Glad you enjoy her parents! They are fun to write.Albus is brilliant, but sometimes clueless. He gets these ideas in his head, you know! LOL!Thanks for reviewing! I really appreciate it!
Hi, so this is the first review I leave, but I should have done this much earlier since I enjoy reading your story very much. I am impressed by its detailed and complex structure. It is also very, very well written, which is something I appreciate a lot in fanfiction (and in all other writing as well, of course) - there are so many brilliant ideas out there, but so many of them are so badly realized that it is hard to stick with some of the stories. What I especially liked about this chapter is the conversation Minerva has with Johannes and Wilhelmina in the staff room. It makes some of the minor characters come alive.Looking forward to reading the rest of the story,Inga
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Thank you, Inga! I really appreciate your review!There's a lot going on in this story -- as you have no doubt noticed, it's a long one! -- and I'm glad you're enjoying the complex structure and detail.I enjoy trying to add depth to a story through having the minor characters provide some interest.Thanks very much for the review!
Hello, still reading avidly. This chapter was so sad! I just had to cry and this nearly never happens with fanfiction. Very well-written and realistic.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Thank you. That was a very emotional chapter, even to write it. I'm glad you liked it.You finished DD, BTW? I was curious . . . I hope you continue to enjoy Resolving a Misunderstanding! I appreciate the reviews. :-)
Hello, after reading an act of love and deaths dominion I decided to also at least get started on this epic fic. Although I am not normally an ad/mm reader (although I like the pairing) I like your writing style and I must say I do really enjoy reading this fic. I am interested though what Albus's thoughts were on all these events we now see from Minerva's point of view. I guess he might not even know at this point in the presen tof the story that he likes Minerva more then just as a friend.
Greetings, Quirkyfish
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
If I remember correctly, "A Success" takes place when Minerva is a student. At that point, Albus cares for Minerva as a child, as a precocious student, not really even as a friend. You're right, though, in that although we do occasionally have some chapters from Albus's POV, this is really Minerva's story more than Albus's. I'm glad you're enjoying the story. It's divisible into fairly clear sections, so even though it's long, it's got obvious stages and it progresses from chapter to chapter. The current section is the "Minerva-in-school" part of the story. :-)Thanks for the review! I hope that you continue to enjoy the story!
Wo0t!Creative end to a creative story!Loved it every step of the way!I love how the story line was complex enough so i wouldn't get bored. It was never boring PWP!I <3 Plots with P=D
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Thank you! I could have easily made a PWP by jumping from the first couple chapters to the "culmination" and the epilogue, but I like plot, too! ;-) And no one could say that RaM was light on plot! haha -- and good to hear you were never bored.
Thanks for reviewing!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Thank you! I could have easily made a PWP by jumping from the first couple chapters to the "culmination" and the epilogue, but I like plot, too! ;-) And no one could say that RaM was light on plot! haha -- and good to hear you were never bored.
Thanks for reviewing!
This is fabulous. You held my attention from start to finish, all 141 chapters. I can't wait to read your other stories.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Thank you very much! I'm very glad that you enjoyed it so much!If I could make a recommendation, I'd say read A Holiday with the Headmaster next, since that takes place between the chapters "The Silent Knight's Tale" and "Back to Hogwarts." Or if you want to read something seasonal, you could try "The Unsentimental Arithmancer" and "A Christmas for Aberforth." They're also both set in the same universe as Resolving a Misunderstanding. I hope you enjoy my other stories. (If you read Death's Dominion, bear in mind that perspective is important and that there's a mystery going on there! )Thanks again!
hi,i'm loveing this story i have been reading the T version till i found this one i'm up to the part where minerva oes to see proff gamp and her family. it's a great story and your use of cannon has been fantastic keep righting stories because i believe you have a good stile. it reads good with the screen reader
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Hi! I'm glad that you are enjoying the story and that the screen reader does a good job with it! Thanks very much for letting me know you're enjoying it! I really appreciate that!
Response from harrypotter6116 (Reviewer)
thanks for righting back i'm still reading on and loveing it more and more i find no flor so far.Michael
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Hi! I'm glad that you are enjoying the story and that the screen reader does a good job with it! Thanks very much for letting me know you're enjoying it! I really appreciate that!
Response from harrypotter6116 (Reviewer)
thanks for righting back i'm still reading on and loveing it more and more i find no flor so far.Michael
I just finished RaM and absolutely loved it! You are very talented and imaginative. Your original characters are so fully developed that its hard to believe that they aren't part of the Harry Potter books. While I enjoyed seeing AD and MM's story develop I have to say that Gertrude Gamp is my favorite character in this story and I really enjoyed her and Malcom's relationship. Any chance that you'll write a Gertrude/Malcolm story (a love interest for Quin would be nice too)? Thank you for the many enjoyable hours I spent reading this story. I'm going to start DD now but know that I'll be rereading RaM soon.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Thank you so much, Esmelle! You just brought a big smile to my face.I adore Malcolm, myself. He's my favorite RaM OC, and I do plan a Gertrude/Malcolm romance -- at least a RaM sequel with a very lot of Gertrude and Malcolm in it! And Gertrude was one of my favorites, too -- I loved the way that, when RaM was a WIP, some people didn't like her or understand her because they were caught up in Minerva's biased POV of her, and then they later came to really like her. (Oh, there's a tiny touch of Gertrude and Malcolm in "Now is Perfect," too.)A number of familiar characters pop up in DD, and I hope you will enjoy that. It's written differently from either RaM of AAoL, and DD has a much more nonlinear structure than either of the other stories. It's important to remember the nature of Minerva's relationship w/ Albus when reading DD, and I mean that in a most positive way. And not to forget that perspective is important. (If you haven't read An Act of Love, I recommend you read just the epilogue before you read DD even if you don't feel like reading all of AAoL -- which is unnecessary to read first, although it directly precedes DD and DD stems from it. In DD, I recapped the most essential bits of AAoL so it can be read by itself.)I know some people hate OCs without exception and won't read stories with them -- and I'm not fond of Mary Sues or poorly done OCs, myself -- but it would have been hard to write a story spanning the years that RaM did without using OCs, not to mention that RaM itself would not have been possible. Anyway, I'm very glad you enjoyed the story and the characters! Oh, and if you like Gertrude, you should read "The Unsentimental Arithmancer," which is a one-shot set when she is young, just after she first becomes acquainted with Albus.Thanks again for the review! I really appreciated it! Hope you continue to enjoy the RaM-verse fics -- I think there are seven of them now.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Thank you so much, Esmelle! You just brought a big smile to my face.I adore Malcolm, myself. He's my favorite RaM OC, and I do plan a Gertrude/Malcolm romance -- at least a RaM sequel with a very lot of Gertrude and Malcolm in it! And Gertrude was one of my favorites, too -- I loved the way that, when RaM was a WIP, some people didn't like her or understand her because they were caught up in Minerva's biased POV of her, and then they later came to really like her. (Oh, there's a tiny touch of Gertrude and Malcolm in "Now is Perfect," too.)A number of familiar characters pop up in DD, and I hope you will enjoy that. It's written differently from either RaM of AAoL, and DD has a much more nonlinear structure than either of the other stories. It's important to remember the nature of Minerva's relationship w/ Albus when reading DD, and I mean that in a most positive way. And not to forget that perspective is important. (If you haven't read An Act of Love, I recommend you read just the epilogue before you read DD even if you don't feel like reading all of AAoL -- which is unnecessary to read first, although it directly precedes DD and DD stems from it. In DD, I recapped the most essential bits of AAoL so it can be read by itself.)I know some people hate OCs without exception and won't read stories with them -- and I'm not fond of Mary Sues or poorly done OCs, myself -- but it would have been hard to write a story spanning the years that RaM did without using OCs, not to mention that RaM itself would not have been possible. Anyway, I'm very glad you enjoyed the story and the characters! Oh, and if you like Gertrude, you should read "The Unsentimental Arithmancer," which is a one-shot set when she is young, just after she first becomes acquainted with Albus.Thanks again for the review! I really appreciated it! Hope you continue to enjoy the RaM-verse fics -- I think there are seven of them now.
Again a brilliant chapter - I'm going to have to stop saying that for every chapter, even though it is true.The age gap between Murdoch & Minerva really helps explain why she's so studious. He does love to tease her though doesn't he? Then again isn't that what big brothers are for.It seems understandable that Minerva is upset with having a different classroom but I think perhaps Albus is just trying to make her feel as though her teaching style would not being compared to his and be a fresh start.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Oh, I don't think any writer could tire of hearing those words! LOL! *blush*It seems understandable that Minerva is upset with having a different classroom but I think perhaps Albus is just trying to make her feel as though her teaching style would not being compared to his and be a fresh start.Very perceptive of you -- a pity that Albus didn't think to mention it!Thanks for the review!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Oh, I don't think any writer could tire of hearing those words! LOL! *blush*It seems understandable that Minerva is upset with having a different classroom but I think perhaps Albus is just trying to make her feel as though her teaching style would not being compared to his and be a fresh start.Very perceptive of you -- a pity that Albus didn't think to mention it!Thanks for the review!
Yet another great chapter. Albus and his lists - bless him! Although he is starting to understand how he could have upset Minerva I do hope Albus is not so endearingly clueless in future. I like how you portray the 12 yr old Minerva - I doubt anything can stop her from studying and such intelligent spell-work.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Glad you liked the lists! And Albus does remain clueless for a good while -- usually endearingly so! The story covers a good many years, though the "primary" story line is set in the summer of 1957. It's always a good thing to remember how many days or weeks have passed, since it is a long story, and sometimes it can feel to the reader as though much more time has passed than really has, if that makes any sense. *grin*I'm glad you liked student Minerva. I don't usually write anyone as a student, but I enjoyed writing her very much.Thanks for the review!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Glad you liked the lists! And Albus does remain clueless for a good while -- usually endearingly so! The story covers a good many years, though the "primary" story line is set in the summer of 1957. It's always a good thing to remember how many days or weeks have passed, since it is a long story, and sometimes it can feel to the reader as though much more time has passed than really has, if that makes any sense. *grin*I'm glad you liked student Minerva. I don't usually write anyone as a student, but I enjoyed writing her very much.Thanks for the review!
This is a great first chapter. I really like your ability to enable your readers to visualize your stories.Your writing is very clear, concise and extremely descriptive. I also really like how you have started off part way into the story and are going back.Sorry if this review seems short and un-detailed but new to reviewing, so still unsure how to word it.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Thanks! And your review was fine. Writers always like to know what a reader liked about the chapter. It's a long story, so pace yourself! LOL!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Thanks! And your review was fine. Writers always like to know what a reader liked about the chapter. It's a long story, so pace yourself! LOL!
Your story was truly marvellous - well-plotted and well-written. I've enjoyed every bit of it!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Thanks, :)
This is by far the best MMAD story I've read! Congratulations on completing it, though the ending is bittersweet to your fans... I wish you could continue the plot forever! Thank you for your frequent updates and incredible writing!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Thank you very much for your kind words! In some world somewhere, perhaps the plot does go on forever! There will be other MMAD stories set in the RaM universe, I hope, in addition to those already written. Thanks again! I'm very glad you enjoyed the story!
*Gigglesnort*I have read a lot of fanfiction in my day, but this chapter takes the cake for originality. No one, absolutely no one has ever done beard sex before. I don't think anyone has thought of it before. A completely unique bit of expositionary writing. You are brilliant, but scary.It is so hard to think of this story being considered complete. It isn't in the sense that you have Death's Dominion in progress and you've treated us to bits and pieces in between.I do hope you will give us their wedding and the reasoning behind their decision to keep their marriage secret.At the beginning, I was a little queasy about Dumbledore sex, but you converted me into finding his relationship with Minerva hot. You made me a MMADfan, too. Thank you for all eight hundred thousand plus words.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
LOL! I have to admit that as soon as I had Albus talk about Aberforth's failed virility potion made with goathorn, and that it had unfortunate side-effects, that side-effect sprang to mind. Combine that with Minerva's expletive, and what do you get? Yep, that is one strange set of associations! Anyway, it's nice to be unique! I am especially happy, naturally, that you are a MMADfan now, too! You're welcome for the the eight hundred thousand plus words! I have notes for other stories about Albus & Minerva, and we'll see if I can find the time, energy, and creativity to write them once I'm finished with DD. I may take a bit of a break. But I do have ideas, and I may find I have to write them, just as I had to write RaM. In the meantime, I may be able to catch up on some of my fanfic reading!Thanks again for all your reviews. I've really enjoyed reading them.
HOW IN THE HECK AM I SUPPOSED TO CONCENTRATE AT WORK NOW??? That's is missy! I'm officially the PRESIDENT OF YOUR FAN CLUB! That was a fantastic birthday and I really wish I could "borrow" Albus for my birthday! I'm sure I could think of a few bits of "experimental magic" of my own...tee hee. You really did a wonderful job of pulling the story together from beginning to end and bringing the story to a perfect closure. However, I will not protest should you happen to write more ADMM lemons!!! WINK WINK, NUDGE NUDGE!Albus' gifts for Minerva were perfect and the opal sounded lovely. He really went out of his way to lavish her with gifts and I'm sure it's her best birthday ever. I know it would be mine. Oh and one more thing...CHEERS FOR POSTING!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
You and Di are both sooooo funny! (Yeah, "cheers for breathing," too!)I'm very glad that you liked the full-circle the story took. As for more ADMM lemons, I might write a few, you never know!Thanks very much! We'll see what else may come!
Response from HogwartsDuo (Reviewer)
Cheers for Breathing!!! Oh that's a good one. I'll have to remember that one for the next time you write a long story for ADMM.
Oh my goodness. Talk about full-circle! I love the title, and certainly would not have thought it truly possible other than...mmmmm, chest hair, mmmm, beard brushing the bare breasts, mmmmm....sorry, what was I saying?How imaginative (and distracting) on both their parts! And we didn't even get to the headboard/footboard section, did we? Tie me up, tie me down, and fix up an Albus ice cream sundae!Woohoo!I must add, as always, CFP Not to be nosy or anything...there have got to be a few lemony bits between now (Epilogue) and Obliging Minerva.Rock on and you da Bombe. Yeah. You are.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
"and fix me an Albus ice cream sundae!"Well, we don't know what they might get up to when fixing their snack, do we? If you want to create a PWP, go with the first chapter and the epilogue, and with a few minor changes, voila! A PWP. But I didn't want to write a PWP, so I added a little bit of plot. Hee!I am certain there will be more than a few lemony moments between the epilogue and "Obliging Minerva"! And a few of them may actually get written!Very glad you enjoyed it! And you are still VERY amusing! (CFP, indeed!)Thanks much for reviewing! (And I love being da Bombe!)
Response from dmf1984 (Reviewer)
Ben and Jerry's new "Albus flavored" ice cream: Lemon stick! Of course, we could always go for a UK Ben and Jerry's...calling it Lemon spotted dick. But that would be naughty... I am trying not to disturb my students while they are taking their exam...rather difficult that.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Oh, yes, that would be naughty! And we are never naughty, are we?
Response from dmf1984 (Reviewer)
"I'm not bad, I'm just drawn that way" Jessica Rabbit*snerk*
A great ending to a great story!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Thank you!
Again, I really enjoy this story, along with your others! Yet, my love of reading has gotten me into a 'fix'....... When reading the DD's latest, I became curious about something & decided to cross-reference RaM; however, now I have a problem. I'm confused :( Around chapter 30?, Gertie and Albus are speaking, and she's thinking of "changing her mind" - as she's in Cornwall, she'll owl him her answer; Minerva wants to know what's going on, & Albus says that he'll tell her when he can. However, after frantic searching and re-reading, I don't think that he ever does, unless I'm blind and can't see it - this is very probable, lol. I've always presumed that it was about her continuing as Deputy; is that it, or something else? Help! Please! Thanks. BT
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Yes, it was about remaining Deputy. She changed her mind and agreed to stay on one more year. She and Albus had a conversation about it in "Collision" -- I don't remember offhand which chapter that is -- and she signed a new contract for a year. She and Minerva later have a conversation about it in one of the chapters about Pretnick's death. Minerva never asked Albus about it again, so it never arose in precisely that sort of context. Albus also saw it as being nothing that needed mentioning since the status quo wasn't changing; it would have been more of an event if Gertrude had decided not to continue and Albus had to decide what to do about a Deputy at that point. I'm glad you enjoy the story so much!
Response from BlackTea (Reviewer)
Thank you; it was driving me mad! So kind of you to detail it for me! I particularly recall the Gertie being deputy conversations, but do not remember if I ever fully connected them to the letter & answer - certainly not when I went back to check if I remembered something else. Thank you, and good luck with DD.
Have I mentioned that I love Marc Chagall? ;-)
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
I adore his stuff, myself. I think he's my favorite 20th c artist.
Absolutely fantastic!!! Can't wait to read "A Holiday...!" Just goin over there right now...:)
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Thank you! I'm very glad you've enjoyed it!
"Cheers for posting.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
3W;LMN/4Z5EX7V 8Y0-.7E5X86RC79TV8YBIUNM,P.0[-Ujhloih/g0]2ik['/@ 6/]\",5/5/08 0:55,9/1/20 17:56,0,
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
66001,8860,9139,"Hrm
Ice cream, a walk along the streets of the city, warm fuzzy feelings....ahhh, it must be looooove!!!!Such lovely little outings for our dear couple sure gave me hope when I read this the first time.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
He was taking her on dates even when neither of them would call them that! :)Thanks!
Minerva has a heart of gold. If she's not trying to protect Albus and play Mother McGonagall, she's spending all of her money on a broom for Hagrid. What an incredible witch and one that Albus is very fortunate to have by his side...aweee. I'm sure Hagrid will never forget Minerva's kindness, not to mention her friendship over the years.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
She remains very fond of him their whole lives, doesn't she? Given how she felt about what happened to Hagrid, it didn't seem any kind of sacrifice to buy Hagrid a broom he could actually ride.Thanks for the review! Or "cheers"!
I was so not amused when I read this chapter the first time. The absolute audacity of Professor Gamp to scold Minerva on Albus Dumbledore's behalf. Oh I was not amused in the least. Once I learned what Gertie's backstory with Albus really was and she found a beau of her own, my heart softened towards the witch.I'm glad it all worked out in the end.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
She was her professor. It is also her duty, as well. And she was much nicer to her than I would have been -- I probably would have sent her home! (Well, maybe not, but I sure would have been tempted.)It is the responsibility of a teacher to teach, and that includes the creative discipline that Gertrude used in this chapter. She wasn't audacious; she was doing her job, and offering some very wise advice to Minerva. It did work out -- and now my cats are telling me I'm late with their supper! Better go before they rampage! Haha!
WOOOOOOWWWWWWZZZZEEEERRRSSSS!!! YOU WERE ABLE TO POST A CHAPTER???? gasp...I mean, I think I might faint! Who knew it was possible to cut and paste or even...dare I suggest it...simply upload a file into the site.....I think I need to go stretch out for a bit. I'm feeling rather faint.Oh and GREAT CHAPTER!!!! TRES TRES BIEN!!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
I know! The blood, sweat and tears that go into posting! Yep, you sure do think you're funny, don't you! (LOL!)Glad you enjoyed the chapter, too!