New Chapter for Resolving a Misunderstanding
Resolving a Misunderstanding
MMADfan954 Reviews | 6.45/10 (954 Ratings, 0 Likes, 108 Favorites )
Minerva has just finished her first term teaching. A series of misunderstandings leads to an embarrassing moment, injured feelings, regret, growing understanding, then resolution. A Minerva McGonagall fic set in 1957, with forays into the past. More than a Romance; stories within stories. Features Minerva, Albus, and Poppy, with appearances by Slughorn, Grubbly-Plank, Hagrid, Flitwick, Moody, Riddle, Grindelwald, and other canon characters. Not DH-compliant. Disregards DH.
Nineteen Parts.
Most content T-rated, but ratings rise to M and MA for several later chapters. Overall M rating reflects later content.
Pertinent warnings in individual chapter summaries.
Voted First Place, Minerva McGonagall: Legacy Fic, in the HP Fanfiction Fan Poll Awards Spring/Summer 2013.
Chapters (141)
About MMADfan
Author
MMADfan
41 Stories | Favorited by 312 | 127 Reviews Written | 4,741 Review Responses
Note 10 December 2015: I've been unable to write fanfic the last couple years, but I haven't abandoned my works-in-progress!
Many of my completed fics are available for download in ebook format through my blog and LJ.
Perfect Imagination accredited beta. PI:7311261659.
More about me here.
Reviews for Resolving a Misunderstanding
This is definitely a dinner party where no one is what they seem and anything that might be a compliment has a sharp edge to it. Rather like an Edwardian comedy of manners.You do such a lovely job of creating atmosphere. I can feel the tension of being present at a social even where the unwritten goal is to score points against the guests. No wonder Gertie wanted company.And Quin is quite the flirt, too.Minerva will have to learn some Slytherin skills to navigate her way through these waters.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Thanks for the review! We've got a lot of "party" to come -- and, of course, a few glimpses of what Albus is up to -- and I'm sure you'll be happy to hear that we haven't seen the last of Valerianna and "Franky"! And Quin, of course!
Thank you for reviewing!
Hedge wizard, eh? Someone was tweaked and not feeling up to properly retaliating. Will we learn more about Frank? Lol.
They do seem to be quite horrid relatives, and talking to the matron of the family of someone you don't really know would be really bad. Quin doesn't seem so bad though.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Yeah, Frank was a little out of sorts, wasn't he? And Minerva's there for a few more days, so we'll see Frankie again, and Valerianna, too! And, of course, Quin.
Thank you for reviewing!
FINALLY! (And might I just say that I utterly adore reading Quin? His in-my-head voice is just charming)
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Yes, I thought this might be a "FINALLY!" sort of review!Very glad you enjoy reading Quin so much -- and that his in-your-head voice is as charming as it should be! (His dialogue always had me going over it a few more times than that of other characters, so it's good to know you like it.)Thanks for the review!
Wow! That was certainly a dramatic entrance on the part of Fawkes! He proved himself a loyal friend to Albus and Minerva through his prompt delivery of that letter, and no doubt shocked poor Egeria in the process! It must be a real shock to have a phoenix burst into her room like that.That letter was wonderful, and I'm glad to see that Quin seems to have awakened the poet in Albus. The poem was beautiful, and the comparisons used in the beginning were very witty: “Sweeter than any putrid potion,“More scintillating than Transfiguration class,“Of greater worth than any treaty, “Thus I respect thee.”Now that the misunderstanding seems to finally be wrapping itself up and our wayward couple finally realizing the truth about their feelings and their relationship, I look forward to seeing their new, revealed love develop further. Needless to say, I am eternally grateful to Egeria, Quin, and Fawkes for helping to lead Albus and Minerva out of the confusion that they have been in.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
The poem that Albus enclosed is one that he had written earlier in the summer. He'd started with that funny bit back at the beginning of the summer when they had their misunderstanding about their meeting & his "beard conditioning," then when he was missing Minerva when she was at the Gamps, he wrote the rest. He figured that in for a penny, in for a pound, so he enclosed it with his letter, trying to let her know how important she was to him, and how deep his feelings for her were. He certainly waited with trepidation, wondering what Minerva would think of his strong feelings for her. I remember when I was writing this story, people were worried that it would end as soon as the two of them got together, but no such luck! LOL! (Just kidding!) I figured after such a long time getting there, and such a bumpy road, the two deserved a bit of happiness together in the story, and readers deserved a bit of "payoff," seeing how they related to each other once they had put the misunderstanding behind them -- and also, I wanted to be able to reveal, to Minerva and the readers, why Albus's misgivings and insecurities were as strong as they were -- after all, he's normally a fairly confident wizard, and even with some worries about age-difference, etc., he was a bit over-the-top with his reaction to having kissed her that time. There's more of a story to that, but Minerva will help Albus uncover it and get past it. Thanks very much for the review! I'm very glad you're still enjoying the story!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
The poem that Albus enclosed is one that he had written earlier in the summer. He'd started with that funny bit back at the beginning of the summer when they had their misunderstanding about their meeting & his "beard conditioning," then when he was missing Minerva when she was at the Gamps, he wrote the rest. He figured that in for a penny, in for a pound, so he enclosed it with his letter, trying to let her know how important she was to him, and how deep his feelings for her were. He certainly waited with trepidation, wondering what Minerva would think of his strong feelings for her. I remember when I was writing this story, people were worried that it would end as soon as the two of them got together, but no such luck! LOL! (Just kidding!) I figured after such a long time getting there, and such a bumpy road, the two deserved a bit of happiness together in the story, and readers deserved a bit of "payoff," seeing how they related to each other once they had put the misunderstanding behind them -- and also, I wanted to be able to reveal, to Minerva and the readers, why Albus's misgivings and insecurities were as strong as they were -- after all, he's normally a fairly confident wizard, and even with some worries about age-difference, etc., he was a bit over-the-top with his reaction to having kissed her that time. There's more of a story to that, but Minerva will help Albus uncover it and get past it. Thanks very much for the review! I'm very glad you're still enjoying the story!
AARGH! While many moons ago I rejoiced at the length and in-depthiness of this fic, now I curse it! The tension is killing me, and I cannot bear much more of this careful tiptoeing. Dear Goddess, intervene and plop these two in a hot tub together, something!Ahem. Meanwhile, back where there is dignity... nope. Sorry, no dignity here, just this reviewer's unspeakable frustration with these characters and their endless hesitance!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Oh, don't worry, Fate will intervene!Remember, it isn't quite endless for them, since Minerva's fit of temper in the first chapter occurred on the fourth of July and the Headmaster's holiday is only at the very beginning of August. But you are getting very close to Fate intervening! (But it won't be a hot tub, though that's a lovely idea! )Really, though, the tension is mounting for them, too, and it will lead to, um, well, to the relief of your tension! I do hope that it doesn't kill you before it reaches its crescendo and gets relieved!
Ack! I knew it! *Gleeful smiles all around* Though getting stuck as an involuntary voyeur isn't always an awful thing, I do feel for the rather... vanilla Minerva. Ever since the underwear scene, I'd thought that there was some romantic possibility, and I'm thrilled to be vindicated. As for the rest of the story, I've made it 65 chapters without reviewing (shame!), but I've really loved every one. Though it's frustrating to watch and be helpless, I really like how Minerva and Dumbles are progressing- slowly, awkwardly, and obliviously. Of course they wouldn't just fall into one anothers' arms- it's not their personality! Although I'm in danger of never leaving my computer again, I really like that you've taken the time and detail to show how this pairing could happen. Especially nice is how well-built the surrounding characters are- a good backdrop is essential to a good story, and this is a GREAT backdrop. Toodles! -L
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Thanks! I'm really glad you're enjoying the story! (I do hope you manage to leave your computer occasionally, though! haha!)I saw that this was a review for "Hagrid's Hut," and my automatic reaction was, "*groan* Somebody's gonna tell me how very gross this chapter was!" So very glad I was wrong!Yep, there were little clues sprinkled around that Hagrid & Wilhelmina were having a bit of a "thing"; so happy that you caught on!Resolving a Misunderstanding is sort of the "mother" for a bunch of my other fics, and I'm very fond of it and put a lot of time into it (!), so it's always great to hear that someone (like you) appreciates the backdrop and the supporting characters. I always say that RaM is my favorite of my stories and Death's Dominion is my best and a close second in my heart. Thanks very much for your review! It made my morning. (BTW, I think that by the end of the story, you won't be sayin' "vanilla Minerva"! haha!)
Oh, a big thank you once more!I'm very glad you did all of this. This story is wonderful!Thank you, thank you, thank you! *Marina
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
You are very welcome! It makes me happy to know you've enjoyed it so much!
Wow. So it, or at least this key portion of the RaMverse Chronicles <g>, ends. I am very glad they had the talk about The Arrival of It, and that Albus now knows just how long Minerva has been utterly devoted to him. Hopefully knowing that will keep the outbreaks of insecurity to a minimum in future. Though his momentary gut-clenching fear 'she doesn't really love me--it's all just some weird side-effect of the staunching' when she told him of It was very "Albus." Has he confessed his neck-nape gandering when she was in the park w/ Melina all those years ago? Perhaps it would help both of them to realize their feelings began to morph from 100% platonic and appropriate to something more at about the same time, though Albus's morphing was much gentler and more gradual. How did he winkle her confession out of her?--she said she hadn't wanted to tell him even then....Letting her see the will was also very Albus. Minerva handled it well, considering. I am w/ Hypnobarb--I wanna see the train of thoughts, communications and persuasions leading up to their actually getting officially hitched. They have been unofficially linked ever since he added her to the blood wards, but ....Legal aside....How was Albus's will probated in DD? I can imagine quite a thicket of intrigue to keep its terms secret. How long do estates remain open under Scottish wizarding law? (B/c I'm sure you've thought through your universe to that level of detail.... <g>) That could be one interesting will to handle--good thing there's not much likelihood of it being contested! I know some good probate litigators if the need arises, but they're Muggles.....<g>The opal was wonderful. As was the weekend away. And the dance music. I'll dance w/ Albus any time. Ditto re the sentiment about the headboards and sundaes expressed by dmf1984....You know I'm not as fascinated by Albus's beard as Minerva is <g>, but it worked for her and Albus, so, hey--beard sex--whatever floats your boat/flies your broom! They both have come so far in their sexual freedom w/ each other. After boinking his beard, I'd say that the lap scene in Obliging Minerva is pretty tame! I too had imagined you'd cover the "Stupid beard" base w/ just lots of stroking and rubbing and tickling.....I won't talk about how wonderful a story it is, b/c it's just part of the RaMverse, and you're still writing! But it is a wonderful, very substantial foundation on which you are building ....
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Thank you! I'm glad you enjoyed it all -- and that you continue to enjoy the other stories in the "RaMverse."Now, for what questions I can answer, here are a few!The revelation of when Minerva had fallen in love with him was actually written out as a full scene, but it never got used in the story -- just had to leave some things out (there are others that never made it in, either) -- and it began by them discussing again Carson's death and her rescue of Albus, and then his conviction at the time that it might be his fate to die defeating Grindelwald, that even if he was successful, that he might still have died, and how during that period, he had thought it might be some justice for his own inaction decades before, etc., but that obviously that didn't happen, and he has quite a different perspective on all that. Minerva responds that it would have been dreadful for her if he had died, and she didn't know if she could have gone on and ever wanted to be happy again. Albus tells her that of course she could, there would still be Rudolf, and if that didn't work, then Quin or someone like him, but Minerva said that it would have been worse for her, because she never would have had the opportunity to become closer to him, become good friends with him, to tell him how she felt, and eventually tell him that she loved him, even if he didn't love her in return.Albus tells her that she wouldn't have known what she had lost, that she would have missed him, but that she was so young at that time, she still had the time yet to fall in love with someone else. She tells him, no, she couldn't, that she had always loved him even before she was in love wtih him, and then she ends up telling him that even at the time of Carson's death and Albus's rejection of her sympathy, she was in love with him. It then proceeded to the discussion that Albus is thinking about in the epilogue.I'm not a big fan of beards, either, in RL, although sometimes on the right man, a short, well-groomed beard can be quite attractive. Somehow, though, when I think of Albus, I can't picture him without his beard, and the Albus in my imagination is quite the sexy guy, so I think he's the exception to the rule for me -- even if he's entirely fictional. I cannot imagine participating in the activity that Minerva did with his beard, though -- although the proximity to his mouth is, um, yeah . . . won't go there.I have, as you surmise, thought about probating the will. Doubt it will come into any active scene in DD, though. But because it's Albus and it's wartime, they could likely get it sealed, temporarily, when it's filed. The wizarding world's laws are different, anyway, and it seems the Ministry by that point was doing whatever it pleased, whether it was legal or not -- poor Stan Shunpike! I'm sure the will's precise provisions could be kept from becoming general public knowledge, even if some of them were obvious. (I actually have a small mini-scene in my notes between Minerva and Scrimgeour that supposedly takes place shortly after the funeral and that mentions the will and a couple other things, but it's not going to end up in the story, I decided.)Thanks for the reviews!
Response from esoterica1693 (Reviewer)
Thank you very much for filling in the details about Minerva and Albus's conversation. It must have been very emtional, and I can see even more why Albus is now, finally, convinced of Minerva's complete and permanent devotion to him.I see we basically agree re Albus and beards--I just don't have as good an imagination as you do to be able to actually join long beard + sexy in my mind's *eye*, just in my mind!I thought that just maybe you'd pondered wizarding probate laws! I worked for some probate litigation attys for a while, and it's quite the interesting field if you are the sort who likes observing family train wrecks....the things folks manage to get worked up about and the loopholes they look for and the grudges they pursue, all at $250--$500/hr or more, plus expenses.... So, leaving all of the complexities and mysteries of the DD plot aside, it's good that Albus's will can be sealed, and that as far as we know none of his friends or family would be likely to object to its terms.
Response from esoterica1693 (Reviewer)
Oh, and btw, today (Tues) is *my* birthday (I'm turning 7 yrs older than Minerva turned in this chapter), and I'd gladly take any of the birthday gifts Minerva received! Alas, I have no Albus nor any reasonable facsimile at the moment....If Albus did all that for her 33rd, I wonder what he'll do for really big milestone numbers?! That crafty phoenix will be sure to come up w/ something good!
Wow, what a great epilogue!
So Minerva finally told Albus for how long she has been loving him and I am glad for that.
I love the last sentence...it somehow reminds me of the ending of 'Casablanca'.
I savoured the whole story and admire your writing talent.
Now, at the ending, I raise my glass of Sylvaner to you saying 'slàinte mhath!'
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Ah, Sylvaner! My favorite wine. Somewhat tricky to find where I live now, but I have one store that usually carries it. So I return your toast! Slàinte!I'm very glad you enjoyed it. Thanks very much!
Why do I have the feeling that competition has just come strolling in the door? Soon to be followed by other less desireable characters?Minerva's vacation isn't going to be very relaxing, is it?And why am I feeling compelled to make statements in the form of questions?
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
"And why am I feeling compelled to make statements in the form of questions?"
Hmm, I'm not sure . . . maybe because this chapter raises more questions than it purports to answer?
Or maybe because there's a peculiar question bug that's spreading?
May I take this opportunity to thank you for reading and reviewing?
Ooh, I wonder what Minnie will do with the info that Albus didn't tell her he was dating someone. Could be trouble for their slowly building ship. Hehe, and Gamp being so forward. Maybe to shock Minnie into being the deputy head? Good chapter.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Thanks! I'm glad you enjoyed it! The next chapter will be up this weekend.
Minnie and her lack of confidence, oh dear. Maybe remembering that conversation will give her a new direction of thought in the present. The Fat Lady has a lot of cheek that needs some straightening out as well.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
All the portraits are rather cheeky, don't you think?
Maybe Dumbledore in the present should remember his own advice! And take it!
Thanks very much for reviewing!
More foreshadowing of the relationship to come. Nicely played with a bit of misunderstood communication. Now, if Minerva would just remember at the right time that Albus affection is not based on what she is, but who she is.Well done.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Thanks!
With all the emphasis on the Marauders in fandom history, there is a tendency to forget about Tom Riddle's time at Hogwarts and what that may have been like. Other than the Heir of Slytherin business and the Chamber of Secrets, along with becoming Head Boy, we really don't know much. I'm glad you've chosen to weave this into your story and gives us a bit more about him.Dumbledore's advice is good, given that he has suspicions about Riddle being a sociopath. Minerva has no idea she's playing with fire.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Thanks -- glad you like it. I'm surprised that more people don't write fics about the first CoS episode.
And yeah, sociopaths are an entirely different beast, and you want to avoid them completely -- don't even touch them with a ten-foot pole! Tunnel vision, egotism, and no conscience lead to a very dangerous individual!
Dang. In her place, I might have gone for a good snoop. Of course, being watched by the portraits would put paid to that idea.It is good that she got a little more reassurance, even if by accident.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
A very convenient accident!
Ooh, that sneaky Riddle, and what an interesting comment about Minnie and Albus. And Minnie getting caught, silly girl. Good chapter.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Glad you liked it!
A peculiar draft, eh? And since Minnie is a cat Animagus, curiosity can be murder, lol. Good chapter!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Thanks! Glad you enjoyed it!
Stubborn woman. Now she's talking herself out of it with the I'm too young argument. Of course, while she's doing that, Albus is talking himself out of it with the I'm too old argument.Something must definitely happen to make both of them see this situation a bit more clearly!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
A number of "somethings" will happen! It's just going to take a while!
Thank you for reviewing!
I cannot help but laugh at Albus' predicament. This romance isn't going to wait for long, especially if Minerva can't resist turning into a cat to get a belly rub.The story about Minerva's apprenticeship and her challenge is an interesting bit about the magical world. Nice touch.It's good that they cleared the air about their encounter the other day. Now, they need to get about the business of romancing each other.Assuming they can stop telling themselves It's only a friendship, It's only a friendship.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
They certainly are working against themselves, aren't they?
I'm glad Albus' predicament elicited a laugh! :D
Thanks for reviewing!
Ahh! That time at the beginning of a relationship when both parties are very insecure, not sure if there is a relationship at all, and making such an effort. Charming!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Thank you!
Heh, challenging an inferior teacher, lol, but you didn't say exactly what the challenge was. Sword in the Stone like maybe?
Dang those two have crossed wires! They need to just forget for a second and do something! The cat, then the hug, geez kiss already!
Good chapter.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Hee! They do have a few problems, don't they? But remember that it's only been a day since Albus overheard Minerva talking to Poppy. It just seems like longer to us because of all the history in the intervening chapters. The next chapter should be up soon.
Thanks for reviewing!
Yay! Now if they'd just give up and get on with it...Anyway, another great chapter!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
They are very stubborn, I'm afraid!
Glad you liked it -- thanks for reviewing!