New Chapter for Resolving a Misunderstanding
Resolving a Misunderstanding
MMADfan954 Reviews | 6.45/10 (954 Ratings, 0 Likes, 108 Favorites )
Minerva has just finished her first term teaching. A series of misunderstandings leads to an embarrassing moment, injured feelings, regret, growing understanding, then resolution. A Minerva McGonagall fic set in 1957, with forays into the past. More than a Romance; stories within stories. Features Minerva, Albus, and Poppy, with appearances by Slughorn, Grubbly-Plank, Hagrid, Flitwick, Moody, Riddle, Grindelwald, and other canon characters. Not DH-compliant. Disregards DH.
Nineteen Parts.
Most content T-rated, but ratings rise to M and MA for several later chapters. Overall M rating reflects later content.
Pertinent warnings in individual chapter summaries.
Voted First Place, Minerva McGonagall: Legacy Fic, in the HP Fanfiction Fan Poll Awards Spring/Summer 2013.
Chapters (141)
About MMADfan
Author
MMADfan
41 Stories | Favorited by 312 | 127 Reviews Written | 4,741 Review Responses
Note 10 December 2015: I've been unable to write fanfic the last couple years, but I haven't abandoned my works-in-progress!
Many of my completed fics are available for download in ebook format through my blog and LJ.
Perfect Imagination accredited beta. PI:7311261659.
More about me here.
Reviews for Resolving a Misunderstanding
Because not only are you not a lady, Horace, you are rarely even a gentleman! Perfect, absolutely perfect. Slughorn has always seemed a bit of a slob to me. And poor Pretnick, but I suppose that leaves a spot open for another new character at Hogwarts, since I don't see any way he can continue to teach the same as before.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Pretnick did teach Defense, after all, and you know who visited Albus looking for a job one recent winter's night . . . <g>
Glad you liked that line! :)
Poor Albus. At least he's lucky to have such loyal friends. The man needs protection from himself.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Doesn't he just?
I would have done more than made her shoes too tight. Very glad we'll soon be moving on from these obnoxious people. Can't stand being around that sort.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Minerva feels the same!
Wow, I come from a pretty easy going family, but that was beyond rude. Announcing an engagement in the middle of someone's speech at an engagement party...Valerianna must have lost her mind.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Pretty much, yeah. ;)
Men and sports, it's always about the competition isn't it? Poor Gertie.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Yup, whether they're wizards or Muggles! LOL!
Hmm. But I do think it amusin that, for all their talk, they end up more like Muggles than the rest of us,
I love that bit; exactly the sort of comment that would drive people like the Blacks crazy. And it's great the way you keep adding more and more to Gertie's history. Her character is developing very nicely. I'll miss her when this story is done. Quin too.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
I'm glad you like Gertrude and Quin. They keep popping up in this story, and, once I've recovered from writing RaM, I have a sequel in mind, and they will both appear there, provided RaM doesn't completely exhaust me! :D
Thanks for the review!
Haven't a clue how it is you are writing this so fast. Congratulations on 100 long chapters. This hummer will hit a million words before you are done with it!Now that Minerva has had a bit of confession time with Father Quin, Quin is going off to visit with Albus. I wonder what vibes Quin is going to get from Albus?Perhaps Quin could be outfitted with a pair of wings and a bow and arrow, since he is determined to play cupid.He'd look cute in the outfit.I can't help my amusement at Quin's discomfort with Malcolm. I can't help wondering what Malcolm is up to and what he's really doing for a living. That it is "unspoken" might be significant?
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
"Haven't a clue how it is you are writing this so fast. Congratulations on 100 long chapters. This hummer will hit a million words before you are done with it!"
I tend to write a lot at once, then go for quite a while without writing anything at all. It helps that I have had it outlined for a while, and that I occasionally write bits of future chapters to be used later. It's also just about my only hobby these days. Good thing most TV sucks! Haha! I'm thinking it'll be less than a mill, actually, but I'm not certain.
"Perhaps Quin could be outfitted with a pair of wings and a bow and arrow, since he is determined to play cupid."He'd look cute in the outfit."
Mm, especially if it were gauzy and, um, not very concealing! LOL!
"I can't help my amusement at Quin's discomfort with Malcolm. I can't help wondering what Malcolm is up to and what he's really doing for a living. That it is "unspoken" might be significant?"
Malcolm's doing what he usually does to earn his living . . . though I don't suppose that was very informative!
Thanks for reviewing!
Response from Hypnobarb (Reviewer)
You are a tease! But then you've been torturing Albus and Minerva for 100 chapters.Evil snicker.Have a good one!
And the plot thickens.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Thanks for the review!
I love the fact that she isn't even considering herself for head of house. Probably can't even imagine herself in that position. I also think that Blampa is a very fun side character. Excellent job.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Thank you very much. I'm glad you like Blampa. She shows up now and again.
Poor Carson, he certainly got the short end of the stick, didn't he?
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
He did, indeed.
I just want you to know that I think this is a wonderful story. Very believable background for both characters. Also, I love the title to this chapter.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Thank you very much! And I'm glad you like the title. :D Every now and then, I can't help myself!
Thanks for letting me know you're enjoying the story! I hope it continues to entertain you.
Very nice! I like the complete turnabout in her feeliings about Gertrude, and how much Gertrude is relaxing around Minerva and showing her feelings. They are a natural match in their support of Albus, and Albus certainly needs someone like Gertrude. Interesting on Gertrude's magical drain, so to speak. And I'm very curious what role Malcolm has in this! I hope she is not seriously ill.Hee, hee, now Minerva knows Albus has a shrine too! I wonder how matter of fact Gertrude really is, of if she is dropping broad hints for her oblivous friends.Love the installation ceremony, and all of the warding/Hogwarts story. It's fascinating, and quite clever. Now...enter Quin, and his matchmaking skills? BTW, love your use of "whinging." That is one of my favorite words!Thanks for all of the quick updates over the past week. My obsession is happily under control!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Glad you like "whinging" -- quite evocative of what it is, I always think!
Yes, Gertrude's hints are getting broader, particularly now that Minerva trusts her more.
Gertrude's just a bit depleted, not suffering from magical drain or magical exhaustion -- she is just exhausted in the ordinary sense and has (mysteriously!) been doing too much magic all of the sudden . . . Apparating about . . . we will eventually learn more about what is going on with her and what's causing her to be so tired.
I may not be able to update quite so quickly again for a while, but I hope at least to get something new up on Wednesday.
Thanks much for the review!
i adored the birthday dinner - it was abosultely perfect.the tension you have created between both of them is wonderfulpoor minerva...she finally gets the courage to say 'i love you' even though it was in a moment that could be open for interpretation and albus says he's fond of herand poor albus also...for being so insecure.a lot of times when people write this kind of thing, it seems forced or unbelievable or a contrivance for plot...but everything you write is so natural... i am completely invested in this story.
i look forward to each chapter of this story and am so happy to see you update frequently. but also i'll be looking forward to anything you write from now on...your stuff is great
also, i love the way you are interweaving albus's and minerva's fantasies/dreams of intimacy in this story. very realistic. i just hope when they finally get together, you give the reader (that's me) some vivid hot sex
okay...now hoping you forgive me for that inappropriate comment, onto my comments for this chapter:
first, your HTML is showing for some reason...second, if i had to climb 7 flights of stairs to get to my apartment, i'd be way too tired.
poor gertie...whta's wrong with her?
oh i'm sure albus will be thinking of minerva when that silk caresses his...oops..did i really write that? sorry ;)
i really enjoyed your imaginative 'sorting' procedure for the new head of house...
oh and i can't wait for Quin to arrivei really like this original character
that's a true sign of talent - creating an original character that your readers are really intrigued by and can't wait to reappear!
a lovely chapter....please update soon!!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
How odd that the html is showing -- I'll have to take a look at it and see if there's some misplaced code somewhere that's throwing it all off.
I'm glad you like Quin so much -- I'm fond of him, myself! :D
Their fantasies and dreams are mere shadows of what reality will be! ;P (BTW, I don't remember whether you've read An Act of Love or not -- if you are looking for "hot sex." ADMM-style, you might want to read that.)
You'll eventually learn all about what ails Gertrude -- in more detail than she shares with Minerva.
Thank you very, very much for reviewing! :)
A very creative idea to have the Sorting Hat be part of the installation of a new Head of House. Why do I get the feeling that there is more going on with Gertrude than she's telling?Eagerly awaiting more Albus and Minerva blurting.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
"Why do I get the feeling that there is more going on with Gertrude than she's telling?"
Um, maybe because there usually is more going on with Gertrude than she lets on?
I'm sure there will be more blurting to come!
Thanks for the review!
Great two chapters. I liked the description of the Hogwarts Heart and Minerva being nervous about becoming the Head. Excellent work!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Thank you very much! :)
It's velvet from f.net or something I can't remember what I changed it too. I never knew this site existed, so thanks for showing me a new place to worship Harry. Glad you kept working on this, it's great. Can't wait to read more.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
You're welcome -- I'm always happy to introduce new folks to TPP. I like this site a lot. :)
Thanks very much for reviewing -- and letting me know you found the story over here! :D
I have a few more chapters written, so the updates should be pretty regular for at least a while -- who knows what RL will throw at me, so I make no guarantees! LOL But unless I die or otherwise become completely unable to do so, I will finish this story. We are in reach of the end now. Comparatively speaking, anyway!
Thanks again for reviewing! Hope you have a look at the other great stories on this site!
Hmm, this is telliing. They both recover from their anguish much more quickly than they used to, and swerve right back into their "inappropriate" feelings. Poor Albus and his insecurities, I feel for him. But I admit I also did not think he deserved any sleep at all after that "fond" remark! I wonder if Wilspy had anything to do with those erotic dreams of Minerva's? House-elf magic is a little mysterious is it not? It is real progress for Minerva that she is getting over her jealousy of Getrtude. I loved Gerturde losing her temper on Minerva's behalf, too. She cares a great deal for Minerva, obviously. A good chapter, and it is brighter than I expected it to be, for our frustrated lovers!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Read the little scene between Albus and Wilspy a couple chapters back, just before he had his nap.
Glad you liked the chapter!
Thanks for reviewing!
Response from stardragon (Reviewer)
Ah, so Wilspy is a dreamweaver! Love it!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
She doesn't give them the dreams, she just "encourages" them a little! Frees them up. It's a talent that comes in handy when taking care of little children and stubborn wizards . . . and broken-hearted witches.
My eyes didn't actually water during the beginning of the chapter. It was just allergies. That's the only reason I had to blow my nose and had to cough a few times to clear the lump from my throat.Allergies. That's all. It wasn't because my heart was breaking for these two.What's really wrong with Gertrude?It was fun watching her kick some Dustern arse.Waiting patiently for my allergies to go away when I read Albus and Minerva stuff. I'm sure that's all it is.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
*sniffle* Now you've got my allergies going! And I'm sure that's all it is . . .
*sigh*It gets better, but then it gets worse . . . but then it gets much, much, much better. And at that point, your allergies may be cured. Or you could develop one for another reason . . . :)
We'll find out a teeny bit more in the next chapter about what's wrong with Gertrude, but as is always the case with that witch, we won't learn the full story.
I've been waiting for Dustern to "have her say" for a very long time -- she's been holding it in for years -- and have Gertrude come right back at her. :D
Thanks for reviewing. Perhaps your allergies won't be so bad next chapter you read. ;)
I don't know where to start! Oh, my, that was worth the wait, it was even better than anticipated (although bittersweet)!She said it, she finally said it, and I cried for her at his reaction. That man--I want to throttle him! I think he got his birthday wish, and he's still in denial!I'm still crying. That was so beautiful, and powerful. This: "Albus looked like power and magic and beauty incarnate in those robes, and she watched as, robes flowing out behind him like the sky..." Wow. What an image! Random observations: Hee, hee, I like that he decorated her rooms in the same color as the gown she had on when he looked down her bodice! LOL at the "non-eccentric" robes. I was wondering what that was about. The tiles were great, another tearful moment. Oh, and the ballad--that was beautiful! I like how you showed her reaction to it, at different ages.Heartbreaking, and wonderful! Please update soon!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Well, the next couple chapters are written, just have to patiently wait the "appropriate interval" so folks have time to find the update and read it and all that. Hopefully you will find the next chapters satisfying in a different way from this one. And we will find out about Albus and what was going through his mind, and what his wish was, and all that good stuff.
Poor Minerva is also feeling heartbreak at the moment, but it will pass, at least for a time, for a rather unusual reason.
Glad, too, that you liked that closing image.
I'm glad you liked the story in the ballad -- I've had that in Malcolm's character sketch for an AGE and was happy to find a very natural place to put it at a time that also makes sense -- I needed to do it before certain other chapters, really . . .
Thanks very much, as always, for your thoughtful and very nice review!
Response from stardragon (Reviewer)
I suppose I can be patient, since you hold out the carrot of "other chapters"...
This isn't Halloween. It's Christmas and you are Santa Claus. What a perfect birthday celebration! Wine, food, cake, and presents. All in a romantic setting and the right company.Now, all Albus needs to do is get over his shock and make a decision to respond in kind to Minerva's blurtette.I shall anxiously await the next chapter and a visit inside Albus' head. Sigh. It's so romantic.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Yup, you'll get that little visit inside Albus's head next chapter. And a visit to Minerva's. And a few other things, as well!
I'm glad you liked the romance!
Thanks much!
What a lovely gift! Surely Albus will realize that the stars in those robes match the stars in her eyes. Then, he'll understand...You are an unabashed romantic and Quin makes a delightful cupid.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Yup! Well, maybe slightly abashed . . . haha! I'm glad you like Quin-as-Cupid!
Thanks for reviewing!
The Quin-tessential charming Irishman! If Min isn't available, would you mind sending him my way?
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
There may be a queue!
I love the way you weave past and present together so we get the history between these two without completely losing the current thread of the story.You show such lovely 'routine' uses for magic -- charmed hampers, charmed underwear, support charms, etc. It's a delicate balance between using magic for everything and using it so seldom it seems there's no advantage to being a witch, and you walk that line very well.The relationship between between young Minerva and Albus is just delightful -- you can clearly see the the mutual affection and respect in their teasing while discussing her animagus training.And Aparius B. White, HA!I think this is a good place to mention that you are a better-than-competent writer!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Thanks! (Especially for the "better-than-competent writer" compliment! )I enjoyed writing the "young Minerva" bits, and hoped they would work well woven into the story through Minerva's (and Albus's) memories. I thought it would let me highlight the more significant events and moments between them when she was a student, and show the development of their friendship, without having the narrative turn too much into the story of Minerva as a student.I'm glad you like their relationship here. It was fun to imagine their respective personalities at that point, especially Minerva's -- the girl that later became the older woman we know from the books. As you say, it is a balancing act between having magic be mere window dressing or an afterthought and having it dominate and have everything be miraculous and easy for magical characters, so I'm glad you like the use it's put to in the story. Thanks very much! Hope you continue to enjoy it!
Yay, an update already! Thanks! Is Minerva really going to tell Quin how she feels about Albus?? I can't wait to read it, and it shows great emotional progress on her part.Quin is such a great character. I hope we continue to see him in future stories, too. Is Pierce Brosnan your model for Quin? I've loved him since his Remy days--yum!BTW, been meaning to mention this for ages--I love you use British spelling in your stories; nice touch.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
I could watch Pierce Brosnan sit on a stool and read the telephone directory and be happy, I think! Yes, he's the source of the pic of Quin. I've pictured him that way since I first conceived of him. But with slightly longer hair, and with some dusting of gray through it.
I can't imagine writing a story set in a British universe and not using British spelling -- well, I can, but not for me, ya know? When I was growing up, I had a tough time in school with spelling "correctly" since I read so many English (as in "British") books, and back then, they didn't change the spellings for an American audience, so I was confused about "colour" and "color" and "behaviour" and "behavior" for years, and it took me a long time to realize that "gray" was the correct spelling, since I always spelled it "grey." Haha! So it's easy for me to spell that way, and I think it adds to the "flavour" of the story. I do use American punctuation because that would require far too much thought, it would feel unnatural, and my typing fingers would have problems with that. LOL So I try to consistently use UK spelling and US punctuation -- and avoid the use of the word "gotten," though I am sure I've slipped occasionally there, and likely elsewhere, but hopefully not too eggregiously. However, I will never put a male character in "knickers" -- that always just makes me ROTFLMAO when I read that, and I know immediately that the author isn't British. I have read more than one SS story that puts him in "knickers," and I always envision him in red satin and lace panties, for some reason, and that just makes me laugh (and spoils any sexy mood that may have been developing). Of course, maybe Severus is into cross-dressing! LOL!
Thanks for the review!
Response from stardragon (Reviewer)
OK, so now I had to break out my Remington Steele DVDs...my hormones are SO confused...I'm an editor by profession, one of the unfortunate side effects being it ruins one for reading. But I do especially appreciate your perpesctive on "British-isms" and punctuation. Yes, the punctuation would be jarring, I agree. It would slow me down trying to type it! Oh, dear, I think I'm going to picture Snape in red lace for quite some time now. Hysterical!