New Chapter for Resolving a Misunderstanding
Resolving a Misunderstanding
MMADfan954 Reviews | 6.45/10 (954 Ratings, 0 Likes, 108 Favorites )
Minerva has just finished her first term teaching. A series of misunderstandings leads to an embarrassing moment, injured feelings, regret, growing understanding, then resolution. A Minerva McGonagall fic set in 1957, with forays into the past. More than a Romance; stories within stories. Features Minerva, Albus, and Poppy, with appearances by Slughorn, Grubbly-Plank, Hagrid, Flitwick, Moody, Riddle, Grindelwald, and other canon characters. Not DH-compliant. Disregards DH.
Nineteen Parts.
Most content T-rated, but ratings rise to M and MA for several later chapters. Overall M rating reflects later content.
Pertinent warnings in individual chapter summaries.
Voted First Place, Minerva McGonagall: Legacy Fic, in the HP Fanfiction Fan Poll Awards Spring/Summer 2013.
Chapters (141)
About MMADfan
Author
MMADfan
41 Stories | Favorited by 312 | 127 Reviews Written | 4,741 Review Responses
Note 10 December 2015: I've been unable to write fanfic the last couple years, but I haven't abandoned my works-in-progress!
Many of my completed fics are available for download in ebook format through my blog and LJ.
Perfect Imagination accredited beta. PI:7311261659.
More about me here.
Reviews for Resolving a Misunderstanding
Albus looked at her with a slight, warm smile on his lips, and Minerva felt her heart begin to beat more rapidly, though she couldn’t say why. Awash with a sudden, overwhelming desire for the wizard seated across from her, she said softly, “I would treat you well, if you were mine . . . if you were my wizard . . . .” Minerva lowered her eyes and took a sip of cognac.Albus cleared his throat. “Yes, well, if you . . . um, if you were . . . um, a cat, I am sure I would be well-looked after. Um, more cognac?” He poured himself a bit more, though Minerva indicated she didn’t want any. “So, what else did you and Quin discuss?”*snip**grins* Oh ho, Minerva is sooooo bold... love this!
Response from Fishy (Reviewer)
“Yes, yes it is. And, conversely, one of the things that makes life so enjoyable. Don’t forget that. You said yourself, when we were at the concert a few days ago, that . . .” Minerva closed her eyes, trying to remember his exact words. “You said that love and compassion are alive and stronger than dark deeds, cold indifference, and selfish desires, and that there is room in the universe for the human soul to create something sublime. You said this gives meaning to sacrifice.” Minerva blushed as she opened her eyes to see Albus looking at her intently. “Something like that, anyway.”*snip*That's just beautiful... pure Albus and pure beauty.
Response from Fishy (Reviewer)
“I will try, but it is something of a habit, I am afraid. Please don’t take offense if I forget occasionally – it’s what happens when you become an old codger!” Albus laughed and Minerva threw a small pillow at him. *snip*Only Dumbledore could be infuriating and adorable at the same time.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Glad you like Minerva's bit of boldness there. She does keep stepping a bit over the lines she draws for herself! Sadly, Albus does keep missing their meaning!I'm glad that you liked the bit of Dumbledore philosophy there. I do try to slip in some of the more serious sides of Albus, and not just his "eccentric" sides -- or his sexy ones! Yes, infuriating, but adorable!
I think I would have just drug Albus along.... actually felt like telling him to stop being ridiculous and jerking his arm over the desk, dragging him with me - er... with her - Minerva that is. *nods* Yes... Minerva ...
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Do I perceive a wee bit of an identity crisis going on here? Yes, he should definitely stop being ridiculous! But you know that will take more than just getting dragged across his desk and out for the evening! Threats sometimes work!
Response from Fishy (Reviewer)
*snicker* Identitiy crises, or more like wishful thinking - what ever you want to tall it.. *chuckles*Good, maybe a few threats from Minerva will work - or wand work, or... anything, to wake him UP!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Minerva . . . hmm, interesting notion, her threatening Albus, but . . . .
She closed her eyes in kitty bliss as they entered the stairway and started the ride up.*snip*I can so see my former lady kitty I had for many years, in this sentence. Kitty bliss shown through loving eyes... that's a cat for you.
Response from Fishy (Reviewer)
I just love this chapter so far, you write cats very, very well - obviously you have known a few in your lifetime - this is soooo puuuurfect - yeah, bad pun intended. *winks*
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Yes, I have known more than a few, and they all had such different personalities, but all taught me a lot about "being feline"! lol! I like to think that Minerva can let herself experience a different aspect of her personality, and sometimes "let go" in ways she otherwise wouldn't, when she's in her cat form.Glad you're enjoying it!
Response from Fishy (Reviewer)
I especially loved her reaction to Albus naming her Morag - in her kitty form - that was hysterical! As was her determination not to let Albus see her disheveled self in natural form and all the theatrics of her having to take a shower in his "loo" - haha! Wilspy is, as always, charming and quite the instigator!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
I thought that was the perfect feline response to that "insult"! lol!Glad you enjoyed Wilspy again!
Very captivating yet also, by necessity, a very gruesome chapter!
You had me completely involved here, from start till end and the horros of war came strongly across as well as that in such situation man can't whine, but will try to cope...even when so horribly wounded as Carson.
Awful that Carson had to die, though it must have come as a mercy to him. The letters to his parents and Minerva I found very touching.
Am much worried for Albus but his strength and discipline are, as always, admirable.
Very sad and very impressive, this chapter!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Thank you. It was a sad chapter to write, too. I'm glad you found that it hit the mark.
Poor Gertie! All those people driving you batty when you just want to get your work done and go cave somewhere with a good book. Poor lady.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Poor lady, indeed! She has friends who are too well-meaning!
Oooh, TWO kisses in a row! Gotta love a double smooch!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Minerva & Albus sure did!
“Richtig. These are, of course, folk meanings, but they are not without their own truth. In this country, I teach more concretely that the ivy vine spirals about a plant, climbing it, being supported by it, embracing it. The ivy vine may appear delicate, but it is powerful; in the absence of trees, it may climb a brick wall and, in time, cause it to crumble. Ivy can reach great heights when it has a support, to the top of the tallest oak it can climb. And yet, without the tree, the ivy can content itself to creep along the earth, spreading widely and vigorously.“Ivy is not a parasite, you know. It coexists quite peacefully with its tree. But just as ivy can crumble masonry, it can also bring destruction to the tree through its mere existence. Magical ivy, however, is different in this regard. It, too, will grow to the top-most branches of a tree. It, too, may blanket the tree entirely, its own leaves obscuring those of the tree. But magical ivy, rather than inadvertently starving its friendly host of sunlight, provides extra nutrition to the tree the more thickly it covers it. And where a mighty oak will fall when the common ivy permits strong winds to knock over the tree by growing so densely that the air can no longer move freely through the tree’s branches, magical ivy, through an as-yet unstudied mechanism, absorbs the power of the winds, allowing the tree to be buffeted, but not to fall.*snip*Love this... loooooove this... using actual nature to explain emotion - plants to people - simbiosis in the human heart, as in plants. Its so beautiful I'm jealous I didn't dream it up!
Response from Fishy (Reviewer)
Symbiosis - my bad.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
I'm very glad that you liked it and saw the analogy with Minerva & Albus. And I'm sure you'll find all kinds of wonderful things for your characters to say or to think! Johannes doesn't appear much in this fic, but he's really quite a full character, and this sort of philosophical, poetical, and yet still somewhat scientific view was perfect for him to express. And yes, those Ys can be tricky little letters! I read it as you meant it, though.
Response from Fishy (Reviewer)
You've got to be sick of me reviewing everything by now! HA, I'll give ya a break and just read another chapter before bed.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
No, not at all sick of it! Occasionally challenged to type anything coherent (I'm up too late, myself!), but always happy to read the reviews. I'll be turning off the light shortly, myself -- as I tried to do 2 hours ago, to be gotten up, and then couldn't sleep again! So I've been reading.
“It’s a better picture of Poppy than it is of me, I’m afraid – which may be one reason I never did anything with it. I look like a braying donkey.”*snip*OMG LMAAAAAAAAAAOOOOOOOOOO
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Well, I'm glad that gave you a laugh! Reading it again & your reaction gave me a bit of a chuckle, too! LOL!
Response from Fishy (Reviewer)
I am STILL laughing.... over 5 minutes worth... so funny, and the next line - where she raises her eyebrows and mumbles - "if you say so, Albus" and he starts grinning, declaring it so - soooooo priceless.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Thanks!
“Oh,” Blampa squeaked, “it’s possible, Professor Headmaster!!! I, Blampa, make possible elderberry preserves for the Professor Headmaster and his Professor Minerva! Yes, yes!”*snip*Am I going mad, or was it Wilspy that called Minerva his Professor Minerva? Is Blampa picking up nick names?
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Blampa thinks that Wilspy is the perfect model of a house-elf, and she has been spending quite a bit of time with her. And they do chat! So I don't think this is a sign that you're going mad!
How very interesting - the wands I mean, showing their magical connection. I have a very similar idea for a fic I'm working on. Wands are so facinating, I love reading and writing about them.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Their wands was one of the crucial reasons for me to keep the story as I'd planned it, rather than trying to change it to comply with DH. I don't think I'd have finished it if I'd tried to do that.It's great fun trying to imagine how magic works, and how various objects in the HP universe fit in, particularly wands with their cores. The brother wands concept was quite stimulating to the imagination!
Response from Fishy (Reviewer)
Oh yeah! I love playing around with wood qualities myself. And cores are quite amazing, even those that Olivander does not use, so much variety.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
I have a few witches and wizards in my fics who carry wands that aren't Ollivander wands -- Malcolm's, for example, is one he picked up after he'd lost his other one, and it's of olive wood with a Jobberknoll feather, and Siofre Tyree's is ivy with Thestral tail hair. I have a whole list of wands for the various characters so that when/if I have need of it, I have it available. I don't know whether Snape ever had a canon wand described, but I have him with a wand of hemlock w/ unicorn hair. They really are fun to play with.I also created "cored broomsticks," which are special broomsticks made with a core like a wand, and which aren't allowed in regulation Quidditch matches, but which are often used in racing. So that was a fun concept to play with -- especially the kinds of cores they might have (ones with Harpy feathers would often not carry wizards! lol!) and what having a core would do for the broom.
Response from Fishy (Reviewer)
OMG that is so brilliant! Of course Harpy (do they have feathers? In D&D they had bat-like wings) would never carry a wizard! That is soooo awesome!Hemlock? Wow... I always thought Hemlock was a large bush but I guess you could make a wand out of it... toxic though it would be - well, mostly the leaves and berries are toxic... but Snape is a bit toxic, and Unicorn hair! WOW - something TOXIC with something PURE - that is peeeeeerfect!I love woods - all kinds and the smells and their pliability and what not. Soooooooo much fun! Cored broomsticks - sheesh woman... by the time I get back to writing my fic, I won't have any original ideas! *winks* Just pokin' ya of course.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Harpies have feathers. In traditional classical mythology and medieval bestiaries (which is where I know them from), they are feathered birds with the heads of women and terrible talons.Sure, you can make a wand out of anything that grows thick enough around, I would think. I thought that was a rather potent combination, too, and perfect for Severus, especially with the hemlock's associations.
Response from Fishy (Reviewer)
If I ever write about Snape, I guess I'll have to think up some strange herbal teas he mixes with his potions fetish - Night Shade Delight! HAHA.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
LOL! The trick being to add just the right potion to counter the effect before actually imbibing it. Very funny!
Response from Fishy (Reviewer)
Night shade - not sure where you live, but I live in Florida and we have several wild varieties that grow around here, and I often find it growing in my yard - odd that birds eat the berries - thus distributing the plants all over - and apparntly don't suffer from it.
I decided to use this chapter as an enticement to make myself get through some revision for the GRE last night, which worked admirably. But then stuff came up and I couldn't finish it until today. >.<It was totally worth the wait, though! I wonder who the flower seller REALLY was...I've had a question rolling around in my mind for quite sometime now, and it occurred to me that now would be the time to ask, not whenever you get there. Are you planning on continuing this story past the point where they recognize and confess their affection for each other? I really hope you do, either as part of this story or in a sequel (I know, kill me now for using that dreaded word). I really like the characters as you've drawn them and I'd like to see you continue their world, if you're willing.And before you kill me for saying that... *runs*
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Aw, I'm glad you like the characters and their world! I must admit to occasionally being somewhat taken aback by the sheer size of the story . . . but not put off by it.
Once they do recognize and confess their affection for each other, as you put it, there will be at least a few more chapters of the story, since I hate the thought of bringing everyone through all of these months of writing and weeks (or years, actually) of Minerva's and Albus's lives and then have it end just where they finally "see the light," so to speak. And that dreaded "s" word . . . I am actually considering a sequel, and even have a few notes for it. If it starts where I think it will, it will be set primarily at a point several years (7 or 8) after RaM ends. I think I'll likely write a couple different stories before I get to the sequel, though -- there are a few other pre-HP stories that have begun to spring up in my mind, and it might do me some good to get away from this little universe for a while once I've finished the story. There is still a lot left, however, so you won't be saying good-bye to the story anytime soon!
Thank you very much for reviewing, and I'm more pleased than I can express that you enjoy the story so much!
Good luck on the GRE!
I'm re reading this story and i love it so much I feel like its my first time. All the little things still make me laugh even though i know they are coming. But I just wanted to stop and say that I really wish I hade a Gertrude Gamp in my life, especially after this chapter with her levitating Hagrid, getting annoyed at Albus and rolling her eyes. I think she is the most interesting, complex and humorous character I have ever read about in a story.
Mew mew... I too think if I could transform into a kitty, I'd have to nuzzle and head butt Albus, of course, I'd also have to bat the beard bells he wears. *winks*
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Oh, horrors! Don't you know that the real Albus Dumbledore would never be caught wearing peculiar things in his beard? LOL! He might, however, wear them festively dangling from his hat! Or from other articles of clothing! I'd defintely require a lot of cuddles from Albus. A lot. And I'd probably be very reluctant to transform back if that was the only way I'd get those cuddles!
Response from Fishy (Reviewer)
*nods* Beard bells, runestones, braidstones.... being a D&D dwarf lover that I am, I am knowledgable of all things to do with beard-fu - gotta love a thick, braided, plaited, adorned beard.And, as was done in the movies since Michael Gambon took over the roll, he did wear beard bells. *nods* I just loved that!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Well, considering how much I disliked his performance overall, and his general creepiness, I'd say that my loathing for the changes to the beard aren't as great as some of my other negative feelings toward MG as AD. I also thought the costumes took a turn for the worse, though I could have lived with that. I really was pulling for Peter O'Toole to take over the role. He would have been great. (Before the movies were made, I always saw Albus as a kind of combination of Richard Harris and Peter O'Toole in my head, but with the massively long beard and the long, flowing white hair -- like RH had in the first two movies.)Dwarves (or "dwarfs," if you prefer) may freely wear whatever they like in their beards, however! They can be kinda cute, in a rough sorta way.
Response from Fishy (Reviewer)
You had it right the first time, "dwarves" - are the sexiest things ever... you can't possibly talk me out of that, in kilts, no less - but I'm a bit of a fanatic for D&D dwarves.Isn't that odd? I've always loved Michael Gambon and always found Peter O'Toole to be super creepy - but one of the first movies I ever saw him in was Caligula - so... probably ruined me. I really did like Richard Harris as Albus - and like you, loved his costumes better - though I think that MG's costumes were a tiny bit more J.K. style, at least they were purple - but... *shrugs*I do think Gambon was much better at portraying a fierce and dangerous Dumbledore - not sure Harris could have pulled that off. Hard to say. But Dumbledore will always be Dumbledore and I will always love him. *winks* Just like another Muggle lass I know of!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
I always thought that MG came off as being more crazy than angry -- I mean, that scene toward the beginning of GoF where he flips his lid about Harry's name coming out of the goblet? Absolutely so non-canon, it made me cringe -- it was completely out of character for Albus. And I think he's very much just a two or three note actor.Yeah, seeing O'Toole in Caligula as the first movie you see him in could defintely turn you off! But he's got great range, and he has enormous presence, too.
Response from Fishy (Reviewer)
The Director of GoF wanted Albus, in that scene, to be fairly gruff and nasty, forcing him to physically shake Daniel - I remember. *it was really out of canon - director's fault though*I still really like Gambon. I think his best performance as Albus was in OoP and HBP but that's of course, just my opinion.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
OotP was my favorite book and my least favorite movie -- possibly because it was my favorite book and so I had read it a lot & high expectations for the movie. I actually rather liked PoA, of the later movies. There were a lot of scenes in there that I liked, and a number of movie scenes that were a bit different from the book, tweaked a bit, but in a way that I actually liked. Basically, there's very, very little that I borrow from the movies, anyway, and I see them as being a different sort of Harry Potter story. Usually anything that I consciously use that is in the movies but not the books is either fanon (like the way Snape dresses in RaMverse with trousers and all, though in "Heat," which is a separate non-RaMverse one-shot, I have him dress as he does in the books) or else is just a fun detail that is somehow a part of the setting, or a visual detail that wasn't in the books, but which is not contradictory to what's in the books, either. So I get only a tiny bit of inspiration from the movies, and the rest of it comes from the books and from who-knows-where-else! LOL! Fiction writing is a really mysterious thing!
Response from Fishy (Reviewer)
Ain't it though? I can't be entirely sure which is my favorite book - PoA was my favorite from the first three books - Hermione in that book was amazing and she is my favorite of the golden trio - and all the twists and turns in that book were fantastic.OoP contains my absolute favorite part of both the books and the movies - of course, you won't be surprised - when Albus and Tom duel - obviously the book is much better, but considering how much the movies hacked the books to shreds, I think they did a fair job depicting the duel - though they left out some of the most important bits - like explaining what Riddle was trying to do when he posessed Harry's body - in the movie you couldn't possibly understand that Riddle was trying to get Dumbledore to kill Harry - though its clear in the books.Truly, writing fiction in someone else' world - like we're doing borrowing Rowling's, is quite fun. Its a bit more strict than writing in one of the D&D campaigns - say the Forgotten Realms - which I dabble in with my own personal characters I've played over the years - but its so enjoyable - as you know! I am still loving this story regardless if Albus wears beard bells or not! HAHA!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Writing any kind of fiction is pretty amazing -- whether it's trying to be strictly canon fanfic with no original characters (though that would be impossibly limiting for me, I think), fanfic that tries to expand the universe yet remain true to the original in spirit, or original fiction with entirely original characters, it's just plain mysterious where the characters and events and fictional consciousnesses come from. I can easily understand why the Greeks believed in the Muses!
Response from Fishy (Reviewer)
I find my muse is most influenced by Pepsi and Hershey's chocolate bars.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
It's Dove dark chocolate for me! lol!
Response from Fishy (Reviewer)
Ooooh, Dove chocolate is yummmies! I also find *don't slap me* fish dip to be inspirational, especially the smelly smoked stuff. Yumms... Not good for the keyboard, however. *winks*
It was all that Albus could do not to blush at Quin’s statement. The boy was a MacAirt; the males weren’t as gifted as the witches, but Quin was rather extraordinary, from what Gertrude had said of him. Had he somehow seen into the old wizard’s heart and discovered his attachment to his one-time protege? “Well, as Minerva says, she can take care of herself,” Albus said.*snip*Ahhh... wonder if Dumbledore can feel when Quin is using his divining skills, and also wonder if Quin did, or if the two of them were just so blatantly obvious with their combined affection... suspense...........At least Albus didn't act the goof and push Quin and Minerva together during their encounter.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
You'll have to just wait and see! (Not to be taunting, but . . . )
Response from Fishy (Reviewer)
Bloody tease... Oh wait, I know how to get back at you....Cheers for posting!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Aaaaaaaaaa! *runs off, frightened!*
“Of course I did! You don’t think I’d consider setting him up with one of my friends if I hadn’t, do you? He is thoroughly sweet, very amusing, quite knowledgeable on many subjects. A generally delightful dinner companion. But he’s not you.” Minerva grinned.*snip*As if she hasn't made it so obvious, nobody is Albus, that right there should tell him - DUH, she's just a tad overly fond of you, you TWIT... wish she'd just grab him by the beard and...
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
LOL! Yep, she practically spelled it out for the poor dope!But there is a reason that Albus is more than just ordinarily obtuse about this, and you'll eventually learn it when Minerva does. And then I think that your anger will be directed toward another character entirely!
Response from Fishy (Reviewer)
Has someone been messing with my Albus? *sharpens axe* I may just have to take action.... *snorts*
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Oh, somebody did mess with him -- big time! But Minerva fixes it for him!
Response from Fishy (Reviewer)
*snorts* Good, I can always count on Minerva to take care of Albus... she always has and always will... I hope she blasts that wicked *insert worst imaginable noun for a living person here* into the beyond.
“And knowing how hard you work, that is not a bad thing. A certain witch I know could learn a thing or two about lightening up and having fun. I’m always trying to get her to loosen up some. She was old before she was young, I always tell her! Say . . . while she’s here in the castle this summer, you could look after her for me – make sure she has a bit of fun.”*snip*Uhhuh.... Gertie AND Poppy.... wonder if Slughorn will join in next... or Hagrid, or Flitwick! Likely they won't, especially with Albus the Unobservant trying to set her up with the Charms professor.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Yes, Poppy's been trying from the beginning! She's not entirely sure that they're both interested in each other that way, but she has a feeling her friend "Min" is interested in Albus romantically! She figures she can give them a bit of a nudge toward each other, anyway!It will take a very special person to make the nudge that works. Um, more than a nudge, though, really! lol!Glad you liked that bit!
Response from Fishy (Reviewer)
To help me with my anxiety, can you tell me, roughly, how many more chapters until either of them GETS IT? I've bitten my fingernails down to nubs.... its driving me mad!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Well, once Minerva gets her "confidante," it moves a bit faster! I will tell you, though, that there are a good number of chapters at the end of the story in which they explore the new dimension to their relationship -- so it doesn't just end with the ah-ha! moment! (There's a chapter with "confidante" in the title, so that will help you figure out where Minerva starts . . . moving ahead more, so to speak.)
Response from Fishy (Reviewer)
Promise I'm not asking just so I can skip ahead.... I never was very patient. Forgive me, I are just a hopeless romantic, who also happens to drool over a certain, bearded wizard.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
I genuinely would have to figure out how many chapters there are left for you, but I can assure you that you have well over a dozen chapters at the end of the story in which they are together -- almost two dozen, if I remember correctly. So you won't be on tenterhooks for the next gazillion chapters!
Response from Fishy (Reviewer)
No, just a bazillion... *winks* Sorry, I couldn't resist, and thankfully you're writing is enjoyable enough that I think its worth all the nail biting. Trust is hard to come by, but you do seem to love these two quite a lot... so I think I'll extend that trust a bit and push forward.Oh yeah - CHEERS FOR POSTING! *smirks*
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Well, you've read A Holiday for the Headmaster, and that takes place some time during the 130s (chapter-wise).You'll also see some of Minerva's other relationships develop, particularly with Gertrude, so that will hopefully be somewhat satisfying, too!And thanks for the "CHEERS FOR POSTING!" I have been soooooooo missing seeing that! lol
Response from Fishy (Reviewer)
But of course! Always a "cheers for posting" for you!Ahh good, glad we'll get to know Gertie better. I really enjoy her.
I like that Minerva took the initiative, embarassing and potentially scary as it was to talk to Professor Grubbly-Plank about Hagrid - I really appreciate she's that direct and takes the care of the students, and children in general, seriously - that wasn't easy to do. I also like that Professor Grubbly-Plank forgave her for 'watching' so to speak, and had someone to talk to who was sympathetic, and also cared for Hagrid - AND, Minerva can see, its quite fine for two employees of Hogwarts CAN have a relationship and it CAN be beautiful - and Professor Grubbly-Plant did mention she fought the desire for a long time, but it was no use... hopefully, Minerva was listening... I also love that she woke Albus - the idea of Albus snuggled up in bed mumbling in his sleep is just yummy to me.Heck, everything about Albus is yummy... Mmmmmm
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Yes, Minerva finds everything about him yummy, as well. I don't think she'll share, but she might let you admire! I've always seen Minerva as being very protective of anyone in her care, or of her friends. And, of course, in OotP, we saw her run out and try to stop them from taking Hagrid away, which had bad consequences for her, but which gave him time to make an escape.
Response from Fishy (Reviewer)
Not only Hagrid, but she tried to fight Umbridge and the aurors when they came to take Albus to Azkaban... yes, protective she is... fiercly, as are most lionesses.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Yup! She sure is!
No, it hadn’t been a crush; it was more like a disease, or a curse, or a madness. A monomania that occasionally subsided with time, but always to return, and now returned to dominate her life.*snip*And it ain't goin away lady, so get a MOVE ON!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Oh, she does! She's workin' up to it!
Awwww, Hagrid got some lovins! 15 inches, good LORD!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Boggles the mind!
Aaaaaaaahaaaaaaaaa! Gertie set that up! She agreed to the early breakfast, poked him to invite Minerva, didn't tell Albus she was going to leave early... and then bolted! *grins*Still going to flog Albus.... even the stupid TEA LEAVES are trying to make it bloody obvious!
Response from Fishy (Reviewer)
Oh yeah, and Gertie's comment to Slughorn about him not being a gentleman was hilarious. Thank God Albus has Gertie, she doesn't miss a trick... while Albus seems to miss the hurricane outsite the window.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Yes, Gertrude set that all up. She's doing her best to nudge them toward each other!haha! Yeah, she and Slughorn go way back, and she can needle him a bit in a teasing way.
“Not necessary, but a good idea.” Minerva looked at him and was almost overwhelmed by the urge to take him in her arms and hold him, telling the whole world to sod off – at least until Albus was rested. Instead, resigned, she just took his hand as she stood. “Especially if Slughorn is late, which he may be, you might as well use the time to rest.”“I’m not doddering yet, Minerva,” Albus said, tensing up slightly. Minerva shook her head and smiled down at him, not taking offense. “You most certainly are not, Albus. But you have had a long day.” She touched his cheek lightly with her fingertips, in lieu of the kiss she wished to give him. “Let me do this for you, Albus.”The words were an echo of those she had said so many years ago after Carson’s death, and he gave in with a smile. “All right, my dear. I could use a short nap, I suppose.”*snip*I really like this tender moment.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Thank you! They are becoming emotionally very close, and they do care for each other very much.
You know what I've noticed, over all, with RaM? Most of the story takes place during meals. I find myself often hungry while reading this and its no wonder! Everyone is always eating! And often, far better food than I'm stuck with!I do miss Tea - lived in England for a while when I was a kid... best meal of the day over there, but English food is fairly awful.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Tea is a great meal, agreed.LOL! Yes, a lot of it does take place during meals, and in this particular story, I often describe the food. In fact, a couple people asked me for a "RaM cookbook." I couldn't manage that, but I did give them a RaM menu list! Still have it somewhere.
Minerva needs a cape. Super Minerva!
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Yes, Minerva to the rescue!
Um.... am I stupid or.... where did I miss that Albus had been married and Minerva knew about it - and what is this about a baby and house elves? *scratches head*
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Minerva didn't know about it -- she only just learns about it from her Uncle Perseus that day when she goes to see them for the afternoon, and then she mentions to Albus that she hadn't known that he'd been married & that his wife's death sounded sad, so Albus tells her about his marriage & his wife's death, and then a few of the ensuing events.So I think you need to go back over the chapter. That bit starts here:“Yes, he’d mentioned the same thing. He said you’d been fairly close at one time—you, Collum, Perseus, a few others.”Albus nodded.“I hadn’t known that you’d been married, Albus,” Minerva said softly.“It was a very long time ago, my dear.” Albus sighed. He was as old as he was, and there was no escaping it. “You may find it difficult to understand how it could be so, but I rarely even think of it anymore. No disrespect meant to Dervilia. But it has been a very long time.”That's from the copy on my computer, so there may be a slight difference between that & the one on the archive -- still catching typos and other glitches years later! LOL!
Response from Fishy (Reviewer)
I did re-read it, it just didn't flow as well as most of your other work does - no worries!And aye... you will NEVER get rid of all typos, I have found. After working for a newspaper for ever, and having 14 editors pour over your work, not only do you keep some of your own typos, but end up with a few of theirs as well!*winks*Despite my complete exhaustion between these two, I'm still READING! Patience is begining to wear... pray for me.
“Yes, we thought so at the time, once we got over the shock of receiving it.” Merwyn puffed a few more times. “She is quite devoted to you, you know, Albus,” he said, looking down at the bowl of his pipe.*snip*“Partly lucky, partly astute – I recognised what I could have with Egeria and grasped it with both hands, never to let go . . .”Now that's not something you see every day.... a FATHER pushing a man toward his daughter... and I love how incredibly empathetic Merwyn is, and how much he trusts his daughter.
Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)
Thank you! Merwyn and Minerva are quite close, really, and he does want her to be happy.Remember, too -- I'm pretty sure it's already been mentioned in the story, but maybe not in detail -- Merwyn was the one who taught Minerva before she went to school, so she spent a lot of time with him. She did accompany her mother on her "rounds" sometimes, but she actually spent more time with him than with her mother, so she knows him well. He was a scholar who was home all day, even when he was working, so they had an opportunity to become close.He's also a Ravenclaw. Hard to get much past him!
Response from Fishy (Reviewer)
Funny you mention that. In my MMAD fic, Minerva's father is a Muggle - thus, never was sorted, though her mother was also, Ravenclaw. Funny again, that in my fic, Minerva and her father are closer than she and her mother - at least in some ways, though her dad ended up being the only non-magic member of the family.Ravenclaws are usually pretty astute.