Heaven or Hell
MsTree358 Reviews | 6.88/10 (358 Ratings, 0 Likes, 34 Favorites )
Severus is found alive after the final battle, and the Wizengamot, in their wisdom, sentences him to five years of probation at Hogwarts.
Start ReadingChapters (38)
About MsTree
Author
MsTree
Member Since 2007 | 11 Stories | Favorited by 106 | 999 Reviews Written | 918 Review Responses
A citizen of Calontir, living in the State of Misery, located north of Are-Kansas and south of Iowewaytoomuch. Writer of fiction who reads more than is healthy for her and owned by two terrors... I mean, terriers. ^_^
Reviews for Heaven or Hell
"Miss Granger, do you really want to watch me in the tub?"A question that if asked at another time, might elicit a different answer. ;p I do like Severus' letter to Minerva. He is a different man, away from the stresses of the war. Acerbic certainly, but more at peace with himself too.
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
Thank you. This is the first fanfic I ever wrote and I'm happy you're enjoying it. ^_^
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
Thank you. This is the first fanfic I ever wrote and I'm happy you're enjoying it. ^_^
Now that the story is nearly done, I thought I'd spend a pleasant afternoon and evening thoroughly enjoying the story again. :)I really like the way you've incorporated both Muggle Medical and Wizarding methods together. They fit seamlessly and act as a catalyst for many reconcilliations between all the characters.As for Rita Skeeter, may she run into either a metaphorical or real bug catcher that she can't extricate herself from. :p
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
*grin* But then what would our heroes have to complain about? I'm glad you enjoyed my very first ever fanfic (even though I've posted others in between). Right now I'm working on a sequel tentatively entitled "A Heaven or Hell Wedding". Imagine Elizabeth, Narcissa, the Hogwarts teachers, and Molly planning a wedding. I think SSHG are seriously considering an elopement. ^_^
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
*grin* But then what would our heroes have to complain about? I'm glad you enjoyed my very first ever fanfic (even though I've posted others in between). Right now I'm working on a sequel tentatively entitled "A Heaven or Hell Wedding". Imagine Elizabeth, Narcissa, the Hogwarts teachers, and Molly planning a wedding. I think SSHG are seriously considering an elopement. ^_^
They have been through Hell, now they can find heaven, { sorry I couldn't help myself } Thank you for a lovely, exciting, and moving story. 
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
You're welcome! The epilogue is in the queue right now, and I'm working on another story temporarily entitled "A Heaven or Hell Wedding". Stay tuned. ^_^
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
You're welcome! The epilogue is in the queue right now, and I'm working on another story temporarily entitled "A Heaven or Hell Wedding". Stay tuned. ^_^
This was such a great story thank you., I loved every chapter I am sad to see it end but alas all good things must come to an end. Hoee you will be writing some thing new soon
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
Thank you. I've posted the Epilogue to the queue, so look for it sometime soon (I hope). *grin*I've been mulling some ideas in my head about doing a short piece (less than ten chapters at most) on the wedding and the preparations leading up to it. While I haven't done a great deal of writing on it yet, imagine the efforts of Minerva, Flitwick, Poppy, and Ginny mixed with Narcissa's, Molly's, and Elizabeth's ideas. The mind boggles, doesn't it? Can you say "elopement"? ^_~
Response from just harry (Reviewer)
That would be fantastic. I laughed out loud just thinking about what Severus would think about all the ladies acting like they have gone crazy. Oh please do it. ELOPEMENT HERE WE COME.
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
Thank you. I've posted the Epilogue to the queue, so look for it sometime soon (I hope). *grin*I've been mulling some ideas in my head about doing a short piece (less than ten chapters at most) on the wedding and the preparations leading up to it. While I haven't done a great deal of writing on it yet, imagine the efforts of Minerva, Flitwick, Poppy, and Ginny mixed with Narcissa's, Molly's, and Elizabeth's ideas. The mind boggles, doesn't it? Can you say "elopement"? ^_~
Response from just harry (Reviewer)
That would be fantastic. I laughed out loud just thinking about what Severus would think about all the ladies acting like they have gone crazy. Oh please do it. ELOPEMENT HERE WE COME.
Read this story a while back and found it again. Absoutely love it! Can't wait for more!
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
Thank you. I put Chapter 27 into the queue last night. Give it a few days (or weeks depending on how busy the admins are *grin*) and there will be an update. ^_^
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
Thank you. I put Chapter 27 into the queue last night. Give it a few days (or weeks depending on how busy the admins are *grin*) and there will be an update. ^_^
Her life just isn't easy, is it? Everyone trying to marry her off to their son.
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
Ironic, considering her first few years at Hogwarts. ^_^
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
Ironic, considering her first few years at Hogwarts. ^_^
Love the experimenting idea. LOL Very academic.
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
What else would you expect from two bookworms? ^_^
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
What else would you expect from two bookworms? ^_^
Ah, some sense. Something tells me Minerva won't be mad at them too long.
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
Oh, I hope not. ^_^
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
Oh, I hope not. ^_^
Love the idea of Minerva as Albus and complaining about the beard. It'll be interesting to see how the evening goes.
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
I thought it a nice touch. ^_^
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
I thought it a nice touch. ^_^
You know, I would have thought Hermione would have liked the idea of a costume feast. Severus I can see being completely against it.
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
Hermione's been spending too much time with Severus, if you ask me. ^_^
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
Hermione's been spending too much time with Severus, if you ask me. ^_^
Good to be a professor and just vaporize a Howler rather than waiting for it to go off. I do feel a bit sorry for Hermione getting isolated from Molly, but I really don't think Molly ever felt as warmly towards Hermione as she did Harry.
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
No, I think the only reason Molly tolerated Hermione was her friendship with Ron and Ginny. Molly was as prejudiced as Lucius, in her own way. *ducks hex* ^_^
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
No, I think the only reason Molly tolerated Hermione was her friendship with Ron and Ginny. Molly was as prejudiced as Lucius, in her own way. *ducks hex* ^_^
Still can't think of a fate evil enough for Skeeter, though I keep trying. Maybe Lucius should buy the Daily Prophet and kick her out on her can?
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
I think she'll get hers in the end. Just haven't written the right story yet. ^_^
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
I think she'll get hers in the end. Just haven't written the right story yet. ^_^
Poor Narcissa out in the Muggle world having problems. Hopefully new books will make Severus happy.
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
I loved writing the scene in the bookstore. Who knew Narcissa was a closet Muggle romance reader? ^_^
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
I loved writing the scene in the bookstore. Who knew Narcissa was a closet Muggle romance reader? ^_^
Uh-oh, I see Hogwarts book club being formed. LOL
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
It certainly seems like it. (whistles and looks the other way) ^_^
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
It certainly seems like it. (whistles and looks the other way) ^_^
Poor Severus. Asking about something to read is definitely telling of his mental state at his imprisonment of sorts. At least he knows where to get his book fix and knows his house is safe.
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
Of course, he manages to instigate something as well, and gets some enjoyment out of that. ^_^
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
Of course, he manages to instigate something as well, and gets some enjoyment out of that. ^_^
Someone needs to do something seriously nasty to Rita - just sayin what everyone is thinking. 
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
Severus already did (even if nobody can prove he did anything). ^_^
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
Severus already did (even if nobody can prove he did anything). ^_^
I'd definitely be interested in seeing if Severus has an animagus form. Probably because we have some around here, I see him as a big black crow or raven. Nice interlude for everything and nice insight into Minerva.
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
Minerva has always reminded me of my favorite English teacher from HS. Pretty much the same personality even though one was from Scotland and the other from Boston. ^_^
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
Minerva has always reminded me of my favorite English teacher from HS. Pretty much the same personality even though one was from Scotland and the other from Boston. ^_^
Finally some good news for poor Severus. Though there are worst places to be stuck than Hogwarts, I can comopletely understand the cabin fever or not being able to leave the grounds.
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
It seems to me that four and a half years of basically "house arrest" would need to be tempered a little. After all, probationers in the "real" world are allowed to go out and about. ^_^
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
It seems to me that four and a half years of basically "house arrest" would need to be tempered a little. After all, probationers in the "real" world are allowed to go out and about. ^_^
Very cool. I always thought Hermione would be a good candidate for becoming an animagus. Ocicats are beautiful cats, too. And much more useful in animal form than her otter patronus.
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
I know. I love the breed and Hermione seemed to be a perfect fit for the characteristics. ^_^
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
I know. I love the breed and Hermione seemed to be a perfect fit for the characteristics. ^_^
At least that didn't go pear shaped. Poor Draco seems a bit disappointed. Nice to see everyone getting along.
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
He was disappointed because he didn't get to use the hexes he really wanted to use on the Weasel. ^_^
Response from phoenix (Reviewer)
It seems he also neglected to bear in mind the Weasel is an Auror. Big whoops there. LOL
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
He was disappointed because he didn't get to use the hexes he really wanted to use on the Weasel. ^_^
Response from phoenix (Reviewer)
It seems he also neglected to bear in mind the Weasel is an Auror. Big whoops there. LOL
I really can't wait to see what goes down at this wedding. Should be priceless. Or a complete disaster since there are so many 'moving parts'. LOL
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
I dunno. Seems to me it went well. ^_^
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
I dunno. Seems to me it went well. ^_^
Loved the outcome. Nice to see everyone so civil about it
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
Civility is highly overrated. ^_~
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
Civility is highly overrated. ^_~
Nice to see everyone having some fun. LOL Scheming Slytherin Severs.
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
Oh, it gets much worse (funwise). ^_^
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
Oh, it gets much worse (funwise). ^_^
Wonderful chapter. I love the Severus-Minerva banter and of course the snarky Severus, who appears to be a bit jealous right now. LOL
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
He's always been a bit unsure of himself in my opinion. ^_^
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
He's always been a bit unsure of himself in my opinion. ^_^
Wonder what the news could be. So nice to see Minerva on his side. I always like to think they had a good friendship and friendly rivalry going on.
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
I have to agree with you. I didn't like their interactions in DH in the least. Of course, that was probably for the best. ^_^
Response from MsTree (Author of Heaven or Hell)
I have to agree with you. I didn't like their interactions in DH in the least. Of course, that was probably for the best. ^_^