Learning
Chapter 24 of 30
livvy6Severus and Harry talk about themselves in hopes of
understanding the other more. However, when the topic of Hermione comes up,
all the hard work between them may have been for naught.
Huge thanks to my wonderful, anonymous beta! Please review, I'm addicted to reviews!
Chapter 24 Learning
"You know it was this same couch where I held you when you were so sick with a terrible cold and colic," Snape said softly as he sat with Harry in front of the fire.
He and Harry were sitting comfortably, side by side, in his sitting room. After they had embraced, the two men didn't know what to do. Sitting and having a drink seemed in order.
"What did you do?" Harry whispered as he looked at him in awe.
Snape's eyes glazed over, and his face brightened as he reminisced. "I told your mother to get on to bed, she was worn out. I rubbed your little chest down with oils to help you breathe, gave you a potion to ease the colic, and I placed you right here on my bare chest," He patted his chest with his hand. "You snuggled right up and slept. I remember rubbing your back and kissing your head. You were a good baby, Harry. The seven months I had with you and your mother were the happiest of my life," he said, remembering fondly.
Harry looked at his new dad and said, "Tell me about her. What was she like?"
Snape sighed. "Your mother was an angel. She was beautiful. She had a smile that could make everything okay again. She loved to play with you." He pointed to the rug in front of them. "She would sit on that rug in front of the fire and play with you for hours. She would talk, sing, and read to you. She had a lovely voice that was so soothing, and you responded so well to her. You and I would just stare at her in awe. She used to tease me and tell me I was a terrible influence on you. She'd say, 'How will Harry ever to find a good witch of his own if he loves me so much?'"
Harry laughed. Snape smiled. Harry liked his smile; it made his face seem more likeable. "You have her laugh, you know," Snape confided. "So infectious...so carefree. You are more like her than you think, Harry."
"Professor Lupin said something like that to me once," he said quietly as he watched his hands roll his glass of firewhisky between them.
Snape turned sharply, making Harry lift his face to look his newly acquired dad in the eye. "Your mother wanted a future for you, Harry," he said in his normal serious tone. "She wanted you to be happy. Find a good witch and give your mother grandbabies. She wanted you to be whatever would make you happy with your life. It is immaterial what you chose for a living," he said urgently. "Just be happy!" It sounded more like him...a command. Harry almost laughed, but Snape wasn't done.
"I know Miss Weasley is the one for you. Don't let her slip away," he said tenderly.
"I won't," Harry whispered. "I promise."
Severus cleared his throat. He was becoming choked up. He sat back and stared into the fire, leaning his head onto one hand.
Harry sensed his unease and said, "It's so strange! I was so sure you hated me with a passion."
"No, Harry," he replied, still gazing into the fire. "I would at times become frustrated, angry, annoyed, irritated, and just plain brassed off at the stunts you pulled over the years. What was uppermost in my head was trying to make sure you didn't accidentally kill yourself with your own stupidity!" he said harshly. He sighed, looked at him and said, "It's hard when you take on the responsibility of being a parent. Your mother's dying wish was for me to raise you. I was not able, but I had you in my sights for six years. Not a day passed that I did not fear for you, pray for you, and, yes, even love you.
"At times, in the beginning, I hated that an eleven-year-old could make me feel so vulnerable. I know I was cruel when I had no reason to be. I know that I could have shown you more care. I just didn't know how. I only knew what my own father had been like. He was a hard man, and he wanted me to be tough so no one would take advantage of me. He demanded I do well in school and approved of my learning Dark magic. He, being a Muggle, couldn't believe the kind of power that a wizard could possess. He would look through the books my mother had from her father on the Dark Arts, and he would tell me, 'Learn this, boy! You don't have the brawn to fight like a man, well, by God, you'll learn to fight like a wizard. You will beat them all at their own game if anyone tries to hurt you!'"
Harry was listening with wide-open eyes. Here were the answers to the motives and reasons behind the wizard who was Severus Snape. Harry had always wondered why he was so stern all the time. He knew it couldn't have been just his existence!
"For a Muggle, my father accepted magic rather well. The darker my knowledge grew, the more impressed he became with me. The ability to be cruel and cold meant being a real man. He knew he wasn't an intelligent man, so he demanded that I learn to speak like 'a gentleman,' he called it. He would thrash me horribly when I did not perform or learn my lessons fast enough. Complaining just got me another thrashing. He said that in the real world, people weren't patient or kind. The real world was hard and cold. Men and women alike were vicious and cutthroat. So, he said he was being the best father he could be by being cruel so I would be tough enough to be a real man in a man's world. He always said, 'Wizard or no, it's still a man's world when you get down to it, my lad!'
"I decided you had enough people to give you hugs and tell you that you were special and loved. I wanted to give you something important, so I gave you what I thought would be the greatest gift I could give: the gift of being a man in a man's world. I knew you were going to have to kill the Dark Lord. I wanted you to be prepared. I knew I couldn't come close, even on my worst day of being nasty and sadistic, to the level of sadism the Dark Lord possessed. Yet, I had to do it. I had to viciously push you...even if there were times I just wanted to...tell you how I really felt," he mumbled at the end uncomfortably.
Harry felt a surge of compassion and connection towards the dark wizard, but he didn't know how to voice it, or if he would be cut down verbally if he tried.
"What about you, sir? You want me to be happy, what about you? Wasn't there another witch over the years that you cared about?" he asked carefully.
"No," he said flatly. "Your mother's memory was enough for me. I never wanted anyone else, however..." He trailed off.
"Yes?" Harry asked.
"Nothing, Harry. I am trying to understand all of this. Lately, many things have been changing. So, do you think you have your questions answered about your mother?"
Harry nodded sadly. "I think from what you told me, that my mum knew she couldn't give me the future she wanted me to have as long as she was alive. I mean, we'll never know for sure, but I do know that it didn't have anything to do with you, sir. From what I've been told, my mum did feel sad and guilty that she didn't have the same feelings for you that she still had for my dad, but I think she just didn't get it!"
"Get what?" Severus snapped.
"Love. I loved Cho. I know I did. Yet, things didn't work out. Then Ginny came along. I love her. I still have a part of me that still feels for Cho, and although she's dead, it'll always be there. That doesn't mean I love Ginny less, just different. I can't love Ginny like I loved Cho. Ginny isn't Cho. Some blokes try to get their women to be and act like a certain 'type' of woman and that's just wrong. So, of course my mum wouldn't love you like she loved my dad. You aren't my dad...James Potter. I think she did love you; she just still missed my dad and was still in a lot of pain and confusion. I reckon that's what pushed her to it. But she had nothing but the kindest and loving things to say about you, sir. I heard about them. Professor McGonagall said my mum confided in her about personal girl stuff, you know, feelings and such." Harry couldn't say what he wanted, that he knew for a fact his mum talked to McGonagall about her sex life with Snape.
Snape raised an eyebrow. He started muttering to himself. Harry strained to hear, but couldn't. Snape jumped up and poured himself another drink, tossing it back forcefully.
He turned around, his eyes glaring, boring into Harry's. The young wizard became edgy and raised his Occlumency walls. Snape scowled at him.
"Please! I have no inclination towards rummaging through your head!" he sneered.
Harry was angry. "Why do you have to be such a bastard?" he yelled.
Snape barked out a laugh. "Really, Potter, what did you expect me to do? Just sit back as you confess how you had a great laugh with Minerva about my most intimate moments with your mother?" he spat viciously.
"So, what did Lily say? That James was the best she'd ever had, and I was a pathetic replacement? I bet you loved that! The old greasy bat of the dungeons is also a terrible lover as well!" he demanded angrily.
"You know, you really are a git!" Harry yelled at him.
Harry went to the Floo and called for Professor McGonagall.
"Professor, it's Harry. Can you please step into Professor Snape's rooms please?"
A minute later, Minerva came in confused, looking between the two men.
Harry raised his hands and stepped back. "There is only so much reality I can handle, and my mum's sex life just doesn't fit. I suggest you direct your accusations towards Minerva and not me!" he yelled at Snape before turning swiftly and storming out.
Minerva watched the young wizard walk out angrily. Then, she turned around to Snape and with her eyes snapping, lit into him.
"What is going on, Severus? I sent a hopeful and reasonably calm young man down here! What happened?" she yelled.
Snape was still raging with fury. "Why don't you tell me, Minerva? It seems all the rage! First Lily, now Potter! How many blasted people need to know I'm a lousy fuck?"
Minerva narrowed her eyes. "You are a sorry fuck, Severus Snape, but from what Lily told me, not so much a lousy one!"
Snape froze. He was confused. "What?' he snapped.
She took a deep breath and shook her head in frustration as she sat down. "Lily was guilt-ridden because she was having such a great time in the sack! She was having such a great time, she even said you were a better lover than James!"
"Ah, yes! That old lie...she fed that one to me as well," he said smugly.
"For someone who prides himself on being right, you are sure dead set on remaining wrong!" the headmistress spat.
Snape threw his glass into the fireplace. "Why did she leave me? Why! She had to have been miserable with ME! I could have fixed anything else that was wrong!"
"Oh, really?" mocked Minerva. "You could just take care of all the rogue Death Eaters wandering the country? All by yourself? My, aren't we full of ourselves! Even Albus never fooled himself into believing he could do all things alone!"
Snape fell onto the couch and covered his face with his hands. "It'sit's not even about her anymore, Minerva," he whispered.
He looked so small and helpless, like the little boy she knew so long ago. She budged down next to him.
"Severus, what is it?" she asked with her hand on his back.
"I kissed Miss Granger," he whispered.
She sucked in her breath and closed her eyes. She knew Hermione loved Severus; she had just hoped nothing would come of it.
"Minerva, I'm afraid. I'm so afraid; I don't know what to do anymore. I feel I can't trust anything," he whispered brokenly.
"Severus," she said quietly. "Lily was a very wounded person. I think in a way she did use you, but not with malice in her heart. No, she wanted things to fit between you. She truly did."
"Potter said she killed herself because she thought she was hindering him from having a real future," he offered.
"That would make sense. Harry's future meant everything to her. She loved him. He is her son. Severus. You are going to have to accept that Lily's death had nothing to do with you, really. You were a good man to her, and she knew it. She appreciated you..."
Snape jumped up. "Damn it, Minerva! I don't want anyone's gratitude, pity, or their fucking appreciation! I want someone who will love me! Someone who wants to only be mine!" he howled desperately.
Minerva sat pale-faced and stricken in her heart. This was what it all came down to, she realized. Severus just wanted to be the love of someone's life, not to chase after a love that could be his only if he tried hard enough to earn it.
"Severus, why do you love Harry?" she asked.
"He's my son! The day I first held him, I just fell in love with him. He looked at me and was so happy and content and...I don't know, I just do!" he snapped.
"He was just a baby. He did nothing to earn that love, right?" she prodded.
"Right," he muttered.
"Then you see where forcing love can get you? Let Lily go, Severus. She never meant to hurt you, but it's apparent she did. And now you have a chance to have a real relationship with Harry. But you also need to face that there is right now a young woman in this very castle who considers you to be the love of her life!" she pleaded.
He turned sharply and gave her piercing glare.
Harry walked back in. "It's true, sir. I can't say I've approved, but it's real, and she's been hurting for a while now," he confessed.
Snape slowly walked over to the fireplace and cast a quiet "Reparo," and the broken tumbler glass flew together into one piece.
If only one could do that spell with a person's heart...
Story Actions
To follow, favorite, like, and more either log in or create an account.
Leave a Review
Log in to leave a review.
Latest 25 Reviews for Love Remains
500 Reviews | 5.65/10 Average
Thanks forsuch an original story!
Yay!!!
Am so glad this isn't the last chapter. Some authors just stop in the middle of nowhere once the end is in sight! :))
Thanks for embarking on this prompt!
Good job! Thanks for wearing your heart on your sleeve as an author with these raw emotions which we readers sometimes may miss in other ffs!
Nice ending. I always like a happy ending and this was a good one. I like the poor kid isn't Albus Severus. LOL I always thought that after all Albus did, he did not deserved to be honored that way.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Me too! If anything, if Dumbledore HAD to be included it should have been reversed. But yes, I thought he was a manipulative old bastard.I'm glad you enjoyed my fic. It was a real gut-wrencher to write, but it makes the happy endings that much sweeter!Thank you for all your reviews!
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Me too! If anything, if Dumbledore HAD to be included it should have been reversed. But yes, I thought he was a manipulative old bastard.I'm glad you enjoyed my fic. It was a real gut-wrencher to write, but it makes the happy endings that much sweeter!Thank you for all your reviews!
Nice to see that went without the proverbial hitch, that neither or them has hosed it up yet.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
LOL! What can I say? Where Severus is concerned a cock-up is always around the corner when it comes to relationships!Thanks!
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
LOL! What can I say? Where Severus is concerned a cock-up is always around the corner when it comes to relationships!Thanks!
Good man, finally putting his past behind him. And he really did need to ensure that Hermione heard it from him. Hopefully he can really move forward now.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Yes, they had to lay it all on the table for there to be a chance at a future.Thanks!
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Yes, they had to lay it all on the table for there to be a chance at a future.Thanks!
Severus, I thought you were over Lily. *sigh* He and Hermione really do need a good long conversation. Hopefully once she's no longer a student they can get to it.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Oh, he is over Lily. It's just that he doesn't know if he has it within him emotionally to do it all over again. That's basically what it gets down to. He is terrified.Thanks!
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Oh, he is over Lily. It's just that he doesn't know if he has it within him emotionally to do it all over again. That's basically what it gets down to. He is terrified.Thanks!
I love the last line. It really is true, isn't it. Hopefully once he lets the truth about Lily's suicide sink in he can begin to heal from all those years of pain. Poor man.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Thank you. There is a lot to absorb after so much time has passed.Thanks!
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Thank you. There is a lot to absorb after so much time has passed.Thanks!
Oh, Severus, love blinded you to the truth and having your heart broken like that... (sorry no sense there LOL). Good thing that Harry went digging for the truth and that Albus meddled one last time sending him to Malfoy. While I like Malfoy, I do like the idea of him being broken and powerless after everything happened, a pariah (though I think he would be like the
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
and rising from the ashes LOL). it's nice to see Harry and Severus coming to terms with what might have been the truth.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
It seems all ironic that it was Malfoy to open the eyes of Harry into what was going through Lily's mind that night. She knew exactly what her fate would be if she stayed with Severus, and she couldn't bring herself to take Harry away from him.Thanks!
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
and rising from the ashes LOL). it's nice to see Harry and Severus coming to terms with what might have been the truth.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
It seems all ironic that it was Malfoy to open the eyes of Harry into what was going through Lily's mind that night. She knew exactly what her fate would be if she stayed with Severus, and she couldn't bring herself to take Harry away from him.Thanks!
I like Harry's quest. It's really enlightening and he can learn a lot about himself as well as Severus. Though he may begin to have as many regrets as Severus and Dumbledore over how his life might have turned out.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
True, but that is one of the benchmarks of becoming an adult: knowing that life doesn't turn out the way they could have and that people make choices that make thier lives and the lives of the little ones in their charge different than what could ahve been.Thanks!
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
True, but that is one of the benchmarks of becoming an adult: knowing that life doesn't turn out the way they could have and that people make choices that make thier lives and the lives of the little ones in their charge different than what could ahve been.Thanks!
I love how it was her intellect that really turned him on. Remus really is his voice of reason and he was right to curse Lily. She really did damage Severus. One can only hope that Hermione can some day heal him, and hopefully some day soon because her insight into the cure/control could be vital.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Yes, Remus is going to find himself frustrated a lot between Harry, Hermione and Snape and all their drama. lol! Poor Remus!
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Yes, Remus is going to find himself frustrated a lot between Harry, Hermione and Snape and all their drama. lol! Poor Remus!
Severus, you are human, embrace it. It's not going to go away no matter how much you try to hide it. I suspect that no longer being a pawn is goiing to make it harder for him to hide the fact that he is human.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Severus is going to to have to reasses how he views himself, life, and realtionships. There are no excuses, like I have to be this way because of the Dark Lord, blah, blah, blah. It's going to take time to get there.Thanks!
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Severus is going to to have to reasses how he views himself, life, and realtionships. There are no excuses, like I have to be this way because of the Dark Lord, blah, blah, blah. It's going to take time to get there.Thanks!
Nice closure for both Harry and Severus at the graves. I really think that was necessary for them both. And I like how Severus has slipped into father mode.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Thanks! I think it had to be this way for them to go forward, especially Severus.Thanks!
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Thanks! I think it had to be this way for them to go forward, especially Severus.Thanks!
Let the emotional floodgates open. Confusion really is a good name for this chapter with everyone learning new bits of the truth and trying to make sense of it all. I think Harry was spot on. He has had his parents on a pedastal and being told they are human in the past has always been hard for him to grasp.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
It is hard when you realize your parents are just normal people with feet of clay. Harry will have to come to terms with that.Thanks!
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
It is hard when you realize your parents are just normal people with feet of clay. Harry will have to come to terms with that.Thanks!
Very well done. That actually went better than I thought it would. I thought for sure Harry would have asked the hard question right after Severus mentioned Lily poisoning herself. Now to see if he can actually bring himself to answer the question.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
It's going to be a difficult time for both of them, but they will get there.Thanks!
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
It's going to be a difficult time for both of them, but they will get there.Thanks!
Nice filler scene with how he helped the students and why Ginny and Neville stuck up for him. He really did have quite the balancing act to carry out. And nice touch with the rocking chair and the duck.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Thank you. Needed to get the emotions in there with Severus fears about a possible future relationship. Then how he wants things to be different for Harry than it was for him.Thanks!
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Thank you. Needed to get the emotions in there with Severus fears about a possible future relationship. Then how he wants things to be different for Harry than it was for him.Thanks!
I was a bit taken aback by them still being at Grimmauld Place, but I do agree that it facilitates a lot as that is neutral territory unlike The Burrow. I can completely see Severus unable to understand compassion and love since he has spent so long ignoring them and quite possibly never really understood them.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Yes, Severus is quite stunted with more positive emotions. He is more comfortable expressing nagative ones. It will just take time.Thanks!
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Yes, Severus is quite stunted with more positive emotions. He is more comfortable expressing nagative ones. It will just take time.Thanks!
Lupin has some wonderful insight, though both Severus and Sirius are childish enough to utterly ignore it. Gits. I look forward to what Severus has to say to Harry. Or is this the Occlumency bit? Anyway, on to the next chapter. LOL
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Oh, yes. The Occlumency bit is going to be a big thing for Severus and he will have words with someone about it.Thanks!
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Oh, yes. The Occlumency bit is going to be a big thing for Severus and he will have words with someone about it.Thanks!
It's a shame that Severus can't really see the benefit of having friends, even if it is someone much younger than him. And he should know that Hermione is really just eager for approval and he is giving her exactly what hurts her most by belittling her all the time.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Yes, although Severus has stop terrorizing prostitutes, he still is a miserable git. Remus will around more and will help him out.Thanks!
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Yes, although Severus has stop terrorizing prostitutes, he still is a miserable git. Remus will around more and will help him out.Thanks!
Poor Severus. It's horrible to see one person so emotionally scarred. And it is horrible that he had to take it out on Evangeline. No one should have to be subjected to that, but at least he wasn't entirely horrible towards her, teaching her about pleasure. Small consolation, but there it was.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
This was the low point. Severus has now reached the depths of his pain and from now on will begin the small move upwards. I hope you continue to like where I take him, Harry and someone else ;)Thanks!
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
This was the low point. Severus has now reached the depths of his pain and from now on will begin the small move upwards. I hope you continue to like where I take him, Harry and someone else ;)Thanks!
I like how he is looking out for her and asking her to be herself and not just an extension of him.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
That is key to a good relationship!Thanks for reviewing!Livvy
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
That is key to a good relationship!Thanks for reviewing!Livvy
Dang! That was harsh. It is nice to see that he helped her, but to have his help thrown back at him like that. Ouch! I'm sure that will only serve to make him less secure. Poor man. Everything he does out of kindness is rewarded with pain.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Yes, it is very painful, however, he has not yet worked out his anger with Lily, nor has he reconciled with Harry. I think these must happen before he can have a real relationship. But yes, it still hurts.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Yes, it is very painful, however, he has not yet worked out his anger with Lily, nor has he reconciled with Harry. I think these must happen before he can have a real relationship. But yes, it still hurts.
Poor Severus. Lily really did destroy him, didn't she? It is nice to see that he is still human however. If only he would listen though. All he could see from Lupin was rule breaking and proof of how Harry and company had been doing so, not that there could have been a mistake.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Yes, he really was destroyed. I can't think of a better word, but true.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Yes, he really was destroyed. I can't think of a better word, but true.