Compassion
Chapter 11 of 30
livvy6After a disturbing conversation with Lupin, Severus seeks to find solace with a prostitute and is forced to face the truth of his cruelty.
ReviewedHuge thanks to my wonderful, anonymous beta! Please review, I'm addicted to reviews! This was one of a couple disturbing chapters I had to write. I want to place an extra warning on this chapter. I did not put down Abuse/Rape as a warning, but rather Dubious Consent because the interaction takes place between Snape and a prostitute. He does pay her; however, I do believe that prostitutes can be taken advantage of, and in this case, I believe it to be true. Snape is not a nice person to be around and won't be for the next couple chapters. However, I shall make sure warnings are placed when needed. I don't want to spring anything on anyone unawares.
It is not my intent to make light of rape or the mistreatment of prostitutes. Any woman violated, regardless of her life choices, is a crime. Snape will not come out of these next couple of chapters unscathed.
Chapter 11 Compassion
Spring, 1994
Lupin nervously sat around a small table at the Hog's Head. He had something he desperately needed to tell the wizard who had reluctantly become his friend. He sipped on his firewhiskey as he glanced periodically at the door. Finally, he noticed the black-clad figure of Severus Snape walk through the entrance. He stood to alert Severus to his table, and the wizard calmly made his way towards him.
As he reached the table, the dark wizard sat down gracefully. "Well, Lupin, this ought to be good since I can't have all and sundry know that I even remotely approve of you," he snarked.
Usually, Lupin would have smiled and laughed at his friend's backhanded attempts at friendly conversation. But things had changed...for good. He did not know how Severus would even take the news, let alone accept what he had to tell him.
Lupin swirled his firewhisky around in his glass before swallowing it down. Best to have some liquid courage in him for this conversation! He looked at Severus. He was sitting stiffly, glowering, and growing impatient. He crossed his arms around his chest, looking decidedly put out. Yet, there was concern etched on his face.
Lupin circled his tumbler around with his fingers, watching the amber liquid swirl. "Severus, you and I have had quite the year, haven't we?" he said, testing the waters.
Snape rolled his eyes. "What is this, Lupin? A stroll down memory lane? I haven't the time." He rose to leave.
"Sit." Lupin didn't even look at the wizard, but his tone was unmistakable. Lupin only used that tone when it was absolutely necessary. Snape sat back down and took off the sardonic mask he normally wore. Whatever it was, it was serious.
Lupin looked at him and whispered darkly, "Severus, I need you to listen very carefully at about what I am to tell you and not react. It could be potentially dangerous for anyone to know something was amiss. I have some very disturbing news, and you and I need to discuss it and try to come to a reasonable decision. Agreed?" he asked forcefully.
Snape nodded curtly and remained silent.
Lupin continued. "I was rather fortunate to come across an old artifact from our old school days. You recall, Severus, a bit of parchment that you confiscated from Harry that insulted you when you tapped it with your wand. I perused the parchment. It held a great deal of sentimental value for me. It was in fact a map. A map that James, Sirius, Peter, and I created. This map was not like any ordinary map. It is a magical map showing the whereabouts of every person on Hogwarts grounds. It cannot lie. It's important that you understand that, Severus, because I have seen the name of Peter Pettigrew on the map."
The mentioning of Pettigrew's name made Snape's head snap to attention and his eyes to narrow.
"No," he insisted. "Black killed him. He killed him, just like he tried to kill Lily and Harry!" he hissed.
"I know it's mad!" Lupin whispered in reply. "Unfortunately, it doesn't change the fact that Sirius has been working awful hard to get into Hogwarts. And for what? Why after all these years would he now come here to Hogwarts if were not for the fact that Pettigrew is alive?"
"You're raving!" Snape said condescendingly. "I saw with my own eyes, Black did everything except drag Lily out of our rooms. He was completely mad, I tell you! He had gone round the twist. I'm sure Azkaban has done nothing to improve his temperament! He's trying to kill Harry, I know it! Now, what is this really about?" he hissed. "Are you secretly helping your old friend for old times sake?" he accused the werewolf.
Lupin was undeterred. "Severus, I only want the truth. What if...no, listen! What if Pettigrew had been the betrayer? What if Pettigrew had been responsible for all those deaths in Muggle London and pinned it all on Sirius? What if it had been Sirius who had confronted Pettigrew and not the other way around?" he questioned.
"Lupin, I think I need to rethink your Wolfsbane Potion. Obviously, it has addled your brain!" Snape seethed. "Sirius Black is the vicious monster that tried to kill Lily and Harry and is responsible for turning against his so-called best friend and murdering him!"
He leaned in and threatened the wizard. "Lupin, we have made strides I never thought possible in our relationship out of our mutual love for Harry. However, my patience only goes so far. If I even smell a hint of a conspiracy between you and Black, I shall have no other recourse than to bring you both to the attention of the Dementors! Do not test me, wolf!" he growled.
He stormed out of the Hog's Head, and Lupin ordered another firewhiskey. That had gone badly. There seemed to be nothing he could do to stop the coming confrontation between the four of them. He only hoped Harry would not get hurt in the process.
***
Snape was enraged at the audacity of Lupin to suggest that Black had been wrongfully imprisoned all these years. All because of a bloody map! Well, at least he knew the secret behind all their near escapes from the professors! They'd had a detailed map of the comings and going of every witch and wizard at Hogwarts!
He was getting too old for all this. He was drinking heavily and eating less and less. He probably was an alcoholic like his thrice-damned father! Well, the apple doesn't fall far from the tree! Look at how he had failed at fatherhood and love for that matter! He needed to get laid. He was drunk enough to get himself a willing whore and fuck her brutally. He made it a source of pride to hurt his whores in direct proportion to how much pleasure he had given Lily. He had let more than one whore walk away in pain after an encounter. He was getting quite the reputation for being a hard and cruel wizard. Not many whores wanted to fuck him anymore, but he could always find a desperate hag who would take his money. A cunt was a cunt. If a whore was resistant to his brutality, it was all the better for him! Fear made cunts tighter. The crying and whimpering was music to his ears. It was the truth. He had been lied to by Lily. She had only endured and suffered his touch. If she had been honest, she would have screamed and begged him to stop rutting on her. So, he went in search for the truth.
He found a plain, young whore on the outskirts of the Alley. She was filthy. He had hood of his cloak over his head, obscuring a part of his face and offered her more Galleons than she could ever hope for in a week's work of peddling her pussy. Once the agreement struck, he lowered his hood, and a look of terror crossed her face. He smiled coldly as he spun her around and yanked up her skirt.
"This is going to hurt, but I think after the money I've paid for your favors, you can take it," he whispered evilly.
She shuddered as he cast a cleansing spell on her privates. The women could be as ugly as sin, but he wanted his pussies clean. He tore into her viciously, and she choked and screamed as he pounded into her. He grunted and panted into her ear. He didn't touch her except to keep his arm around her waist. He continued for a long time, her blood creating the lubrication he needed to make it easier. He finally came and withdrew from her. She cowered as she slid to the ground.
"I know you hate me, but I paid you well, whore," he sneered.
She was crying. No whore had ever broken down before. It unnerved him.
"What is wrong with you? If you can't take a cock, you need to take on a different occupation!" he snapped viciously.
"It's j-just it was my first night selling myself. I never had...sex...before," she whimpered.
He bowed his head in defeat and threw a bag of Galleons in her lap. "Get to a Healer and get some potions for the pain. Next time, be more aware. Wizards such as myself are not interested in virgins," he sneered.
He wanted to not care. He wanted to walk away and forget her, but his feet wouldn't move. She looked so helpless and broken. His conscience hurt him. He knelt down and took the witch's arms in order to help her up from the ground. She flinched, but when she saw he wasn't going to hurt her, she relaxed to his touch.
"What is your name?" he asked.
"Moira," she answered.
"Moira, get the hell out of here. You don't need to spend your life doing this. You don't have to do this."
"I don't have anything. Death Eaters killed my brother, and he was the only family I had. My parents were too poor to send me to Hogwarts, and now they are dead. I had to learn my magic at home. I don't have an education. I don't know how else to survive!" she admitted desperately.
Snape felt his chest clench at the mention of Death Eaters. As far as he knew, he could have been the one to cast the Killing Curse! He cleared his mind and focused on the girl. "Well, I've given you 100 Galleons. That's a start. Meet me here at this time, this day, every week, and I shall give you more, and don't worry, you don't have to give me anything in return. I don't want to see you whoring ever again. Have I made myself clear?" he ordered.
"Yes, sir," she said. "What is your name?" she asked.
"I'm no one, Moira. I'm of no account," he answered darkly as he withdrew from her. Then he stood, turned sharply on his heel, and left.
Story Actions
To follow, favorite, like, and more either log in or create an account.
Leave a Review
Log in to leave a review.
Latest 25 Reviews for Love Remains
500 Reviews | 5.65/10 Average
Thanks forsuch an original story!
Yay!!!
Am so glad this isn't the last chapter. Some authors just stop in the middle of nowhere once the end is in sight! :))
Thanks for embarking on this prompt!
Good job! Thanks for wearing your heart on your sleeve as an author with these raw emotions which we readers sometimes may miss in other ffs!
Nice ending. I always like a happy ending and this was a good one. I like the poor kid isn't Albus Severus. LOL I always thought that after all Albus did, he did not deserved to be honored that way.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Me too! If anything, if Dumbledore HAD to be included it should have been reversed. But yes, I thought he was a manipulative old bastard.I'm glad you enjoyed my fic. It was a real gut-wrencher to write, but it makes the happy endings that much sweeter!Thank you for all your reviews!
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Me too! If anything, if Dumbledore HAD to be included it should have been reversed. But yes, I thought he was a manipulative old bastard.I'm glad you enjoyed my fic. It was a real gut-wrencher to write, but it makes the happy endings that much sweeter!Thank you for all your reviews!
Nice to see that went without the proverbial hitch, that neither or them has hosed it up yet.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
LOL! What can I say? Where Severus is concerned a cock-up is always around the corner when it comes to relationships!Thanks!
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
LOL! What can I say? Where Severus is concerned a cock-up is always around the corner when it comes to relationships!Thanks!
Good man, finally putting his past behind him. And he really did need to ensure that Hermione heard it from him. Hopefully he can really move forward now.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Yes, they had to lay it all on the table for there to be a chance at a future.Thanks!
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Yes, they had to lay it all on the table for there to be a chance at a future.Thanks!
Severus, I thought you were over Lily. *sigh* He and Hermione really do need a good long conversation. Hopefully once she's no longer a student they can get to it.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Oh, he is over Lily. It's just that he doesn't know if he has it within him emotionally to do it all over again. That's basically what it gets down to. He is terrified.Thanks!
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Oh, he is over Lily. It's just that he doesn't know if he has it within him emotionally to do it all over again. That's basically what it gets down to. He is terrified.Thanks!
I love the last line. It really is true, isn't it. Hopefully once he lets the truth about Lily's suicide sink in he can begin to heal from all those years of pain. Poor man.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Thank you. There is a lot to absorb after so much time has passed.Thanks!
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Thank you. There is a lot to absorb after so much time has passed.Thanks!
Oh, Severus, love blinded you to the truth and having your heart broken like that... (sorry no sense there LOL). Good thing that Harry went digging for the truth and that Albus meddled one last time sending him to Malfoy. While I like Malfoy, I do like the idea of him being broken and powerless after everything happened, a pariah (though I think he would be like the
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
and rising from the ashes LOL). it's nice to see Harry and Severus coming to terms with what might have been the truth.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
It seems all ironic that it was Malfoy to open the eyes of Harry into what was going through Lily's mind that night. She knew exactly what her fate would be if she stayed with Severus, and she couldn't bring herself to take Harry away from him.Thanks!
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
and rising from the ashes LOL). it's nice to see Harry and Severus coming to terms with what might have been the truth.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
It seems all ironic that it was Malfoy to open the eyes of Harry into what was going through Lily's mind that night. She knew exactly what her fate would be if she stayed with Severus, and she couldn't bring herself to take Harry away from him.Thanks!
I like Harry's quest. It's really enlightening and he can learn a lot about himself as well as Severus. Though he may begin to have as many regrets as Severus and Dumbledore over how his life might have turned out.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
True, but that is one of the benchmarks of becoming an adult: knowing that life doesn't turn out the way they could have and that people make choices that make thier lives and the lives of the little ones in their charge different than what could ahve been.Thanks!
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
True, but that is one of the benchmarks of becoming an adult: knowing that life doesn't turn out the way they could have and that people make choices that make thier lives and the lives of the little ones in their charge different than what could ahve been.Thanks!
I love how it was her intellect that really turned him on. Remus really is his voice of reason and he was right to curse Lily. She really did damage Severus. One can only hope that Hermione can some day heal him, and hopefully some day soon because her insight into the cure/control could be vital.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Yes, Remus is going to find himself frustrated a lot between Harry, Hermione and Snape and all their drama. lol! Poor Remus!
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Yes, Remus is going to find himself frustrated a lot between Harry, Hermione and Snape and all their drama. lol! Poor Remus!
Severus, you are human, embrace it. It's not going to go away no matter how much you try to hide it. I suspect that no longer being a pawn is goiing to make it harder for him to hide the fact that he is human.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Severus is going to to have to reasses how he views himself, life, and realtionships. There are no excuses, like I have to be this way because of the Dark Lord, blah, blah, blah. It's going to take time to get there.Thanks!
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Severus is going to to have to reasses how he views himself, life, and realtionships. There are no excuses, like I have to be this way because of the Dark Lord, blah, blah, blah. It's going to take time to get there.Thanks!
Nice closure for both Harry and Severus at the graves. I really think that was necessary for them both. And I like how Severus has slipped into father mode.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Thanks! I think it had to be this way for them to go forward, especially Severus.Thanks!
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Thanks! I think it had to be this way for them to go forward, especially Severus.Thanks!
Let the emotional floodgates open. Confusion really is a good name for this chapter with everyone learning new bits of the truth and trying to make sense of it all. I think Harry was spot on. He has had his parents on a pedastal and being told they are human in the past has always been hard for him to grasp.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
It is hard when you realize your parents are just normal people with feet of clay. Harry will have to come to terms with that.Thanks!
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
It is hard when you realize your parents are just normal people with feet of clay. Harry will have to come to terms with that.Thanks!
Very well done. That actually went better than I thought it would. I thought for sure Harry would have asked the hard question right after Severus mentioned Lily poisoning herself. Now to see if he can actually bring himself to answer the question.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
It's going to be a difficult time for both of them, but they will get there.Thanks!
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
It's going to be a difficult time for both of them, but they will get there.Thanks!
Nice filler scene with how he helped the students and why Ginny and Neville stuck up for him. He really did have quite the balancing act to carry out. And nice touch with the rocking chair and the duck.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Thank you. Needed to get the emotions in there with Severus fears about a possible future relationship. Then how he wants things to be different for Harry than it was for him.Thanks!
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Thank you. Needed to get the emotions in there with Severus fears about a possible future relationship. Then how he wants things to be different for Harry than it was for him.Thanks!
I was a bit taken aback by them still being at Grimmauld Place, but I do agree that it facilitates a lot as that is neutral territory unlike The Burrow. I can completely see Severus unable to understand compassion and love since he has spent so long ignoring them and quite possibly never really understood them.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Yes, Severus is quite stunted with more positive emotions. He is more comfortable expressing nagative ones. It will just take time.Thanks!
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Yes, Severus is quite stunted with more positive emotions. He is more comfortable expressing nagative ones. It will just take time.Thanks!
Lupin has some wonderful insight, though both Severus and Sirius are childish enough to utterly ignore it. Gits. I look forward to what Severus has to say to Harry. Or is this the Occlumency bit? Anyway, on to the next chapter. LOL
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Oh, yes. The Occlumency bit is going to be a big thing for Severus and he will have words with someone about it.Thanks!
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Oh, yes. The Occlumency bit is going to be a big thing for Severus and he will have words with someone about it.Thanks!
It's a shame that Severus can't really see the benefit of having friends, even if it is someone much younger than him. And he should know that Hermione is really just eager for approval and he is giving her exactly what hurts her most by belittling her all the time.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Yes, although Severus has stop terrorizing prostitutes, he still is a miserable git. Remus will around more and will help him out.Thanks!
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Yes, although Severus has stop terrorizing prostitutes, he still is a miserable git. Remus will around more and will help him out.Thanks!
Poor Severus. It's horrible to see one person so emotionally scarred. And it is horrible that he had to take it out on Evangeline. No one should have to be subjected to that, but at least he wasn't entirely horrible towards her, teaching her about pleasure. Small consolation, but there it was.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
This was the low point. Severus has now reached the depths of his pain and from now on will begin the small move upwards. I hope you continue to like where I take him, Harry and someone else ;)Thanks!
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
This was the low point. Severus has now reached the depths of his pain and from now on will begin the small move upwards. I hope you continue to like where I take him, Harry and someone else ;)Thanks!
I like how he is looking out for her and asking her to be herself and not just an extension of him.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
That is key to a good relationship!Thanks for reviewing!Livvy
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
That is key to a good relationship!Thanks for reviewing!Livvy
Dang! That was harsh. It is nice to see that he helped her, but to have his help thrown back at him like that. Ouch! I'm sure that will only serve to make him less secure. Poor man. Everything he does out of kindness is rewarded with pain.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Yes, it is very painful, however, he has not yet worked out his anger with Lily, nor has he reconciled with Harry. I think these must happen before he can have a real relationship. But yes, it still hurts.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Yes, it is very painful, however, he has not yet worked out his anger with Lily, nor has he reconciled with Harry. I think these must happen before he can have a real relationship. But yes, it still hurts.
Poor Severus. Lily really did destroy him, didn't she? It is nice to see that he is still human however. If only he would listen though. All he could see from Lupin was rule breaking and proof of how Harry and company had been doing so, not that there could have been a mistake.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Yes, he really was destroyed. I can't think of a better word, but true.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Love Remains)
Yes, he really was destroyed. I can't think of a better word, but true.