New Chapter for A Murder of Crows
A Murder of Crows
HogwartsClassof911,052 Reviews | 7.3/10 (1,052 Ratings, 0 Likes, 798 Favorites )
Adult Hermione wants to forget the mistakes of her past. Snape
knows all about secrets and lies. Forced to work together, their dislike for
one another turns into reluctant desire. Will they learn to trust each other in
time to stop the insidious plot bent on changing the future of the wizarding
world forever?
Chapters (33)
About HogwartsClassof91
Author
HogwartsClassof91
Member Since 2008 | 6 Stories | Favorited by 316 | 137 Reviews Written | 1,552 Review Responses
"A Murder of Crows" was my first foray into fan-fiction, and I treasure the lessons I've learned while posting it.
Reviews for A Murder of Crows
Wow, she just barged in and had at him. Good for her! I can certainly understand his reasoning, but really, things are only going to work for this project, as well as their future, if they are honest.
I wondered how you were going to force them to believe in each other. Nice use of the Patronus change. I especially loved that Hermione named hers.
Believe him or not, she still must be a little nervous for what the next day will bring. Off I go ...
Every time I start a chapter I think, "This is the one that will answer my questions, or make me feel better about the situation." But by the end, things are always worse. Man this thing is a roller coaster ride.I was so nervous for her the entire time at Arglist and during the escape. I kept thinking, "Severus, just say something that will make it clear to Hermione that you are fooling Lucius, but that he won't understand." I know he didn't know she was there, but I was still hoping it would happen. Of course, if they leave the same way she did, he will probably figure out without much work, who might have been there.So, will he be waiting for her when she arrives? Will she blindside him? Will she show up all furious only to find he isn't there?Two things occurred to me while reading this chaoter. McGonagall seemed quite interested in making sure they spend time together. If he is playing Lucius, maybe she is helping. I always trust her judgement. And/or since you made it clear that Neville went to read to him and he was able to hear every last miserable moment of it, did Lucius visit him as well and spill some secrets? Or is it all coincidental, and the only reason he is at Arglist now is that he is setting the framework for giving Lucius the altered memories?The biggest question of all remains: Why am I sitting here speculating when I can just read on?
Response from HogwartsClassof91 (Author of A Murder of Crows)
Your last question made me laugh! Why, indeed? :-)I'm sure you don't really want answers, but I appreciate your sharing the speculations running through your mind as you read. It's always fascinating to hear how each individual reader has such different expectations and interpretations. Yours have been spot-on with where I wanted the reader to be at each step, which is one of the reasons I've enjoyed reading your reviews so much. You've made me feel like a very clever little author!Interesting theory about McGonagall. We shall see in a few chapters whether the headmistress's arrangements were coincidence or motivated by something else. Getting very near the end now. Oh, and I should mention that I didn't intend for Snape to be aware of everything going on around him while he was semi-Petrified. Sorry ... I probably didn't make that very clear in the early chapters. He did hear Neville reading to him now and then, but his moments of lucidity were few and far between. Just wanted to clarify, since I'm sure I didn't do a good job of explaining that in the story. Someday, I'll go back and clean up the first half of the story. Maybe. :-)
Response from HBAR (Reviewer)
Oh, I think I knew that he wasn't aware 24/7, but at least was in and out enough throughout the duration that he could have heard people talking around him. You are nervous about your early writing, and while I will say that I think your writing gets stronger as you go, it was already well above and beyond the average new writer from the start.
“We weren’t sure what you might like, so we had a contest to determine who would ask Professor Snape for a suggestion.”Hermione had a feeling the task had fallen to the loser of the contest, not the winner.Too true! This cracked me up. But then, what a wonderful gift, both the fact that her students thought so much of her, and because Severus did as well. I came to the same conclusion as she did even before she voiced it: it is important to him, but maybe he gave it to her with the thought that it would still be his because she would be his.Interesting conversation between Draco and Hermione. I'm sure she does feel miserable about the choices she has to make.The teacher tracking spell is genius and certainly would come in handy. Lucky Hermione befriended a house-elf. Or maybe not so lucky. Damn you, woman! This is the sort of moment I have been dreading (even though deep down I think he is a good guy), and I can almost hear you laughing at me during the last few chapters, knowing this was coming. Grrr! Off to read more.
Response from HogwartsClassof91 (Author of A Murder of Crows)
I think it was sweet of the students to approach Snape (as terrifying as that must have been) and work so hard for the gift. I also think it's funny that they'd go to him in the first place. Is the relationship between Snape and Hermione common knowledge, or do they just reckon one Potions professor knows what to get another? Adults often forget just how observant kids can be ...I promise I wasn't laughing at you over the past few chapters (although a 'heh, just you wait' might have slipped out). You're too savvy a reader not to have suspected something dreadful near the end. I've proved you right, that's all ...
I love that they were caught and chastized like a pair of students by McGonagall. And she wants Hermione to use her relationship to get what she wants from Severus, but they use it against her in order to get more snogging time. :)I was so pleased with the Snape/Neville interaction. And how shell-shocked Neville was.Sandy was in interesting character. I wonder if she is important in this story, or if she was just a device for the monument (which was a great concept, but both beautiful and creepy).
Response from HogwartsClassof91 (Author of A Murder of Crows)
I love the headmistress in that chapter, so torn between propriety and getting what she wants. And Neville ... poor man, half-terrified by the sight of a kinder, gentler Snape. :-)I was about to type, "I'd forgotten about Sandy," but I realize I've been doing that in nearly every review and you must think I'm half daft by now. Memory like a sieve, I tell ya. You'd never know I'd wrote the freaking thing to begin with. But I'm glad you found Sandy interesting. I believe we haven't seen the last of her ...
I am very glad that the visit to the Granger's went as well as it did. I especially enjoyed the part where her father carried on about her old potions professor :)Why on Earth can't Severus just love her? I know he is insecure and scared and all that, but come on. Is there more to it, or is he just a big baby? I do hope that changes.Lovely picture, by the way.
Response from HogwartsClassof91 (Author of A Murder of Crows)
I enjoyed embarrassing Hermione in this story, although it's nothing to what I did to the poor woman in one of my other stories. But really, who is allowed to bring their significant other around to their parents for the first time and *not* be embarrassed at some point?I think he's fighting an awful lot of demons. Six months ago, he was lying on the floor of the Shrieking Shack, taking one last look into Lily's (Harry's) green eyes before he died. Fourteen years may have passed, but he was in and out of consciousness during that time, so in his mind it probably doesn't seem like all that long ago. I think he's jumped some enormous hurdles already, just to get to the point where he recognizes Hermione as an equal, allows himself to be attracted to her, to be with her, and to care for her. Love ... well, that's not going to come easy. Let him adjust to the idea that someone might actually love him, that it's not simply the notions of a "foolish girl" ... then we shall see what happens.Nothing is easy with this man. But that's why we love him. :-)
I love how Hermione teases him about the gobs of baby Severuses born shortly after the war. He would just die if she were serious.The scene in the minister's office was very, very interesting. Just what is he up to? And the "he" in that statement I believe refers to both Severus and Ustinov. Now Severus seems more to be plotting in a good way than bad. He and his buddy Millie. I loved his complete 180 in attitude when he spoke with her!
Response from HogwartsClassof91 (Author of A Murder of Crows)
Yes, I think it would have been very interesting to be a fly on the wall in the Minister's office after Hermione left. There does seem to be something afoot ... with both men.I love Millie; you just now she's hoping for a different man in the Minister's chair.
“That doesn’t matter anymore! You could have ruined everything!”“What does that mean?” she asked. “What could I have ruined?”“Nothing … I misspoke,” “Are you involved with something at Arglist?”Well, this is the conversation I have been waiting for, but I had hoped for a better answer from him. Not that I don't love it that he cares about her and is concerned about her welfare, but is that really, really what he is talking about?He is a character (especially in this story) that makes it really hard for me to trust him, but also really hard for me not to trust him. Frustrating man!Incidentally, if you begin to get hate mail in your inbox, it is probably my family wondering what happened to hot meals and clean laundry. Of course I'll give them your name. It is your fault that I can't get anything else in life done at the moment :)
Response from HogwartsClassof91 (Author of A Murder of Crows)
I agree. I think I would have liked to hear an emphatic denial to that question. He can be so frustratingly cagey sometimes! Then again, I'd expect no less from a man who had lived so long as a spy. I think he is very, very careful about what he says. Which is why the "could have ruined everything" was so surprising. (To him, as well, seemingly.)Thanks for the heads-up on the hate mail! :-) I will be happy to tell your family that hot meals and clean laundry are overrated, especially when there's fic to be had!
I haven't liked this new minister since he was first introduced at the party. I do hope that Severus is really tryihg to keep her from the ministry for her own safety, and not due to an ulterior motive. How does he know it will all be over soon?
Response from HogwartsClassof91 (Author of A Murder of Crows)
That's an excellent question. Funny how a simple statement can be both reassuring and menacing, depending on one's viewpoint.
Oh, man, I was really nervous for her. It was good that she took Severus' advice and pretended to not be intimidated by Lucius, but I couldn't help feeling a little nervous about her going with him alone.You have written Lucius disgustingly suave, and everytime he opens his mouth I think I nearly break out in hives.You could just feel the pull of Hermione towards the amazing lab. And she is so right about all of the wonderful things they could accomplish. I had hoped that the promise of fame and fortune would win out over blood prejudice, but some things never change.And then Lucius has to go and mention Snape and trust issues. I am having enough of those as it is, thank you very much.
Response from HogwartsClassof91 (Author of A Murder of Crows)
I think Hermione would agree about the trust issues! One has to wonder whether he truly knows something or simply enjoys toying with her. He's not a nice man, that's for certain. Evil must pay well, given that amazing lab. All those resources, wasted. And of course the crusader in Hermione couldn't resist trying to sway him, even if it was a hopeless cause. I'm just glad she kept her wits about her. And I enjoyed the double stunner. :-)
Schitz & Drewls Baby Emporium ... you make me laugh at least several times per chapter.I like how you've used Ron as a vehicle to put doubt in the minds of both Hermione and the reader where Snape is concerned. Even though Ron is never really in favor of Snape, he isn't whiny about it here, or dwelling on what could have been with Hermione. He is simply pointing out his feelings toward the man, and at least has a basis for them. If terrible acts had to be committed to achieve a virtuous result, was the person performing the acts terrible or virtuous? What a great way to put that. And, I don't have an answer any more than Hermione does.Somehow, she just knew this wasn’t going to end well.Well, that makes two of us. I hope she can remember Severus' words about not letting him affect her. Not that it will be easy with someone like Lucius. Oh, the man creeps me out!
Response from HogwartsClassof91 (Author of A Murder of Crows)
Ha! I'd forgotten about the baby emporium ... that made me giggle again. I would totally shop there. I actually liked Ron's character in the books, although I know he's not very popular in this ship. Sure, he frustrated me at times, but then they all did. That's just life, right? No one does what we want them to do 100% of the time. Canon-Ron was a good foil for Harry, even if he's totally wrong for Hermione. I could never see that relationship lasting. I don't think Hermione respected him enough to make a marriage work. But that's the beauty of fan-fiction ... I get an opportunity to "fix" all the little things that bothered me. Like Snape dying, obviously. And Lucius escaping unscathed.
I am a bit horrified at how much I enjoyed the naughty storeroom scene *pretends to blush*“Why do you insist on wearing those preposterous Muggle clothes?” “Well, I used to wear them because they were comfortable.” ... “But from now on, I believe I’ll wear them just to irritate you.”I couldn't love your dialogue between these two any more!And then the info about Arglist ... hmmm. I hope he has a good reason for keeping it from her after their pledge for no more lies.You don't have to respond to every review. It could very well take all of your free time. But I am glad that you do, because it is fun to see your thoughts (even though you never put me out of my misery about anything!)
Response from HogwartsClassof91 (Author of A Murder of Crows)
Heh, these two put the "private" in private storeroom. :-) I'd forgotten all about that scene.So glad you're enjoying the dialogue. Canon Snape had a lovely wit to him, I thought, and I like to imagine Hermione getting a bit less shrill with maturity. I adore her when she sasses him.And then I have to ruin the fun with another sprinkling of suspicion. Why would he have hidden the article from her? And did they *both* pledge 'no more lies,' or was that something Hermione said? Can't remember whether he answered ... Or maybe I can. ;-)
I, too, would be shocked if Draco had anything to do with Arglist. But, you never know. I can't help the niggling feeling that Snape is somehow more involved than we know. I hope not, but ... well, I don't know what to think.I am glad he did not let her leave the lab without clearing things up. Both of these guys let things irritate them, and then instead of resolution, they let it simmer all day until they are consumed by it. Maybe "they" are growing up as a couple.Of course, just like you, I love it when they fight. :)And just where does Snape run off to all the time?
Response from HogwartsClassof91 (Author of A Murder of Crows)
I love your observation that they are growing as a couple. In this story, I imagined them both as fairly naive in the relationship department, so they are both learning as they go.As to Snape's periodic disappearances ... that is quite a mystery, is it not? ;-)
I have literally just finished reading this and I have to say that was an exquisite piece of storytelling. Your grasp of the characters is second-to-none and your story/plot and pacing rivals anything by JKR herself. Thank you for sharing your artistry with us, your readers. Thank you!
Response from HogwartsClassof91 (Author of A Murder of Crows)
Thank you for sharing this lovely feedback! I'm delighted you enjoyed the story. In fact, I did a little happy-dance when you said the pacing rivaled the originals - high praise indeed! Your words will keep me going as I edit the original fiction novel I just finished. It will be a long process, so I'm beyond grateful to have kind words like yours for the days when I'm convinced it's all rubbish!Thanks for reading and taking the time to leave a review. I really appreciate it!
I don't remember ever laughing so hard at a story as I did at the drunk Hermione scene! It was wonderful!
Response from HogwartsClassof91 (Author of A Murder of Crows)
Aww, thank you so much! What a lovely compliment. I had great fun writing that scene, and I sometimes wish there had been more humour in this story. (Which is why, I suppose, I wrote "All You Need is Love," a SS/HG story where I could be as silly as I wanted.) Thanks so much for reading and leaving this review!
My boss was very upset today when I called in sick... you see I had this amazing story I HAD to finish!!! Once I started I just couldnt stop! I feel like I just read a new HP book!!! I loved every single chapter! I litterally felt every emotion while reading this, I hated Snape (the alcove scene in the begging... Him just LEAVING HER there, and saying what he said... AHHHH!!! I FELT what Hermione was feeling!) and I fell in love with Snape. I really love how you developed their relationship. I thought the concept was very origional, and the mystery brilliant, I gotta say I didnt see the last bit coming! LOL Thank you SOOOO much for writting this, I really REALLY hope you write another long story like this soon. Your an amazing writer!
Response from HogwartsClassof91 (Author of A Murder of Crows)
Aww ... Thank *you* so much for this lovely, heartfelt review! I can't tell you how much it means to me, knowing someone enjoyed the story and appreciated the effort that went into writing it. It's the ultimate compliment when a reader can actually feel the emotions of the characters, so I thank you very much for opening yourself to that experience (I know it wasn't always pleasant in this story!). Of course, you saying you felt as if you'd just read another HP book is the type of feedback I can happily live off of for the rest of my days! Thank you so, so much for reading my story and leaving me this review. I truly appreciate it!
Out of all the SS/HG stories that I have read this is definitely one of the most original plot that I have seen. And your Severus has the perfect balance of all. In all a good read. Keep it up.
Response from HogwartsClassof91 (Author of A Murder of Crows)
Thanks very much - it's been months since I've received a review for this story, and I tend to forget it's still out there! I appreciate you reading and leaving a review for me.
Thanks so much for the read, again. Absolutely a great ride. And you added some more humor in this chapter, just for me! Right? ;) Thanks, thanks and some more thanks!
Response from HogwartsClassof91 (Author of A Murder of Crows)
Absolutely - I was writing the epilogue and thought, "I bet someone will read this in a year and REALLY appreciate more humor." Good thing I listened to intuition! Thanks so much for all your lovely comments; I really enjoyed reading them!
I hope that each of my little reviews - although they are more like comments because I rarely actually review - pushes you a bit more towards that 1K mark you set for yourself. And you were right, the ending was well worth all the motion sickness after riding all those emotional roller coasters. Sigh. I'm adding this story to my favorites and after reading the epoligue I plan on moving on to more of your stories! I'm very excited and interested in what I may find. You definitly capture their characters very well and I think you do them justice. And again, I love the humor - the thing that drew me into this story in the first place. Not being able to label Hermione as a girlfriend/lady friend/lover was cute - but don't tell him I said that. Thanks very much for the story, lady, it has been one of the best I've read in a long time. I'm sure I'll come back to it time and time again simply because of the re-read value. :)
Response from HogwartsClassof91 (Author of A Murder of Crows)
You're very kind; thank you for these lovely comments. If you enjoyed the bits of humour in this story, you might like "All You Need is Love," the gift I wrote for the SSHG Exchange last year. It is more or less angst-free, and there are parts that still make me laugh to think of them! Definitely my favourite as far as humour goes. Thanks again for all your feedback - I really do appreciate it!
So, of course, I wanted to say "OMG! NOOOOOOOO!" to continue my review theme. And as it would have been appropriate (AGAIN) I won't. Mostly because well, it's almost comical how much I want to say it. Seriously, so heartwrenching. He's begging her! BEGGING HER! Now he's had to endure two deaths (although hers might not count right now since I don't know for sure if she's dead or simply in a coma or what have you). A man can only take so much!
Response from HogwartsClassof91 (Author of A Murder of Crows)
You know, I think yours is the only review I received that commented on his helping cause such dreadful events in the lives of the two women he loved. That fact was very much in my mind when I wrote the chapters, so I'm delighted to have someone mention it! As you will see in the next chapter, it is on someone else's mind, as well.
OMG!!! NOOOOOOOOOOOO! This appears to be a revolving theme of my reviews. So. Can anyone say, awkward? Geeee. So, I'm a bit, well. Apprehensive to read on. Mostly because well its so awkard. But you'll have that. IIEE. And I'm so close to finishing - FINALLY!
Response from HogwartsClassof91 (Author of A Murder of Crows)
OMG!! YESSSSSSSSSSSS! LOL - I'm enjoying your reviews immensely!
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!! EVIL! Well. At least I said that I had hoped it wouldn't happen. And there it is... happening anyway. I guess I should have said I suspected it - because I did - but there's no proof of that. Oi. Well. I'm not sure I want to continue... mostly because this has turned out to be rather sad. But as I am trying very hard to convince myself that perhaps this chapter is too a trick I suppose I will read on. My spirit is dampened though. :( "Remember the mare" ... pfft. As if, Snape! AS IF!!
Response from HogwartsClassof91 (Author of A Murder of Crows)
If you say you suspected it, I believe you! Honestly, I wanted readers to still carry some doubts at this point, and considering what we know of Snape from canon (and from the liberties I've taken in this story), you are wise to suspect all is not as it would seem. I am glad you've decided to read on - I would be very sad if you'd come this far only to stop now. I hope the ending will prove you've made the right choice!
AH-HA! Good news! But with all this flip-flopping around I sure hope Snape doesn't flip back to the dark side. That would be a total let down. ;( But boy, when these two fight, they sure fight, don't they?
Response from HogwartsClassof91 (Author of A Murder of Crows)
They are indeed very strong-willed, passionate people, their disagreements will channel those aspects of their personalities. I wouldn't want to witness their fights, to be sure. Regarding flip-flopping ... well ... I loved the way Snape's character (in canon) always made me second-guess my instincts and struggle with whether or not to trust him. I hoped to include some of that same distrust in this story, so it really comes down to whether each reader believes in him to do the right thing or not. All will be explained by the end, I promise. :-)
OMG! SAY IT ISN'T SO!! Well, still, there are a few chapters left... and possibily... that Chapter that has Death in the title doesn't really mean... death. Although, the rest of the chapter titles were pretty spot on. Sooo... oh boy. Totally going to jump to the next chapter now! I'm glad I found this story in its entirety or else I probably would have had died of anticipation already.
Response from HogwartsClassof91 (Author of A Murder of Crows)
I posted the last several chapters with only a few day's gap in between them, as I felt it would have been cruel to do otherwise. Sometimes I wish I hadn't, as it means fewer reviews (and I'm dying for the day this story pushes into the 1,000-mark territory), but I'm an impatient reader who understands the pain of waiting, so I couldn't bear dragging out the ending. There are several chapters left, and many more revelations to be had, so carry on, dear reader, carry on. Thanks so much for the review!!
You say that this was your first fanfic. But you write it as a seasoned writer. There was some kind of silly server maintence done last night so I wasn't able to read throughout the night like previously desired. And this chapter is a bit heartwrenching. Between her crying and his anger it was a bit hard to read all at once. Why is he such a meanie? Sigh. As this story has a bunch more chapters (YAY!) I am under the impression that things turn out all right in the end. :)
Response from HogwartsClassof91 (Author of A Murder of Crows)
Poo on server maintenance interrupting our fanfic indulgence! :-) This was a dreadful spot to have to leave off, but I wanted to assure you I am a die-hard, SS/HG shipper and cannot envision a world where they don't end up together. I hope you have the nerve to persevere to the end of the story! I like to think it's worth it. :-)