... You and I Collide - Part II
Chapter 3 of 9
livvy6How can you live when your whole life has been a lie? A Death Eater's daughter needs answers about her dead father, and Severus Snape is the only one who can help her. Unfortunately, he wants nothing to do with dredging up his past. Inspired by "Collide" by Howie Day.
ReviewedA/N: Thanks to my beta, ImOnMedication! She's awesome. I would love to get some feedback on this. I'd love to know your thoughts on Snape being a victim. Remember, reviews are better than chocolate!
***
"I must say, Severus, that was the most disappointing display I have ever seen," said Dumbledore reprovingly. "You acted like a fifth year...damn your infernal temper!"
Snape sulked in his chair. It was uncharacteristic for the Headmaster to speak to him in such a tone, but Snape had never acted in such an unprofessional manner towards a student during all his years of teaching. And in front of the other Heads of Houses! It was a good thing she ended up a Slytherin, or one of the other professors may well have had his hide for breakfast!
Dumbledore sat in his chair behind his desk and observed the surly young wizard.
"Severus," he began in his normal tone. "I have never asked or pushed for you to divulge information that was not pertinent towards the defeat of Voldemort. However, it seems there is some history, some deep-seated...dare I say hate...towards this young girl?"
"Headmaster, I have precious little privacy as it is. May I please ask that you not force this issue?" he spat bitterly. "I shall give you my word that I shall treat Miss Dangler no better or worse than any other student."
"Severus, I received an owl today. I was going to discuss this while Miss Dangler was with us, but alas, we must do this now. You do know Madam Peale?"
Severus frowned. "Peale? You don't mean the Potions mistress, Margaret Peale?"
"The very same. She lives here in this country, but years ago, she moved to France when she married and had a child. Soon after the birth, she divorced and returned to England. Her husband refused her to take the child out of France. The child is our Miss Dangler."
Severus was stunned. "Margaret Peale had a child? Isn't she old?"
Dumbledore smiled. "Well, yes, she was 40 when she had Amanda, but that is not the point. You are aware of her reputation. She is one of the most honoured and well-respected Potion mistresses in the country. She is very determined that Amanda be apprenticed in Potions. It seems Amanda wants to become an Auror, and that is unacceptable to Madam Peale. She is insisting that you take her on for a two-year apprenticeship after she finishes her term here."
Snape was incensed. "Absolutely not! Absolutely NOT! I don't want that little chit around me anymore than is necessary!"
"And again, Severus, I cannot seem to avoid the issue. What history could there possibly be between you and a 17-year-old girl?"
"It's her father!" Snape blurted out bitterly, annoyed at the insinuation of impropriety.
"Severus," Dumbledore sighed. "Not another student that will bear the brunt of your spleen because of the 'sins of the father'? Aren't you rather occupied in that area with Mr. Potter?"
Snape glared at the old man. "This is nothing like Potter. This is nothing like that. And I refuse to talk about it. It's private."
"What shall I say to Madam Peale? Taking her daughter on as an apprentice...that would be a wise move. Very ambitious move, Severus." Dumbledore knew he was playing dirty pool. Ambition and recognition were what fueled the Potions master.
Snape glared darkly at the old man again before he swept out of the office with a loud bang.
***
Amanda woke early, before anyone else. She took her trunk and made her way into the bathroom, showered, and changed. She managed to find her way to the seventh-year girls' dormitory and slid her trunk under an empty bed. A girl stirred in the bed next to her. She quietly stole away and made her way out of the common room with her satchel.
She wandered the halls and stumbled upon the Great Hall. She sat on a chair near the door, fiercely clutching her wand. She must have fallen asleep, she woke up with a start...someone was near her. She jumped.
"I apologize for startling you, Miss Dangler," said Dumbledore. "I noticed you were up rather early and that you had made your way here. Did you sleep well?"
"Yes, sir," she answered.
Dumbledore observed the girl. She was clean, showered, dressed appropriately, but had horrible dark circles under her eyes. There was a look there in her eyes, like a hunted animal. Her eyes never stayed still. She was edgy and nervous.
"Is there something I need to know about, Miss Dangler? Something about Professor Snape?" he asked quietly.
"Snape?" she blurted as she whipped around.
Dumbledore was deeply concerned. The girl was extremely paranoid and clearly frightened of the Potions master.
He tried in vain to meet her eyes. "I want you to know that Professor Snape gave me his word he would treat you like any other student. You have nothing to fear here at Hogwarts, Miss Dangler. I promise you."
"Okay," she muttered. But she still shook. She was trembling with fear.
Students were filing in as well as the teachers. Dumbledore pointed Amanda towards the Slytherin table, and she sat back at the end, far as she could from the High Table where Snape sat.
***
Amanda had been thoroughly embarrassed when Dumbledore had announced her arrival as a new Hogwarts student. She stood and refused to make eye contact with anyone. If she had observed, she would have seen the smarmy leers from some of the Slytherins, and the angry look upon Professor Snape. All she could think of was getting through her Advanced Potions class.
She came in and did not know where to sit. Snape roughly told her he wanted her to sit at the front of the class opposite him at his desk. She wearily went forward and went about her business.
Snape announced they would be making the Draught of Peace Potion. Amanda had precious little room to work with, as his desk was full of all his papers and other students' scrolls waiting to be graded. She felt as if she was being baited, but she knew she couldn't risk getting expelled if she lost her temper again. If she were bold, she would try to pry into his mind, but she was too exhausted and jittery to concentrate. If she had infiltrated his mind, she would have seen his plot to vex her into attacking him again...and in front of her classmates as well! As she worked, she felt his glare on her. Then he began his verbal assault, his voice soft and quiet. Only she could hear his bile.
"I don't know why you are here. It seems a waste of time. You should tell your mother to make you return to Beauxbatons."
"I see the older Slytherin boys looking at you. You have not been prepared for life as a Slytherin. If you are still a virgin, you may as well kiss it goodbye. You probably won't be one by the end of tonight."
She felt her jaw clench at that remark. Her anger was rising dangerously.
"Your father was a swine, and you are probably just like him. Are you a little slut, Miss Dangler? I think I know you better than you realize."
That was it. She'd had enough.
She leveled her eyes to his and shouted out loud enough for the entire class to hear.
"What was that, Snivellus? That was your little nickname, wasn't it?"
The class fell deathly silent, and then someone tittered. Snape's eyes were ablaze. He didn't think...didn't care. He raised his wand and shouted, "CONFRINGO!"
Learning how to Wizard Duel with an ex-Death Eater had made Amanda Dangler a formidable combatant. With amazing skill she screamed, "PROTEGO!" and shielded herself from his curse. The room around her shield blew apart, sending students running for their lives. But it wasn't over.
Amanda dashed over towards the door, and flung a table on its side to shield herself and think of what to do next. She had only a split-second before Snape thundered, "REDUCTO!"
Her table was blasted to bits. She flew back into the wall, wounded from the bits of flying wood.
"INCARCEROUS!" she yelled as ropes flew out of her wand and bound Snape.
He sneered and muttered, "Diffindo."
The ropes burst off him as he slowly stalked towards the girl. Damned if he was let her destroy his room! She was fast, but not fast enough as he shut the door and warded it with a flick of his wand. She tried to work out the wards quickly as he prowled towards her. She finally gave up and ran in the opposite direction screaming, "STUPEFY!"
She missed. She stumbled as a Tripping Jinx hit her. She glanced backward at the wizard. What had she been thinking? Battling a grown wizard! She scrambled to get up and get her wand that had flown out of her hand, but Snape was already standing over her. He placed his boot on her hand and squeezed down. She screeched in pain. He let up and assessed her situation. He grabbed her by her long hair, and pinned her against the corner of the room; his hand wrapped tightly around her throat, but loose enough to allow her to talk.
"Why are you doing this? Who sent you?" he ordered.
"No one sent me," she gasped as she tried to claw at his hand.
"What grudge do you have against me?" he demanded.
"I don't have one, Snape. But you have one with my father. I know. I know everything!" she panted. "Now go ahead, rape me, kill me, torture me...just get on with it, and let me die!"
Snape was frozen in horror. He released the girl and quickly backed off from her. She slipped down the corner. Her robes were ripped, her face bleeding. Her eyes were so black from exhaustion and defeat. What had that animal told her? he thought.
Suddenly, the door blew apart. There stood Dumbledore and McGonagall with the entire N.E.W.T. level Advanced Potions class, staring in disbelief at the shambles of the Potions room. Dumbledore fixated solely on Miss Dangler, wounded and prostrate in a corner, her face peppered with lacerations and her robes torn, with Severus Snape hovering over her, seemingly in a trance, unaware of their presence.
"Severus?" he called out gently.
"Everyone, get out!" Snape roared. "I take full responsibility for this."
"Severus," Dumbledore pleaded.
"LEAVE!" he screamed.
He whirled around with anguish in his eyes. "I assure you, I will take Miss Dangler to Madam Pomfrey, and I will deal with this situation. Now if you please?" he asked curtly.
Dumbledore looked directly into Severus' eyes. The unspoken words in the young man's eyes told him it would be all right. Dumbledore then nodded and led the group away from the room.
When the room finally emptied, Snape knelt by Amanda. "Tell me," he whispered.
"Just do Legilimency. I can't say it." She broke apart sobbing. All of the terror and fear came out.
Snape saw her father hit her, leaving a scar to make her remember his name: Severus Snape. He also saw him forcing his daughter into the Pensieve and saw his own rape and the rape he committed under Dangler's tutelage. Just when he thought he could bear no more, he heard the threat, "You come across him, don't ever let him know you are my daughter, because if you do, he will do to you what he did to that poor Muggle girl, and probably worse. He is one of the most vicious and cunning Death Eaters to have ever served the Dark Lord." Then he saw the suicide. Amanda was covered in her father's blood, screaming, trying to make the blood flow stop. It was enough.
He released the girl's mind. She was lying on the filthy floor, broken in her fear. She truly believed he would do all those things and worse at the first chance. He hated Dangler, hated what he and Lucius had done to him, and hated himself for being the person that such a bright, and intelligent witch would loathe and fear. He looked down again and saw she had passed out. He reached down and picked her up and carried her into his private rooms. He tended to her wounds, and repaired the tears to her robes. He traced the scar on the side of her left eye delicately with his finger. What was he going to do? She knew...she saw the most humiliating moment of his life.
He backed off the bed as if it were on fire. His shame and self-hatred overwhelmed him. She was a mirror of his filth. He had to get her out of here! He summoned Madam Pomfrey, and she helped to get her up to the infirmary. After she was settled, he came back and wrote a letter to the girl, explaining her fears were unfounded and he would not ever hurt her again, and also that it would be best for them to never pass one another's paths. When he finished and had the letter sent, he drank himself into a drunken haze, so full of rage, fear, and shame that he eventually passed out on the floor.
Story Actions
To follow, favorite, like, and more either log in or create an account.
Leave a Review
Log in to leave a review.
Latest 25 Reviews for Collide
35 Reviews | 6.29/10 Average
Wow . . . that was intense! O_o
Response from livvy6 (Author of Collide)
I hope you continue to enjoy the rest of the story! Thanks for reviewing.Livvy
Response from livvy6 (Author of Collide)
I hope you continue to enjoy the rest of the story! Thanks for reviewing.Livvy
wheee... new chapter!The part with "there is both good and evil in people" is true. I mean, a person can actually be two-faced. To have a bright side and a dark one. Snape, on the other hand, blames everything that happened for not having a normal life. Amanda is right: he should really just let go all those horrible things that happened to him.They really, really need each other to discover their true selfs.btw... HPFF is driving me crazy. I finished the new chapter but they took a validation break... 'till january 3rd.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Collide)
Oh, I know. THey are very conservative, but they aren't particular about grammer at all. THat's one of the reasons I started coming here and THe Restricted Section. Well, I'll check after the 3rd for your next chappie.
Glad you liked the chapter!
Thanks,
Livvy
I LOVE Amanda she is a breath of fresh air! Severus needed to hear a few home truths, and she is dishing it to him in spades!
Response from livvy6 (Author of Collide)
Thanks alot. I was sweating over this one. But dammit, I just had this stuff coming out and I'm so glad so far people have been cool with Amanda's views on Lily. Hope you enjoy the rest of the story.
Thanks,
Livvy
I started this story tonight, I usually stay away from OC stories, but your summary hooked me. So, you've asked for the good and the bad...I think your story idea is good, I thought in the first couple of chapters the pace was a little fast...and at times I thought Snape's reactions were a bit over the top...however, I loved the part after they fight in class and he realizes why she is acting the way she does...and I do like the tentative friendship they've developed. OK, this chapter...for me...I can't see Snape asking such personal questions and even her responses seem a bit inappropriate, that being said the part where Snape states that he has forfeited his right to probably have a woman was beautifully written, and it feels like something Snape would think/feel. I'm heading off to the next chapter!
Response from livvy6 (Author of Collide)
Thanks for reviewing! I appreciate all your comments and I have to admit, this story has been the most difficult for me to write. I stuck with it though, trying to see where I could stretch Snape and see how he deals with a very volitile and "in your face" kind of girl that Amanda is. I'm happy you are still sticking with the story. I hope you are satisfied with the conclusion.
Thanks again,
Livvy
This really was a long chapter. Love it. Now for the chapter itself. I think its great that you explained everything in the beginning. It helps put everything into its place. And as for Lucius, never trust anyone who says trust me. lol Thats what I found. Especially someone with the last name Malfoy. Bad news all around. Oh Amanda you go girl. Tell him like it is. If Lily truly loved you she would have been with you not Potter. She made her choice. Deal with it. What you truly want and need is right in front of you. So don't be a git and lose it. She gets in you face and tells you the truth. Now learn something from your past. And I hope Amanda works through her issues with men.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Collide)
LOL! You made me laugh. So true, never trust a Malfoy when he says "trust me". And Lily, oh man, yeah, she needed to tell him off. That's the kind of girl Amanda is, she'll blow you out of the water! Yes, Amanda will be coming to terms with a lot soon.
Thanks for reviewing! I hope you like the next chapter.
Livvy
wow... this is like the best chapter everi simply adore it!!!!the dialogue between those two was simply perfectit was... beyond wordsthat part when she said his namethey need each otherto understand. to accept. to love.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Collide)
Yes! That was what I was hoping to convey. There is so much sorrow in their lives, they need to lean on one another and in turn help each other.
Thanks for reviewing!
Livvy
Oh my what a chapter. It reveled so much. Well done.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Collide)
Thanks for reviewing! I loved writing this chapter.
Livvy
While she has him pegged, doesn't she? She sure will give him a run for his money.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Collide)
They are quite the pair aren't they! More to be revealed!
Livvy
Interesting. Are you implying Severus is a virgin or is he just shocked she isn't?
Response from livvy6 (Author of Collide)
Severus is a virgin in a way, a very important way. Remember from when Amanda viewed her father's pensieve and saw Snape ordered to rape and kill the Muggle girl? That was a significant , or you could say defining moment in his sexual life. I can say that he does feel threatened and perhaps scared that she has had experience and he is very curious as to how "normal" sexual relations are like. Lots of dysfunction and insecurity there with Snape. More to be revealed.
Thanks for reviewing
Livvy
Oh my what could have happened. And Peale wow scary woman. What is it she doesn't she have time to take care of her own child?
Response from livvy6 (Author of Collide)
Madame Peale basically got the crap scared out of her when she realized what kind of man she had married. Dumbledore told Severus Dangler refused her to take the child from him. She is a cold woman and chose to save her own skin and I guess felt even a sexual predator like Dangler would still have enough scruples to keep Amanda safe. You see it a lot with abusive men. For example, Nazis, they loved their families and took care of thier children, but thought nothing at all to torture, rape, and kill Jews. This was the kind of man Dangler was and that will be mentioned later.
Another thing about Madame Peale, she pushed her daughter to take on her profession of Potions mistress, while Amanda had her heart set on becoming an Auror. It is obvious Peale only cares about herself and her own status and she views her daughter as an extension of herself. Amanda will have to come to decision about her mother's forced influence on her life.
Livvy
I don't see Severus as a victim. He chose to become a Death Eater. I don't think staying away from her will help the situation. She needs to see the Severus. All of his sides. To see that her father was a very sick man.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Collide)
Yes, he chose to be a death eater, but did he chose to be raped? That is the victimization I am referring to. Snape will talk about his feelings about his own rape as well as the rape of the Muggle girl.
True, they need each other to help the other to put the past to rest. THey both were given warped ideas of the world and the people in those worlds at a young age- even at 15, 16, 17, those are critical years.
Thanks for reviewing,
Livvy
Response from Arabella Bloodgood (Reviewer)
I wonder if Severus knew what he was getting into when he thought about joining the Death Eaters. Do they tell them ahead of time what is expected of them? If not then the only chose he had was either be raped or killed.
It's amazing the line between love and hate. A very powerful chapter. And the bit about her hexing Draco, loving it .
Response from livvy6 (Author of Collide)
Yeah, I've always hated that little bastard. There is a lot of tension and fear there- on both sides. And it's interesting you pointed that out: the opposite of love is not hate: it is indifference. And these two are NOT indifferent to one another.
Livvy
Oh my I wonder who her father is at first I thought it was Severus and then Voldermort and now I'm just not so sure now. I can't wait to find out.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Collide)
Interesting point of view! Hope you continue to like the story.
Livvy
I must admit that I enjoy your writing style, but I'm dispappointed that all of your stories seem to have the same themes--rape, boy gets girl in the end. Do you have any that aren't abusive and themed with rape? I also wish you would write a story with Hermione. that would be great.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Collide)
I wish I could write a SS/HG fic. I love them, and read them all the time. Unfortunately, I can not write Hermione. I don't think I have the ability to give her character an honest voice. Now, Snape, I know-and there is enough dysfunction to go around.
My very first fic, "It's not going to stop", doesn't have rape and the more darker aspects that I admit the ones I am writing now have taken. Also, there is no fairy tale ending.
My husband agrees with you, but I have to admit, I write what I know. I'm not saying my stories are my life, but having experiences with dating men who were like Snape before I found the wonderful man my husband is- I feel I understand the character and the many, many, issues that surround this complex character.
My next fic that I will post after "Collide" is not centered on rape, there are aspects of abuse, but not physical, more emotional. And even that is not prolonged. Hopefully, you'll like the change, although the fic is still serious. When you have Snape as a male romantic lead, these things can not be avoided. He is a very psychologically warped character, and I like to remain true to what Rowling gave us. I love the quote she said when a woman claimed she would love to be in a relationship with Snape. First, Rowling asked her if she were thinking about Snape or Alan Rickman! LOL
But the thing Rowling said that stuck with me was when she shuddered and said; "Who would want Snape to be in love with them. That's a scary thought." And it is- to me, so I have to work with him. I guess I do "work out" my own feelings through my writing Snape. My Original characters are so hard to write. I blame the muse! I've been able to be more honest and open about feelings I have had inside me and have shared them with people like yourself, more than with people I've known my whole life.
Sorry this is so long. Your comment truly has struck a chord. I do hope you'll keep reading after you've read this one. Once you've been told by a man "You belong to me- you are mine" and then experience what that means, you can never be light-hearted about certain things again. You can grow to forgive and see them in a new light, but never light-hearted.
Thanks,
Livvy
Response from Cissy_n_Snape (Reviewer)
In no way did I mean to sound as if I thought the subject matter was flippant. Many of us have experience abusive relationships and rapes. I guess that's why I choose not to read about them, to be away from it. I guess it's why it was disappointing that this was another one.You have a very different perception of Snape than I do. Canon has the Harry filter where we get to see what a prat Snape is to Harry and other students, but if you'll look at all the situations where we see Snape without Harry's filter or with other adults when he doesn't know Harry is around, he's well liked by the others (staff, Order), amicable (hangs round in the staff room, goes to parties), and even caring (clutches a chair to show concern over Ginny Weasley's fate, other things)--though not sappy. After book seven, I've seen first hand how Snape is with someone he loves, and I will never be able to buy an overly controlling Snape completely I'm afraid. He was quite whipped by Lily, even crying over here nearly 20 years later. I've read the Rowling interviews as well, and I believe up until now (after it's all said and done), she was trying to steer people clear of what was deep down behind his mask. She wanted us to dislike Snape so we'd be duped when we found out he was actually Dumbledore's man. She's finally changed her tune.I think you could do Hermione justice. You make these girls sound just fine. Have you tried to write her? Perhaps write a story from Snape's pov only so that you don't have to be inside Hermione's head. That might be a starting place for you.No hard feelings. I will check into what you upload next to see if it's my cuppa. Good luck
I love the first two chapters. I couldn't read them all because I got to go to work, but be assured, I will catch up!
Response from livvy6 (Author of Collide)
Thanks for reviewing! I'm glad you are liking the story!
Livvy
and again... interesting posture of snape... never would have thought of it. i wonder, though, if his "immature" feelings have anything to do with lilyupdate soon!(btw, I finally finishedwith my exams- i did well even on algaebra :); my third chpater will appear soon too)
Response from livvy6 (Author of Collide)
Excellent! Congrats on Algebra- I was an abysmal failure at it. I was more of a geometry person. Can't wait for your next chappie, I've been looking to see if you had posted.
Yes, Lily will be an interesting discussion point between these two and I hope I won't be scalped by those who are die-hard Lily fans. Amanda has her own opinion about Lily. I guess I can always blame the muse! :)
I'll be waiting for your Chapter three!
Thanks,
Livvy
wow... i swear, your stories keep getting better and better by each chapterthinking at snape as at a victim is simply...different amanda's mom is realy, really annoying... i hate parents who act like this :)and about snape and amanda...they both need someone who can understand them
Response from livvy6 (Author of Collide)
Yes, they both have a lot of hurt and betrayal issues. Plus they both use aggression to hide thier feelings behind. It's going to continue to be bumpy for a while, stubborn people! LOL
Thanks,
Livvy
i like that picture of amandait really suits the characterhey- i finally learned how to review on tpp - it was SO hard - or it was me being clumbsyon the other handgood chapterkind of scary, thoughthe concept is very interestingit explains her rage against snape... and his against herkeep it up! i can't wait to see what's next
Response from livvy6 (Author of Collide)
Thanks, when I saw her picture I thought, damn that's her! Especially in later chapters, can't tell you why, but the hair up and not perfect looking and all in black.
Sorry you had a time trying to review. It's so different for each site, but I'm glad you got theough.
Thanks,
Livvy
"It was unbelievable for a student to attack a teacher so quickly" good one i use to attack the teachers later, thats for sure the "relationship" between amanda and snape will be very interesting to watchit's fantastic the way you use snape's characternever would thought of that
Response from livvy6 (Author of Collide)
Thank you so much!Livvy
wow... extraordinary storygreat chaptersnape as a victim... it's a very interesting point of viewkind of creepy, tooseverus and amanda can't seem to stay together longer then 5 minutes without cursing each otherand amanda really seems that doesn't belong there, to hogwartscan't wait to see what happens next
Response from livvy6 (Author of Collide)
It's great seeing you over on this site! Awe, that was sweet. I feel so much better now. Yes, that's the thing with those two. They definately grate on each other's nerves.
Thanks so much for reviewing!
Livvy
"The robes burst off him" you do mean "ropes", right? cuz somehow I think there'd be more of a commotion if his robes came off.
Response from livvy6 (Author of Collide)
Whoops! That would be correct-much more upsetting given the situation.Thanks!Livvy
very intense, i like it, keep it coming
Response from livvy6 (Author of Collide)
Thanks for reviewing! It is very intense, but I hope you will continue to like it and keep with the story. I LIVE for reviews!
Next chapter will be up soon.
Thanks,
Livvy
very true words, but does Snape listen?
Response from livvy6 (Author of Collide)
It's going to take some tie for it to sink in :)
Response from livvy6 (Author of Collide)
It's going to take some tie for it to sink in :)
urg, what an ugly scene. I trust the rest gets easier to swallow. My thoughts? Well, probably D.E. inauguratíons could be somewhat like this but they also are great fighters and strategists. All the violence against women doesn't win a war, does it?
Response from livvy6 (Author of Collide)
Yes, it was pretty horrific, but it was only specific parts that Amanda's father wanted her to see.THanks for reviewing!Livvy
Response from livvy6 (Author of Collide)
Yes, it was pretty horrific, but it was only specific parts that Amanda's father wanted her to see.THanks for reviewing!Livvy
OH MY! What has hapened to Severus?
Response from livvy6 (Author of Collide)
He's had a really hard life coupled with two bad choices. He's got a lot of self-loathing.Livvy