Canary Yellow
Phoenix Song (or, Hermione Granger and the H-B P)
Chapter 13 of 25
grangerousWhen Professor Snape heals Hermione's injuries after the Battle of the Department of Mysteries, they are both surprised by what they learn. The two must work together to help Harry defeat Lord Voldemort.
ReviewedPhoenix Song, Chapter Thirteen : Canary Yellow
DISCLAIMER : The characters and many of the situations described in this story are the property of the incomparable J.K. Rowling. I make no money from this story, which exists as a work of tribute. Where dialogue from the original Harry Potter books is quoted by me, the relevant text is marked with an asterisk.
I'd like to thank my betas, LAxo, who can point out weak plot points in the dark, and WriterMerrin, who can spot a comma splice at 40 paces. Without them, this story would be far less coherent.
"It wasn't a very slick attack, really, when you stop and think about it,"* remarked Ron, encouraging a first year to give up his comfy chair with a gentle smack on the back of the head. "The curse didn't even make it into the castle. Not what you'd call foolproof."*
It wasn't likely to make it into the castle, either...Filch's Secrecy Sensor would have seen to that, thought Hermione. "You're right,"* she said out loud to Ron, kicking him insistently in the knee until, with a grimace, he surrendered the chair to its original occupant. "It wasn't very well thought-out at all."*
Since Ron was now left without a seat, he plonked down onto the arm of Hermione's chair. The closeness of his body left her with a curiously pleasant, tingly sensation. Definitely not how proximity to Harry makes me feel. If she moved her leg just a fraction...there...it pressed ever so slightly into Ron's thigh. The warmth of it was extraordinary.
Harry was still carrying on about Malfoy, and Hermione glanced upward at Ron. He caught her look and rolled his eyes companionably. Hermione smiled back. The warmth generated by the touch of Ron's leg spread to her face, and she looked away quickly...guiltily, hoping he wouldn't notice her blush. Professor Snape's lesson on Legilimency had left her with an uneasy conscience toward her red-headed friend.
"Are you ever aware of knowing what someone is thinking?" Professor Snape had asked.
Hermione had considered the question carefully. "Well, I frequently have to explain what girls are thinking to Harry and Ron, but I always assumed that was because they were, well . . ."
"Imbeciles?" he suggested smoothly, one eyebrow raised.
"Boys." Hermione shot him a disapproving look.
By the end of the lesson, it was clear that Hermione's insights into the thinking of others relied less on women's intuition and more on low-level Legilimency. Thus she knew that, in his own confused way, Ron liked her. And she knew herself well enough to acknowledge that she certainly wasn't opposed to the idea. But knowing what he felt without him having told her was a bit like cheating. Like she'd spied on something personal. She pressed her thigh a little more firmly against his and looked up at him under her eyelashes. He was leaning forward, urging Harry to play a game of chess. His sleeves were rolled up, and the vein of his forearm stood out against the muscle below. At the pressure on his leg, he glanced back at her and winked. Hermione smiled to herself and pulled out her Ancient Runes homework. Hermione Granger was not one to wait around for some foolish boy to make his move. She was perfectly capable of taking events into her own hands, and Slughorn's upcoming Christmas party offered the perfect opportunity.
During her first lesson in Legilimency, Hermione had found herself in the awkward situation of having to enter Professor Snape's mind. The experience had overwhelmed her with a combination of terror, nervousness and intense curiosity. She needn't have worried, really, for Snape was in control the entire time. He allowed her to see nothing but a stream of memories set in the Potions classroom...most consisted of Hermione herself, at various ages, coaching Neville through an innumerable number of potions disasters.
In subsequent lessons Jocelyn Smith was present, and the two witches practiced their Occlumency and Legilimency skills in tandem. The initial anger with which Hermione had responded to the young girl had faded with the realisation of Jocelyn's medical condition and personal history, and the first conversation they'd had was sufficient to provide the basis of a very friendly relationship. Hermione had found it an enormous and surprisingly pleasurable relief to talk with someone who liked Professor Snape almost as much as she did.
At first, Snape insisted that the lessons work in one direction only, with Hermione attempting to enter Jocelyn's mind over and over again. Many of the memories she encountered in the process were grindingly depressing...overheard arguments between Jocelyn's mother and a stream of foul-mouthed and often violent men, beatings, miserable dinners and lonely intervals in a dirty flat...but as Hermione got better at navigating her way through someone else's thoughts, and as Jocelyn got better at tucking some thoughts away, she had also witnessed much of the younger girl's joy in her newfound magical talents and the friends she had made at Hogwarts. When Snape finally ordered them to switch roles, Hermione realised, with an ill-concealed flush of pleasure, that he deemed her Occlumency skills adequate to keep all mention of the Order and Harry's fight against Voldemort from the probing intelligence of her young friend.
That same evening, as Jocelyn and Hermione left Snape's office, the younger girl shifted her satchel from one shoulder to the other and asked an unexpected question.
"Are you as good at Transfiguration as everyone says?"
Hermione hesitated, surprised. After a long second, she switched her focus from the heavy stones of the corridor wall to Jocelyn's pale blue eyes. Hermione shrugged. "I'm pretty good," she acknowledged, "though I don't know how good or bad people might say I am."
"Supposedly, you're the best student the school has ever seen."
"That's patently untrue," Hermione responded automatically. The conversation was making her uncomfortable. It can't be true, she thought a little wistfully. The Marauders had all managed to turn themselves into Animagi by my age, even Pettigrew. Professor McGonagall said that she wouldn't dream of letting me even try until next year. Hermione turned as if to walk away.
"Wait!" Jocelyn's small hand closed around her elbow. The younger girl took a deep breath. "I wondered whether you might help me with my Transfiguration revision. Unlike my other classes, I never really seemed to catch up after the weeks at the start of term when I couldn't do magic."
Hermione's wounded pride was instantaneously mended. "Of course! That makes perfect sense, you know, because unlike the other first-year classes, Transfiguration skills are cumulative. We'll have to start from the very beginning!"
Jocelyn looked relieved. "Thanks, Hermione. I appreciate it."
"It would be my pleasure! How about after classes tomorrow? I'll ask Professor McGonagall if we can use her room."
"Perfect, thanks!" Jocelyn grinned and gave Hermione's elbow a quick squeeze before turning in the direction of the Slytherin common room and scampering away.
Could my schedule get any more crowded? wondered Hermione bemusedly, smiling to herself as she turned the other way and headed upstairs in order to swing by the library on her way back to Gryffindor Tower.
The more time Hermione spent with Vector's arithmancy calculations, the more convinced she was of her role in the coming events: her job was to keep Harry alive. This year, that task seemed to be fairly straightforward, but next year, the equations promised, things would be much more difficult. Hermione sighed and ran her hands through her hair, wrenching her finger through a knot of curls that was threatening to take up permanent residence. Vector looked up from her work with a sympathetic expression. The professor was writing furiously with one hand and clicking a set of worry beads back and forth with the other in a constant and slightly irregular rhythm, that truth be told, was irritating Hermione.
"Trouble in Arithmantic paradise?" she asked.
"No," sighed Hermione. "I just wish the equations were more specific about what I have to do."
Vector graced her with a wry smile. "It might help to leave the equations that deal with your future for a while and concentrate on something else. Why not recalculate some of the probability distributions for earlier events? Even a small improvement in accuracy there could affect the indeterminacy that's bothering you in the later formulae."
It was good advice. Hermione had begun to obsess a little over the details of the subset that described her interaction with Harry and Ron. The quaternions, in particular, had occupied her for several weeks, and she'd spent hours watching the graphical representations spin themselves through four-dimensional space. She found something deeply reassuring in the tight coils of their three selves, particularly during the last few days, when Ron had been unaccountably cross with her. With another sigh...this time directed at her absent and irritating friend rather than the equations...she banished the graph that hung in front of her face and rolled up the parchment she'd been writing on. Rifling through her bag, she unearthed her notes on the earlier calculations and spread them out in front of her. Hmm.
"Professor?" Vector looked up at once, her encouraging gaze punctuated by the clicks of her worry beads. "Have you added Katie Bell's accident to the set of current events?"
Vector's body stilled entirely, and the pendulum of the beads gave one belated click. "No. Do you think it could be part of the pattern? I admit it seemed fairly random to me."
"It can't hurt to put it in, right? We'll see soon enough if it's significant or not."
"Right. There are a lot of unknowns...the why, the who, the target . . . Do it. You're right. It might prove crucial."
Hermione felt the flush of intellectual excitement and turned to her task with a new energy. She pulled her abacus towards her and turned over a clean set of parchment.
"I wonder," muttered Vector before turning back to her own calculations, "I wonder why Albus didn't already make that suggestion?"
Hermione stormed down to the Quidditch pitch, her insides in turmoil. How dare Harry? Felix Felicis! He should have saved that potion to help him against Voldemort, but oh no! He wastes it on a Quidditch match. He MUST know that's illegal. As if MY STUPIDITY in Confunding McLaggen was an EXCUSE! The thought of her own brush with illegality twisted the tight, guilty knot in her stomach a turn further. What kind of influence am I? Hermione wanted to weep, swallowing hard in a futile attempt to rid her mouth of the metallic taste of guilt and impotent rage. And Dumbledore...her mind replayed Dumbledore's commentary on her own indiscretion: "Do you want to be expelled? . . . Good. Because we can't afford to expel you. Statistically, it would be a disaster . . ."...Dumbledore wouldn't do anything, even if he knew.
Reaching the stands, Hermione found a seat and took refuge behind her morning's mail. She had no desire to make small talk with Neville this morning. Unfurling her most recent letter from Viktor, she stared at it unseeingly. How could Harry be such an idiot? How could I be such an idiot? Neville nudged her when the players emerged from the dressing room, and she folded her still-unread letter distractedly and returned it to her pocket. She fisted her hands tightly in her scarf and pulled it down fiercely as an unaccustomed scowl pulled her mouth down in an analogous line. The unwelcome pressure against the back of her neck eased her stress marginally.
"You all right, Hermione?" asked Neville solicitously.
"Fine," she growled.
He raised his eyebrows dubiously, but returned his attention to the unfolding game.
Ron saved everything. He flew brilliantly, long arms and capable hands safely shepherding the Quaffle away from the goal hoops at every opportunity. His body moved with a lean grace and explosive power that, in other circumstances, would have moved Hermione to a deep appreciation. Today, it left her feeling sick.
Hermione didn't even notice when Harry caught the snitch because she couldn't drag her eyes from Ron. Only when the onlookers around her leapt to their feet in celebration and her line of sight was broken, did she look away. As Ginny collided with the commentator's podium, Hermione came to an unpleasant decision. Harry and Ron wouldn't be happy with her, but she had to confront them about this. Cheating is cheating, even...or especially...when it's Gryffindors trying to beat Slytherins. She tried to squelch all consideration of what this might do to the already tenuous rapport between Ron and her.
"I'll see you later, Neville," she muttered as she began to squeeze her way past the other spectators, fighting her way against the flow of people and down towards the change rooms. When she got there, only Ron and Harry were left.
Gathering her Gryffindor courage with a deep breath, she laid her metaphorical cards on the table, "I want a word with you, Harry. You shouldn't have done it. You heard Slughorn, it's illegal."*
"What are you going to do?"* interjected Ron aggressively. "Turn us in?"*
"What are you two talking about?"* Harry sounded as if the whole thing was a huge joke. Is he really so unconcerned about breaking the rules?
"You know perfectly well what we're talking about!"* Hermione felt her voice slide upwards and silently cursed her lack of self-control. "You spiked Ron's juice with lucky potion at breakfast! Felix Felicis!"*
"No, I didn't."*
Cheating was bad enough, but to lie to her about it, too? Hermione clenched her hands hard, the nails biting into her palms. "Yes you did, Harry, and that's why everything went right, there were Slytherin players missing and Ron saved everything!"*
"I didn't put it in!"* Harry pulled the tiny bottle of golden potion from his pocket, the seal still noticeably intact. "I wanted Ron to think I'd done it, so I faked it when I knew you were looking."* He turned towards Ron and gave him a friendly slap on the upper arm. "You saved everything because you felt lucky. You did it all yourself."*
Hermione stared at Harry, her eyes wide in shock. You bastard, she thought, letting go of her anger only minimally.
Ron looked astounded, his mouth hung open for several seconds before he could say anything. "There really wasn't anything in my pumpkin juice? But the weather's good . . . and Vaisey couldn't play. . . . I honestly haven't been given lucky potion?"*
Harry grinned and patted the pocket into which he'd slipped the phial of potion. Hermione saw the exact moment that fury replaced the surprise on Ron's face. He spun towards her and imitated her voice in a cruel falsetto, "You added Felix Felicis to Ron's juice this morning, that's why he saved everything! See! I can save goals without help, Hermione!"*
You bastard, she thought again, incriminating her other best friend along with the first. The conversation was a train wreck she was unable to prevent. "I never said you couldn't...Ron,"*...he was already leaving, but she called after his retreating figure in desperation..."You thought you'd been given it too!"*
Alone with Harry, Hermione rubbed the heel of her hand roughly across her eyes.
"Er,"* Harry hesitated, his earlier confidence derailed in the face of Ron's reaction. "Shall . . . shall we go up to the party, then?"*
"You go!"* Hermione gave her knitted hat a sharp tug and pulled it lower over her ears. "I'm sick of Ron at the moment, I don't know what I'm supposed to have done."* She shot Harry a quick smile that she hoped came across as mature and forbearing, though she feared she just looked miserable, and hurried out onto the grounds. A walk around the lake suddenly seemed like a very good idea.
Under the beech tree, she sat down and forced herself to read Viktor's letter with the attention it deserved. As asked, he'd provided further information about his advanced Transfiguration research, and the details proved remarkably soothing. He'd also reiterated an invitation for her to visit him once again in Bulgaria. She blushed at the thought: she knew exactly where things would lead if she took him up on the offer. Well, she remarked crossly to herself, maybe I should. At least some people can appreciate my charms. Folding the letter decisively, she decided that her equilibrium was now such that a return to the common room was within the realms of the manageable. Besides, it was getting chilly.
The sight in the common room, however, would have fazed Hermione even under the best of circumstances. Ron was draped over Lavender in a grotesque parody of teenage enthusiasm. Hermione turned on her heel, getting a hand to the Fat Lady's portrait before it had closed behind her, and pushed her way back out into the corridor. She had to get away.
The first couple of doors were locked, and on the third try she muttered, "Alohomora," before slipping inside with a dry sob of relief. Walking towards the front of the empty classroom, she went over several of Snape's mental exercises inside her head. I am calm, she repeated. I am calm. She sat up on the teacher's desk, stroking the surface of the table with one hand. I am calm. She drew out her wand and thought about Viktor's letter. The experiments he is doing with animal Transfigurations really are interesting. She conjured a canary out of thin air and sent it circling above her head. I am calm. She conjured a second canary. Viktor is a very intelligent, internationally famous Quidditch player. He also lives in Bulgaria, added a more cynical internal voice, but she squashed it ruthlessly. I am calm. She conjured a third canary and set it circling with its brethren. Her parents were unlikely to send her off to Bulgaria a second time, but hey, she could always invite him to visit her instead. She determined to do so that very evening. I am calm. A fourth canary popped into existence and joined the fluttering circle above. I certainly don't care about the love life of one Ronald Weasley, a mediocre Quidditch player who couldn't Transfigure his way out of a paper bag. A fifth canary made its appearance at the same moment that Harry opened the door and slipped into the room.
"Oh, hello, Harry, I was just practicing."* Hermione concentrated on keeping her voice even and the canaries circling smoothly. I am calm.
"Yeah . . . they're...er...really good . . ."*
Nice one, Harry. Lovely and coherent. Hermione was slightly mollified that her friend had come to find her. But they might as well face up to the reason they were both here.
"Ron seems to be enjoying the celebrations,"* she stated. Hermione wished she had the vocal control of Professor Snape. Smooth and sarcastic was the sound ideal she was aiming for, not the high-pitched squeak that stress inevitably triggered.
"Er . . . does he?"*
Harry always was a terrible liar. "Don't pretend you didn't see him. He wasn't exactly hiding it, was...?"* Hermione broke off as the door was flung open yet again. At the sight of Ron, her heart leapt, only to plummet again as he dragged Lavender through the doorway, laughing a little hysterically. Bitch. The voice in Hermione's head was oddly dispassionate.
"Oh,"* said Ron, catching sight of the room's occupants and stopping in his tracks.
"Oops!"* Lavender giggled, backing out with one hand pressed to her mouth.
As the awkward silence stretched interminably onwards, Hermione repeated her mantra over and over: I am calm, I am calm. Ron didn't even look at her.
"Hi, Harry! Wondered where you'd got to!"*
Bastard. Hello, Ron? I don't suppose you could spare a thought to wonder where I'd got to?! Moving as carefully and deliberately as she could, Hermione slid off the desk and walked towards the door, her halo of canaries trailing in her wake. I am calm.
As she passed Ron, she gave him a saccharine smile. "You shouldn't leave Lavender waiting outside,"* she commented, mentally commending herself on the level tone of her voice. "She'll wonder where you've gone."* The look of relief that crossed Ron's face at her comment was almost comical, and her smile slipped from falsely sweet to smug. At the last moment, she spun towards him, wand in hand. "Oppugno!"* she shouted, unleashing the canaries in a golden stream of avian fury. She slammed the door behind her, abruptly cutting off his shrieks of discomfort.
In the relative safety of the hallway, Hermione broke into a run. Undoubtedly Lavender had returned to Gryffindor tower, and Hermione had no desire to cross her path again in either the common room or the dormitory. She headed, therefore, for Professor Vector's office...the only place none of her friends would follow and where she could be guaranteed entrance, no matter the time. The corridors were deserted, to Hermione's relief, for her tears were flowing freely. Though they blurred her vision, the path was so familiar that she could navigate almost by instinct. Only a couple of turns from her destination, however, she raced around a bend and cannoned into someone. She would have fallen, had strong hands not caught at her elbows, and she rocked on her feet for a second, her face pressed into the thick black wool of a set of teaching robes. Her heart thudded in her throat. A set of teaching robes that smelled distinctly familiar...an odd mixture of herbs and smoke that had followed Snape from the potions lab to the DADA classroom. A small sob escaped her, and she twisted away, determined to run once more, but the hands on her elbows held her back. Her humiliation, she realised, was now complete.
"Miss Granger, when I instructed you to take up running, I did not intend for you to train in the corridors."
Hermione took a shuddering breath without looking up. "I'm sorry, sir, it won't happen again."
Snape held her away from his body without releasing his grip. She felt the intensity of his gaze and stared determinedly at one of the buttons on his robe. It was embossed with a slightly raised serpentine "S." Breathing through her nose as deeply as she could, she struggled to regain some self-control. For extra measure, she raised her Occlumentic shields, though she hadn't made eye contact.
When Snape did let go of her arms, she swayed slightly on her feet, astounded by the keen sense of loss that swept over her. To her surprise, he withdrew a handkerchief from his pocket and passed it to her. She grasped at it gratefully, wiping her eyes and turning away to blow her nose thoroughly. She folded it afterwards and extended it towards him, looking him in the face for the first time. He was eyeing the proffered handkerchief with a look of singular disgust. She glanced back down at the soggy folds that were gripped between her fingers and the tear-swollen planes of her face twisted into a wry smile.
"I can clean it for you," she offered, hurriedly.
Snape flared his nostrils as if the very idea offended him. "Keep it," he replied, infusing his voice with disdain. "Tell me," he continued before she could thank him, "did you have a destination in mind, or were you running for the sheer joy of movement?"
"I was headed for Professor Vector's office."
"By rights I should send you back to your dormitory."
Hermione blanched visibly. "Please, sir, don't." Her voice was tinged suddenly with a hint of her previous tears.
Snape raised one eyebrow. "Alternately, you could serve detention with me."
"That," responded Hermione with conviction, "would be infinitely preferable."
Snape raised a second eyebrow to join the first and abruptly switched tack. "What would you have done on discovering that Professor Vector is not in her office?"
"She added me to the wards, sir. I can go in anytime."
Hermione didn't dare to breathe. Would he send her back to Gryffindor Tower? Would he let her go to Vector's office? He stood considering the options for a long moment, one finger rubbing against his lower lip.
"Come along, Miss Granger," he ordered, turning on his heel. She followed him quickly, relieved beyond measure that he was leading her onwards rather than back towards the common room. Outside Vector's door he paused. "Don't let me catch you in the halls after curfew, Miss Granger, or it will be detention."
Hermione knocked gently on the door to be certain it was empty, then opened it with a tap of her wand. She looked over her shoulder as she stepped through. "Thank you, Professor," she said. Snape made no reply, merely encouraging her to step through the doorway with a dismissive flick of his fingers.
Once the door was shut, Hermione lit up the room with a wave of her wand. Professor Snape was unbelievably nice, she noted, placing his handkerchief on her worktable and smoothing it out with her left hand. I almost would have enjoyed a detention. She took a deep breath and stretched, her arms extended above her head, her back arching. Since she was here, she might as well get some work done. Resolutely, she pushed the calculations that involved her, Ron and Harry to one side, and pulled forward her new equations dealing with Katie Bell's accident. By the time she headed back to her bed, the excursion could have counted as "up early" rather than "out after curfew," but she was still relieved to meet no-one but The Grey Lady, who drifted past rather absentmindedly. She slipped into the dorm before anyone else was awake and shut her curtains very carefully around the bed. Thank God it was a Sunday morning, and she could safely sleep much of the day away.
Story Actions
To follow, favorite, like, and more either log in or create an account.
Leave a Review
Log in to leave a review.
Latest 25 Reviews for Phoenix Song (or, Hermione Granger and the H-B P)
566 Reviews | 5.69/10 Average
I am absolutely LOVING this story, and am only mildly miffed that I had begun writing something similar, because your creation is miles better than mine would have been. However I cannot BELIEVE you wrote this but weren't sure about writing a follow-up - are you crazy?! Of course we want a sequel!!! I can't wait to continue to the final chapter and also to read Phoenix Tears... and then to rethink the story I've been working on! Damn you for being so bloody good, well done!
I loved the story, and am going to go see what i can find in regards to a sequel now. Curious to how you will continue the canon events in your almost non-canon way. :)
This was a truly wonderful, emotion filled story. I loved hearing the book from Hermione and Snape's perspectives. You answered a lot of questions that JK's book left me asking, and made it a more believable. I am so glad to discover that you wrote the sequel as well. I can't wait to go read it.
A great fic!! Congratulations for it! It's cool the way you are following the original story and, in the same moment, telling a diferent one. Kisses
this is awesome. awesome awesome awesome. everything holds together so well; it's all so tightly knit! you've incorporated everything perfectly! I don't know how you do it. this is right up there with Diana Wynne Jones novels, where everything fits and I'm left going "how did she do that." I am so impressed! Thanks for a great story :)
so hermione got snape's help with planning for being on the run. annoyingly convincing...I like to think she did it all herself. but really, it makes a lot of sense.
your explanations of arithmantic thought are fascinating. the details you give are logical and convincing. it's awesome.
I love love love it when authors go into the intricacies of magical theory. I love the explanations of the differences between charms and warding. This is so cool!
"I suggest running, perhaps supplemented with yoga." possibly one of the most bizarre things I have heard Professor Snape say. Ha!
terribly sad, and fascinating. You've really managed to convince me that muggleborns are more likely to be good Occlumens than their counterparts.
What a brilliant fic!!! This is definitely one of my favorites now, and I especially love how Sev shared the Felix Felicis!
Response from grangerous (Author of Phoenix Song (or, Hermione Granger and the H-B P))
Thank you very much! I'm really delighted that you enjoyed the story, and thank you for leaving such a nice review. The sequel to this story is now completed, and I do hope that you enjoy that, too. :)
I am utterly astonished at your revelation that this is your first piece of fiction! You have a masterful command not just of narative but of character, motivation, plot, and drama. I am really impressed!And I'm delighted to see that I'm not the only one clamoring for more. I await what is to come with baited breath, and thank you profusely for a darn good read!I don't know if you've read Lariope's "Second Life," but I am delighted that you both chose the same method for sharing those last drops of Felix Felicis. I can't think of a better moment to prepare them both for all that is to come....Brava--excellent work! Looking forward to the sequel.
Response from grangerous (Author of Phoenix Song (or, Hermione Granger and the H-B P))
Thank you very much! I have written non-fiction stuff (dissertation, etc.), but yes, this is the first piece of fiction I've written. Trust me to decide to start with something small and easily managed. :)I have read "Second Life," and very much enjoyed it. Thanks again, I do hope that you enjoy the sequel as much as you have this. :) Your reviews were a pleasure to receive.
She is the one person clever enough to puzzle it out. I can believe that she would have guessed it and known it to be true because it is indeed the simplest--the most elegant--solution. Can he at least find some comfort in her knowing?
Response from grangerous (Author of Phoenix Song (or, Hermione Granger and the H-B P))
The way I've constructed the story, she did have enough information to work it out--in fact, I didn't need to make sure she knew very much beyond what she already should have known from canon. I think she'd be capable of seeing the lie of the land.Thanks for the review!
Wow! So much here! And all of it to do with Severus, quite delicious.It makes sense that he would have killed his father--that's the most interesting explanation I've heard for his choice to become a Death Eater: they were the only ones who would have him after such a tragedy.And it was nice to see him touched by Davis' project. He needs to remember how much esteem his Slytherins have for him, especially in these dark days.You keep driving home so effectively the damnable place he's in and the bleak future ahead. It makes sense that he would have known about the Elder Wand, and that he would have understood so well how alone he would be after killing Albus.Now to find out what he needs to tell Hermione....
Response from grangerous (Author of Phoenix Song (or, Hermione Granger and the H-B P))
Thank you very, very much! The question of why or how Severus joined the Death Eaters is one that everyone has to hurdle sooner or later. Given his place and his treatment from others at the time, I just can't see how he would have done anything else, really--he would have been so happy for the acceptance. Hogwarts, well, Dumbledore at least, really failed the Slytherin students.Thanks again for the review.
Utterly fascinating!I must commend you throughout all of this for making the magical, theoretical, and academic components ring so true. I know nothing of mathematics (I can barely add without a calculator and a lot of scrap paper!), but your Arithmancy sounds so plausible that I buy it completely. And all the details you've supplied of the lessons that have been going on all make it sound quite realtistic (magically, of course!). What else, I wonder, does Albus need to tell Severus, and what does Severus need to tell Hermione (besides "You have to let Harry die in order to allow him to live, and, oh, by the way, I rather fancy you" that is)?
Response from grangerous (Author of Phoenix Song (or, Hermione Granger and the H-B P))
Thank you! I was a big maths geek when I was in high school--with a particular love for calculus and imaginary numbers. Given how well imaginary numbers work in Muggle mathmatics, the possibilities for magical mathematics seem boundless!! :)Thanks again for the review.
Oh, dear lord, bless her for the extreme act of courage it took to come down to his office, and bless him for the equal leap it took to offer one of the best apologies I've ever had the pleasure of reading.And I'm terribly glad it was only McLaggen--she could've handled him eventually, but it was good that Severus was there to lend a hand and deduct points from the great bully. I think it might've also helped him decide later to allow her to stay long enough in his office to have it out with him.This chapter makes me very hopeful!
Response from grangerous (Author of Phoenix Song (or, Hermione Granger and the H-B P))
I'm glad that you liked the apology! :)Hermione's got the courage she needs, when she needs it. That's her special Gryffindor flair.She would have handled McLaggen eventually--and I couldn't bear to write her as a complete damsel in distress.Yay for hope! Thanks for the review.
ARE WE INTERESTED?!?! ARE YOU KIDDING?!?!?! IT CAN'T BE ABOUT TO END?!?!! I was desperately afraid that this was a WIP, but YES, PLEASE, YOU ABSOLUTELY MUST CONTINUE IT!!! (Okay, I'll stop yelling now. I think I've made my point.) Will now go on and read the FINAL CHAPTER. Arghh!!
Response from grangerous (Author of Phoenix Song (or, Hermione Granger and the H-B P))
LOL. Your point is coming accross loud and clear, I promise! :) Thank you for the enthusiasm!The final chapter is pretty satisfying, I think--even if I do say so myself!! :)Thanks for all of your reviews.
Oh, hell, who's got her?! Evil cliffie! No time to review, must rush off and see what's next!
Response from grangerous (Author of Phoenix Song (or, Hermione Granger and the H-B P))
Ha ha ha. Oh, yes. My first cliffhanger! What sweet memories . . .
Hermione, please use that very big brain of yours and actually listen--perhaps you can figure out why he's behaving like a jealous, self-pitying prat. (One of you needs to be thinking clearly in all of this.)Love the fact that Dumbledore's horrifying revelation to Severus about Harry's fate is delivered while he's rather drunk. Gives me just a tiny bit more pity for Albus. And I also love the idea of Severus hearing it while he's more focused on his own jumbled emotions.
Response from grangerous (Author of Phoenix Song (or, Hermione Granger and the H-B P))
Hmm, perhaps he's acting like a jealous, self-pitying prat because he's a . . . um . . . jealous, self-pitying prat?? *smirksCan Hermione's year get any worse??Dumbledore's a manipulative old man. He must have know Severus would see through him were he sober.Thanks for the review!
I think we all wish we had mothers who understood the concept of a fuckbuddy--if not the frankness to insist on having a discussion about such things!Hermione is discovering the complications of the delicate dance of her position.I'm curious to see how her reunion with Severus goes, though I expect they are both convinced they have their feelings well in hand. (At least Hermione has had some nice distractions for her holiday treat!)
Response from grangerous (Author of Phoenix Song (or, Hermione Granger and the H-B P))
I thought Hermione deserved a nice Christmas present after Ron had been such an arsehole all semester. :)And yes, the embarassing forthrightness of liberal mothers!! :) I'm sure she'll be more appreciative once she gets a bit older!Thanks, again.
He took a vindictive pleasure in secretly being a better man than the so-called nice, friendly people around him.That's an amazing insigh and obviously one of the reasons your portrayal of Severus is so spot-on.Poor Severus, seeing the echoes of the tragedy of his past, feeling he can't even want Hermione, and watching her with Krum, who isn't a bad guy (especially in this portrait--kind of thick in social situations, but fundamentally decent), but who isn't him.(Nice touch with the Italian portrait speaking Italian, by the way.)This continues to be fascinating!
Response from grangerous (Author of Phoenix Song (or, Hermione Granger and the H-B P))
Ma certo che i ritratti italiani parlono italiano!! :)I'm thrilled that you're enjoying my characterisation of Severus. I think he's so fascinating! Thanks for the lovely review.
And I just added it, too. This is really an accomplished, fascinating piece.The scene in the Room of Requirement was especially terrific.
Response from grangerous (Author of Phoenix Song (or, Hermione Granger and the H-B P))
Thank you, and thank you! She's noticing an awful lot about him. :)
I completely buy this picture of the staff at play.I love Severus' interrogation of Hermione about Krum; found out more than he bargained for, I think, but she at least got some information in return.You are doing an amazing job of drawing a truly believable portrait of everyone, but most especially of Severus. This is a competent, complex, interesting, intelligent man who knows very clearly what he's doing. I love it.
Response from grangerous (Author of Phoenix Song (or, Hermione Granger and the H-B P))
I really like Severus--he's so nice and complicated. :) And he needs some downtime with his gay friends, too!!Thanks for the thoughtful review, it--indeed all of them--mean a lot to me.
And they continue to learn a little about one another. Such a shame that Ron can be such an idiot. This was in an earlier chapter, but it still applies all too well:"I always assumed that was because they were, well . . .” “Imbeciles?” he suggested smoothly, one eyebrow raised.Made me laugh. And now I'd sad for Hermione. Because he's right.
Response from grangerous (Author of Phoenix Song (or, Hermione Granger and the H-B P))
Ron gave her a really hard time that year, silly sod. But at least Snape is providing some comfort at this point! :) Plus, as you now know, I'm sending her a Christmas present!!
Complexities and fascinations! Dumbeldore's reaction is quite intriguing, considering his own history (does Severus know about Arianna? probably not). You continue to weave an entirely new, interesting tale into the cloth of canon, and I continue to find it a wonderful read.
Response from grangerous (Author of Phoenix Song (or, Hermione Granger and the H-B P))
I'm assuming that Severus didn't yet know about Ariana; though eventually he will learn.I'm glad that there's enough new stuff that the story isn't boring! Thanks for the review!