Chapter 21 - Showdown At Godric's Hollow
Chapter 21 of 29
star_girlLife does not always turn out the way we want it to. Ten years after the Battle of Hogwarts, Severus Snape, thought by everyone to be dead, is living out his days in solitude on the edge of the wizarding world. Ginny Potter, meanwhile, is juggling a high-profile career, three small children, a Kneazle and a workaholic husband. A family crisis within the Potter household unwittingly brings Snape out of hiding and his and Ginny's lives are changed forever, with both of them ultimately offered a second chance for happiness. This story is mostly canon compliant but discounts the epilogue in Deathly Hallows.
ReviewedChapter 21 Showdown At Godric's Hollow
Motes of dust swirled lazily in the shard of sunlight that pierced through the living-room window of the Potter household. Harry looked through them without really seeing; his gaze was caught in a thousand-yard stare as he processed the events of the day. The tick, tick, tick of the clock on the mantelpiece was the only sound that he could hear. At one time, Harry had associated this soothing repetition with peace and tranquility, reflecting a time for solitude and relaxation. But today it imitated a bomb that was ready to go off. Harry couldn't stop a bitter smile pulling at the corner of his mouth; he felt that the bomb analogy was an accurate description of his current predicament as he waited for his wife to return to their marital home.
Once Harry's incantation in the grounds of Hogwarts had revealed his son's saviour's true identity, he'd felt equally angry and betrayed. The final piece of the puzzle had slotted into place, and he was now under no doubt that Ginny was being unfaithful. The journey home to Godric's Hollow had been a blur as he struggled to contain the rage within him, whilst he mulled over all the possible scenarios of their illicit coupling, each scene more lurid and impossible than the last. The bile that rose in his stomach at the sickening images was as bitter and acrid as his feelings towards Ginny.
Yes, it was strange, but all of Harry's ire was aimed directly at his wife. He knew that Snape was just as guilty as Ginny was in carrying out the affair, but oddly he was not angry with him. Maybe he felt too much in Snape's debt, in the way he'd all but sacrificed himself to bring Voldemort down and then seemingly selflessly stepped in to save his son. Or maybe it was because he believed Snape to be as lonely now as he was in his previous life and could therefore easily understand his attraction to the young, beautiful Ginny. Either way, Harry thought that Snape wasn't really to blame in all this and that Ginny herself was entirely responsible.
However, throughout his pain and anger, Harry felt he had a trump card up his sleeve; he was convinced Ginny was unaware that the man she was having an affair with was really Snape. For one thing, Snape had left the wizarding world behind and didn't want to be involved in that world any more. He was happy with people thinking him dead. He wouldn't even answer Minerva's letters, for Merlin's sake, and besides Dumbledore, she had to be the one person who knew him really well. Snape had been so careful to protect his identity during Al's illness that Harry couldn't imagine for one minute that he would let his mask slip. Snape was stubborn and the master of keeping secrets after all. And, Harry knew, he was also a master of Potions. It would be very easy for him to rustle up a perfect batch of Polyjuice Potion, or to change his appearance in some other way with a skillfully concocted brew. Added to that, Ginny was not the type to harbour latent crushes on her former professor, unlike the surprisingly soppy Hermione. Hermione had admitted some time ago that once the truth about Snape had come to light, she'd held a little flame for him for a while. Ginny had snorted with laughter at the very thought of her friend having a crush on a dead man whilst Ron had sulked at this admission for a whole month. Harry was not surprised by Hermione's revelations, however. Snape had been an intelligent wizard who was very proficient and skilled in magic, with a dark, brooding edge and a surprisingly romantic core, very much like Viktor Krum. In other words, exactly Hermione's type. Ginny had made a witty comment about Hermione wanting Snape to enter her Chamber of Secrets and Hermione had blushed furiously, mumbling that it was a long time ago and that Ron was the only wizard for her.
So what would Ginny do if she found out that she was actually having trysts with the Bat of the Dungeons, as she used to call him? Well, that was exactly what Harry was going to find out.
In the hours after returning from Hogwarts, Harry had calmed down considerably. The kids were still at Molly's and that had given him the time to think things through rationally. He'd processed the facts and waited calmly on the sofa, the monotonous ticking of the clock hypnotising him. Nyx, the family Kneazle, was now curled up beside him and occasionally he would scratch her behind the ears, an action that soothed them both. The sound of the front door slamming pulled him abruptly out of his reverie, and he listened to the sound of his wife dropping her handbag on to the dresser in the hallway and kicking off her shoes with a sigh, before finally, eventually, entering the lounge.
'Hi,' Ginny said breathlessly, barely looking in Harry's direction as she absently picked up a stray teddy from an armchair and tossed it into the toy box in the corner of the room.
Harry's knuckles whitened as he seized his grip on the armrest of the sofa. 'We need to talk,' he said softly, almost monotonously.
It was obvious that Ginny was still unaware that something was wrong, as she was now plumping the cushions on the armchair before sitting, the whole while still not looking at Harry. A prickle of anger and indignation surged through Harry at this. How dare she pretend that everything was alright? How dare she have the gall to lie to his face, and not be in the least bit concerned that their marriage was very nearly over?
'We need to talk,' he repeated through gritted teeth, struggling hard to keep his voice neutral.
Ginny raised an eyebrow as she perched on the edge of the armchair, her hands knotted on her knees.
'Something wrong?' she asked quietly. Harry looked pale and tense; she knew that whatever was coming couldn't be good.
Harry breathed heavily through his nose. Yes, something was wrong. This whole scenario was wrong. It was more than that; it was insane! He forced himself to meet her gaze.
'I know you've been having an affair, Ginny,' he said, in a calm tone that surprised even himself.
Ginny felt her stomach plummet towards her feet. Of all the things she imagined Harry would say to her, this wasn't even on the list. She'd been careful and discreet. How the hell did he know?
Ginny's look of shock and, Harry noticed with a twisted form of triumph, guilt, was enough to steel him for the second allegation.
'Well? Aren't you going to deny it?' he asked, his knuckles clenching the armrest of the sofa once more.
Ginny didn't know what to say. Instead, she shook her head imperceptibly and looked down at the tangle of fingers in her lap. She thought she was in control of the situation. She thought Harry would never find out. This wasn't the way this was supposed to turn out...
Harry watched her carefully, letting the moments drag by uncomfortably before interrogating her once more. 'So, what's he like then? This Alfric O. Nobel?' he asked in a forced jovial voice.
Ginny's head shot up as if she'd been electrocuted. 'How do you know?' she asked, rather more shrilly than she'd
anticipated. 'Have you been spying on us?'
Harry merely snorted. 'In case you've forgotten, I'm an Auror. I don't need to spy on people to put two and two together. Now tell me, what is he like? The man who saved our son? I want to know every detail.' His smile was broad but yet ugly, stretching his face so he looked like a caricature of himself.
Ginny looked bewildered at Harry, not knowing if he was joking or not. She felt on the back foot; anger she could deal with. But geniality at a time like this?
'Come on, Ginny. You haven't been this tongue-tied around me since my second year at Hogwarts. Tell me. Is he tall? Handsome? Biceps like coconuts?'
'What difference does it make?' Ginny asked carefully, not knowing where this was going.
Harry turned in his seat so fast, he startled Nyx, who promptly jumped off the sofa and skittered out of the lounge, her huge, fluffy tail held upright.
'It makes ALL the difference,' he answered, and his green eyes were glinting in a way that made Ginny feel very uncomfortable indeed. 'Now I will ask you once more: What. Is. He. Like.'
Ginny had never felt afraid of Harry before, until now. She swallowed, her throat suddenly feeling like it was blocked with cotton wool. 'He's tall... with fair hair...' she began unsurely.
Harry was now wearing a quizzical smile. 'Yes? And?'
'H-he's got blue eyes. Broad build. And has a tanned complexion.' She noted that Harry's smile had now turned into something resembling triumph. 'Oh, what does it matter? Why do you even care?' she finished wretchedly.
'Well, I must say, he sounds rather dashing, this Alfric,' Harry said after a moment, his smile still utterly maddening. 'Let me guess: it was lust at first sight, ever since that cosy evening at the Quidditch together.'
If Ginny's eyebrows rose any higher, they'd disappear into her hairline. She managed to let out a little gasp of shock and indignation. He even knew about that night? And how long had he known?
'Oh yes, I can see it now,' Harry continued. 'Tall, blond and handsome; the man who saved our son. How could you not be attracted to him? He's a hero, after all.'
Ginny closed her eyes. 'Harry, don't,' she pleaded softly.
'I bet he's a real beefcake, isn't he? All rippling muscles and designer stubble...'
'Stop it!' Ginny implored, a little louder now.
'Yes, quite the hunk,' went on, ignoring his wife's appeals. 'But I'm afraid your lover boy isn't all that he seems.' Harry fixed her with his steely green eyes.
Ginny stared back at Harry, and her stomach flipped over. Oh, Merlin. So this is what all this is about. He knew something. Her mouth felt, if possible, drier than ever as she waited for Harry to go on.
'Your lover has been lying to you, Ginny. He's not the man you think he is.'
'What are you talking about?' Ginny asked in exasperation. Couldn't he just cut to the chase?
'There's no easy way to say this, so let's start at the beginning. Rather good at potions, old Alfric, wouldn't you say?' Harry said mysteriously.
'I hardly see what that has to do with anything...'
'The Prophet called him a genius the likes of which have not been seen in a generation, did they not?' Harry asked, cutting Ginny off abruptly. 'Can you think of anyone else this might apply to?'
Ginny merely screwed up her face in disbelief. 'I have no idea what you're talking about.'
'Can't you think of anyone who was gifted at Potions? An old teacher, maybe?' he prompted lightly.
Ginny's mind wandered back to her final year at Hogwarts, when she was taught by the eccentric yet undoubtedly brilliant Horace Slughorn. The old man was surely nearly a hundred by now! Harry surely couldn't be implying the one-time Head of Slytherin was her suitor... Unless he actually meant...
'Snape?!' Ginny asked incredulously.
'DING DING!' Harry cried victoriously. 'Give the woman a prize. Yes, Snape. You, my dear, have been having your end away with Severus Snape, Bat of the Dungeons himself.'
Ginny shook her head slowly and looked at Harry like he was a Blast-Ended Skrewt. 'Harry, I really think you've lost it this time...' she murmured, feeling her husband was on the edge of insanity. Snape was dead! Wasn't he?
'Think about it,' Harry went on. 'How else would this Alfric person know about the rare allergy Al had? It was because my mum had it too, and Snape knew that.'
'No...' Ginny said firmly, shaking her head.
'I knew you wouldn't believe me,' Harry said matter-of-factly, pulling his wand from the belt of his jeans. 'So this is why I'll have to spell it out for you instead.'
And so, using the same incantation as he'd performed at Hogwarts, Harry spelled out Alfric's name in shimmering, fiery letters. One swoop of the wand was all it took for the letters to rearrange themselves into the old Potion master's self-styled nickname.
The horror on Ginny's face was indescribable, and a small, vindictive part of Harry felt vindicated.
'You're lying,' she gasped, staring at the letters like they were something diabolical. 'This can't be true... How... ' she spluttered, unable to comprehend.
'Polyjuice Potion, Ginny,' Harry answered grimly, removing the letters with a firm swish of his wand. 'The oldest trick in the book.'
'No!' Ginny cried, standing up. She had a wild look about her, just like she'd had at St.Mungo's. 'I don't believe you!'
Her mind was in turmoil; part of what Harry was telling her made sense, but the other part seemed utterly, utterly mad.
Harry sat back on the sofa, gazing at his wife coolly. 'Well, don't just take my word for it. Why don't you ask him yourself?'
Ginny stared back at Harry for a few moments before turning on her heel and fleeing the house, her heart in her mouth. Was what Harry really telling the truth? Had she been hoodwinked by her former professor? The feeling of nausea which spread through Ginny's body had nothing to do with the jolt of Apparition that took her from her garden in Godric's Hollow and straight on to the doorstep of the man she knew to be Alfric O. Nobel, PHD.
Story Actions
To follow, favorite, like, and more either log in or create an account.
Leave a Review
Log in to leave a review.
Latest 25 Reviews for A Second Chance For Happiness
167 Reviews | 8.14/10 Average
I LOVED this pairing, dear! The adultery thing did bother me a bit initially, tbh, but the realistic and aesthetic portrayal of things was a great help! Thanks for the roller-coaster ride which ended on a happy note for everyone, especially Severus! I solemnly swear to be a loyal (if somewhat inconsistent) reader of your fics!
Response from star_girl (Author of A Second Chance For Happiness)
THANK YOU so much for taking the time to both read and review. I know the adultery theme isn't to everyone's taste, but I was hoping that by showing unhappiness on both sides that it lead to an understanding of WHY adultery might happen, rather than glorify it. And it had to be adultery if I wanted to remain as canon as possible. I am so glad that you enjoyed this story and stuck with it til the end, your reviews have put a big smile on my face :)
Engaging chapter. Btw... BOSTON BRAHMIN???!!!! Hehe... I am a Brahmin girl and have a cousin staying in Boston. Gotta pay more attention to her accent during her next visit to India!
Response from star_girl (Author of A Second Chance For Happiness)
Sending much love to India :)
Response from MayavanavihariniHarini (Reviewer)
Loads of love (and greetings! Yes, it's the festive season here :) ) in return, dear!
Hey! I did NOT notice the rearrangement of letters back then, though the choice of pseudonym certainly intrigued me (I mean, Nobel and all, LOL!) *hurries back to reading*
Response from star_girl (Author of A Second Chance For Happiness)
I'm glad it was a surprise :)
Response from MayavanavihariniHarini (Reviewer)
You are indeed a product of your House! :P
Stack up more Polyjuice, Severus! :P
Response from star_girl (Author of A Second Chance For Happiness)
Oh, he's going to have to make a whole barrel full! :p
I must confess that the quill is quite *pause, looks for the appropriate word* extraordinary!
Response from star_girl (Author of A Second Chance For Happiness)
Tricksy!
*jaw hits floor hard* Polyjuice??!!
Response from star_girl (Author of A Second Chance For Happiness)
Classic eh?
Response from MayavanavihariniHarini (Reviewer)
'Classic' would be an understatement!
Ah. He steps in. Finally!
Response from star_girl (Author of A Second Chance For Happiness)
Finally :)
Albus. Severus. Potter. Yes, that does sound bit of an oxymoron, doesn't it? :P
Response from star_girl (Author of A Second Chance For Happiness)
It's not the best of names is it? :p
Response from MayavanavihariniHarini (Reviewer)
Most certainly not. The mere idea of 'Severus' beside 'Potter' sounds scary!
As a newly graduated doctor, I loved your description of the hospital scene! Very poignant, yet very realistic!
Response from star_girl (Author of A Second Chance For Happiness)
Thank you, that's a huge compliment :)
Response from MayavanavihariniHarini (Reviewer)
Trust me, it's as hard for the doctor as it is for the mother. I found the Paediatrics (especially the Sick Newborn Care Unit) posting to be one of the toughest phase of my internship days... Watching so many children suffer (and even die) while you are forced to keep cool proved genuinely tough for me. So I can understand Ginny's pain, even if it is to a very tiny extent. ;(
Response from MayavanavihariniHarini (Reviewer)
Trust me, it's as hard for the doctor as it is for the mother. I found the Paediatrics (especially the Sick Newborn Care Unit) posting to be one of the toughest phases of my internship days... Watching so many children suffer (and even die) while you are forced to keep cool proved genuinely tough for me. So I can understand Ginny's pain, even if it is to a very tiny extent. ;(
'Churning out offspring'... Like mother, like daughter! Thanks for the rec... I'm thoroughly intrigued!
Response from star_girl (Author of A Second Chance For Happiness)
Oooh you found this one! I'm so pleased you were intrigued!
Nice pseudonym! *HUGE GRIN*
Response from star_girl (Author of A Second Chance For Happiness)
*Bows*
Hooray for a happy ending! I think you did a nice job staying close to canon. I am a huge SS/HG shipper, but I will agree that the fandom is saturated with that pairing. It is nice to read something different every once in awhile. I don't believe you glorified adultery at all. Yes, Ginny's affair felt exciting, but I suspect that is the case in real life, or people wouldn't do it so often. It happens in the real world, why not in fic? I think you've done quite a nice job here.
Response from star_girl (Author of A Second Chance For Happiness)
Thank you for your kind comments, I'm flattered that you took time out of your usual ship to read this and thrilled that you enjoyed it. Thank you.
Response from star_girl (Author of A Second Chance For Happiness)
Thank you for your kind comments, I'm flattered that you took time out of your usual ship to read this and thrilled that you enjoyed it. Thank you.
I love that Harry and Ginny are amicable and even happier and more family oriented than before. I do hope that Snape is able to come out from hiding. Maybe it is nice and peaceful in his seclusion, but it will be hard on Ginny, I think, to not be able to be totally upfront about her relationship to others. I do like his solution so they can live together, yet not.
Response from star_girl (Author of A Second Chance For Happiness)
Glad you're enjoying how this is turning out. Thanks for leaving a note.
Response from star_girl (Author of A Second Chance For Happiness)
Glad you're enjoying how this is turning out. Thanks for leaving a note.
THank you for the happily ever after! Lovely
Response from star_girl (Author of A Second Chance For Happiness)
Thank YOU, for reading and reviewing :)
Response from star_girl (Author of A Second Chance For Happiness)
Thank YOU, for reading and reviewing :)
I wondered what that would be like adjusting to seeing Severus and not Alfric when they are in bed. Im glad you touched on that. Made things feel all the more realistic.
Response from star_girl (Author of A Second Chance For Happiness)
Thank you, I'm glad it seemed plausible for you.
Response from star_girl (Author of A Second Chance For Happiness)
Thank you, I'm glad it seemed plausible for you.
ACK I cannot beleive the personal questions the warlock asked! So prying. What would have happened if he would not have agreed to terminate the marriage? Goodness. I was on pins and needles the whole time!!
Response from star_girl (Author of A Second Chance For Happiness)
Yes, divorce is not made easy for either party! I think all three of them were relieved to get it over with.
Response from star_girl (Author of A Second Chance For Happiness)
Yes, divorce is not made easy for either party! I think all three of them were relieved to get it over with.
I almost dont want to read about the divorce. They have just admitted their love and now its going to get ugly and torrid in court. Nooooooo
Response from star_girl (Author of A Second Chance For Happiness)
Sadly, it's the price they have to pay :(
Response from star_girl (Author of A Second Chance For Happiness)
Sadly, it's the price they have to pay :(
Very good chapter. I hope this wasn't the end. I'm glad the divorce is done. I have liked this story a lot though in JKR's version I think Harry and Ginny would never end up here. She loved him since he was a child and family was always a deeo desire for him. But never the less i really love your take on this story. Iv'e only read one other SS/GW story and they have both been excellent. I look forward to more.
Response from star_girl (Author of A Second Chance For Happiness)
Thank you for continuing to read. No, this is not the end, although there aren't many chapters left. I hope you'll enjoy how the story concludes. Thank you for your support even though this isn't your usual ship and the plot isn't quite what you'd expect - it means a lot to know you are still reading and enjoying it even though it's not to your usual taste.
Response from star_girl (Author of A Second Chance For Happiness)
Thank you for continuing to read. No, this is not the end, although there aren't many chapters left. I hope you'll enjoy how the story concludes. Thank you for your support even though this isn't your usual ship and the plot isn't quite what you'd expect - it means a lot to know you are still reading and enjoying it even though it's not to your usual taste.
A very compelling drama! I am looking forward to how it all unfolds!
Response from star_girl (Author of A Second Chance For Happiness)
Thank you very much!
Response from star_girl (Author of A Second Chance For Happiness)
Thank you very much!
I am so relieved that things went okay, but it was so sad. I mean, there was no way I wanted Harry and Ginny to stay together, but it just finally felt so real, all of them there in one place, admitting that things would never work out. I think Harry is being very mature about all of this, and I hope that the title of the story goes for him as well. I was hoping for an interaction between he and Snape, only because I wonder if they would be civil or have a shouting match or what. Thanks for a new chapter so quickly. I hope there aren't too many bumps in the road as everyone puts their lives back together.
Response from star_girl (Author of A Second Chance For Happiness)
Thank you! All I can say for now is trust me; I've already written the epilogue so I know how things turn out. I just need to get from here to there (and hopefully it won't take too long!) Thanks again for your support.
Response from star_girl (Author of A Second Chance For Happiness)
Thank you! All I can say for now is trust me; I've already written the epilogue so I know how things turn out. I just need to get from here to there (and hopefully it won't take too long!) Thanks again for your support.
Oh, there is so much anger and resentment at the moment, and rightfully so, but at least Harry had the decency to let Snape off the hook.I will be quite interested to see how she breaks the news to him, and how he takes it. Hey, at least it gives them a reason to talk again.This makes me wonder, what happens if the second person in the affair doesn't show up in court? Or is there some way of making them appear? Doesn't matter, really, just wondering if he didn't have the option to just not show up. And would they then not be able to divorce?
Response from star_girl (Author of A Second Chance For Happiness)
Oh yes, the next chapter is a humdinger! well, they woudn't be able to divorce if both parties didn't show up. It's a wizarding formality designed to prevent promiscuity ;)
Did that mean that she, Ginny Potter, was actually in love with and pining for Severus Snape? Yes yes YES it does! Dump Harry, grab the kids and move in. YIppeeeee!
Response from star_girl (Author of A Second Chance For Happiness)
Again, thank you for your support! *hugs*
I do hope that after Ginny calms down and has a chance to think on what he said she will give him another chance. ((sniffle))
Response from star_girl (Author of A Second Chance For Happiness)
All will be revealed, my dear :)
Lovely, poignant insight into the human condition as always and as always leaving us poor readers longing for more - update asap! Pretty please? They are all in such pain, blame, guilt and conflict - love it! Of course, I'm partial to Sev, how much more can he take? We know how *extreme* he can get sometimes... please hope he gets some relief... for better or worse, it seems Ginny holds that power...again, can't wait for the next chapter!
Response from star_girl (Author of A Second Chance For Happiness)
Thanks for all your support nag, it means a lot :)
Ginny has some serious thinking to do. Well, more than she already has, anyway. Snape, while he is miserable, at least has no doubt in his mind what he wants. If she could see how much he is suffering, I wonder if it would make her decision easier or harder? I do hope she chooses to give him another chance. But what a thing to wrap her head around: being in love with Severus Snape.
Response from star_girl (Author of A Second Chance For Happiness)
Thanks for continuing to read. I hope you'll like where this goes.