Chapter 4
Chapter 4 of 13
debjunkAfter hiding for five years, Severus Snape is found and convicted of Dumbledore's murder. His punishment is way beyond anything ever thought of before. Can Hermione help restore what Severus has lost?
ReviewedChapter Four
Hermione was with Severus in his cell. They had about half an hour before his trial would begin. Hermione sat on the bed with her back against the wall. She watched as Severus paced back and forth in the small space between his bed and the cell wall. The man fervently paced the three steps to the cell bars, then quickly wheeled around and retraced his steps to the toilet. Over and over again, he repeated this, his hands held tightly behind his back. His gray prison jumper lacked the billow of his robes, but in the state he was in, even they seemed to enlarge and make him look intimidating.
"Severus! Please sit down!" Hermione demanded.
"I can't," he said in a clipped tone.
"Wearing a hole in the floor will not make the trial start any faster," Hermione mused.
Severus stopped his pacing. "I'm not hoping that it will come sooner, Hermione. I'm hoping it will never begin. With the beginning of that trial comes the end of my freedom."
"Severus, it will work out. They will find you innocent because you are."
Severus sat heavily on the bed next to Hermione. "No, they will not. They will sentence me to a deserved fate. I just didn't realize when I made myself vulnerable to capture that I would now be regretting my decision."
Hermione's hand rested on his shoulder. She squeezed it encouragingly. "You don't deserve such a fate, Severus, and deep down, you know it."
Severus frowned. "It matters not what I know or do not know. I have doomed myself to this fate. There is no chance, Hermione. Surely, you recognize that."
Hermione shook her head violently. "No, I don't, Severus. There's a mountain of evidence to prove that you were working for us. You'd have to be blind not to take it all into account. You will be acquitted."
Severus looked at the ground, but smiled ruefully. "I will miss your positive attitude when I'm put away, Hermione."
Hermione caught her breath. "Please! Don't speak like that. This will all work out."
"Nothing ever works out for me. There's no reason for it to start now."
Dolores Umbridge sat in the courtroom and made sure that everyone in the Wizengamot was assembled. When she was certain, she rose.
"Excuse me, Minister," she said to Kingsley Shacklebolt. "I forgot my wand at my desk. May I be excused?"
"Yes, Dolores, but make it quick. The hearing is to start in ten minutes."
"Of course, Minister," she tittered.
She left as Minister Shacklebolt gave the Wizengamot some last minute instructions before the courtroom was opened to the public.
Dolores paused outside the closed door and extracted her wand from her robes. She silently cast a spell that opened the small vial she'd left on the floor by her seat. Looking at her watch, she followed the time and waited for two minutes. Her partner had warned her not to enter the room before then, as the gas would not dissipate for that length of time. Pocketing her wand once again, she reentered the courtroom.
"Hem, hem... Just some guidelines for the trial today," she instructed in her high-pitched voice. "Severus Snape will be found guilty, no matter what evidence is presented. No memories are to be seen today. They will be considered to be inadmissible evidence. His punishment will be to have the Hollowing Spell cast upon him. This will remove his personality and magic. He will be no more than a shell. It is the BEST alternative. Does anyone have any questions?" She asked the last bit quite cheerfully. Her eyebrows rose as she looked at all of them with a happy smirk on her face.
The entire Wizengamot shook their heads at her.
"Wonderful!" She turned to the guard standing at the back door of the court. "You may let in the observers," she commanded.
The man opened the doors, and a flurry of reporters and spectators filed into the courtroom. Dolores returned to her seat. She wondered which person was her contact. He had told her he'd be in the courtroom and would meet her and the Minister in the courtroom's antechamber to administer the hex. She perused the audience, seeing many people she didn't recognize. She wasn't sure which one was her partner.
Harry Potter and his wife Ginevra had come in and sat on the far left. Umbridge frowned. She tolerated Potter, but would never like him. He'd been an insufferable boy, always meddling where he wasn't needed. He was now a colleague...an Auror here at the Ministry...so she needed to be somewhat respectful, but secretly she loathed him. She hoped he would be sacked soon, but he seemed to be climbing the ladder of advancement at a quick rate, being loved by everyone in his department. Oh, well. It was impossible to drive everything in the world.
Soon, everyone was settled. Minister Shacklebolt pounded his gavel on the block to quiet the courtroom.
"Bring in the prisoner," he commanded.
Severus was brought in, his wrists shackled. Hermione followed closely behind him. Severus was led to the seat in the center of the room. Hermione made her way to a table next to the seat and settled into the chair behind it. The guard roughly thrust Severus down. His shackles attached themselves to the arms of the chair. Chains surrounded his legs also. Hermione winced at the sight of a bound Severus Snape.
The Minister brought the court to order, and the trial began. Hermione stood.
"Your honor, our first piece of evidence will be the memories that Severus Snape gave to Harry Potter on the night of the final battle."
"That evidence is inadmissible," Umbridge tittered. "Those memories could have been altered as they left the defendants body."
"Yes, they are inadmissible," the Minister mimicked.
Hermione frowned and looked down to her notes. "Then I would ask that a Pensieve be brought in and Mister Snape's own memories be examined."
"My dear," Dolores drawled. "No memories can be used in this hearing. For all we know, with the defendant's abilities in Legilimency and Occlumency, his memories could be showing pure lies, and we wouldn't be able to tell."
Hermione bristled. "Madam Umbridge, surely you know that when memories are tampered with, there is obvious evidence to the fact. Even Mister Snape could not change his memories in such a way to avoid detection."
Kingsley spoke up then. "The memories are inadmissible. The defendant's ability to direct his thoughts makes them unreliable."
Hermione scowled. She hadn't foreseen this argument, and she berated herself for not anticipating it being used. She perused her notes and pulled herself together. It would do no good for her to begin to have a tirade only five minutes into the trial.
"Very well," she acquiesced. "I call Harry Potter to the witness stand."
Harry rose and came to the center of the room, taking the empty chair to the left of Severus which faced the Wizengamot.
"Mister Potter, what where your feelings towards Mister Snape before the final battle?" Hermione questioned.
"I didn't trust him. I thought he'd murdered Dumbledore. I knew he was a Death Eater."
"And after the battle, did your opinion of him change?" Hermione asked.
"Yes. He'd given me some of his memories so I saw that he had been told by Dumbledore himself to kill him. He continued to spy against Voldemort and worked to defeat him."
Kingsley interrupted then. "Memory evidence is not permitted Mister Potter."
"Your honor," Hermione retorted. "This is Mister Potter's view of the events that happened. Surely, he shouldn't be kept from speaking."
Kingsley narrowed his eyes at Hermione. "I'll allow it."
"Mister Potter, since the final battle, have you come across anything that would support Mister Snape's claim that he was on our side?"
"I found out that it was he who planted the Sword of Gryffindor in the woods so I could destroy the Horcruxes I came across."
"How can you prove that, Mister Potter?" Hermione questioned.
"He sent his Patronus to guide me to the sword."
"What is the form of his Patronus?" Hermione asked.
"It's a silver doe," Harry answered.
Hermione turned to the Minister. "Permission to allow Mister Snape to conjure a Patronus."
Umbridge chimed in. "We can't give him a wand! He might escape!"
Hermione sighed and looked to Umbridge. "He is chained with magical irons. There is no way he can break those bonds, whether he has a wand in his hand or not. Letting him have a court wand for a minute to conjure a Patronus will in no way help him to escape."
The Minister motioned to the guard. "Please bring in the courtroom wand." The man left the room to get the wand.
"With this wand, Mister Snape, you will only be able to cast a Patronus," Shacklebolt explained. "It is tied to the courtroom and can only perform the spell that I allow. Do not try anything else with it, as you will be knocked unconscious. Is that understood?"
"Fully," Severus said.
The wand was brought to him, and Severus cast his Patronus. A silver doe gracefully emerged from his wand and looked at the Wizengamot. It turned quickly from them and nuzzled Severus' cheek before dissolving. The wand was taken from Severus, and the trial went on.
Harry finished his testimony and other witnesses were brought up. Many were for the prosecution, telling of Severus' doings as a Death Eater. Hermione tried to direct their testimony to always reflect that Severus was a spy when he did the things that were reported.
Finally, it was time for Severus himself to testify.
"Your honor, I wish to administer Veritaserum to the defendant," Hermione requested.
"Request granted," Kingsley stated.
Three drops of Veritaserum were dropped into a spoon and given to Severus. The court waited a few minutes for the serum to take effect. Hermione walked over to Severus.
"State your name," she ordered.
"Severus Tobias Snape."
"Are you a Death Eater?"
"No."
"Have you ever been a Death Eater."
"Yes."
"When?"
"I joined the Death Eaters as a youth. I left them when the Potters were killed."
"Why did you continue to associate with them?"
"I became a spy for Albus Dumbledore."
"How long did you serve as a spy?"
"Until the end of the war."
There was chatter in the courtroom. The Minister banged his gavel to quiet everyone.
"Why did you attack Albus Dumbledore?" Hermione asked. Severus and she had determined that the fewer who knew about Albus not having been killed, the easier it would be to find out what had happened to him. Hermione chose her words carefully so that Severus could answer without giving the full truth away.
"He told me to kill him."
More whispers and mutterings came from the court.
"Why?"
"He was dying. He knew that Draco Malfoy had been ordered to kill him. He wanted to save Draco and end his life without having to suffer extensively. He asked me to do it in fear that the Death Eaters would torture him if given the chance."
"What did you think when he first asked you to kill him?"
"I was mortified."
"Why did agree to do it?"
Severus looked directly at the Minister. "It was what Albus wanted. He wanted me to ensure my place in the Death Eater circle. He wanted me to be trusted by the Dark Lord. He also wanted to make his end a bit easier."
The questioning continued. Soon it was the prosecution's turn to question Severus.
"Mister Snape, when did you become a Death Eater?"
"At age seventeen."
"Why did you join them?"
"I wanted to be looked up to. I wanted to be powerful. I had spent my entire life prior to that being taunted and teased and beaten. I looked upon being a Death Eater as an end to such treatment."
"How many people have you killed, Mister Snape?"
"I don't know."
Is a human life so unimportant to you that you don't remember when you take one?"
"No."
"Then how many have you killed?"
"I'm not sure."
"You don't know how many people you've killed, yet we are to believe that you killed Dumbledore at his request. How can you even remember that?"
Severus' lips thinned. "Albus was my friend. I would remember such a request. Most of the people I killed were killed among raids. It was easy to lose track of who killed whom."
"Would you say you are an experienced killer?"
"No."
"After the hundreds you've struck down, you don't consider yourself to be an experienced killer?"
Severus struggled against his shackles. "I did not kill hundreds!" he snarled.
"My, my, Mister Snape. That's quite the temper you have. Could it be that your murder of Albus Dumbledore was simply a crime of passion. After all, he was the strongest wizard who fought against your beloved master."
Severus' hands clamped into fists as a snarl emerged from his throat. A hand closed around Severus' arm. He looked to see Hermione leaning over and calming him with her hand. He settled down immediately.
"No further questions," the prosecutor said as he sat down.
The Minister looked to Hermione. "Do you have anything more, counselor?"
Hermione rose again. "Mr. Snape, what are your feelings towards Voldemort?"
"He was a murdering despot who yearned for power. His ego and desires made him the most dangerous wizard of our times."
"Yet, you still followed him as a Death Eater?"
"I was young when I joined him. I didn't fully understand his madness. His message is very enticing to those who are searching for acceptance. I was duped."
"Once you realized his true character, what did you do, Mister Snape?"
"I turned from him and began my spy work."
Hermione turned to Shacklebolt. "No further questions."
"Do you have any more witnesses to call, Miss Granger?"
"No, sir."
"Anything more, Mister Duncan?" he asked the prosecutor.
"The prosecution rests."
"Wizengamot, are you ready to rule."
"Yes, Minister," Dolores Umbridge said.
"All those who find Severus Snape guilty, raise your hand."
Every member raised their hand, including Shacklebolt. Hermione's mouth dropped open. Severus frowned intensely.
"The judgment is unanimous. We the Wizengamot find the defendant, Severus Snape, guilty of murder and conspiring with Tom Riddle, also known as Voldemort. The penalty for this offense is for the defendant to undergo a spell to remove his personality and magic from his person. He will be left as little more than a hollow man, able to follow simple commands."
Severus turned white. Hermione stood immediately. "Minister, I was under the assumption that the penalty would be life in Azkaban. I was not informed of this change in penalty."
"The penalty stands as explained." Kingsley pounded his gavel, and the reporters fled from the room.
Two guards came to Severus and released the shackles from the chair. They lifted him up and began to lead him away. Hermione rushed to his side.
"Severus!" she exclaimed. "We'll fight this!"
"It will be useless if my being is to be destroyed," he muttered grimly. His face was a mask. "Thank you for your effort," he whispered as he was led away.
Another guard kept Hermione from following him. "You may see him when you are summoned," he told Hermione. She stopped fighting him and stood helplessly, watching Severus being led away.
Harry bounded up to her. "What happened?"
Hermione shook her head forlornly. "I don't know. I've never seen a unanimous vote in the Wizengamot. I don't even think there's one on record. Something's wrong here, Harry."
"We need to find Dumbledore, and fast," he whispered to her.
"Do you have any leads?"
"No, but I'll get back to work. Will you be all right?"
Hermione nodded absently. Harry turned and left the courtroom. Hermione fidgeted, awaiting her admittance to the room where they had dragged Severus.
Story Actions
To follow, favorite, like, and more either log in or create an account.
Leave a Review
Log in to leave a review.
Latest 25 Reviews for Empty
281 Reviews | 7.16/10 Average
Hurrah! But seriously, why aren't all of these on your ffnet account? SO glad I joined this website...Great story! I kept almost-crying, and I'm at uni at the moment, so that would have been... well, most inappropriate.
Response from debjunk (Author of Empty)
Most inappropriate indeed! ~tissue? This is a great site. I'm glad you found it. There are so many stories here that I haven't had time to upload to FFN. Also many of them are drabbles for Saturday Night, and I don't think to load them up until it's way late. But I should, and I probably will at some point. :) Glad you liked this.
WOW! What a neat clean up job you have done with the villains and thanks for the happy ending! I read this straight through and loved every minute of it. I hope you win!!!! This was very 'in canon' and I give you an Outstanding!
Response from debjunk (Author of Empty)
Thank you so much,
Response from debjunk (Author of Empty)
! I'm very glad you enjoyed it and thought so highly of it. Don't forget to vote in the challenge. Whether you vote for this fic or not, the more people who vote, the better it is for all of us!
I really liked this story and am sad it is ending.But you gave us a happy ending and the villains have been punished.Thank you for writing your take on the challenge. I liked it very much.
Response from debjunk (Author of Empty)
I'm glad you liked it apisa. It was fun to write. Thank you for following it to the end.
So, I love how you handled the Dumbledore thing. I love the idea of him being stuck with his own thoughts for so long and only being able to dwell on what he did to everyone.
I'm glad Severus got the appology he didn't even know he needed. I can only imagine how huge of a weight that would have been lifted with those words.
I'm also glad to see the toad and Lestrange being hauled of to Azkaban, may they rot forever.
Much Love
~ Brena
Response from debjunk (Author of Empty)
Oh, they'll rot all right! And Severus really did need that from Albus. After searching fruitlessly, he was feeling pretty guilty. Now he knows he doesn't need to. Opens the door for him to begin a new life... filled with Hermione.
Wow, I didn't realize I fell so far behind with my reading! I pulled up this fic today to start trying to catch up and I see that its already completed!
I'm very happy that the bad guys have been foiled and even more excited that we know what happened to Dumbledore. I hope there aren't any huge repercussions from him being Staute-Man for 6 years. I'm just going to have to go to the next chapter and see for myself!
Much Love,
~ Brena
Response from debjunk (Author of Empty)
Slacker! That's okay. We all live in the real world. I'm glad you are catching up. Hope you enjoy the rest.
Bravo for happy endings.
Response from debjunk (Author of Empty)
Yes, they're wonderful, aren't they? Thanks so much!
Beautiful ending, Hermione and Severus get happily ever after, and Umbridge and Lestrange get life in Azkaban prison. Everything is as it should be.
Response from debjunk (Author of Empty)
Heh, dang right! No escapees here. Umbridge and Lestrange will spend the rest of their days with the kitties. And Hermione and Severus will spend the rest of their days with each other!
Thank goodness Dumbledore didn't waste away in his own mind for the time he was prisoner. I am so glad Umbridge finally got her dues!!
Response from debjunk (Author of Empty)
Dumbledore is a calculative and clever wizard. Luckily, he was able to keep his mind from slipping into insanity. That would have truly been tragic... despite his penchant for meddlesome behavior.
Hmmm. I thought it was Dumbledore that was being held prisoner. I just hope that being stuck like that for 6 years has not made him insane.
Response from debjunk (Author of Empty)
And you were oh, so right! At least he had a good reason for being gone and untraceable for all that time.
Meddling old man. He nearly completely ruined the first spontaniously ramantic thing Severus has ever done. I really loved this story.
Response from debjunk (Author of Empty)
That's a good way of putting it! Lucky that Hermione is quick thinking and helped to save the day. I'm so glad you enjoyed this! Thank you for all your wonderful and thoughtful reviews.
Ha! I love Hermione's revenge on Umbridge's precious kittens. At least now they are getting to the bottom of things.
Response from debjunk (Author of Empty)
They are. They'll have all the pieces soon.
Yes! I knew Hermione would get it in the end. Now they need to kick some Umbridge ass!
Response from debjunk (Author of Empty)
Indeed they do!
What a terrible situation. Niether of them being able to communicate with the other.
Response from debjunk (Author of Empty)
It's frustrating as all get out for Severus, and poor Hermione only knows that he can hear her, but not what he might think of anything she says.
Yay! She sang like a canary. One would think she would have been more wary of the ex-student she tortured for a year. Good for Harry. Now let's hope Hermione can save Severus.
Response from debjunk (Author of Empty)
You would think she would be. I think, though, that Umbridge is very full of herself. She would never imagine that she could be duped or that anyone would have the guts to even try.
Ha ha. Turn about is fair play. I hope she spills her guts! Poor Hermione. She really did not think about what it would be like to have Snape like that araoun all the time.
Response from debjunk (Author of Empty)
I think it's like most things. You have an idea of what something will be like, but it's always much more intense than what you expect. How horrible it would be to have to see someone you respect, and well, love, be like this.
Oh my. That is definately a worse punishment that death would have been. Thank goodness for Hermione's quick thinking.
Response from debjunk (Author of Empty)
Yep. We've already established what a @!$% Umbridge is. If he'd wound up with here there might have been little left to save.
Evil, twisted, coniving B+*@ch. I hope there is some magical residue left that explains what happened in rhe trial.
Response from debjunk (Author of Empty)
She's all that, all right. It's amazing how evil she is. And willing to work with who-knows-who to achieve her goals.
Whew. Severus has absolutely no chance against those two terrible plotters. I think I may have a slight suspicion as to who the imprisoned wizard may be...
Response from debjunk (Author of Empty)
And you may well be right on the mystery prisoner. Severus really is in it deep. He has no idea how twisted everything will become soon.
Wow. Somebody really has it in for Severus. I can't wait to find out who it is. At least Kingsley has the good sense to follow the old addage "keep your freinds close and your enemies closer"!
Response from debjunk (Author of Empty)
True for Kingsley. Poor Severus really does have an enemy.
Ok, I'm sadistic - I think that Umbridge and Lestrange got exactly what they deserved. Did part of their duties incluse scrubbing toliets? Say yes and make my day! Please....Oh, and Merlin, but leave it to Albus to pop the cork before the party started! Goading Severus like that.I love how it took Hermione a while to catch on that he wasn't jsut showing her. Very nice ending. That you so much for this story, you did a great job and it was quite enjoyable.
Response from debjunk (Author of Empty)
Scrubbing toilets was one of the nicer things they had to do. I think some of the Aurors made them kneel on the floor and shine their shoes... the Muggle way.
Thank heavens Hermione saved the proposal by keeping a clear head. Albus really doesn't know when to shut it, even after all that time as a statue.
Whooot! Umbridge is off to the pokey! Yippeee!I almsot expected a Polyjuiced version of Dumbledore the way he was babbling so OC until he said how he'd had nothing but his memories to keep him sane. I suppose a good long mental reevaluation was in order. At least Kingsley has seen the light!
Response from debjunk (Author of Empty)
LOL, yeah. Who would have thought he'd act that way, right? I think he felt a tiny bit of guilt which became a lot of guilt given the lack of other things to think about.
Interesting beginning. I can understand the Ministry being adamant to round up every last Death Eater, but I thoight Kingsley would be more leniant.
Response from debjunk (Author of Empty)
Thanks, I hope you enjoy the rest of it. I think Kingsley feels a little pushed into the corner by the adamancy of the Wizengamot. Silly him, being the Minister, but he's new... well, not that new!
Great story. I've enjoyed reading all of it, though it was hard when Severus had been Hollowed, I'm glad that Albus also was found. And happy endings make me happy! *g* Thanks for taking the time to share this wonderful fic with us!
Response from debjunk (Author of Empty)
Thank you so much! I'm glad you enjoyed it, even though poor Severus was 'out of it' for a while. That part was hard for me too, but the knowledge that everything would work out in the end kept me going.
Anonymous
And off they ride into the sundset... on two brooms, of course.
Very fitting ending to this tale! So nice to see everything is rounding up quite nicely and some things never change *giggles*.
Author's Response: Some things definitely never change! Albus better watch it, or some day he's going to really get killed by an irate Snape!