New Chapter for What the Lonely Know
What the Lonely Know
Agnus Castus27 Reviews | 5.0/10 (27 Ratings, 0 Likes, 2 Favorites )
After Snape answers the call of Tonks’ Patronus, his evening takes an unexpected turn.
Start ReadingChapters (10)
About Agnus Castus
Author
Agnus Castus
Member Since 2008 | 10 Stories | Favorited by 26 | 24 Reviews Written | 278 Review Responses
I’m a 40-something British woman, residing in the Ribble Valley in north-west England. I’m a pharmacist and a counsellor. My penname, Agnus Castus, is a herbal remedy for women’s hormone problems. I also co-write with The Snapettes.
I can also be found in the Facebook group "Muffliato!" for folks who appreciate SS/OC fanfic.
Reviews for What the Lonely Know
Wow. That was so unique and felt very honest and real. I appreciate your style and loved the last chapter. Well done!
Response from Agnus Castus (Author of What the Lonely Know)
Thank you so much - uniqueness is hard to achieve in the competitive world of Harry Potter fan fiction! This story took me back to a very lonely chapter from my own life, which may account for its realism and honesty. Your reviews have been much appreciated
Intense start. Not a couple I ever pictured but in a moment I'd desperation I can see it happening. I am curious where this will lead.
Response from Agnus Castus (Author of What the Lonely Know)
Thanks for reviewing! The idea popped into my head years ago when I was feverish with a flu-like illness... Before this, I too had never pictured these two as a couple. The story was originally a one-shot, but the characters wouldn't leave me alone. I had no clue where they would take me, so I placed my trust in them and they led me in unexpected directions!
Nooooooooo! How dare you break my heart like that? Surely our Severus deserves some solace now!
*wipes tears violently*
OK, enough dramatics, back to the point.
You. Are. Outstanding. I am just amazed, to say the least. Wow. Just wow.
Response from Agnus Castus (Author of What the Lonely Know)
How lovely to receive a new review after all these years! Thank you so much for sharing your emotional response to my writing and for your kind praise. I'd love to know what stood out from the story for you? *passes tissues*
Response from MayavanavihariniHarini (Reviewer)
You wrote about the leading duo with zero compromise.. They were TOTALLY true to character. Frankly I feel at times that writing good fanfiction is TOUGHER than writing original fiction. You just reinforced that idea. Perhaps moving Tonks back to Lupin is what gives the story its powerful quality that makes me love you and hate you at the same time!
I hope I could convey my feelings properly..English isn't my mothertongue, you see!
Response from Agnus Castus (Author of What the Lonely Know)
Certainly, writing canon-compliant fan fiction is quite challenging, and forces authors to think carefully about plot and characterisation. I'm glad you think Snape and Tonks were true to character - I tried hard to make it so! Thank you for replying. You made my day
acutely insightful and realistic. thanks for the happy ending though it could so easily have resulted in unforgiveness
Response from Agnus Castus (Author of What the Lonely Know)
Thank you for leaving a review; it's nice to know this story is still being enjoyed all these years after publication. You found the ending happy? I suppose it was the lesser of two evils! Couldn't have them skipping off into the sunset together now, could we? ;)
Wrenching. It's a shame she never knew the truth.
Response from Agnus Castus (Author of What the Lonely Know)
Yes, it is a shame. Tonks was a bit too ham-fisted to get close enough to really know him, Snape was too scared to let somebody truly see him, and so despite their physical intimacy, they never shared real emotional intimacy. I like to think Tonks had an inkling, but sadly they both perished before the truth was revealed. Thanks for reading, and for leaving some nice shiny stars!
This is a truly engaging tale. I'm totally sucked in and can't wait to see how this resolves (even though I know it can't end well.)
Response from Agnus Castus (Author of What the Lonely Know)
Thanks for reviewing; it's nice to know this story is still being discovered and enjoyed by readers
Ooh! I got shivers when Tonks' eyes metamorphosed into Sevs. This felt a little like the calm before the storm for some reason. Everything is going well for them, but how can it end well? I wonder how the DADA classroom rendezvous will play out? Looking forward to finding out.
Response from Agnus Castus (Author of What the Lonely Know)
The calm before the storm, you say? Very perceptive. I wanted them to have a bit of fun at some point in the story, because the end is coming as surely as the Chudley Cannons shall finish bottom of the Quidditch league. Thank you so much for the stars and your review!
They are both so in tune with each other; the metamorphosed reaction Tonks has from Sev - she's renewing herself, her strength again from him...hmmn, they're both getting into deep waters from which neither will be the same - though neither would maybe admit it, due to circumstances and consequences... as painful as it is, can't wait to read further :)
Response from Agnus Castus (Author of What the Lonely Know)
I love your interpretation of the metamorphosis; there's definitely a bond between them now, although it's not exactly conventional, and you're quite right - they won't admit it to each other, or to themselves. Next chapter's up; I hope it's not too painful for you!
Wonderful chemistry and insight into these kindred souls!
Response from Agnus Castus (Author of What the Lonely Know)
Thank you! Who says a Hufflepuff and a Slytherin can't have chemistry? Hehe
Perfect! Thank you - I was always struck by the intimacy of Severus' remark to Tonks - implying that he knew all too well her state of mind and emotions for changing her Patronus and fading looks - thanking you for fleshing it out! Speaking of 'fleshing' things out - thanks for this ship :) Poignant, wonderful & juicy; really capturing their immediate needs.
Response from Agnus Castus (Author of What the Lonely Know)
I, too, noticed the intimacy of Snape's remark to Tonks at the school gates, and his nasty comment was the inspiration for this story. Thanks for reviewing!
This is so poignant. I feel sad for both of them knowing what is ahead for them. I really think that Snape is deluding himself here; he claims to want something undemanding, but I have a feeling he wants more - maybe not necessarily from Tonks, but I think Snape is a one woman man who craves intimacy and all that it brings, despite what he says. What Tonks wants is less clear - perhaps to herself as well. She is obviously in love with Lupin, but I suspect she feels something for Snape. Yes, she wants him as a 'fuck-buddy' but he is an emotional support too, whether either of them acknowledge it or not. I know this can't end romantically well for either of them, but I am intrigued to know how you will end it. Thank you for a lovely take on two lonely people's lives.
Response from Agnus Castus (Author of What the Lonely Know)
Reviews like yours make posting on TPP worthwhile; thank you for your insightful words. I think there's a lot of denial and distortion going on between them, but I think they also draw comfort from each other. Both of them suffer the pain and loneliness of unrequited love, and both have an inability to move on. I'm intrigued by the lies the characters tell themselves. I hope the ending completes the story for you.
I like the way you compared Severus to a dragon when he got angry. Tonks extinguished him quick enough;) Also loved the tenderness at the end. Good job.
Response from Agnus Castus (Author of What the Lonely Know)
Thanks for your review,
Response from Agnus Castus (Author of What the Lonely Know)
. I'm pleased you enjoyed his transition from anger to tenderness.
So very poignant and well-done; thank you - my three favourite characters... thanks for filling in the gaps in such stirring ways!
Response from Agnus Castus (Author of What the Lonely Know)
I hope I handled your three favourite characters well! Many thanks for all your reviews.
Enjoyed the telling, biting dialogue and reflections going on between/in both of them. Thank you for capturing the angst and turmoil of each. So sad. And realistic. Reading on...
Response from Agnus Castus (Author of What the Lonely Know)
I'm glad you enjoyed the dialogue, which is getting edgier as time passes by. Sadness and realism, wow - thank you!
I knew the ending did not bode well for our man, but at least there was some sort of hope and the promise of a happy ever after for Tonks. Of course we know how short that happy ever after is going to be for the two of them, but its nice to think that they had some happiness, if only for a brief time. Thank you for sharing this little glimpse into the lives of two, or perhaps I should say three lonely people.
Response from Agnus Castus (Author of What the Lonely Know)
And thank you for reading and reviewing,
Response from Agnus Castus (Author of What the Lonely Know)
. I'm glad you saw some happiness and hope in these characters, during a very bleak time of their lives.
I'm sad to see this end (especially as I still had hopes about Teddy being a Snape) but I really enjoyed this story from start to finish
Response from Agnus Castus (Author of What the Lonely Know)
I'm glad you enjoyed the story. Snape and Tonks weren't sustainable enough to last until the time she fell pregnant with Teddy; Snape couldn't handle intimacy and Tonks couldn't manage without it. Thanks for reviewing!
What achingly empty lives. This was an extremely well written story.
Response from Agnus Castus (Author of What the Lonely Know)
"Achingly empty" really sums it up well; their lives are so lonely and bereft. Thank you very much for your kind review.
Perfect... really felt like I was at Grimmauld Place; everything really captured spot-on, all the details and description (the last line really hit the spot!); really love your perfect characterisation and the banter and chemistry between Tonks and Severus. Yummy! Thanks!
Response from Agnus Castus (Author of What the Lonely Know)
Thanks,
Response from Agnus Castus (Author of What the Lonely Know)
, it was nice for me to go back to Grimmauld Place, I quite like it there. I'm pleased you're enjoying the chemistry between the two characters; Tonks always struck me as a witch who could hold her own in a conversation, and I've had fun playing her off against Snape. Many thanks for reading and reviewing!
I like your Tonks and Severus. It is nice he has some moments of interacting with another person in relatively peace in this awful year of his
Response from Agnus Castus (Author of What the Lonely Know)
Yes, this has to count of one of his least enjoyable years at Hogwarts. Thanks for your review!
Wow Snape did something kind for someone else (although of course there was a nice thank you in it for him:)). Good chapter looking forward to more.
Response from Agnus Castus (Author of What the Lonely Know)
He did something kind but ultimately self-serving. Snape is a Slytherin, after all. Thanks for the review and the shinies
Nicely done :)
Response from Agnus Castus (Author of What the Lonely Know)
Thanks. Are you referring to any part in particular?
Response from Lexandrac (Reviewer)
I just love the emotional bits in this chapter, Severus' sadnesss, as well as Tonks' is almost palpable.
I'm glad they aren't ending it, I'm enjoying this story too much for it to be over :). I've always thought Tonks and Severus could have made an interesting couple. Looking forward to more.
Response from Agnus Castus (Author of What the Lonely Know)
Thanks for your encouraging review. I was also glad they decided not to end it... yet. Tonks and Severus popped into my head one day and refused to leave, and up until then the pairing had never occured to me. There will be ten chapters in total. Hope you enjoy!
Wow that answered the one question I had after the incident which was "Who is Teddy's real father?"
Response from Agnus Castus (Author of What the Lonely Know)
Teddy's father is Remus Lupin, after all.
very sad
Response from Agnus Castus (Author of What the Lonely Know)
I know. They seem doomed...