Chapter Four: A Long-expected Party
Chapter 5 of 9
Prof M McGonagallHermione hosts a Muggle-style Christmas party. The "Mother Hens" attempt matchmaking, and a moment of romance occurs.
ReviewedDisclaimer: JKR, Scholastic and Warner Brothers own the words and images belonging to the Harry Potter universe. The Tolkien estate, its various publishers and New Line Cinema own the words and images belonging to The Lord of the Rings universe.
Thanks, as always, to my alpha/beta team of morethansirius and sshg316.
**********
How'd I get myself into this? Hermione looked around the small dining room off the Great Hall. Somehow, the Muggle Christmas party she had planned for the book club meeting in her sitting room had turned into a full staff Christmas party for the purpose of introducing Edward Beekman to James's colleagues. Minerva had not forgotten Hermione's offer to help, and once she and Severus had found a spell to allow a Muggle access to Hogwarts, Minerva had asked Hermione if she would consider turning her small party into a bigger one.
James's wife had offered to help. Jasmine was a Muggle-born witch and did understand Muggle Christmas customs. Their six-month-old son took a lot of her time, however. So Hermione was taking care of the final preparations herself. She had overseen the placement of the Christmas trees, the decorations, the party favours, and the arrangement of the room. There was a small space for dancing since Arthur Weasley had found a way of charming a CD player to work at Hogwarts. Hermione had a selection of Christmas CDs that had been gathered from Muggles that she and Jasmine knew.
She and Jasmine had overseen the preparation of the food, giving the house-elves specific instructions about the Muggle recipes. There were a variety of sandwiches, including hot beef, cucumber, and tomato and watercress. The food and drink came in Muggle and wizarding varieties: cheeses, crackers, candies and cakes, fruit and fondues, wines, mulled mead, Firewhisky, holiday punch, and eggnog.
The arrangements taken care of, Hermione went off to get dressed for the evening. She had decided to wear Muggle clothing, since she had suggested it to her book club members, but when she went shopping for a holiday party dress, she knew that many of the current fashions would shock her colleagues who were used to witches being covered by robes. She chose instead to wear a vintage dress in holiday green velvet. The boat neckline and tight sleeves to just below the elbow seemed demure enough but were offset by the fitted bodice and the plunging back neckline. Looking at her reflection in the full-length mirror, she decided that she liked the green organza cummerbund that seemed to cinch her waist in. She wore a faux diamond pin that matched the accents on the cummerbund. Wearing her hair up showed off the back of her dress with its deep "V" cut.
Fairly satisfied with how she looked, she made her way down to the small dining room. As hostesses, she and Jasmine had decided to be there early enough to greet the guests as they arrived. She noticed several people in the room. Oh no! It must have taken me longer than I thought to get ready. Looking again, she realised that half of the people were Jasmine's family, and the other three were Minerva, Septima and Pomona, who had promised to arrive early in case of last minute emergencies.
Feeling a little better, she walked over to Jasmine and James and the third person in their party, a man dressed in a gray suit, burgundy shirt and silver silk tie. That must be Edward. Wow, he's quite a bit better looking than James, and James isn't exactly bad looking. "Hi, James. Hi, Jasmine. I hope you weren't waiting long."
Jasmine replied, "No. We just got here ourselves. Hermione, this is James's brother, Edward. Edward, this is Hermione Granger, the Charms professor here at Hogwarts."
Hermione held her hand out to Edward Beekman. "Hello, Edward. It's nice to meet you."
Edward shook her hand, replying, "Nice to meet you, Hermione. I've heard a lot about you, but no one told me how stunning you are."
Yeah, right. She looked at Edward carefully to see if he was teasing her. His admiration seemed sincere, so she smiled and said, "Thank you. I'm not sure why you would hear a lot about..." Just then, she noticed Minerva, Pomona and Septima all watching her conversation with Edward with avid interest. Those three just couldn't take a hint. "Ah, you've been talking to Minerva, I expect." She looked at her three friends, eyebrows raised. They sent sheepish glances her way.
Madam Hooch and Firenze arrived, followed shortly by Professor Binns and Sybill Trelawney. "Time to greet our guests, Jasmine," Hermione said. As she walked towards the newcomers, she passed by Septima, Pomona and Minerva. "I will speak with you later," she said with a meaningful look.
"Oh, good. We'll want to hear what you think of Edward," the irrepressible Septima answered.
Hermione chose to ignore that response. She followed Jasmine and went to speak to the newcomers, welcoming them and inviting them to help themselves to the refreshments.
Bathsheba Babbling and Poppy Pomfrey arrived. Hermione spent a little time responding to their complimentary remarks about the Christmas decorations. They headed toward the food table. Hermione turned back to the door and saw Severus walking into the room. He had dressed in Muggle attire, wearing black trousers and a black cashmere sweater with green flecks in it. His graceful stride was even more pronounced without his billowing teaching robes. Oh my...
"Good evening, Severus," she said with a smile, trying very hard not to let him know she had been watching him walk.
He shook her hand but lingered with her hand in his as he glanced at her dress in appreciation. He actually smiled at her. "You look lovely, Hermione."
"Why, thank you, Severus." Hermione felt herself blushing a little and turned away quickly to point out the food and beverages.
"Where is that music coming from?" Severus asked. "That doesn't sound like the WWN."
"No, it's not," Hermione agreed. "Arthur Weasley figured out how to charm a Muggle CD player so that it doesn't need electricity to operate, so we're listening to Muggle Christmas music."
"It's certainly an improvement over Celestina Warbeck's Greatest Hits for the Winter Solstice."
Hermione laughed. "I agree. I was thinking of sending a selection of Muggle Christmas CDs for Ron to take home to the Burrow with him this year. Maybe Molly will become a convert."
"And give up 'a cauldron full of hot, strong love'? That's asking an awful lot," Severus responded with mock seriousness.
"You're probably right, but it certainly can't hurt to try."
At that moment, Ivy Turner walked in. Hermione saw that Ivy had noticed the good-natured conversation she and Severus were having. Ivy hurried to Severus's side. "Good evening, Severus." She smiled warmly up at him. Turning to Hermione, the smile disappeared. "Hermione," she barely acknowledged.
"Hi, Ivy." Hermione had to work to give her a genuine smile and to find something nice to say. "Your robes... I've never seen anything like them."
Ivy preened a little. Ivy's green dress robes were unique. The collar fit closely around her neck to just below her jaw where the back half suddenly flared out around the back of her head and reminded Hermione of nothing more than the wicked queen in the Disney movie Snow White. She wore a green velvet cape that stood straight out from the shoulders as though an iron rod had been threaded through the fabric. "I had them made from my original design," Ivy said proudly.
"Oh?" Hermione tried not to laugh. "How creative you are, Ivy."
"Thank you." Ivy's voice finally sounded gracious. "Severus, would you escort me to the food table?" Ivy grabbed his arm, accidentally jabbing her shoulder into Severus's arm, and steered him away from Hermione.
Jasmine came up to Hermione. "What on earth was that get-up?"
"Ivy's own design," Hermione said, biting her lip to keep laughter from bubbling up.
"Poor Severus. I hope his arm doesn't get bruised." Jasmine giggled, and Hermione stifled a laugh.
"Hermione," Edward called. Both Hermione and Jasmine turned to see Edward walking towards them. "No one is dancing. Why don't you and I get the ball rolling?"
"Okay," Hermione answered.
They walked to the dance floor, and Edward took her in his arms. He was a pleasant dancer. "What is it you do, Edward?" Hermione asked.
"I'm a solicitor."
"That's interesting. Before I started teaching here, I worked at the Ministry of Magic for Magical Law Enforcement. I worked in the department that deals with the laws and regulations regarding interactions with magical creatures."
"You need special laws for that?"
"With the large numbers of magical creatures and the differences in intelligence, intent and information...or misinformation...we know about them, it is really important to have rules in our dealings."
They danced for a bit in silence. They had been joined on the dance floor by Argus Filch and Sybill Trelawney. Argus isn't a bad dancer, thought Hermione in amused surprise, but I'm not sure how well wizarding dance steps go with this song. Ivy glared at the dance floor before practically dragging Severus out to dance. "What made you want to teach?" Edward's questions quickly drew her attention back to her partner.
"Minerva was very persuasive about teaching young minds not to be prejudiced. That was what the Voldemort Wars were basically fought over."
"According to her, you played a key part in the war."
"I never really looked at it that way. I was just helping my friend, and I was trying to protect myself and my family."
"You're a Muggle-born like James, then?"
"Yes, my parents are both dentists."
They continued to get to know each other throughout the rest of the dance. They both enjoyed the research aspect of the law and the chance to fight for the rights of the underprivileged. A love of history was something else they both shared. The dance ended very pleasantly.
After their dance, Edward said, "I'd like to dance with you again, but I promised Jasmine I would dance with her because James doesn't like dancing. Maybe later?"
"Later would be fine." She gave him a smile before she walked over to the refreshment table and picked up some food and something to drink. She looked around for a place to sit. I might as well face the interrogation now. She went to sit with Pomona, Septima and Minerva.
Septima asked, "Well, what did you think of Edward? You two looked very nice together."
"He is very nice," Hermione responded. "He was charming. I think he's going to ask me to dance again later."
"Nice and charming? That's it?" Minerva asked.
"What did you expect after one dance? He's nice, and we have some things in common."
"Now, dear, don't be irritated with us," Pomona urged. "We just want to see you happy."
"I know. You're all very good to me, but I'm certainly not going to be pushed into a relationship. If it works out, fine. But, please, no pushing."
Septima nodded. "We'll try to be good. Right, ladies?" Pomona and Minerva agreed.
Just then, Severus approached their table. "Hermione, would you care to dance?" A sudden gleam appeared in Minerva's eye. Hermione ignored her for the moment and said, "Sure, Severus." She gave Minerva a quick glare as she got up from the table.
She and Severus walked to the dance floor, and he held out his arms. Hermione stepped into his arms, and they began to dance. Why didn't I notice if Edward's hands were warm? Her hand felt cocooned in his, and the warmth that she felt through her dress from his hand on her back seemed to spread to her toes.
"You've done a marvellous job on the party, Hermione," he commented.
Hermione hadn't realised how deep his voice sounded until now when his mouth was so close to her ear. Suddenly, her senses seemed to be attuned to him. He smells like new parchment, and herbs, and... something else. What is it?
"Hermione, are you all right?" Hermione suddenly noticed she'd been taking deep breaths through her nose, trying to ascertain what Severus smelled like. Stop that before you make a fool of yourself!
"I'm fine, Severus. Thank you. Jasmine and I had a good time planning the party together."
They danced silently for a moment. Still lost in the spell of her senses, she didn't know that she had been rubbing one finger of her hand on his sweater, enjoying the softness of the cashmere. That is, she didn't know until Severus moved his hand slightly so that his thumb was caressing the skin of her back at the lowest point the plunging neckline left bare. Suddenly all Hermione's attention was drawn to that spot on her back.
What is happening here? Hesitantly, Hermione raised her eyes to Severus's face to find his dark eyes looking into hers. Her stomach gave a little flip at the vulnerability she saw there.
"Hermione?" Severus asked softly.
What should I do? What is happening here? Hermione's thoughts were whirling. She bit her lower lip, confused.
"This is unexpected, isn't it?" He was looking at her with one eyebrow raised, a hint of humour in his eyes.
"Yes. I'm barely beyond thinking of you as my professor." I hope he doesn't feel insulted by that.
"I hope you've gone beyond thinking of me as your professor, or this could be awkward," he replied.
Hermione gave a nervous, little giggle. "Well, I've begun to think of you as a friend since our take-away dinner."
"So have I. I was expecting this to be a dance between friends."
"I don't know..." Hermione stopped, not knowing quite what to say.
"I'm guessing that you would like some time to mull things over. Is that right?"
Hermione gave a little nod.
"Good, because I would, too. Is that okay?"
Hermione gave him a relieved smile. Severus gave her a small smile in return. He pulled her closer as they danced, his jaw resting lightly against her hair. Hermione relaxed and let herself enjoy the dance. She smiled slightly. I'm not telling the "mother hens" about this.
~~o~~0~~o~~0~~o~~
A week later, the book club met to discuss Book Three. Christmas holiday was coming, and the staff members were wearing down. Hermione herself felt a bit unprepared for leading a discussion. Preparing for the Christmas party had taken more time than she had planned. Thinking about the Christmas party in the week since...particularly one special dance...had kept her rather more preoccupied than she had anticipated.
Ivy had told her rather coldly that morning that she wouldn't be attending the book club that night as she had only committed to one meeting per month for this Muggle club, and the Muggle Christmas party had fulfilled that requirement. Hermione had expressed her regret that Ivy wouldn't be able to be at the meeting, but privately she thought, hugging herself to contain a little thrill of excitement, Maybe she has some reason to be jealous after all. Then she had covered her mouth with one hand to stop herself giggling like some hysterical teenage girl over her first date. Get a grip, please. You're in the staff workroom. Anyone could come in at any moment. Besides, all this is very preliminary; nothing has been decided or really even hinted at. Okay, so there's a definite mutual attraction, but that might not turn into anything else... Taking a deep breath, Hermione had decided that the best thing to do would be to go to the privacy of her office as soon as possible.
Somehow, she managed to get through classes and to the book club meeting without embarrassing herself. The discussion at the meeting covered a wide variety of topics without very much organization, as had become the norm. The Ents were discussed in some detail. Although some magical plants had rather highly developed instinctive systems, such as Mandrakes or Whomping Willows, none had the intelligence and longevity that the Ents seemed to have. Pomona enthused at length over the imagination of Tolkien in coming up with these wonderful trees.
Septima enjoyed the hints of romance to be found between Aragorn and Eowyn and the Ents and Entwives. Hermione hoped that Septima wouldn't be too disappointed over the fact that there was so little romantic development in the story. She determined to buy Septima some good romance novels for a Christmas present. She also began to wonder if it would be possible to show the book club the movie adaptations where the romantic element seemed to be played up quite a bit more. Hmmm, The Return of the King is due out in theatres any day. She set that aside to be thought about later.
The discussion then moved to the themes of death and new life and how they were developed in the characters of Boromir, Gandalf and King Theoden. Hermione was thrilled that they were finally talking about some of the deeper aspects of the story. When they started talking about the dual nature of good and evil in the character of Saruman, at first...remembering their discussion about Dumbledore and Gandalf...she worried that this might strike too close to home for Severus. He seemed to be enjoying the discussion and the debate over the finer points of the story, however.
Eventually the discussion wound its way down, and Hermione pointed out that the first Friday of January was the last Friday before school began again. Did they want to put off the meeting until the second Friday or go ahead and meet as scheduled? They chose to meet the first Friday as they were mostly planning to be back by that point to be getting ready for the next round of classes. After mentioning that Book Four followed Frodo's and Sam's progress, she wished them a good final week of classes before the holidays.
She was glad that Severus appeared to be taking his time about leaving, waiting until he was the last book club member left in Hermione's sitting room. "That was a good discussion," he said.
"Yes, it was a lot of fun to talk about some of the themes of the books."
Severus came up to her and taking a gentle hold of her chin, he raised it to look into her face carefully. "Are you all right? You look a little tired."
Hermione gave him a rueful smile. "Don't we all? I'll be glad when this next week is over and Christmas break is here."
"Indeed." Severus gave her chin one final caress before walking over to the table and sitting down. "What are your plans?"
"I'll be here for the first few days until all the Gryffindors have gone home. I don't have any students staying the entire holiday, do you?"
"No, my last Slytherin leaves for home on the 22nd, and then I plan to go home for a few days."
"So do I. I'll stay at my apartment for a bit, probably visit Harry and Ginny, Ron and Luna, maybe the Weasleys. I'm spending Christmas with my parents."
"What are you doing Christmas Eve?"
"Oh, nothing much. Probably I'll go to Mum and Dad's and watch Christmas movies. We usually attend a Christmas Eve service. What will you do?"
"Well..." Severus took a deep breath. "I've been mulling things over this past week. Have you?"
Hermione felt a little breathless, too. "Yes."
"Would you spend Christmas Eve with me?"
"I'd love to."
Story Actions
To follow, favorite, like, and more either log in or create an account.
Leave a Review
Log in to leave a review.
Latest 25 Reviews for Book Club
45 Reviews | 5.98/10 Average
This always has been always *will* be one of my favorites. The only thing cooler than a Tolkein wedding would be a Jane Austin wedding .Severus as Mr.Darcy beyond yummy.
Response from Prof M McGonagall (Author of Book Club)
What a nice comment! I'm so glad you enjoyed this story! And, yes, I could see Severus as Mr. Darcy.
What a sweet and lovely tale. I love how you wove The Lord of the Rings into this, and the romance between Severus and Hermione was delightful.
Response from Prof M McGonagall (Author of Book Club)
Thank you! I'm so glad you enjoyed it and appreciate your taking the time to tell me so.
Very well done. I love having the wedding embed LOTR. And I was especially fond of borrowing bits from Bilbo's birthday party. That was truly brilliant. I definitely enjoyed this whole story, thanks for sharing it with us.
Response from Prof M McGonagall (Author of Book Club)
Thank you so much for your kind reviews throughout the story! I had written the ending of the epilogue two or three different ways before hitting on the idea of Bilbo's birthday party.
Response from Prof M McGonagall (Author of Book Club)
Thank you so much for your kind reviews throughout the story! I had written the ending of the epilogue two or three different ways before hitting on the idea of Bilbo's birthday party.
Very nicely done. It was nice of Severus to play along with the old hens, though I wonder if he didn't plan it or at least accidentally let slip his plans.
Response from Prof M McGonagall (Author of Book Club)
Perhaps, the whole thing was just a wonderful coincidence! I'm glad you liked it.
Response from Prof M McGonagall (Author of Book Club)
Perhaps, the whole thing was just a wonderful coincidence! I'm glad you liked it.
Severus you sneak. At least he seems to be learning something about relationships when he takes to heart her advice about asking questions rather than assuming things. Funny about Ivy and Edward. And hooray for Hermione for learning from Severus about keeping secrets.
Response from Prof M McGonagall (Author of Book Club)
Hooray for our characters learning and growing! Thanks for reviewing!
Response from Prof M McGonagall (Author of Book Club)
Hooray for our characters learning and growing! Thanks for reviewing!
There goes Hermione over thinking things. Hopefully she doesn't let her imagination run away too much. After all Ivy hugely insulted Severus.
Response from Prof M McGonagall (Author of Book Club)
Hermione strikes me as the type of person who would tend to over-analyze every aspect of a relationship if she isn't careful.
Response from Prof M McGonagall (Author of Book Club)
Hermione strikes me as the type of person who would tend to over-analyze every aspect of a relationship if she isn't careful.
Another wonderful chapter. I loe how you are developing the relationship between the two of them. Wonder how the next book club meeting with Ivy will go?
Response from Prof M McGonagall (Author of Book Club)
Thank you! I'm glad that you are enjoying watching their relationship come along.
Response from Prof M McGonagall (Author of Book Club)
Thank you! I'm glad that you are enjoying watching their relationship come along.
Very nice. I like the Severus Hermione moment over the Thai food and the opening up to each other. I'm also enjoying the green eyed monster in Ivy. Not a very observant woman, is she. I really liked Minerva's comment about reading to the end of the book. Makes a big difference when discussing Boromir. And poor Hermione looks like she's about to be set up.
Response from Prof M McGonagall (Author of Book Club)
I'm so glad you enjoyed Severus and Hermione's conversation. And yes, the mother hens are bound to try to take care of Hermione. :)
Response from Prof M McGonagall (Author of Book Club)
I'm so glad you enjoyed Severus and Hermione's conversation. And yes, the mother hens are bound to try to take care of Hermione. :)
I have to agree about thebfirst part of LOTR. Perhaps Hermione should have started with something lighter. Very well done on the interactions and comparisons with the wizarding world. I love the idea of Ivy trying to win Severus over and Hermione's reaction to those revelations.
Response from Prof M McGonagall (Author of Book Club)
I had read LotR so many times prior to writing this story, but I reread it especially with the Hogwarts professors in mind, trying to determine what they would think of the story.
Response from phoenix (Reviewer)
It was tons of fun to see what they each got out of the story. One of many things I love about the written word is the ability for everyone to see it differently.
Response from Prof M McGonagall (Author of Book Club)
I had read LotR so many times prior to writing this story, but I reread it especially with the Hogwarts professors in mind, trying to determine what they would think of the story.
Response from phoenix (Reviewer)
It was tons of fun to see what they each got out of the story. One of many things I love about the written word is the ability for everyone to see it differently.
Definitely think the idea of improving knowledge of the Muggle world is long overdue. I love the idea of the book club and do feel a bit sorry for Heremione getting stuck with Snape.
Response from Prof M McGonagall (Author of Book Club)
I thought the idea of Hogwarts staff interacting over a book was a chance to showcase their different personalities. I had so much fun writing the book club conversations. :)
Response from Prof M McGonagall (Author of Book Club)
I thought the idea of Hogwarts staff interacting over a book was a chance to showcase their different personalities. I had so much fun writing the book club conversations. :)
I like the start and he just unwittingly laid down a challenge. Something tells me he doesn't know Minerva offered Hermione a job and will regret that challenge.
Response from Prof M McGonagall (Author of Book Club)
Yes, the challenge does set some things into motion. As to whether or not he'll regret the challenge, well, you've probably decided for yourself by this point. :)
Response from Prof M McGonagall (Author of Book Club)
Yes, the challenge does set some things into motion. As to whether or not he'll regret the challenge, well, you've probably decided for yourself by this point. :)
Me encantóGracias
Response from Prof M McGonagall (Author of Book Club)
Thank you! I am glad you liked it.
Response from Prof M McGonagall (Author of Book Club)
Thank you! I am glad you liked it.
This is a fantastic story! I loved every second of it.
Response from Prof M McGonagall (Author of Book Club)
Thanks for reviewing and letting me know that you enjoyed it!
Response from Prof M McGonagall (Author of Book Club)
Thanks for reviewing and letting me know that you enjoyed it!
Lovely and entertained. This is one of my favorites. My question is how did Ivy and Beekman get together.
Response from Prof M McGonagall (Author of Book Club)
Thanks for your review! I'm glad you enjoyed the story.As for your question, the answer is in the reader's imagination. All I can say is that opposites attract. :)
Response from Prof M McGonagall (Author of Book Club)
Thanks for your review! I'm glad you enjoyed the story.As for your question, the answer is in the reader's imagination. All I can say is that opposites attract. :)
Poor Harry! Like the wedding speech. :)
Response from Prof M McGonagall (Author of Book Club)
I'm glad you enjoyed the wedding speech. Thanks for all your reviews!
LOL. Those scheming women. :)
Response from Prof M McGonagall (Author of Book Club)
*grins* They're mother hens to the last.
Ivy and a Muggle? ROFL. Poetic justice. :)
Response from Prof M McGonagall (Author of Book Club)
She'd hate having to eat her words. :)
Silly boy has got it all wrong! :)
Response from Prof M McGonagall (Author of Book Club)
Yes, Severus's vulnerabilities are showing.
Thank you for the fun story. I can almost see a spin off with Edward and Ivy being like Darren and Samantha. Ahhh, what's a Slytherin girl to do when the muggle men are just so darn good-looking?
Response from Prof M McGonagall (Author of Book Club)
LOL! Your "Bewitched" idea is a fun one.Thanks for your review! I'm glad you enjoyed the story.
LOL, Prisoner of Azkaban comes out in May? I like your alternate, Hermione-centric, titles, The Battle for Buckbeak and The Tale of the Time-Turner.
Response from Prof M McGonagall (Author of Book Club)
I checked the release dates pretty carefully when writing in order to fit into my timeline.If nothing else, my titles are very alliterative. Haha!Thanks once again for your detailed reviews. They are much appreciated.
I forgot to mention in my last something that you touch on again in this chapter. Severus is able to help Hermione deal with the emotional baggage from the war, as much as she can help him. So often we read tales in which Hermione helps Severus find his inner truth or express his emotions. But no one is perfect, and trauma injures all it touches.I have a bad feeling about Ivy, but maybe I am being too suspicious.
Response from Prof M McGonagall (Author of Book Club)
I think having both of them acknowledge their need for healing really helps bind them together as a couple.As for Ivy, well, I hope I've thought of a suitable fate for her.
You've exposed the problem of the Hogwarts sorting system. it would make more sense for a sentient Sorting Hat to have been "programed" to have a mixture of personality types in each house. AND to keep troublemakers apart. If the Mauraders had been separted, and the junior deatheaters had been scattered through the houses, it would have been easier to keep order and promote inter-house unity. Thanks again for a chapter that is both amusing and well-thought-out
Response from Prof M McGonagall (Author of Book Club)
The book club meeting in this chapter was one of my favorite scenes to plan out. I had that scene planned for weeks before I actually got to that part of the story and would giggle thinking about it. I'm glad you found it funny, too.
I am surprised that Ivy didn't come to the meeting, simply to keep an eye on Severus. But Ivy may have confidence in a long-term plan to keep Hermione and Severus apart. In that case, she'd love the opportunity to snub Hermione.
Response from Prof M McGonagall (Author of Book Club)
Ivy can be a little short-sighted in her desire to put Hermione in her place.
This is a really sweet story. You've given a lot of thought to details: The teachers' relationships, Binns gets his horrid-smelling cheese, whether Muggles can ever see Hogwarts, Not to mention Hermione's relationship with her parents, and Severus's enlightening comments about forgiveness. I like how much planning you've put into this tale. Thank you
Response from Prof M McGonagall (Author of Book Club)
I really enjoyed thinking about how the staff would interact with each other and how they would perceive The Lord of the Rings. Reading the book as a Hogwarts professor was a whole different approach to other times I had read Tolkien's work.
That is so sweet (and in character) of Hermione to have thought of Professor Binns! I love Snape's and Minerva's comments about the food. she even used paper plates!I laughed out loud at Snape's comment about slogging through the wilderness. Your little touches are wonderful.This is shaping up to be a delightful tale,
Response from Prof M McGonagall (Author of Book Club)
Thank you so much for mentioning the little details that caught your interest. I'm glad that you're enjoying the story.