Chapter Five
Chapter 5 of 12
bluewillowSeverus and Hermione bump into each other in NYC after the war and an unlikely friendship slowly develops.
ReviewedChapter Five
Hermione had tried making friends with her classmates but found that she had little in common with them. Even when she was tempted to socialise or given opportunities to "let her hair down", she held back because she was afraid that if she relaxed too much, she might let slip something about the Wizarding world. Or she would miss some reference that she should understand, despite the difference in culture between Britain and America. Like cable television or email. She had become pretty good at hanging back, listening to what others were saying and finding out what she should know, but it meant that others saw her as shy and insecure. Nobody seemed interested enough to poke a little deeper.
So it was with very little regret that she surrendered her weekends to exploring the city with Snape. He often muttered imprecations against her monopolising his time, but she knew that it was not in his nature to do anything without intention or forethought. Thus, if he showed up when she suggested a bookstore or museum or other outing, it was because he wanted to be there.
The day after Thanksgiving found the two of them at an oddly triangular brick building in Queens. Peering at the sign on the door as they walked into the lobby, Snape quizzed her, "So, what is this Noguchi? Please tell me this isn't going to be like the last museum, where there was naught but squares of primary colours . . ."
"Isamu Noguchi was a Japanese-American sculptor and artist." She picked up one of the brochures at the visitor desk and passed it to him.
"These . . . objects . . . then, are considered to be sculpture?"
"Yes, quite famous ones. Sculpture doesn't have to be representational, you know."
"Did you think we would have a shared interest in looking at rocks and chunks of wood?"
"I read about it in The New Yorker and it sounded peaceful. Quiet. Unfrequented."
"Hmm. There is that." They walked slowly through the museum, each pretending to be absorbed in the rough stone blocks pierced by peculiar holes, whilst watching the other out of the corner of their eye.
"How is the auditing going?"
"Well, I confess myself surprised that the Muggle world isn't rife with disease and unhappiness. The state of their potions and cures is miserably inadequate . . . It's all chemicals and machines – nobody wants to touch the materia medica or get their hands dirty. Nobody does any work themselves – they just type something out and it's all plastic and test tubes . . . I asked some questions about how the properties of the substance they were using to prepare their experiments affected the ingredients, and not one of them had even considered it! Nobody was familiar with the famous alchemical wizards of al-Andalus; one professor even referred me to the history department . . . I know that our burn salves and remedies work more efficiently than their bottles of pale pills, but if I stay here another six months, I won't know one end of my wand from the other . . ."
Hermione was astonished by this diatribe. It was more an angry grumble to himself than anything directed at her. As one of the few women involved in abstract mathematics, she too had felt alien in her courses. There was always a degree of translation involved in taking arithmetic concepts and working them through the Greek notations and diagrammatic proofs required by this system of learning. It was challenging work, but there was no one with whom she could share any of the struggle or accomplishment. At Hogwarts, even though she was alone in her academic ambitions, at least it was a matter of degree and not of type. She had expected that Snape would swan around in his classes at Columbia – she assumed that his rather negative charisma and his undoubtedly forceful presence would necessarily translate to respect among the teachers and distance from the students. She didn't know what to make of a Snape who was unsure of his place in the world.
His grousing subsided and he was brought back to his current situation. "So, with you here at university, whatever happened to your partners in crime?"
"Harry scraped the N.E.W.T.s to become an Auror – he's doing the training program now. I get the occasional letter from him saying how he's bruised or exhausted, but he sounds pretty happy overall."
"So in addition to rocks, I'm supposed to take an interest in Potter's happiness?"
"Well, you did ask. He's engaged to Ginny, but they're waiting to get married until after she graduates and he completes his training."
"And Mr. Weasley? There was some . . . understanding between the two of you?" He carefully studied the text on the wall explaining the provenance of a particularly uninspired piece of driftwood art.
"Misunderstanding would be closer to the mark. He and I are no longer a couple."
"I always considered him to be far below your intellectual level, so I'm not surprised he wasn't able to keep up with you."
"That wasn't the issue." Did he just compliment my intelligence?
"Oh?" He raised one eyebrow in schadenfreudic glee. What on earth did the wretched lad do? Hermione is clearly the best thing to have ever happened to him, so whatever he did to have ruined it must have been spectacularly obtuse.
"We fought all the time, of course. But the final straw was him getting some daft bint up the duff. Ron had taken to going to the pub with the lads after a match, since I wasn't interested. I'm sure he met her there. A bloody Quidditch groupie."
"Oh. That must have been rather difficult for you." He could barely restrain the urge to rub his hands together, like a parody of a miser being presented with a sack of gold.
"Naturally. His mum and dad put a great deal of pressure on him to do right by the girl, so now they're married, and it's her job to ensure the Weasley name doesn't die out . . . Good on her, I say."
Hermione had a rather savage look on her face; he could tell that she was immensely rankled by how events had turned out, but he was oddly, unexpectedly, rather pleased. He told himself that they were friends and his happiness was just because she was rid of a bit of bad news, but a quiet voice in the back of his mind muttered that she was available for wooing, should the need occur.
"You seem more aggravated than sad, Hermione."
Damn. Granger. Granger. Granger. I wonder if she'll notice . . .
"True – it was humiliating, but I have to admit that it was a relief. We didn't suit each other; we'd been tangled up in each other's lives for such a long time – but we couldn't find a way to end it."
Wait, did he just call me 'Hermione'?
She gave herself a mental shake and concluded, "Maybe we'll be friends again years from now, I can't say. For now I'm free to read whichever books I like and use words like 'differentiate' and 'hitherto' without being told I'm off my head . . . Well, around you, at least." She smiled cheekily up at him and his heart lurched.
Story Actions
To follow, favorite, like, and more either log in or create an account.
Leave a Review
Log in to leave a review.
Latest 25 Reviews for The Thing With Wings
89 Reviews | 4.43/10 Average
I literally just finished reading this on Ash and in my desperate search for more of your stories, I was lead to your account here. You are amazingly talented and I hope your will grant us with more of your writing in the future. Btw, I LOVE THIS STORY!!!
Response from bluewillow (Author of The Thing With Wings)
I'm sorry to say that I think this story is a one-off - I just woke up one morning with the idea of it very detailed and I knew exactly what the major twists and turns would be. I wrote like a fiend, had it beta-ed and brit-picked like crazy and then let it loose on a friendly audience. I have other friends who are real writers - they were very encouraging of me and of this effort, but I can't imagine how hard it must be to write something when you don't have that kind of clear vision of how it all must go.I promise that if I ever get another bolt out of the blue like this one, I'll write again.
Response from bluewillow (Author of The Thing With Wings)
I'm sorry to say that I think this story is a one-off - I just woke up one morning with the idea of it very detailed and I knew exactly what the major twists and turns would be. I wrote like a fiend, had it beta-ed and brit-picked like crazy and then let it loose on a friendly audience. I have other friends who are real writers - they were very encouraging of me and of this effort, but I can't imagine how hard it must be to write something when you don't have that kind of clear vision of how it all must go.I promise that if I ever get another bolt out of the blue like this one, I'll write again.
It was a lovely story. Thank you.
Response from bluewillow (Author of The Thing With Wings)
Glad you enjoyed it - thank you for the feedback!
Response from bluewillow (Author of The Thing With Wings)
Glad you enjoyed it - thank you for the feedback!
*sigh* oh, that was perfect. loved sev's to git or not to git soliliquy. thanks and mucho smoochies
Response from bluewillow (Author of The Thing With Wings)
You get halfway through your life and then suddenly something forces you to re-examine your presuppositions. It can be vertigo-inducing :)
Loved this ending! Great story! Thank you for sharing it! After finishing I read your profile and cracked up -- we could be the same person, though I'm 36. Hopefully I'll have some stuff up here soon. Thanks again!
Response from bluewillow (Author of The Thing With Wings)
I look forward to seeing your stories :)
This chapter had me laughing out loud. Bwahaha
Response from bluewillow (Author of The Thing With Wings)
Thank you! I thought it was rather clever, myself. I was snickering as I wrote it. I asked my spouse to read it and his reaction was very noncommital, so I thought perhaps it wasn't as funny as I had hoped.
Response from cmwinters (Reviewer)
Oh no! It was funny! Maybe if your spouse doesn't read HP, and doesn't know what a stick in the mud Snape is, he wouldn't understand, but Snape's comment of "I find this entire conversation offensive in the extreme" had me CRYING laughing.BWAHAHAHA
What was his objection again? ;)
Response from bluewillow (Author of The Thing With Wings)
I think he just thought the conversation was getting away from him and he was feeling huffy and unsettled.
Obviously they are at cross purposes, neither one secure enough to think the other would want a relationship. I'm glad they will continue to get to know each other, though.
Response from bluewillow (Author of The Thing With Wings)
Which one of them, do you think, is brave enough to venture forth? Don't give up hope.
Very nice, I'm looking forward to how you bring them together.
Response from bluewillow (Author of The Thing With Wings)
Glad that you're coming along for the ride :)
Looking forward to more :)
Response from bluewillow (Author of The Thing With Wings)
More is in the pipeline - Chapter 9.5 has been submitted to the queue.
Some progress at least he opened his mouth and told her she meant something to him, I'm looking forward to more of the "ice" melting.
Response from bluewillow (Author of The Thing With Wings)
It took a lot of courage for Severus to get to this point.
LOL annoying when you hear their thoughts and they care for eachother but don;t open their mouths.. Excellent descriptions of Hermiones reactions.
Response from bluewillow (Author of The Thing With Wings)
One of my friends was reading my earlier drafts and noted that there wasn't any dramatic tension. Thus - the conflict between what they mean and what they say, and what they say and what the other person hears.
These are such nice chapters of conversation and thought. I very much like the way this is developing.
Response from bluewillow (Author of The Thing With Wings)
Thank you!
Very much enjoyed their day and the Beach and their comfortable companionship
Response from bluewillow (Author of The Thing With Wings)
Discovering Rockaway Beach was one of my favorite surprises about living in NYC.
What better place to find eachother again than a book store. Thats a nice encounter.
Response from bluewillow (Author of The Thing With Wings)
I like spending my Saturdays at a bookstore, too.
:) only he would part with that remark...LOL I enjoyed their conversation and hearing his thoughts.
Response from bluewillow (Author of The Thing With Wings)
Good!
I'm really not sure if I started this already but am reading it now. Very much enjoyed the first encounter.
Response from bluewillow (Author of The Thing With Wings)
I hope you stick with it!
I like the reasons you've given them for being at Columbia. She's matured quite a lot, to be able to understand that his venomous comments are routine protection, not personal. And I love the descriptions of texture in his clothing - wonderfully evocative. In fact, I love your descriptions generally.
Response from bluewillow (Author of The Thing With Wings)
I think Hermione is a pretty reflective and perceptive person. I can see her connecting the dots. And I see Snape as having a wholely undeveloped sensual side. Long repressed.
Ooh, cerebral sexual speculation - love it! And now I wonder what Hermione was wearing. Audrey Hepburn's dress is a stroke of genius.
Response from bluewillow (Author of The Thing With Wings)
Well, if *I* had the power to make my clothes look like anything I wanted, I'd do that.
I look forward to seeing how it will play out.
Response from bluewillow (Author of The Thing With Wings)
Thanks!
He should owl her, it would be quite interesting. Or whatever you decide, actually. I am so enjoying this.
Response from bluewillow (Author of The Thing With Wings)
He's telling himself that he wants to let her figure out her path without influence from him - but really, I think, he's afraid he's imagined the whole thing, and if he approaches her she'll reject him. Such a conflicted fellow, our Severus!
stalking the wild snape with book and sandwich. sounds like a plan! great update. thanks and mucho smoochies
Response from bluewillow (Author of The Thing With Wings)
Observe the lone Snape in his natural habitat...
I can't wait for the next chapter! Very well done. The best stories are the ones in which the writing becomes pictures in my head. This is only possible with reasonably well-written stories. Awkward grammar, repetition of the same words all the time, spelling and punctuation errors tend to drive me nuts. Of course there is none of that here. So I read and I don't notice that I'm reading words because it's all in pictures in my head. Excellent!
Response from bluewillow (Author of The Thing With Wings)
*blush*Thank you! I try to write in an impressionistic manner - capturing moments in terms of how they feel, the real meat of the matter. My punctuation is not the best (commas, in particular, bedevil me), but has been ruthlessly pruned and pared by my excellent betas, and the admins of this site. I use the online thesaurus religiously in an attempt to avoid repetition, for the same reasons that you mentioned. I'm glad that it's all coming together for you!
OH Noo, poor Snape. He'll think she had a bad time, now. Silly people, so confusing. Excellent story.
Response from bluewillow (Author of The Thing With Wings)
People ARE silly. And romance is so treacherous. The whole idea of trying to communicate with our hearts in the balance, when it's clear that everyone is speaking his or her own private language with its whole lexicon of specific meaning - well, it boggles the mind.
Response from mimmom (Reviewer)
It certainly boggles my mind. I tend to be a bit of an open book, like a Gryffindor. I have to work at not blurting out whatever is in my head. I live in a house full of people who are either unable or unwilling to communicate what is in their heads. My son has asperger syndrome so isn't a great communicator. My husband has asperger tendencies so a lot of times it's a communication skills thing. But he also has Slytherin tendencies and knows how to leave out information. My daughter is very able to communicate but can choose not to divulge information if she feels it is in her own best interest. My husband and son will speak in metaphor or will finish a sentence without having started one. They forget I don't know what the beginning of the sentence was. It's pretty typical asperger stuff.
yay! That's weasley out of the way. Silly Snape slipping and calling her Hermione. LOL. Oh but things are going in a nice direction.
Response from bluewillow (Author of The Thing With Wings)
The situation with Ron seemed like something that could happen, if two people weren't well matched. Not that he's a terrible person - just that neither of their affections were particularly engaged.