Commentary
Chapter 10 of 19
KingPig***Winner of the Judge's Choice: Best Avada Kedavra in The New Library Awards 2008***
A conversation between two friends ignites a passion, if not an obsession, to uncover Severus Snape's dark and violent past.
Heed the warnings. Dark material below.
Severus Snape glowered at his apprentice as she shakily unwarded the room and opened the door for Remus and Tonks to enter. Hermione could feel the heat of his stare burning her face, but she steadfastly refused to look at him and instead focused on the advancing forms of two of her friends. "Oh! Severus, are you feeling better?" Remus asked politely, though he directed the question more at Hermione.
"I'd say he's feeling... all right," said Tonks with a slight, lop-sided grin after running her eyes up and down his figure. Hermione's eyes grew large as she turned to Tonks and quelled any further commentary with her admonishing glare. The pink-haired witch quickly covered her mouth with her hand to suppress her giggles and then shrugged at Hermione. Lupin peered quizzically at the women. Severus looked dumbstruck.
"Right..." Remus said after an uncomfortable silence. "Well, then, we've come down here to check on you both, and Hermione, there are some people upstairs who would..."
"Excuse me," growled Severus as he pushed past the group and stalked out the door. Taking the opportunity, and utterly unable to keep her quip to herself, Tonks shouted after him, "Oi, Snape, you might want to stop off at the loo to, uhm, freshen up before heading to dinner!"
Hermione didn't have a chance to make sure her withering stare hit its mark, as immediately following Tonks' comment, the Auror threw all three of them to the floor when a jet of light penetrated the room, crashing into a vacant worktable behind them. The older witch let out a barking laugh as they were all showered in sawdust and slivers of wooden debris. Her husband haltingly stood, dusting his clothes off with a frown. "Really, Dora, you shouldn't make fun of his personal appearance..." His reprimand was cut short when another series of infectious giggles erupted from the Auror. He let out a long-suffering sigh, though it lacked conviction as he was now openly grinning at her. "Right, well, let's be off then. As I was saying, Hermione, there are some people upstairs impatiently awaiting your arrival."
***
Severus Snape was easily the most challenging patient Poppy had ever had the opportunity to treat over her many years as a Healer. He routinely protested, fought, fled, growled, groused, screamed, and cursed. Once, as a child, he even bit her. In fact, the quick-tempered little boy radiated a feral energy from the first day she met him, and thus she was extremely pleased to watch him grow into a slightly more civilized man civilized, at least, when he was at full health. However, when injured or ill, Severus simply regressed to that eleven-year-old state of mind where instinct overpowered reason. This was one of those times.
The Healer had been making her way from the infirmary to the Great Hall for the Feast when she found him: a thin figure dressed in black, slumped against the barrister of the Grand Staircase, trembling violently. She had not needed to get a closer inspection to know it was the Potions master, especially since, upon noticing her, he quickly tried to spin his body around and make his way in the opposite direction. "Severus?" she prompted, but received no answer. This, of course, was expected.
Poppy rushed to the form that was now threatening to collapse, rocking dangerously from side to side. His skin was devoid of any color, much more than usual, and his pupils were dilated as his eyes flitted nervously around. "Severus, come with me," she stated in a brusque, matronly tone that brooked no argument.
Despite his seemingly weak state, he shoved her aside roughly and shook his head violently. Anticipating this, as it was his usual behavior, Poppy had braced herself firmly and showed him that she could not be deterred so easily. With a silent flick of her wand, Severus found himself prone and restrained on a conjured stretcher, struggling in vain and hissing incoherent curses with vehemence.
The Healer ignored him and led the floating stretcher to the hospital wing, taking great care to maneuver around the moving staircases and fidgeting furnishings. Speaking more to herself than to him, she scolded, "I don't know why I even bother, quite honestly. I keep hoping for the day that you will wake up and cease this mindless self-destruction! What is it this time, eh, young man? Pick a fight? Overdose on potions? I don't see any blood, so it's not a self-inflicted wound, I assume? Although, truly, they are all self-inflicted injuries, aren't they..." She rambled on even as they reached their destination, and she gently transferred the wildly thrashing man to a solid bed. "All right, you know the drill," she said wryly. "Will it be Silencio and restraints, or do you think that, for once, you can act like an adult and lie there quietly?"
He grew very still and looked up at the Healer hopefully, and though she smiled back down at him, she was not fooled. It took only a matter of seconds before he tried to stand, screaming obscenities at her as he toppled off the bed. She leaned against the wall and observed him with an eyebrow raised, watching humorlessly as he tried to crawl out of the room.
With a dramatic sigh, she said, "I see. No need to break tradition, is there?" A few delicate, wordless, flicks of the wrist, and Severus Snape was restrained on the bed, his mouth opening and closing in blissful silence.
"Yes, that's better. I'm going to administer the usual: the modified Calming Draught first, and a potion for anxiety, then we will run some diagnostics, all right?" His dark eyes glittered maliciously at her.
Poppy had long ago adopted this particular bedside manner, especially the reciting of her every action to the patient, because of this man before her. Her first time to attend to him, small child that he was, she did not bother to explain her actions, as most children at Hogwarts did not care what she would do, just so long as it worked. But for this little Slytherin, any touch on his person (especially, and understandably, when restrained and silenced) that was not given a full commentary resulted in very, very extreme panic attacks. (Although, truth be told, even when she took great care to describe her treatments, his stay in the infirmary was always punctuated with anxiety-induced complications.) Poppy had even enlisted his help to create a specialized Calming Draught to ease his stay, one she always had in stock just for him.
In fact, ever since Madam Pomfrey was first introduced to the young man, Severus Snape had provided a peculiar challenge to the Healer. Unlike most of her patients, this wizard required a special, careful treatment both psychologically as well as physiologically. His violent mood swings were tolerated, if not subtly encouraged, by Poppy. Outside these walls, she knew that he never expressed his fear or pain instead, he dissociated himself from his emotions. It was a survival technique, a coping mechanism, employed by many children that hailed from severely abusive homes. A learned response: never show weakness when threatened, shut down.
Yet, Poppy was able to somehow establish a trust between herself and the younger man over the years. With her, and only her, he allowed himself to feel, to convey his emotions to her, never fearing that she would twist the circumstances to her advantage. She supported his intuitive need to scream, curse, cower, hide, and even cry. The only action she prohibited was physical harm, especially as it was nearly always directed at himself.
It was a link, a deeply etched connection. It united them both, allowing him to know he was protected while in her care. Subconsciously, the two shared a profound, maternal relationship, something that defied speech and emotion: an impenetrable bond.
While ruminating over this, the Healer administered the potions to him and was pleasantly surprised that he drank them without resistance. Poppy waited for his body to release its tension before she rattled off her diagnostic spells, intensely focused on the colors the waves of light emitted.
She tsked tsked a few times before staring him directly in the eye and inquiring, "If I lift the Silencio, will you be calm enough to explain your injuries without resorting to idle threats?"
He shook his head.
"Fair enough." She left the small room momentarily, returning with a vial that she explained patiently, "This contains the general pain reliever." In a more cohesive state of mind, Severus would know immediately what the container held but Poppy did not want to risk any chance at unsettling him, so she quietly described every medicinal element that she used.
The Healer lifted his head slightly and pressed the potion to his lips, slightly concerned that he drank it so greedily. "I'll leave you alone for a bit, and when I return, I'll see if you feel better enough to be released from the two spells so we can continue treatment, all right?" He nodded in silent acquiescence.
*
Fifteen minutes later, Madam Pomfrey peeked in on her irascible patient. His wide, dark eyes followed her every moment as she confidently strode into the makeshift room, carrying with her a few jars of cream. He still trembled, though it was not nearly as pronounced. His eyelids drooped sleepily; his breathing was slow and steady.
"Feeling better?" she asked kindly.
He nodded in agreement and gave a lopsided smile.
"Nausea?"
He shook his head slowly.
"I'm going to check your temperature." Poppy stated as she leaned over his motionless form while casting another diagnostic charm. "You still have a fever, but it is much more mild. Ready to move and talk again?"
Another slight nod.
"You agree to the rules? No cursing, no screaming, no biting, kicking, or hitting? No harm to me, and certainly no harm to yourself? And you will stay in this bed?"
An emphatic nod this time.
"All right. There's a good lad," she said gently as she lifted the charms and gingerly perched on the edge of his bed.
He immediately sat up and laid his head in his hands, rubbing vigorously at his temples. "Headache still," he gasped out in a raspy, hoarse voice. Poppy retreated from the room and returned with another vial that Severus recognized immediately: a headache potion. He downed it in one gulp as she resumed her position, taking a seat next to him on the bed.
Severus looked around the room, taking in the present scenery for the first time since arriving. His head throbbed with growing intensity, his stomach still fluttered as the last vestiges of anxiety slowly began to dwindle. He did not want to look up at Pomfrey, did not want to see the pity in her eyes, did not want to hear platitudes from her lips. He was bested, physically, by a slip of a girl. It was beyond humiliating, beyond shameful, and pity would push him over the edge of any shred of reason he still entertained.
Yet, Snape could not help watching with trepidation as the Healer reached out to him, then asked, "Severus, mind if I adjust that hair of yours?"
He nodded and only flinched minutely when her fingers tucked a lock of his hair behind his ears. Inwardly, he berated himself for the display of weakness. Though Madam Pomfrey was one of the elite few people he allowed to touch him, and she had always respected his boundaries by asking first, a flinch was still a flinch, and there was no mistaking the irritatingly condescending compassion in her question.
"I brought in some salve for your more pressing injury, and I'll give you privacy to apply it yourself. When I return, we'll take a look at your forehead... Although, it seems that it has been partially healed already. I didn't realize that you were properly self-medicating now?"
"I'm not."
"Ah." She knew better than to question him. He always explained his injuries to her in his own time, if he felt it was necessary. She stood and smiled down at him lovingly before exiting the area, drawing the curtains closed as she left, securely ensconcing him in comfortable seclusion.
***
The dinner had ended both far too quickly and not soon enough. Hermione's head ached as the feast wore on, and she found herself too emotionally drained to truly interact with her friends. At best, she was able to smile and laugh at their recounts of their current affairs; at worst, she was unable to fully concentrate on the thread of conversation and just nodded dumbly in what she hoped were the appropriate places.
Their company soothed her frayed nerves, allowing her to fixate on the swirling, musical sounds of tinkling laughter and crescendos of heated debates and discussions that played out through the massive room. An immense, vocal symphony surrounded her, distracted her, comforted her. It was a paradox, then, when the same relaxing tones would sharply, unexpectedly, attack her senses. When the solace of her tightly knit cluster of friends suddenly sparked within her a deep, penetrating loneliness.
So it was with a mixture of relief and profound sadness that Hermione found herself in her rooms and alone once again. Her brain hurt. Her heart hurt. Her soul hurt. She didn't want to dwell on the events of that afternoon, nor did she want to revisit the wave of emotions that had assailed her when she had come to the sudden realization that Professor Snape would not be making an appearance at the dinner. Her lips broke into a small smile when she remembered the livid expression on the Headmistress's face when she reached the same conclusion.
With a long stretch, Hermione made her way to her wardrobe. Stifling a yawn, she stripped herself of the cloak, robes, sweater, skirt, shoes, and stockings (in that order) and dropped them at her feet. Leaving on the camisole, she slipped on a pair of crimson red pajama pants and made her way to the bathroom. It wasn't until she returned that she noticed the tiny box protruding from the pile of clothes. She gasped. She had completely forgotten her stolen treasure. No, not stolen, just borrowed, she assured herself.
She sat heavily down on the thickly carpeted floor, crossing her legs and leaning forward slightly to pluck the tiny shoebox from its confines. Reaching for her wand, she muttered the quick counter charm and restored the cardboard rectangle to its original size. She felt the tiny tendrils of magic wrapping around her mind, urging her to put the box down, reminding her overworked brain of uncompleted to-do lists, whispering of the allure of sleep, but she resisted. As soon as she removed the top of the box, the feelings vanished immediately.
Hermione sifted through the container, carefully avoiding the rat corpse. The first thing she pulled out was a photograph that resembled a Muggle Polaroid picture, the kind that had to be shaken vigorously before anything would appear. Peering closely at it, she could make out a tiny human form: a toddler. It appeared to be a boy, though at that age, it was difficult to tell. Especially when said child was clad only in a diaper. She had a strong feeling, however, that it was another image of a young Severus Snape. This feeling was validated as she looked at the bottom white strip of the photograph, which was labeled: "Subject: Severus Snape. Age: 3" in bubbly, feminine handwriting. Below that was something indecipherable typed in faded ink, obviously stamped on some years ago.
Puzzled, Hermione continued to stare at the unmoving image, willing it to reveal its secrets. It was in black and white, and in the background seemed to be a wall on which was painted a mural of some sort. The child sat staring off into the distance, seemingly oblivious to the small mountain of toys set before him. Squinting her eyes and bringing the picture closer, Hermione was able to make out the corner of a clipboard intruding into the photograph. Curious, she thought to herself as she laid the picture gently down on the carpet, off to the side.
She reached for another photograph: it was a magical image she retrieved, one that presented an auburn-haired young girl of around nine or ten. The girl giggled and reached for the camera, causing the scene to tilt from side to side, before a lanky boy rushed into view and sat next to her, pointing at Hermione.
A single tear traced a path down Hermione's cheek as she watched the magical loop cycle over and over again. The boy was the same child she had seen in the other pictures, and yet he wasn't, because she had never seen Severus Snape laugh so freely. She had never seen him happy. She had never seen the look of wonder and awe that crossed his face as he gazed at the girl next to him. She had never known the innocent face that stared up at her, the black eyes that hinted at playfulness. She never knew this boy; she had never seen him before.
Wrenching her eyes from the photograph, she quickly set it down and reached for another object, pulling out a crisp envelope with the broken seal of Hogwarts on the flap, and displayed across the front "Severus Snape," along with a smudged address. Hermione smiled though her tears, her heart warming to the fact that young Severus thought this letter to be a prized possession, much like she did when she received hers. Briefly reading the standard letter sent to all eleven-year-old witches and wizards and allowing herself a moment to reminisce, Hermione set the envelope and its contents carefully down beside the picture of the laughing young Lily Evans and Severus Snape.
She resumed her digging with renewed vigor, pulling out a very thumbed-through, dog-eared, paperback book. The faded cover revealed a title, Oliver Twist, in a simple black typeface. She carefully pried open the novel, inhaling as she did that beautiful musky scent that accompanies all older books. On the back of the front cover, scrawled in the poor penmanship of the very young, was written:
I am an orphan in this house. These people share only my blood, nothing more.
Hermione furrowed her brow in a mixture of despair and concentration. She flipped through the rest of the pages, looking for more notes in the margins, but found none. As she lifted it gingerly to set it aside, an object fell from a hidden spot near the end of the book.
Another photograph.
Hermione picked up the Muggle Poloroid and studied it carefully, even though her body fought valiantly to release it in disgust. It was also in black and white, portraying a tiny Severus Snape, no older than four or five. His hair had been shaved off to within a half inch of his scalp, and he was completely nude. His dark eyes bored into Hermione's, but they were shuttered, lifeless, cold, numb. Even at his young age, he looked starved, his ribs protruding frighteningly above his concave belly.
A plump, large hand was splayed across the crown of his head, nearly fitting the boy's skull into its palm, as it pushed the child forward, into the camera.
Another hand, with long, thin fingers, was between Severus' legs.
With a rising wave of nausea, Hermione threw the photo across the room, unable to examine it any further. Her body began to shake. Her mind screamed within her head, in one long sentence, Ohmygodohmygodohmygodohmygodohmygod!
With tears prickling at the edges of her vision, her stomach wrenching itself into knots, Hermione conceded defeat to the overwhelming need to distance herself from her recent discoveries. Carefully packing the box back up, she slid it deep into her wardrobe, hidden from view.
She crawled into bed, doused the lights, and after several hours of broken sobs, she fell into a fitful sleep. That night, she dreamt of the sweet, laughing, dark-haired boy...
Only to have the vision replaced by a child staring at her with eyes already dead.
Author's Note Three cheers for my amazing beta, Angel Mischa, and the awesome Amsev both of whom take time from their busy schedules to help out this struggling author. Without their combined efforts, this story would not exist.
Up Next: Childish behavior.
Story Actions
To follow, favorite, like, and more either log in or create an account.
Leave a Review
Log in to leave a review.
Latest 25 Reviews for Conversations
323 Reviews | 6.63/10 Average
Wow, what a wonderful story!I've been finding those kind of stories for a long time.Love the way you describe Snape and his horrible past.This is the first time I've ever wrote a review on a fic.Please continue with your story! :)
Response from KingPig (Author of Conversations)
Thank you so very much! I'm so honored to be the first receipient of a review from you! I know I haven't updated this story in almost a year, but my RL career has had me working overtime constantly, and I'm almost finished with my all-consuming project, and around this time next month, I should have the free time available to post the next chapter. Thank you again!
I'll say that you've continued to write wonderfully. I like your plot, and the way you protray the characters. I've happily favorited this story and hope to see it up-dated soon.
Response from KingPig (Author of Conversations)
Thank you so much! The story is on a little hiatus right now, as I have a deadline for my RL work – but in the next few weeks I should have time to come back to Conversations and update! Thank you again!
I LOVE your banner!! It looks amazing! And I really like the chapter! I hope the rest of this story is this good!
Response from KingPig (Author of Conversations)
Thank you so, so very much! I hope I don't disappoint!
Anonymous
I do love Luna. What a wonderful vehicle she is for all things wise. If you need any help with chapter 20, don't hesitate to poke me. I promise there'll be no more disappearances! ;)
Author's Response: LOL! I'd be really, really, really grateful and appreciative of any help you'd offer! Kittylefish has graciously offered to beta for me, but I can use all the help I can get! LOL.
I have all but the very beginning of chapter 20 – which may be superfluous anyway (the beginning). Not sure.
I just found this story by accident a couple of days ago. Now I see that you have not updated for months. I do hope that nothing has gone so terribly wrong in your life that you cannot finish this thrilling tale. That is a selfish attitude, I know, but it is all your fault for being such a good writer. I simply must know how Hermione wins him over and helps him to realize how precious and beautiful and special he really is. Please, please update soon. Don't abandon this exquisitly written piece of fan fiction.
Response from KingPig (Author of Conversations)
LOL, no, not a selfish attitude at all! I greatly, truly appreciate your review and encouragement! I do feel very guilty about the lack of updates, and thankfully I have no tragic excuse – I have just been extremely busy with "RL" issues regarding work, vacations, and, unfortunately, a horrible case of writer's block. However (!), I have written a bit of the next chapter, and am posting a little snippet of it on my livejournal today (I'm a bit worried that this particular section of the story might be too... fluffy, so I'm looking for some constructive criticism), which you can check, if you'd like, at http://kingpig.livejournal.com/ ... please let me know what you think if you do take a look at it, and don't mind a bit of a spoiler. Once I get it all worked out, and find a willing beta, then I should have something posted here soon. Thank you, thank you, thank you again!
I've been reading all day long to read this story in one rush and it was so, so worth it! Psychological stories are hard to write and I have to say that I love this one! Please keep going! xox
Response from KingPig (Author of Conversations)
Response from KingPig (Author of Conversations)
Thank you so much! I'm so thrilled you enjoyed it, and I agree, psychological stories are very difficult to write (and very draining) – but without at least some psychological aspect, a story can become very hard to read. I am working on the next chapter, but I am stretched a bit thin when it comes to RL occupation, RL in general, and the SBB project... plus the fact that Severus is just not cooperating :( But I am working on it, so please stay tuned, and thank you again!
Oh, welcome back! I just love having my empathy beaten up from all directions at once. Your portrayal of Snape's PTSD is so believable. I can imagine that he must feel like a accident victim brought to a trauma center to have his life saved. First you're found (by strangers), then immobilized on back board and hard collar to prevent further injury (whether or not you find it uncomfortable or claustrophobic), then you're poked and prodded and a mask put over your face. Transported who knows where. Everyone is talking at you all at once. You arrive at the ER and then they cut off all your clothes in front of God and everybody and proceed to expose you, open your wounds, clean them out with industrial solvents, manipulate your body, more needles but no pain meds, blinding lights, a whole cacophony of incomprehensible sound, and no control, no say in what is being done, nowhere to hide, no way to escape. And all the while, they say they are helping and you're supposed to believe them. **small animal sounds of distress**Hermione will need every bit of her very old soul's experience to help this terribly battered hero with the new soul to learn that there really is love in the world for him. Bravissima. Please continue.
Response from KingPig (Author of Conversations)
I absolutely adore your review, and I don't think I could ever apologize enough for my response being so late. *hangs head in shame* I'm very, very sorry!I love the analogy as well, as I never really thought about it in that context, although I had quite a similiar experience! (On top of all that you described, my little sister had witnessed the car accident, and because they put me on a board with the collar, she called my mom and told her I was paralyzed, then she called my grandmother to say I was dead. She was only ten, and I 16, so you can imagine my surprise when I was wheeled out into the lobby in a wheelchair, with only superficial wounds and one cut needing a paltry three stitches, and my entire family – including some I had never before met – greeted me with tear stained faces and the expression as though they were looking at a ghost. I fear most of them were disappointed I didn't at least break a bone, LOL!)And I agree that Hermione will need to draw on her wisdom-beyond-her-age reserves, but she'll also have a few issues of her own, in regards to emotional maturity, so it probably become a "blind leading the blind" scenario for a small bit.Thank you, thank you, and thank you some more! I don't know when the next chapter will be posted, but I am spending what little free time I can to devote to it! Please stay tuned!
Minerva must have a lot of grief on hr plate. She made some serious mistakes with Severus over the years. Hopefully he will be willing to try to let her make amends.
Response from KingPig (Author of Conversations)
Thank you so much for the review! Yes, I believe Minerva is just now realizing the magnitude of her and AD's past behavior. I think Severus may be feeling as though it's really convenient, that MM and RL and PP suddenly want to apologize, now that the damage is done and was ignored for so long. But, that's not to say that Severus will completely shut her, them, out.Thank you again!
Yay! I'm glad you're back!This is a great story, gripping and intense, though I found difficult to read sometimes.A lot of authors who go high on angst can't portray their characters as -well- f#cked up enough for what they've allegedly been through - your Snape is a stellar exception!It's chilling to watch him vacillate between the persona of the controlled Professor and that of a wounded child. You make it all psychologically believable - great job!My only worry is how on earth will he be capable of forming any sort of functioning relationship with Hermione.You DO have "romance" listed in genre tags for that story, albeit at the very end - is that how long we'll have to wait to see some lovin'?Do you have this story mapped out, or do you write as it unfolds for you? (I think I've read in one of your Author's Notes that it started off as one-shot. Sorry if I got it wrong, I seldom notice A/N's when on a reading binge.)Good luck in all your RL exploits, may nothing distract you from updating ASAP!Thank you for a great evening!
Response from KingPig (Author of Conversations)
Thank you so, so much! Although it can be very difficult indeed, I'm so thrilled that you stay with it. And I very, very greatly appreciate your comment about my characterization of Snape as a realistic survivor of intense trauma. I often feel, because I'm my own worst critic, that I'm not truly conveying the gravity of his circumstances, so a review like yours means so, so much to me! I also share your concern over how he and Hermione will be able to form a healthy relationship – I know it will happen, as that's the true plot and original direction of the story, but <i>how</i> and how long it will take is a little worrisome, I admit. I do know that it is possible, as I write some of his childhood directly from my own experience, and I have found and formed a healthy relationship with my husband – it just took a while to do. And, also, I sadly don't have this story really mapped out, there was no outline – you are correct, it did just start as a one-shot, and I'm letting the story write itself. Which may upset some readers, because I have no idea how long this story will be, or exactly what obstacles it will contain, and I have a feeling people can tell that it's unfolding as it goes... mostly because, to me, it seems to jump around a lot, and there are a few scenes that have yet to be really explained (what Minerva saw when she walked into his room that made him so angry, what Hermione will do with the shoebox of mementos, what kind of potion Severus was about to drink before his fight with Remus...). Sorry to make this response such an epic novel in and of itself, but I really appreciate your insightful review, and I wanted to reply to it with the respectful explanation that it is due. Thank you so, so much again! Chapter 20 is in the process of being written as we speak!
“I bet this is a strange world to him.” Luna is so remarkably perceptive! And I do hope she is right about Hermione's ability to help this poor, tortured, brave soul.I think it may be a testimony to his courage that he did not become a true psychopath, that he did what he was driven to do yet still did not break into a thousand pieces.And good for Minerva trying to get through to him, telling him of her own shame and shortcomings, as well as of her love. He may never truly believe it, but his confusion suggests that perhaps he might be able to at least know that she believes it.Who is Patsy communicating so carefully with? And how will they use the knowledge of Severus' role in the family tragedy?Fascinating!
Response from KingPig (Author of Conversations)
Thank you so much! In regards to the Luna comment, I'm really relieved that you enjoyed it. Their entire dialogue (HG and LL) was something I wasn't sure of including, even up to the point of clicking "submit." It was in constant risk of being cut, and I'm so glad that you liked it!As for Minerva and Pansy, I can't really elaborate on that just yet, as it's central to the upcoming chapters, but I don't think you'll be disappointed! Thank you again, your reviews are always delightful!
This was a most interesting chapter!! I loved the 'discussion' between Luna and Hermione. Luna always has such a deep understanding of life. I think her 'knowing' always leaves people a little confused. What really surprised me was the whole bit on Pansy's letter writing. It made me laugh as it is basically the same way I write things. The rewriting, the editing, the careful scanning to make sure it says only what I want it to say... it was funny to see my own unconscious process under a new light.I was also very taken with Minerva's heart-felt speech to Severus. "And every time you proved your intense loyalty, your passionate veracity, your inherent Light that shines so blindingly bright, it casts pale shadows over all the others I had ever perceived as heroes – every time, Severus, I would stand in awe..." - Oh Yes! That is our Severus.
Response from KingPig (Author of Conversations)
Thank you! I'm so relieved to hear that you enjoyed the scene with Luna and Hermione – it very nearly ended up on the cutting room floor. Even after it was submitted, I was very uncertain about it.LOL, yay, another person who writes things with such a neurotic process as Pansy and I do! I'm really bad about it, for because of this, it takes me forever to even type out a text message. And I see tones and inflections in emails, texts, etc., so people are always confused when I call them and say, "What did I do to make you so disappointed/angry/sad/etc?" They're like, "Wha?" and I say, "You used '...' after [insert word here], which could only mean you were slightly annoyed/uncertain/etc." It drives my friends, family, and especially my husband insane. And I'm thrilled that you enjoyed Minerva's speech to Severus, it was, admittedly, my favorite piece to write in this chapter. Thank you again!
this has to be one of the darkest fics i've ever read. but phenominally well written. everyone failed severus, everyone. and your story shows that perfectly. thanks so much and i await the next chapter.
Response from KingPig (Author of Conversations)
Thank you so much! The next chapter is currently in the works, but has been delayed due to a recent death of a family member as well as current job deadlines looming over my head. I hope to have something up in the next few weeks, please stay tuned!
well, the idea of young snape having to take matters into his hands that way is fairly disturbing, and pansy sending off that article with her letter is of concern. perhaps minerva's words will somehow get through to him. very dense and complex chapter.
Response from KingPig (Author of Conversations)
Thank you so very much! Things are starting to come together, and the next chapter is in the works!
Can't wait for the next chapter! Plese don't make it too long! I've just discovered your story and I really appreciate its psychological depth. But I have to confess that so far, I really don't see how Severus and Hermione could end up together. Not that I don't want them to! Snape seems to be a "hopeless" case. But I trust you to make it credible:)
Response from KingPig (Author of Conversations)
Thank you so much! I know it seems bleak for our heroes, but love often pops up in the most unexpected, even inappropriate, times. I can say it won't be all roses and rainbows – but have faith... love may not be able to heal <i>all</i>, but it can still heal.Thank you again! The next chapter is in the works, but may be delayed due to a recent death in my family in addition to a looming job deadline. I do, often, give updates to the story's progress on my livejournal – my LJ name is kingpig (I'd post the link but I don't know if I'm allowed to...)
okay, so Pansy might just be caught in a bad situation and not really doing something wicked, although she knows she needs to be careful. Minerva has finally communicated to Severus, and I hope she sticks with her intentions. the article Pansy found is heart-wrenching, and I can see a small Severus always regretting that he didn't act soon enough to save his mother's life. stupid wizarding world had no Dept of Social Services to care for wizarding orphans and maltreated kids! Dumbledore was not a good parent-figure to anyone.thank you for the new chapter, and thanks to Sonia and shellsnapeluver for stepping in to help you!
Response from KingPig (Author of Conversations)
Thank you so much! I agree, a Wizarding equivalent of a Dept. of Social Services is desperately needed – hopefully, in the future, Hermione will be able to remedy that. :)
I usually can't read stories that involve abuse and rape, but your writing manages to do that in such a touching manner that I find myself helplessly reading it all in one go. Thank you for such a powerful chapter.
Response from KingPig (Author of Conversations)
Thank you for such a wonderful review! I do apologize that it has taken this long to respond, RL has really caught up with me these last few months.RL as in real life, not Remus Lupin, lol. Just for my own clarification.
Response from KingPig (Author of Conversations)
Thank you for such a wonderful review! I do apologize that it has taken this long to respond, RL has really caught up with me these last few months.RL as in real life, not Remus Lupin, lol. Just for my own clarification.
Just re-read this wonderful tale, well as much as you have written, and am eagerly awaiting your next chapter...
Loves you, Sonia :)
Response from KingPig (Author of Conversations)
Thank you so much! I dearly appreciate your reviews. I did write a little of the next chapter, and it is turning out to be pretty dark. Grrrrr, I can't wait until things start to look up. Did you have a chance to go over the SS/HG x-change stories I sent? Did they send okay? I ask because the last time you replied to my email I didn't get it, only your message on LJ. If you haven't had a chance, I totally understand!
Response from sbrande (Reviewer)
No I went through it that night and wrote you back a lengthy reply as well as beta'ed it.
Damn it... Did you get either of them back??? I am VERY reliable and if I say I will do something I do. Shite a brick, I think I deleted it too. Please re-send.
I think you should go with the second one as the Zombie one will be too complex, unless you want to write like the wind. I like the Zombie one better for plot, but I think you will receive more reviews for the other one as that is what people want... NOT ME.
Love Sonia :)
Response from KingPig (Author of Conversations)
Aaaw :( I'm so sorry. For some reason, it seems as though I can't receive emails from you, but I can send them to you. I'll give you another email addy to try (kingpig@mac.com) when I resend you the files. I didn't mean to imply that you didn't do it, just that I'm afraid I can't receive emails from you, or that perhaps you are a little busy. I agree with what you said, and I will probably go with the first prompt (though I'm afraid to state either here, as the prompter may be reading the reviews...). It is less complex, but I really would have loved to do the, uh, more interesting one. But I agree, it is something that does not lend itself to a short story format – it is something I'd like to explore in depth. So, I'll do the the prompt that most people might want to read, and then after the exchange, I'll probably write the more interesting prompt in a chaptered format, dedicate and credit the idea to the prompter, and probably ask permission to write it. I'll resend!
Response from sbrande (Reviewer)
Okay. Have just woken up. Am feeding the dogs and then the kids are next however, I shall get right on it.
love Sonia :)
Response from KingPig (Author of Conversations)
Thank you so much! I dearly appreciate your reviews. I did write a little of the next chapter, and it is turning out to be pretty dark. Grrrrr, I can't wait until things start to look up. Did you have a chance to go over the SS/HG x-change stories I sent? Did they send okay? I ask because the last time you replied to my email I didn't get it, only your message on LJ. If you haven't had a chance, I totally understand!
Response from sbrande (Reviewer)
No I went through it that night and wrote you back a lengthy reply as well as beta'ed it.
Damn it... Did you get either of them back??? I am VERY reliable and if I say I will do something I do. Shite a brick, I think I deleted it too. Please re-send.
I think you should go with the second one as the Zombie one will be too complex, unless you want to write like the wind. I like the Zombie one better for plot, but I think you will receive more reviews for the other one as that is what people want... NOT ME.
Love Sonia :)
Response from KingPig (Author of Conversations)
Aaaw :( I'm so sorry. For some reason, it seems as though I can't receive emails from you, but I can send them to you. I'll give you another email addy to try (kingpig@mac.com) when I resend you the files. I didn't mean to imply that you didn't do it, just that I'm afraid I can't receive emails from you, or that perhaps you are a little busy. I agree with what you said, and I will probably go with the first prompt (though I'm afraid to state either here, as the prompter may be reading the reviews...). It is less complex, but I really would have loved to do the, uh, more interesting one. But I agree, it is something that does not lend itself to a short story format – it is something I'd like to explore in depth. So, I'll do the the prompt that most people might want to read, and then after the exchange, I'll probably write the more interesting prompt in a chaptered format, dedicate and credit the idea to the prompter, and probably ask permission to write it. I'll resend!
Response from sbrande (Reviewer)
Okay. Have just woken up. Am feeding the dogs and then the kids are next however, I shall get right on it.
love Sonia :)
Hey Babe,
I am going to read this wonderful story again now. Just read the first chapter because I love it so very much.
Love Sonia :)
Response from KingPig (Author of Conversations)
LOL oh no! If you read it all from the beginning, all the plot holes will become obvious!! *ducks*
Response from sbrande (Reviewer)
No, because it is not complete yet. If it were complete then sure there would be a whole heap of plot holes ;)
Love Sonia :)
Response from KingPig (Author of Conversations)
LOL I need to remember to fill those holes at some point...
Response from KingPig (Author of Conversations)
LOL oh no! If you read it all from the beginning, all the plot holes will become obvious!! *ducks*
Response from sbrande (Reviewer)
No, because it is not complete yet. If it were complete then sure there would be a whole heap of plot holes ;)
Love Sonia :)
Response from KingPig (Author of Conversations)
LOL I need to remember to fill those holes at some point...
Uh oh. So many intriguing questions! What is Pansy's role in all this (and it's interesting to see her reluctance); Hermione's decidedly odd not-Hermione'ish dream certainly explains her sleeping through the disturbance Pansy caused.I really liked Poppy here. Her concern for Severus feels achingly real.
Response from KingPig (Author of Conversations)
Thank you so much for the thoughtful, encouraging review! I very much enjoyed writing Poppy's scene, and I felt very saddened that I have to write him leaving like that, which only ramps up her anxiety and concern to new levels. I hope she'll forgive me.Thank you again!
I enjoyed Poppy the most in this chapter. Her concern made the chapter for me.
Response from KingPig (Author of Conversations)
Oh, I am so glad you enjoyed that! It was very cathartic to write Poppy's scene, in a way. Thank you for the thoughtful review!
Ah so, the precious, precious shoebox and its contents have once again been "found." Hermione still seems to be tangled in Severus' most intimate memories. Is he in any way tangled in hers? And Pansy Malfoy ne Parkinson, a woman who feels scorned by everyone, presented with such an "opportunity"... What will she do with it? I wonder what happens when someone hands a beyond-Hades fury a monkey wrench? Welcome back.
Response from KingPig (Author of Conversations)
Thank you so much for this thoughtful review! Unfortunately, I'm not quite "back" yet... I will try really hard to update before Feb 1st, but as that is my newest work deadline, I can't make any promises. But I'll try! And, though it'll be explained more in coming chapters, I'll go ahead and answer at least one of your questions... No, Severus is in no way entangled in Hermione's memories. It's a one-way phenomenon. Thank you again!
The dream Hermione is having is quite interesting!
Response from KingPig (Author of Conversations)
Thank you for the review! I'll be able to explain the dream more fully in the coming chapters.
Another tantalyzing chapter, filled with more questions than answers (that is not a criticism!).Poppy's concern is very touching, while Severus' near-catatonia is frightening. And what in heaven's name is Pansy up to, and at whose behest? (I know you've warned of a not-at-all-nice LM, so I'm assuming he's part of it, but part of what, I wonder?) That letter (and the box it came from) should be interesting--what is it doing there?And what's with that funky, odd dream? Who is dreaming, and how do Hermione and Severus get so mixed together, and in Lily's presence?SO many questions! Hope you have time to give us more soon--this is a dark and twisty tale, and I am hooked!
Response from KingPig (Author of Conversations)
LOL, thank you so much!! I just adore your reviews! I had a lot of fun writing Poppy in this chapter, and I think if she had her way, she would have showed up at his doorstep intending to spend the next two weeks with him, 24/7.As for the dream, it will be explained in depth a little more later, but I'll try and clarify it a bit for you now. It's not quite so much a dream as it is one of Severus' memories, inexplicibly (for now, and did I even spell that right?) connecting her and Severus like a long-distance, unconscious Legilimency... thing. Heh. I promise, it will all become clear (...eventually)!I will try really hard to update before Feb 1st, but as that is my newest work deadline, I can't make any promises. But I'll try!
(blinks...) wha??? I need more, please!!! what did Pansy find, are Lucius-Cissa-Draco part of the thing she's in, who is masterminding the thing that Pansy is in, what is the meaning of Hermione's dream?? at least I know Severus is able to get about on his own, and he prolly feels "safe" at Spinner's End. I will cross my fingers for you to finish your yourdeadline! thanks for updating.
Response from KingPig (Author of Conversations)
Thank you so much for this wonderful review! I really, really want to answer your questions right here in this response, but then I know it will take all the fun of discovery out of it. I will try really hard to update before Feb 1st, but as that is my newest work deadline, I can't make any promises. But I'll try!
so happy to see the update! and i do hope it won't be so long until the next, as what a place you've left off! i shudder to think of pansy seeing what's in that box - poor snape has already been violated enough. plus, not knowing what her agenda is, it worries me. anyway, i am still really enjoying this story. happy holidays and good luck with the work stuff. and i hope rl lets up soon so we can hear more from you on this story!
Response from KingPig (Author of Conversations)
Thank you so much for the thoughtful review! I do have a work deadline of Feb 1st, so I can't promise an update until after that date, but I will work really hard to try!