New Chapter for Beyond All Doubt
Beyond All Doubt
dolefully desired682 Reviews | 7.59/10 (682 Ratings, 0 Likes, 482 Favorites )
An unusual request by the Wizengamot leads Hermione to witness a side of her professor she never imagined could be real.
Start ReadingChapters (18)
About dolefully desired
Author
dolefully desired
Member Since 2007 | 3 Stories | Favorited by 102 | 4 Reviews Written | 99 Review Responses
University student and science geek, 20, who spends far too much time reading fanfiction and far too little time focusing on future career.
Reviews for Beyond All Doubt
Amazing story! I saw this over at Ashwinder, and having become quickly addicted, had to find if it was posted elsewhere! Thankfully, I found it here, and am so glad I did! What a great, great story. You depicted Severus as remarkably human, and this story literally took my breath away. Fantastic work!
This story was absolutely wonderful!!! I'm so glad to see everyone had a happy ending, especially Hermione and Severus. I really loved this story, and I'm really glad to have had the chance to read it.
I agonized at considerable length over this scene, as it is the first extended explicit sexual content I've written. I'm hoping that after so much miserable waiting on Hermione's part, everyone is satisfied by the conclusion. :)
Erm, yes. I'll just be needing a cold shower now. ;-)
I already wonder if I've carried it too far beyond my original outline, but I hope that you've enjoyed what I've opted to do.
Obviously I don't know what your original outline was, but I do like where you've gone with it and don't feel like you stretched it too far or anything. I've enjoyed the ride thoroughly.
Much as I'd rather this story not end yet, I understand that you have to stop somewhere. Am I satisfied? Yes. Great job!
I do want to congratulate you on the achievement that is this story - your Severus and Hermione are remarkably _real_ and their interactions complex. I am glad to see them intimate (grin) but I do wish you had shown their first time together and maybe a bit of the conflict that would have marked their initial months. Given the buildup of their relationship and the troubles they had to overcome, as well as the complicated nature of SS's sexuality, it would have been an even stronger story had you shown how those issues were worked through. (I'm glad to know that all of H's friends are happy, but this chapter was almost more about them!) I hope you will keep writing as your style and character development are excellent.
Response from dolefully desired (Author of Beyond All Doubt)
I would like to have written more, but I will be busy with classes and research this summer and would have had little time to update. I think everyone reading it would have been disappointed with the extreme delays and/or hiatus.
Response from missblue (Reviewer)
Fair enough (being a grad student I do appreciate the other demands)...it's always a dilemma when you're pulled in several directions.
I think you did a fantastic job. I love the ending, it seems just right.
I loved the end. Not really what I had pictured in my mind- it was even better. Thank you for writing this story and being constant in your updates. Thank you also for the time and effort you took writing this great work.
Congratulations for the great story! 5 stars for this is certainly not good enough but it will have to do.
Sincerely,
Response from dolefully desired (Author of Beyond All Doubt)
Thank you very much for your story. I really like how you wrote the character of Severus. We can never really know what he is thinking, which is a lot like real life. We can only speculate based on his words and actions. I think you wove those words and actions together in a way that always made it a guessing game as to how he was truly feeling about Hermione. Frustrating for her but very intriguing for us. Like everyone else I am glad the characters find some peace in your last chapter. Thanks for the happy ending.
This was a beautiful story. Thank you
Fantastic ending to a great story...
Ahh! Its finished? Already? That was a nice ride though, thank you for sharing it with us. I thoroughly enjoyed it. Hope we get to see more from your pen. As always... Cheers!
The forbidden, illicit thoughts, persistence, love and passion are elements in many stories. However, it is the way they are combined and twisted and embellished that makes for an interesting read. I thought your story was very unusual and I thoroughly enjoyed the read.
Response from dolefully desired (Author of Beyond All Doubt)
Thank you! :) I'm glad you've enjoyed it.
This was definitely an incredibly fulfilling conclusion, and absolutely lovely story overall. Perfect has been stated before, but I think the appellation bears repetition. It sounds a bit overeffusive, perhaps, but it really is true! Thanks for putting your talents to use here; hope to read more from you in the future!
Response from dolefully desired (Author of Beyond All Doubt)
Thank you! :) That was incredibly kind of you. I hope to write another story, but as of yet I have no concrete plans. I'm happy to hear you've enjoyed it!
This has been great - a good tale well told. Thank you!
All in all, I like this ending. It actually annoys me somewhat when people stretch out the story they're writing far beyond the place where it should've ended. I find that I lose interest if it goes on for too long—if events keep being tacked onto the story even though the plot itself has already been wrapped up.
Congratulations for having written a thoroughly interesting story—and for knowing when to stop.
Response from dolefully desired (Author of Beyond All Doubt)
Thank you! I'm relieved to know that at least some people agree with me that it was time to wrap it up. I'm glad you've enjoyed it. :)
I think that was the perfect ending.
The chapter was beautifully done, lighthearted and quite an ending. Thank you so much for sharing this lovely gem. Good luck with your Finals!
Response from dolefully desired (Author of Beyond All Doubt)
Thank you! I really appreciate all the great reviews you've left me! I'm glad you've enjoyed the story. :)
I think that you found the perfect ending to a perfect story. I have actually read a lot of stories but this one is one that I will definitely remember! It was beautiful to read and I really enjoyed the time I spend with it. Thanks a lot for sharing this with us!Kisses
Response from dolefully desired (Author of Beyond All Doubt)
Response from dolefully desired (Author of Beyond All Doubt)
You're very welcome. :) Thank you so much for the kind reviews!
Great happy ending. I enjoyed reading their journey together. I thought you did a great job of bringing the characters from a very dark place in the beginning of the story to mutual acceptance and love at the end. Beautiful. Thank you!
Aw, and it's a perfect place to end. You've given your audience the little smut-biscuit they've asked for, allowed us to get a glimpse of them in social occasions, humoured us with the account of them living together, and made an all-around delightful work.Good job!
Response from dolefully desired (Author of Beyond All Doubt)
Thank you! :)
It was a perfect ending! I was so glad to see what happened but I hated for the story to be over. Now what will you write next?
Now this is a hell of ending and fitting one at that. By far one of top HG/SS stories i have read this week. Ranks 2 of being my favorites.
Nice finish. You brought the story around to a nice fullness. Your conclusion seemed to fit. You provided enough scope of time to see that they make a good couple and have made peace with their pasts and acceptance of family and friends. Good going. I look forward to reading more of your work. Thanks, JoAnne
I think you picked a wonderful point to end the story. Thank you, I've enjoyed it very much.
I enjoyed your story very much and thank you for the happy ending. [Real life has enough misery in it.] I've been disappointed a bit lately, so I particularly thank you for the unequivocally happy ending here. Thanks for your work -- I'll be looking for more!