New Chapter for Regrets
Regrets
RachelW9 Reviews | 3.0/10 (9 Ratings, 0 Likes, 0 Favorites )
Chapters (1)
About RachelW
Author
RachelW
Member Since 2005 | 6 Stories | Favorited by 106 | 2 Reviews Written | 46 Review Responses
Reviews for Regrets
I have often thought that with Polyjuice and other means there must be some people hidden or lost, who can never come back. This brought tears to my eyes and I am ever so cynical normally.
Hmm I've seen this theory before, and it's an interesting one simply because I don't think cannon ever delt with Snape's family. I kind of feel sorry for her though, maybe after the war peace can be found.
Oh poor thing. That must be ever so painful... Hopefully our favorite Potions Master will live at the end of DH so he can be reunited with his mum...
Nice story.One mistake though, in book 5 it says that Snape has been teaching 14 years so at this moment it could never be 17 years. The man already was a very young teacher when he started, your timeline would have him teaching almost out of school himself, no time to become a master in any field.And indeed, bittersweet story that this is, it has no bushy haired favorite character of mine, thus should not be up on potions under duress.But again, very nice story.
Response from RachelW (Author of Regrets)
Hmm, I double checked on the Harry-Potter Lexicon and it said he'd been Potions Master from 1980 to 1996... and then another year as DADA teacher. Lexicon is considered a reliable sourse, but I'll try checking elsewhere. Also, completion of NEWTs would qualify him to be a potions master. 'Master' in the British system being synonymous with 'teacher'. Also according to the Lexicon, he finished his NEWTs in the summer of 76. I've changed the category... I should have double-checked the category meanings, and had been thinking that 'Potions Under Dures' was the Snape category. It's now in 'Hogwarts Castle' where it belongs.
Nice little drabble. Finally someone who agrees with me there seems to be something fishy about Madam Pince...
A wonderful telling of one of my favorite pet theories going around. Great job!
That was very well written. Also, the story line is original and clever.
Response from RachelW (Author of Regrets)
Thanks! As for origonality, it's one of those theories that's been kicking around for a while and that I've read about in multiple places... this is just a fictioalised snippet of one possibility of the theory is true. :-)
Very interesting take. I like stories about minor characters--it's novel. But, how is this a "potions under duress" story--they are suppossed to be SS/HG.
Response from RachelW (Author of Regrets)
Whoops, I thought that was for Severus Snape category. I'll go change it right away.
A nice take on the theory that Pince is Severus mother.