Chapter 2
Chapter 2 of 2
AuretteSeverus Snape dressed for his wedding with care. The brief ceremony was to be at the Ministry, and only McGonagall was to witness. Granger had informed him that her horrified parents had agreed that this was no wedding to celebrate and honored her wishes that they not attend. They did send their profuse thanks for his timely intervention and invited them to dinner. Snape had declined the invitation with an overlong scowl and a raised eyebrow. Taking a last, long look at himself in the mirror, he limped out of his rooms.
He made his way slowly up the stairs to the Entrance Hall, where he met his bride and her bridesmaid. He took a moment to study her. The bloodshot eyes and swollen nose, together with the unkempt hair, and even her school robes, created the perfect simulacrum of the horrified virgin going to her doom. He couldn't help the resentful thought that it wasn't all show. She gave him a brave smile, trembling lip and all.
"Severus, you look remarkably unappealing. And I must say the stink of Firewhisky is a nice touch," Minerva said. "You look every inch a young girl's worst nightmare. Well done. Shall we go?"
He nodded and signed to Granger. Wait until the last moment. The toad will expect a show.
"I will," she replied. "If I didn't think the symbolism would be lost on the toad, I'd rub ashes in my hair."
I thought you already had, he signed. Granger burst out into a sharp, angry laugh.
"You're in mourning, Miss Granger," said Minerva with a tsk. "Don't ruin all our work with inappropriate giggling on your wedding day; that would just be bad form."
Snape gave her a courteous nod as he walked past her towards the door. The Headmistress followed.
They walked down the lane in silence. She didn't speak until they were almost to the gate.
"I think this is a wonderful thing you're doing, Severus. And what you did for Harry. He and Miss Weasley will be very happy. And now Miss Granger will be safe until she can be with the one she really loves. I'm dying to know how Malfoy convinced Umbridge that ruining Potter's life would be political suicide and that giving Miss Granger to you would be revenge enough." She gave him a proud smile. "One of these days, I will have to learn this sign language you use. I will try over the summer."
As they stopped at the Apparition marker, he turned to her and mouthed: "Don't bother."
She blinked at him, trying to understand what he was saying, but he just looked away. She grabbed his elbow, and they disappeared with a crack.
Severus Snape hunched down on the floor of his shower and let the scalding water beat at him. The nerve damage reduced sensation, so it was only the bright pink of his skin that showed he should have been uncomfortable. He sat with his arms wrapped around his knees and watched the water swirl into the drain around his feet. The one was still slightly twisted from the damage caused by the snake venom, but the other was now straight and narrow. There was no denying the improvement. Perhaps, over time, they would both be straight. Perhaps not. What did it matter? No one was ever going to see his feet anyway. He had stopped submitting himself to Pomfrey's intrusive examinations.
He closed his eyes and dropped his head onto his knees as his mind replayed images of the day. The look of horror on the bride's face as she entered the Ministry office, the look of malicious glee on the face of Umbridge as she granted him permission to kiss his bride. Mostly, he replayed his own feigned brutality as he claimed her lips with his own, the look of disgust on her face and the way she shuddered as she wiped her mouth on her sleeve. He couldn't help the twisted grimace every time his mind wondered if she knew it was an act.
Severus Snape packed up his belongings. The school year had ended. The students were gone. Granger had won accolades for her improvement on the potion for nerve damage and had started her work at St. Mungo's this morning. He hadn't seen her in over a week. She had decided to spend a week with her parents before starting her new job. He assumed she needed a break to adjust to her new life as a working member of society. He didn't know for sure; she hadn't spoken to him in two weeks, not since she had screeched her frustration for anyone in the dungeons to hear and tore her hands through her hair before stomping off to her bedroom and slamming the door.
"Did you want me to shrink the wardrobe as is? Or will you be leaving that as well?"
Snape pulled his mind out of his thoughts and turned to Flitwick, who had graciously offered to help. He shook his head and gestured to a box before pulling his clothes off the hangers and piling them on the bed to fold. Filius had been tactful in allowing him to do what he could without insisting charms would be faster. The act of packing his things by hand was not only meditative but dragged out the time until he would finally walk out that gate and move to Spinner's End.
"I do hope that you will come and visit often, Severus. I have enjoyed our chess matches very much these last few months and will be sorely tested to find a more pleasant way to spend a Friday evening."
Snape smiled and made an ambiguous gesture that could be taken for agreement, but didn't tie him in to any definite plans. He had no intention of ever returning.
"I'll just send these off and come back for the last, shall I?"
Snape nodded. He emptied his drawers and closed up the boxes in quiet solitude that would have looked peaceful to an observer. But behind his eyes he heard Granger yelling at him in frustration.
"But why? Don't just stand there and stare like a git, sign, write, use the blackboard. It took me enough effort to drag it into our rooms, damn it!"
"Snape, you have to take it! I made it for you! It works! I don't understand! Is it because I didn't try to fix your voice first? Is that it? I will! I'll work on that next!"
"It's for your own good! You need it! I've watched you, Snape. I've seen you injure yourself because you couldn't tell something was hot or cold! If we can improve the nerves, you will get some dexterity back, you will be able to use more of your magic! Merlin, you could even be able to enjoy a nice wank once in a while!"
"Alright, you're a grown man. Surely you have your reasons. Explain them to me. Why on earth would you refuse to take my potion? Please. I want to understand. I need to understand. Don't just walk away from me, Snape! It's because I made it, isn't it. All this time I thought you were proud of my work, but you don't trust it do you? Come back here! Damn you!Talk to me!"
As he made one last turn through his quarters, leaning heavily on his cane, as he peeked into Granger's rooms, seeing nothing more than the stripped mattress and emptiness, as he looked at the bare walls that had been both the bars of his prison and the protective membrane of his cocoon, he heard the frustrated screech and the slamming of a door in an endlessly repeating cycle. Had he been capable of making a sound, the emptiness would have been filled with the sound of his sadness. As it was, his breath hissed out through his teeth.
Severus Snape jumped in surprise when his Floo activated. He was standing in the middle of his sitting room, wondering how he was going to move all these boxes and crates, when behind him the flames grew with a sudden whoosh and turned green. He watched in apprehension, pulling his wand and hoping he could at least make a decent showing of himself if it were an enemy coming through. When he saw the bushy hair in the flames, he cried out. Not that anyone could tell. He stood straighter as she came through and stopped before him, nervously brushing off her robes with her lip caught in her teeth.
He slid his wand up his sleeve and rested his cane against a box, managing to keep his balance without leaning against anything. His head was jangling with all the questions he had. Why was she here? Will she stay? Has she forgiven me? Does she understand? Has she eaten well? She looks thin...
How was work? Tea?
In the end, he decided to just go on as they had been. They were not a real couple that needed to work out their issues.
She smiled at him. She closed her eyes and took a deep breath and when she opened them, she smiled at him.
"I would love some tea, Severus. Mum sends her regards, and I have a lemon cake she made for you. Let me grab my things." She flitted back through the Floo with a shout, and he dug through the box of food from the Hogwarts larder that had been a gift from Minerva..."So you have something to eat while you unpack."...and grabbed up a tin of tea and some sugar. After stuffing them in his pockets, he grabbed some milk as well. He picked up his cane and hurried to see what state his kitchen was in after all this time.
Severus Snape had learned he could dust things. His silent Evanesco was so pathetic that all it removed was dust. He limped through his house dusting everything and anything he could reach in every room but one. He wouldn't go in there. He couldn't go in there. He had slept in that room as a boy, but it hadn't been his in more years than he could count. Now it was hers. He wanted to go in there very much, and so he refused.
He heard the sound of the Floo and turned and hurried down the stairs. She hadn't said anything about coming home for lunch when she had left this morning, and he was worried he had made an error. Part of him was sickened at his craven desire to keep track of her and the way he had been reduced to little more than a housekeeper, but the chit was all he had, and it was only natural that he would obsess a little over his only source of interaction.
He found her in the sitting room crying on the couch. He stopped and stared, utterly out of his element. Finally, he limped over and sat down heavily next to her on the faded couch and handed her his handkerchief. She took it with a muttered thank you, but couldn't get a hold of herself.
He looked over at the blackboard she had wrangled from Hogwarts with Minerva's blessing. It dominated the tiny room, even though it was the smallest one in the school. He flicked his wand and then tapped her and pointed to it.
Tell me what's wrong.
She burst into a fresh round of sobbing, and he ground his teeth together.
Did you lose your job?
Gods, he hoped not. His little pension and savings wouldn't keep them both for very long. He would have to sell his book collection. That was his real fortune.
"No. No, I didn't lose my job. The job's fine. Great, even." She mopped her face and sniffled. "I saw Ron. We met for lunch in a Muggle place a few blocks from St. Mungo's."
And?
"His... wife, she drugged him. She was a little tired of his disability and took matters into her own hands. She drugged his food. He..." She broke down again and twisted, planting her face against his shoulder. "He woke up naked in bed with her. He didn't remember anything. He's sick and scared he might have got her pregnant."
No. The potion you provide would have protected him from that if he's taken it within two weeks. It can be overcome with anything containing Ashwinder eggs soaked in fermented Foy Bean, but potency takes longer to come back. He's safe from that at least.
When she twisted her head and read his words, Granger sagged against him in relief and started a fresh wave of tears. He sat back against the couch and pulled her into his arms and patted her shoulder. It was a singular experience. He'd had to console the occasional Slytherin in his care before, but he couldn't remember a time he held a grown witch and tried to soothe her misery.
We could brew him something to counter what she gave him, but she will try something else, and we risk poisoning the boy.
She sniffed and nodded. "You should have seen him, Severus. He looked like he would have rather been poisoned. It was so awful." He rocked her gently.
He was violated. It's to be expected he would be upset. Be there for him. It will make a difference.
She pushed out of his arms. "I'm so sorry to have dumped this on you. I just couldn't go back to work."
He nodded his understanding and then signed, Tea?
"Yes, tea would be lovely. I'll make it. It will give me something to do."
He nodded and watched her push herself off the couch and as she walked away he thought: But what does that leave me to do?
Severus Snape had dinner ready when she came home from work and hated that fact. He read and he puttered and he tidied and he stared at the clock, waiting for hours until it was time to perform the only useful task he could do. Make dinner. There were days when she'd had a late lunch and wasn't hungry, and he thought he would take his cane and smash everything within reach. He never did. She never knew. She would usually come back later and heat it up with a wave of her wand and then come find him to tell him how much she appreciated it.
He wanted to not give a damn about her. He couldn't.
There were times when he hated her. When Weasley would show up, sneaking in the door or dashing through the Floo, and he gushed his appreciation for the care Snape took with 'his girl.' Snape would nod and turn away, nose buried in a journal, and pretend he didn't care as they slipped off to that room he never went in. Mercifully, he didn't show up often, just once a month when he needed more potion. On those nights when it was too quiet, signaling the presence of a Silencing Charm, when Snape would shut out the lights in his room and strip out of his clothes in the dark, when he would lie down in his cold and lonely bed, on those nights he hated her with such a passion it would have scorched the world had he been able to physically show it.
But he still gave a damn.
Severus Snape ate alone in his room. He had made dinner, a precise six minutes early, and then had filled a plate and taken it upstairs to his room to eat alone. He had taken to doing this several nights a week in an effort to show he had some dignity. He wasn't sure whom he wanted to show it to, her or himself. After all, he always made sure he took his plate up to his room before she came home. She always looked at him with a question when he returned to the kitchen with his plate later to find her loitering over her meal. It was as if she couldn't remember how to eat if he wasn't there.
But tonight was different. Tonight, he had set his plate on his little, round table and had sat and placed his cane just so, and had just placed his napkin across his lap when he was disturbed by a knock on the door. He sat and blinked. The sound echoed strangely through the room, and it occurred to him that no one had ever knocked on that door. Ever. Not in his lifetime at least. He had never heard that particular noise before. He was completely confused. He hated to be confused. He stood up, and in reaching to catch the falling napkin, he knocked his cane to the floor. He hissed, a noise he could make easily but indulged in rarely, and simply shuffled to the door with a hand out to grab the knob. He turned it and opened the door, leaning heavily on the knob.
"Snape, I know you were looking for privacy, but I have something I wish to discuss with you if it's not too bad a time. I need to make a decision by tomorrow, and I want to give you as much time as you need to think it over, since it concerns you."
He blinked again and then felt the cold hand claw at his gut. He stepped back, hanging onto the door for support and gestured to his chair. He hadn't realized he had closed his eyes until he felt something brush at his hand and opened them to see her offering him his cane. He snatched it and then limped away from her when she was seated, he sat on the corner of his bed and gave her the short sharp upward jerk of his chin that had meant 'start talking' for over a year now.
"I need a lab partner at work. I've had two so far, and I can't find the rhythm of working with them; they either try to dominate the work or are so timid in their approach they make me want to scream. The Head brewer told me to go ahead and bring in my own rather than have them go about trying to find a suitable candidate and, well, I want you."
He stared at her and damned himself for the flush he could feel crawling across his face. He tilted his head down and let his hair hide it.
Go on.
"You and I work well together. You don't need to do the actual brewing; I can do that. It's the millions of other little things that I know you can do. If there's anything you have difficulty with, I know you can just tell me. Don't think I haven't noticed the perfectly diced cucumber or the garlic cloves pressed with the side of a knife, Snape. I know you've been honing your skills, and I know we would be a perfect team. We flow together, and your mind and experience are wasted in this house. Even if we are a team less efficient than we could be, you and I together would be a hell of a lot better than the people they have there. You won't believe the inefficiency. It's mind boggling." She stood up and smoothed her hands against her sides. "Well, I've stated my case. I will leave you to think about it. But they want me to present them with a few candidates tomorrow, and I wanted to give you the option to think about it."
He stopped her with a gesture and then signed: When did they tell you to find your own?
"Late this afternoon. About an hour ago."
And they want your candidates tomorrow morning?
"Yes."
Why are they setting you up to fail?
She looked down at her shoes. "Because I make them look bad." He hissed through his teeth, and after she saw he was laughing, she smiled her brilliant smile.
I told you I overtrained you.
"So, you did," she said with a laugh. "Now enjoy your dinner, Snape. I'm going to go stuff myself; it smells delicious. Let me know your decision in the morning."
The next morning found him standing impatiently by the Floo, tapping his cane against the flagstones.
Severus Snape and Hermione Granger worked together with the ease that comes with practice and familiarity as well as that intuition that comes with knowing the other's strengths and weaknesses like their own. Snape gathered the needed ingredients from the storeroom, and while he needed to make more trips, he still managed to save time by getting the correct items the first time.
Granger left him all of the paperwork and half of the prep. He lined up what she needed, just before she needed it, and they managed to brew at least three potions at a time on the average, and a tap on her back with his cane warned her if she was about to make a mistake.
Their immediate supervisors, maliciously inclined to find amusement in the odd married couple at first, eventually accepted and even praised the team. The hospital apothecary was full of praise for the stream of potions coming in. The efficiency was almost as welcome as the efficacy.
It was the other brewers that were resentful. They produced capable potions but in twice the time and with twice the waste. They watched covertly while they sweated and snapped at their own ever-changing stream of assistants. When Granger left the room, they seemed to forget that Snape was only mute and not deaf as well, and he was treated to all of their petty resentments and salacious speculation on what the two of them must be like in bed.
Granger always pestered him in sign when she would return to find him grinding his teeth. He just looked away.
Severus Snape entered the sitting room quietly. He found his young wife on her knees with her head stuck in the green flames, conversing with someone he couldn't see, because of the wild mass of curls she called hair.
"I know, Gin. But he's cut himself off from everyone. I'm all he has," she said with a heavy sigh.
He couldn't help himself. He backed into a shadow near the door and continued to listen.
"No. He's strong. He's unbelievably strong despite what he's been through and what has been done to him." She paused to listen to whatever Potter's wife was saying. "I do. But I'm not just saying that. My feelings for him aren't confused. I'm as sure about them as I've ever been about anything in my life. I love him."
Snape couldn't help the nearly painful banging of his heart as it slipped free and raced.
"I will be there for him. I will see him through. I will never abandon him. Snape said he would need support, but it has to come in his own time. Until then, I will just be there for him in whatever way he needs me. This can't go on forever. Eventually we will both be free, and then I can spend the rest of my life putting him back together. I think quitting is fine. Working for George is a positive sign to me. It means he's doing something for himself, and that is miles ahead of where he was at two months ago."
Snape staggered back out of the room. 'Fool!' he shouted in his head, still hearing his former baritone. He stumbled up the stairs to his room and closed the door silently before sinking to the floor and screaming like an injured child. No one heard his wails, no one ever had.
Severus Snape was the first to understand the pattern. Orders for various antidotes and blood replenisher had tripled over the last two weeks, and the brewers were speculating on what the cause of the sudden spike was. Even Granger seemed confused.
"Any theories, Snape?" she asked as she took the bowl of mashed toad livers from his hand.
He turned to her and signed.
Check the papers. The obituaries report most of the deceased were recently married. They are killing themselves. The recent brides, the reluctant grooms. They are starting to despair that the Ministry won't save them. We are treating the ones that were unsuccessful.
Granger's eyes flew wide, and she grabbed at his arm in panic and pain, and he tried to soothe her.
He has you to live for, girl. Don't be afraid.
Snape turned away from her and began chopping daisy roots with a vengeance.
She placed her hand on his arm. "Thank you," she whispered. "I'm so glad I had you to save me. I will forever be grateful and in your debt. Her eyes were brimming with tears, and her face was full of emotion. "The Ministry will save us. Don't despair. I know you will be free of me soon."
As you say, he replied. He turned away and would look at her no more for the rest of the day.
Severus Snape read the letters to the editor with a grim heart. The scandal had broken, and the people were in an outrage at the fate of those swept up in the Marriage Law. Occasionally, some romantic story of a reluctant couple finding true love was slipped in, but the tide of opinion had turned, and the readers were having no part of any attempt to paint it in even a neutral light. Umbridge had fled the Ministry in disgrace, as her manifold petty revenges had come to light.
The Minister's repeal of the law was on the fast track and gaining momentum with each day. Granger bounced around, not even aware that her happiness was seeping from every pore. Snape listened to her quiet, gentle humming as she cleaned up the dishes from breakfast. He wanted to rail at her to stop, but found himself hanging on every note. He folded the paper and left the room, grabbing up a bottle on the way.
Sunday, he never left his room at all. She never knocked.
Monday morning he was standing straight and tall at the Floo, waiting. She came into the room with a worried frown and an inquiry about his health, but he just turned away from her and waited for the Floo to be activated so he could go through.
Severus Snape was at his bench chopping when the news came. Brought by the brewers who had watched them so intently for the last nine months, trying to understand the strange dynamic between the two. He knew bets had been made on whether or not they would split or stay together, and so as the news spread, work stopped to see their reaction. Severus bunched his shoulders as the storm broke over them, and Granger let out a strangled sob of relief and then flung herself at her husband. They all wandered away confused as he held her, shaking and sobbing and occasionally laughing, in his arms with his face frozen into stone and his hands patting uselessly at her shoulders.
Severus Snape dressed for his divorce with care. He wore his best robes and had shined his boots to a high gloss. He combed his hair and brushed his teeth and fixed his cuffs and donned his best cloak. After all, there was to be a wedding immediately following.
He waited by the Floo and blinked as the bride entered the sitting room. She was dressed simply in a white dress under her cloak of blood red. Her hair was carefully arranged into glossy ringlets that cascaded down her narrow back. She stopped and stared sadly, tears in her eyes, as she looked around her temporary home for the last time. She took a deep breath and came and stood at his side.
"Thank you, Severus. For everything. I can't tell you how much you have meant to me. It seems there's no way to express it. Our situation has been so strange. But thank you for taking me under your wing, into your life and into your home. Without you, I could have been one of those names in the paper. You are a great friend, and I will always love you for what you have done for me and Ron and for Harry and Ginny." She swiped at her tears and gave a small, self-deprecating laugh. "It's not like I won't see you tomorrow. I'll be right back here in the morning to bring you to work, after all. And you're probably looking forward to not having me underfoot all the time. It's just that... I'm going to miss being underfoot all the time, you know?"
She looked up at him with her beautiful, honey-colored eyes, and he nodded. Then, with slow, cautious movements, as if his hands were ready to flee at any moment, he touched his fingers to her face and bent down and gave her a chaste kiss in reply. Her eyes flew wide, and she blinked rapidly before gracing him with a warm smile and giving him a second, quick kiss.
As she turned toward the Floo and tossed in the powder, just after she called out their destination, he saw her touch her lips, and a small look of wonder slipped across her features.
Severus Snape followed his ex-wife out the door of one room and over to the knot of people gathered before the doors of another. The happy chatter and exuberant smiles accompanied many hearty slaps on the back and the enthusiastic and rather emotional hugs from Minerva, Molly Weasley and Helen Granger. Ronald Weasley had handed his bride a fistful of daisies, and after kissing her passionately, to the applause and catcalls of the assembled, he had turned toward Snape and proudly signed his gratitude with his hands. Granger broke into a beatific smile, and Snape extended a hand and accepted his gratitude with austere graciousness.
When the short ceremony was over, the boisterous crowd moved swiftly out into the hall and set off for the Floos, ready for the party at the Burrow. Severus Snape looked down and saw a single daisy, crushed underfoot and lost. He bent down and plucked it from the floor and took a moment to try and straighten its bent and crippled petals. Two of them came off in his hand and he frowned. When he looked up again, everyone was gone and the Floos were silent. He stood there, staring around him, unable to leave on his own. The blushing bride had stepped lightly towards her future with nary a glance back.
Eventually, he found a custodian and handed him a scrap of parchment he'd found and scrawled on. The gentleman was only too happy to assist, and Snape bowed courteously as he stepped into the flames.
Hermione Weasley looked around again and worried at her bottom lip as the party shifted into full swing and everyone was shouting and laughing. She smiled at the guests and laughed at their jokes and repeatedly gave in to the demands for another kiss for the bride and groom, but through it all she searched and waited and searched again until finally the worry became too much. Her new husband came over to her side, and after a few quick questions, he made their excuses and pulled her over to the Floo.
The Floo in the sitting room activated, and she stumbled into the room in frantic haste. Her husband followed in her wake with an equal concern. Her eyes caught the letter on the table first, and she cried out when she read the name on the envelope.
"Who's Esmeralda?" Ron asked in confusion.
She tore the envelope open, and when Ron saw the last will and testament it contained, he took off running through the house. Hermione's hands shook as she looked for more, a letter, an explanation that he had gone on vacation or emigrated to Canada. Anything. Anything at all.
Ron gave a horrified shout, and she flew across the room and raced up the stairs. Ron came running out of her former bedroom and grabbed her and pushed her back. "Don't! You don't want to see..."
She slapped him aside with a strength she didn't know she possessed, but when she ran into the room, he grabbed her from behind and held her tight.
Severus Snape lay sprawled across her bed, dressed in his finest robes; his limp hair fanned out around him. In one hand he clutched a tattered daisy, the other was open, and on the floor beneath it, an empty vial and his cane.
She screamed. She screamed for hours. And even years later, deep inside, where no one could hear, she still screamed.
Thank you to Astopperindeath, Clairvoyant, and especially windwings, for the beautiful art.
Story Actions
To follow, favorite, like, and more either log in or create an account.
Leave a Review
Log in to leave a review.
Latest 25 Reviews for The Tattered Man
51 Reviews | 5.61/10 Average
"Severus Snape dressed for his wedding with care... Severus Snape dressed for his divorce with care." Ach, this is so painful to read. The hopelessness and impotence, no magic, no voice... then to be forced to celebrate his ability to dust? The desolation of the empty rooms, and Ron in the background, and going through with a farce of a marriage ceremony, walking through the motions of a real marriage when he's in love with her and has to deny himself while watching her act out her disgust at his kiss, wondering if her horror is real or feigned? Then, the glimmer of hope in the fact that HE SAW HER TOUCH HER LIPS IN WONDER? That we know now that she's beginning to become aware of him and that, hypothetically, he's recognised that she might feel something for him? To have it all taken away? My heart broke at 'Who's Esmeralda?' Broke.This is so lovely and so terrible. I think I need to go hug a puppy now.
Response from Aurette (Author of The Tattered Man)
*hugs* Just in case no puppy as near.Thank you.
I am shaken. What a beautiful story.Real drama about a real man. Oh my! Our dear Prof. Congratulations
Response from Aurette (Author of The Tattered Man)
Thank you so very much!
Good Lord! This is HEARTBREAKING!! So he loves her, and now he will be married to her for two years and not be able to consumate the marriage? Or will he?... If his toes moved in the bath, who knows what else might improve.And if she falls in love with him in this state, he would know beyond doubt that she will love him if he makes a full recovery some day.This is a brilliant story. I can't wait for more.
Response from Aurette (Author of The Tattered Man)
I was really reluctant to reply to reviews until Chapter two dropped. The tale is complete now. Thank you for this comment.
What a wonderful beginning; my heart is just breaking for Snape. Though, I know you've forewarned this is supposed to be an angst filled, sad tale, I hoping that only pertains to Ron and Hermione and not for Snape and Hermione. Either way, I am waiting for Chapter 2.
Response from Aurette (Author of The Tattered Man)
Keep the tissues nearby... Thank you for your review.
This is a wonderful beginning. Keep up the good work. i am eager to see where you take this. ^_^
Response from Aurette (Author of The Tattered Man)
This one is taken to a dark place... Thank you for your review.
Q uite the story. It prsents a crippled person in such a manner that his affliction can be felt, but no pity is felt for him.
Response from Aurette (Author of The Tattered Man)
Only his own... Thank you for this review!
OMG, I'm totally speechless. Up until the very end I had been in denial... wondering how you'd turn this around. You didn't! And the story is so incredibly powerful and unique because of it. I can imagine how hard it must have been to write - well done for going through with it.My initial reaction was "no way - he wouldn't do that!" But I think you're right and he might. How utterly sad and desolate. It's almost worse than if he had died in the Shrieking Shack, having to suffer through pain, humiliation and unrequited love all over again.You are an amazing writer, and this story is perfectly crafted. It left a deep impression on me.
Response from Aurette (Author of The Tattered Man)
This story was incredibly hard to write, but it wanted to be written, and in the end, it still is the one I am the most proud of. I thank you, deeply, for your review.
I'm literally sitting here sobbing. Actually weeping. I can't tell you how much this story affected me.
Response from Aurette (Author of The Tattered Man)
I'm sorry, I only saw this review now. I am very grateful you took the time to share your feelings with me, and wish I saw this sooner. *hugs*
Response from magicalpresence (Reviewer)
Aw that's okay. I still can't get over this! It was so sad! (It's probably not helping that a person I knew killed himself not that long ago. But I would have been sobbing anyway. Your words are powerful :)
Response from Aurette (Author of The Tattered Man)
I will admit that someone I cared for had died recently when I wrote this. I pulled out a prompt I'd been hiding from and I think I did my best to try and make the world feel my pain.
Response from magicalpresence (Reviewer)
It totally worked!
Response from Aurette (Author of The Tattered Man)
Thank you!
My face is currently like this: :O I can feel the tears already, and from the warnings I had a feeling they're going to come in floods. Beautiful writing, so incredibly tragic. I'll probably have to find a parody fic after this one hehe.
Response from Aurette (Author of The Tattered Man)
I lost it at the ant. It was rough...
This story was perfect! Not that I want Snape to die, it just fit so perfectly. Another beautifully written story. I only cried when he had to as for help getting home after the divorce....
Response from Aurette (Author of The Tattered Man)
*hugs* THis one was hard to write, but I am very proud of it.
Response from Aurette (Author of The Tattered Man)
*hugs* THis one was hard to write, but I am very proud of it.
OMG!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!Well, you did give a warning, but dear god in heaven, what a horrifying little tale this is!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! And it all rings so true, so sad, so, well, yes: tragic.Brilliant, my dear. Utterly, utterly brilliant.And windwings' art is perfect.
Response from Aurette (Author of The Tattered Man)
Thank you! I was really blown away by Windwing's art. It is so awesome.
Oh, this is suddenly heartbreaking! (Not that a permanently mute, nerve-damaged Severus isn't already, but now it really hurts. God, you write beautifully!)
Response from Aurette (Author of The Tattered Man)
It is...
Wow! This was so painful that partway through this chapter, my mind started making up automatic defenses. I started thinking, "Oh, it's okay; I don't have to be sad, because this is just a story. Everyone knows the REAL truth is that he spoke up and she stayed married to him and he took the damn potion [GORGEOUS touch, by the way, her project] and they found happiness." Or "...threesome with Ron." *snrt* My mind went pretty far afield to deny this story, even while I was reading it!I loved, loved, loved the opening line of this chapter. And then how you started the subsequent paragraphs the same way. Gorgeous stuff. Really gorgeous. I started laughing inappropriately when she touched her hand to her lips after the kiss. Give us that last glimpse of hope before you KILL IT ALL, why don't you, Author?! Hurts too much. Ow.Thank you. For me to lose it and be unable to read this story straightforwardly -- that ought to tell you that the story worked for me. My condolences for your loss.
Response from Aurette (Author of The Tattered Man)
It was really very difficult to write the end for me. I didn't want it. I kept thinking, right up to the last paragraph, that I would balk. I didn't. I think it's a much better piece for all that...
Wow. I have wanted -- for AGES -- an SSHG story in which Snape survives the war but can't speak! Are you in my head??? How do you know and write, so beautifully, the things I want to read and feel? Thank goodness for the chalkboard. I was about to scream with sympathy for the frustrated man. Thank you, too, for not Ron-bashing. It's too easy. I like the decency with which he came and gave his brief thanks.
Response from Aurette (Author of The Tattered Man)
I think it would be almost logical, after the way they described his injuries after the sanke, that he would have difficulty speaking. But so few people ever do this. I think I've done it twoce now. Maybe three times, I lose track.
The time i began to read your little fanfiction, I didn't thought that someone, in this case you, can write everything to be needed in a story with only two chapters. But you can, you have done it and I love it, although it made me nearly cry.You described the situation so wonderful, you catched Severus feeling in a way, I comprehend that he killed himself thinking perhaps I would do the same in his situation. On the other hand I want to slap him in his face for what he has done. Thanks for writing. Best wishes
Response from Aurette (Author of The Tattered Man)
Response from Aurette (Author of The Tattered Man)
I'm glad you were touched by my story. That means a lot to me. Thank you for your review.
wow. super moving. you've written a truly heart-wrenching tale. though I didnt want to see the end coming, it couldn't have ended any other way.thank you for your time and effort
Response from Aurette (Author of The Tattered Man)
Thank you so much. It was difficult to write, and yet at the same time, pretty much wrote itself. I'm glad it has been appreciated!
This is the best MLC fic I have read since Tyger tyger, it is so deep and heartbreaking in it's intensity that it challenges the canon Snape for depth of written character. Thank you for sharing your story .
Response from Aurette (Author of The Tattered Man)
It was certainly an odd take on the MLC. I was asked to write one, and thought everything had already been said about them. Then I just came flying in on a tangent and twisted it inside out.
Exquisite. Although the ending was sad, it fitted the story perfectly. :)
Response from Aurette (Author of The Tattered Man)
Thank you. The ending was wretched, and I almost choked, but that was what I intended, and I had to go there.
Anonymous
Brilliant story. Enjoyed it very much.
Author's Response: Thank you very much!
oh my..devastingly sadshe must blame herself in the end.Why did he write Esmerelda?i think i missed iti enjoyed your storyi kept hoping she would form feelings for Sev
Response from Aurette (Author of The Tattered Man)
Thank you for your review. As for the name on the envelope... In Victor Hugo's story The Hunchback of Notre Dame, the deformed Quasimodo was in love with the beautiful Esmeralda, a compassionate and kind Gypsy girl. Hermione knew Snape called himself Quasimodo. By calling her Esmeralda, he was admitting that he was in love with her.
You've heard my thoughts on this story several times already, but I'll comment again.This is such a poignant and bittersweet story and the way Severus allegories himself with the crushed daisy is still so vivid and beautifully fitting to him in this story.His death affected Hermione more than she thought it would judging by her screams. In the end their screams and torment became intermingled and equally unheard.You gave Severus a more visually poignant and meaningful death than JKR. Thank you (again) for sharing!
Response from Aurette (Author of The Tattered Man)
Thank you (again) for your wonderful words. I am thrilled that you enjoy my work so much. It means a lot.
The building of their relationship is believable and so very basic. Thank you for (finally) posting this story here!
Response from Aurette (Author of The Tattered Man)
They will all be posted here, eventually. I promise. ;-)
Half of me desperately wanted it to be a happy ending - and the other half admits, very very reluctantly, that you were right. And that this was where it was going. Dammit.I could feel his helplessness, and his anger. Very nicely done.
Response from Aurette (Author of The Tattered Man)
Thank you. I think what is the most frustrating, is that it *didn't* have to end this way.
This story is still haunting (and bringing tears to my eyes each time I thought about it) me one full day after I read it.Heartbreakingly beautiful but cruel...
Response from Aurette (Author of The Tattered Man)
I understand. This one stayed with me for weeks.