New Chapter for Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping
Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping
diabolica34 Reviews | 3.24/10 (34 Ratings, 0 Likes, 19 Favorites )
The most convincing lies come dressed in layers of truth; the best-kept secrets hide themselves in a thicket of public knowledge, blending in so well as to become invisible. Caught between the Ministry and the Dark Lord, Narcissa Malfoy must choose her alliances carefully.
Start ReadingChapters (5)
About diabolica
Author
diabolica
Member Since 2009 | 11 Stories | Favorited by 18 | 28 Reviews Written | 90 Review Responses
Malfoy fangirl. Sometime fanwriter. Slytherclaw.
Reviews for Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping
This tale is breathtaking! You've taken a criminally under-developed character and turned her into something fierce, flawed, and utterly magnificent! It should be canon; it fills the gaps by telling the story from the "otherside" and shows the shades of gray within the Dark Side. I love the complex yet rather beautiful relationship that Lucius, Narcissa, and Severus share, and the oddly poignant relationship between Narcissa and her sister. Absolutely magnificent!
Response from diabolica (Author of Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping)
Thank you so much! This review made my day. I agree that Narcissa was criminally underdeveloped in canon, but then again, that's what makes her such fun for me to write. ;) Upon exploring her relationships, I realised what a complex character she is and I'm ever so pleased that you felt the complexity came through.
Wonderful story... such an inspiring, empowered, captivating Narcissa - thank you for all of your intricate, beautiful work! Along with everything else, I love her last line and the last moment/imagery is so perfect! Again, brilliant work!
Response from diabolica (Author of Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping)
Thank you so much for all your thoughtful feedback on this story! I like to think of Narcissa as being very capable--smart, loyal and utterly Slytherin. I'm so pleased to know you found her inspiring. :) :) :)As for the last two paragraphs, my beta AmyLouise deserves a lot of credit there, as she nudged me to give the story a more satisfying wrap-up. She inspired me to do my best.Your comments have been so fun to read and so generous. Thanks again!
Thank you for the breathtaking, intimate scenes between Lucius and Narcissa... Hoorah for Draco! So glad that his better sense got the best of him to cover for his mother against Bella. I don't why, but I was on the border of tears with the healing scene between Severus and Lucius and Narcissa; such deep loyalty, care and friendship, unspoken and powerful (actions speak louder than words..?) Can really feel the tension of the war atmosphere as the end draws near. reading on...
Response from diabolica (Author of Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping)
Thank you! I'm so pleased that you noted the strong ties of loyalty that bind Snape and the Malfoys. I feel they were each other's best allies in this situation, despite the complications Narcissa and Snape have created for themselves, for all of them, at this point in the story. That loyalty is ultimately what (could have) saved them all. It's lovely to read your thoughts on this!
Dare I write: yummy, juicy, brilliant?! Absolutely! Delightful twists: Lucius not coming out, an honest Ministry official (?), Bella being blatantly Bella, and of course the delectable scenes with Severus... and the last line! Wow!
Response from diabolica (Author of Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping)
*blushes furiously* Thank you so much!Your review touched on the things I worked hardest to achieve with this chapter: the twists, the careful laying of groundwork, the slow build of attraction. I'm so pleased you enjoyed!
Really wonderful chapter - especially the scene between Severus and Narcissa. The relationship and characterisation of Narcissa and Bellatrix is captured so well; moments of touching sentiment, with the photographs; seeing Bella through Narcissa's eyes, that before the Dementor's, there were memories of joy and happiness in her life, other than the mad, sadistic existence she solely exists in after Azkaban. Looking forward to reading on!
Response from diabolica (Author of Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping)
Thank you! The scene between Narcissa and Severus is the first one I wrote for this story. I had a very clear idea of his agenda in going to see her, of their conversation. As you can see, things quickly spiralled out of control from there. ;)Thanks as well for sharing your thoughts on Narcissa's relationship with Bellatrix. Bella's such an unsympathetic character in canon, but once she must have had a good quality or two. I'm glad that comes across.
Brilliant work! I am so very intrigued and love your Narcissa; she's so intelligent, passionate - such strength and determination to endure, along with maintaining her (and the family's) dignity. 'Then he asked her a question that brushed her heart with nimble fingers until it found the bruise and pressed' - so achingly lovely writing. Thank you! Reading on to catch up with the rest of the chapter!
Response from diabolica (Author of Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping)
Thank you very much for this generous review! I'm more than a little in love with Narcissa as a character, so I'm thrilled that you noted those positive qualities in her. I hope you enjoy the rest of the story!
Oh my that was good. What a wonderful way to make a horrible day much better. Thank you!
Response from diabolica (Author of Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping)
Thanks! It's lovely to know this story brightened your day.
wow. this is an incredible cool and complex story. I love it.
Response from diabolica (Author of Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping)
How kind of you to say. ;) I'm very pleased to know you enjoyed it. Thanks!
this is a really, really good piece of writing.
Response from diabolica (Author of Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping)
Thank you so much!
Fabulous! Of course, I expected nothing less after the last 4 chapters, and you really tied the whole thing up so beautifully while still leaving an opening for these characters to continue roaming around in my head. I love that.I also love that you saved Severus. That *she* saved Severus. And how, in many ways, they saved each other.While the ending is pure poetry, it's the beginning of this chapter that is really my favorite part. Clever and evocative wording tie the present moment into every moment preceeding it, while also throwing Narcissa back into that light of grace and style and magical prowress that one expects of a Malfoy in ordinary circumstances while she is facing a situation that is anything but ordinary.You really made me like her. Not just like, but stand in awe of her. Really, really, really well done :)
Response from diabolica (Author of Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping)
Do you hear the squee? Do you? *twirls you*Thank you, honey, for sharing your thoughts on this last part. I am so grateful you gave this fic a chance and found something you liked in it and, moreover, that you have been so generous in your comments. I'm very pleased that you enjoyed the opening scene and that the ending worked for you. The cooperation among these characters was very important for me; their loyalties really demanded that they help each other through.Also, I had to save Snape; it was so unfair of JKR to kill him just at the point where he might have been able to free himself for good. And, further, Narcissa couldn't just let that go; she had to intervene, and I let her 'cos, you know, she can be pretty scary when she wants. ;) But more than anything, I'm just so honoured to receive comments like these from someone whose writing I respect so much. *blushes furiously* Thank you.
Great chapter. One thing I always wonder why Draco sudden didn’t trust Snape in HBP. The simple explanation was that he wasn’t sure who he was loyal to, but I like a juicer story, like the one you are giving us.
I also wonder where you are going with Bella. The part where she keeps forgetting things makes me wonder.
Response from diabolica (Author of Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping)
Thanks! I imagine Draco feels his father's absence quite keenly and thus would be very protective of his mother during this time. So naturally, he would question Snape's motives--and not in a particularly diplomatic way. (Plus it made the story a little juicier. ;) )As for Bella, I'd hate to spoil the fun. Good to know I've raised your curiosity, though. Thanks for sharing your thoughts on this chapter!
I came here via the_new_library. What a wonderful first chapter.
“‘Don’t tell me your sons haven’t got a similar stash. Or have they got only one magazine to share among them all?’”
I couldn’t help but laugh when I read this. I like how you portray Arthur, especially with this line.
“‘We can bring you in any time, you know. There’s plenty of room in Azkaban for your sort.’”
I look forward to reading more.
Response from diabolica (Author of Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping)
Many thanks for your very thoughtful review!Arthur Weasley. He's so kind and bumbling in canon, because we only see him through Harry's eyes. But you know he hates the Malfoys, so I let my imagination have a bit of fun with him. ;)I hope you'll keep reading and that you'll enjoy the next parts. Thanks again for commenting!
You've taken treachery, malice and violence, and woven from them an unexpectedly beautiful and even gentle tale. Excellently done. Congratulations.
Response from diabolica (Author of Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping)
Thank you! I'm so happy you've continued reading. You're very right that this situation is rife with treachery, malice and violence, but there's loyalty, too. (Well, and an awful lot of denial.) Happy to know the result pleases. Thanks again!
Again, I am utterly wowwed. So much wonderfully drawn imagery, I really am getting the sense of being in every room with them, seeing what they're seeing and feeling what they're feeling.Just curious ... how close do you plan to stay with canon? Also, I am so sad to see how few reviews this amazing piece of work is getting. I hope it's doing better elsewhere and that you won't let the lack of reader response discourage you. This is honestly one of the best HP fanfics I've ever read.
Response from diabolica (Author of Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping)
Many thanks, again, for your super encouraging review, dear! I'm so happy to know you enjoyed this part. As for how close I'm planning to stay to canon--put it this way, Part V will be ever-so-slightly AU, but if you turn your head and squint, you could still theoretically call it canon-compliant. ;)You know, I'm sure there are many stories on TPP that have got more reviews. I'm new to fandom, and I'm not very well known. But the reviews I have got for this piece, like yours, have been so thoughtful. I'm grateful for every one. I wrote this more for my own edification, without thinking about readers' responses. In fact, I'm very encouraged by the response I've had here.Please feel free to tell your friends about it, though! This story won't be everyone's cup of tea; it deals with some ugly ugly issues. But if you've found it worthwhile, it's likely that others who share your interests would like it too, don't you think?
Response from slasher454 (Reviewer)
I'm perfectly happy with going AU, but think that the fact that this fits in so well with canon gives it a special dimention. In some ways it's easier to stick with canon events, and some ways it's much, much harder. Since so much of the Malfoy's story is left up to the imagination in canon, and Narcissa's in particular, I've had a great time watching you color it all in. And I think you can easily go AU without losing me at this point. I'm completely hooked!
As for reviews ... well, I can't help but notice that SS/HG is king here. Actually, they used to be my OTP, but ironically this archive along with a few others have drown it out with a multitude of really terrible stories -- ridiculously AU and OOC stories that would really have been better as original fiction, except for the fact that most of them are hardly even original.
Oh dear, that sound so b!tchy! I don't want to trash people who bravely put their work out there. It's the people who eat it up with such relish, rec them everywhere, and ignor really interesting and well written stories like yours that frustrate me so.I wrote a little ss/hg story and posted it to ff.net last year. It's definitely not my best piece of work, riddled with errors and cliches, and I honestly cringe every time I see a review/favorite story alert for it in my inbox. And, of course, the stories I'm really proud of get hardly any notice at all because they are not ss/hg. Cest la vie. As you say, we authors must write first to please ourselves. After all, at least then we can be assured of making at least one person happy! I'm going to rec your story at The New Library on LiveJournal. It's a great little comm for pimping new/under appreicated authors and stories. I hope others there will derive as much pleasure from your story as I have, and that you'll get some more well deserved reviews.
Response from diabolica (Author of Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping)
You're on LJ? *runs off to friend* I just got an LJ recently; hope you don't mind me friending you! You've been so kind, really, and it's lovely to discuss writing with others.Canon-compliance can be a real challenge, but it's one I really enjoyed with this fic. I was so curious about what might have happened at Malfoy Manor during HBP and DH, all the things we never saw in canon. I couldn't find a story that gave me that experience, so I decided to write it myself. I'm happy with the result of my scribblings, and if others like it too, that's fantastic. It's quite rewarding to know this story spoke to you, even if you're not typically interested in Narcissa. I'm more than a little in love with her (is it horribly obvious?), so I'm not very impartial. ;)
I would be very honoured if you saw fit to rec this story, hon! These characters and their lives are so close to my heart that I would love to give them a wider audience--not to get the reviews per se (although feedback is love), but just to find others like yourself with whom to discuss. Thanks for your very generous offer.
Response from slasher454 (Reviewer)
community.livejournal.com/the_new_libraryYou are offically recced! And, of course, I'd love to be LJ friends, though I must warn you that I'm terrible about updating my own journal. I go by paya27 :)
This story really is excellent. Well done. You write so beautifully, and your doing a superb job of painting complex, detailed characterisations. Congratuations.
Response from diabolica (Author of Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping)
Thank you! I'm so happy to know you found these characters well-drawn. I really appreciate the feedback!
Well-crafted, clever story. I'm loving it!
Response from diabolica (Author of Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping)
Thanks! There are two more parts to come. I hope you'll keep reading!
Response from snapesbeatrice (Reviewer)
Oh, definitely! I'll be looking for more of your stories, too.
Oh wow. This is simply brilliant. The best fanfic I've read in quite some time. I'm almost jumping out of my seat.The relationship between Bellatrix and Narcissa is wonderfully complex and achingly sad. Bella and her madness, her glutenous greed for pleasing (to her) emotions, conflicting as they are, is presented so well. She is definitely no cartoon here.I also love that Narcissa is not as helpless as she once appeared.I greatly look forward to the next chapter!
Response from diabolica (Author of Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping)
Hallo, lovely! Thank you so much for your encouraging feedback. I haven't blushed so much since Madame Pomfrey said she liked my new earmuffs. It makes me flail happily. :)
Bella and Narcissa's relationship is awfully complicated, true. I was hoping to capture that--the way sisters know how to both comfort and hurt each other.
I also wanted to portray a Narcissa who is certainly not helpless. So glad it worked for you. Thanks again for sharing your thoughts on this!
Wow. This is a really heartbreaking, soft, beautiful piece. You made me really feel for Narcissa in a way that I generally don't- I feel sympathy for her, and how her world seems to be falling down around her. I'm dreading the great Victory of the Light, just because it will mean the end of Narcissa's hope. I am deeply impressed, both by the intensity and the gentleness of your writing here. Most definitely not what I expected, but it's a pleasant surprise.
Response from diabolica (Author of Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping)
Thank you so much for your kind review! Narcissa's certainly in a bad spot; her options are limited and she has so few people she can trust. The idea was to explore what that would mean, not shying away from the ugliness of her situation. I'm happy to know you found the end result a worthwhile read. I hope you'll keep reading!
What an interesting start. Let's see where this goes.
Response from diabolica (Author of Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping)
Thanks for reading and for letting me know what you think! There are four more parts to come.
I'm so glad you posted the ending. You made some subtle changes, no? I don't remember the line about Narcissa's birthday being in the earlier version, but that could just be my memory.There's a lot of tying up of loose ends and very little action in this chapter, but I remain impressed by how you manage to infuse the whole with the sense of tense anticipation that I feel sure you intended us to imagine Narcissa was labouring under during those first post-Voldemort weeks.Congratulations on such a fabulous story.
Response from diabolica (Author of Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping)
Thank you, darling! You remembered right; the bit about Narcissa's birthday wasn't in the original version, but a bit of concrit got me thinking, and I'm pleased with the end result you read here.So good to know the tension of waiting for the ultimate decision on their post-Voldemort fate came through. Those first few weeks had to be tough for them all--well, except for Snape, who I imagine was enjoying a well-deserved holiday of sorts.Thanks again for your thought-provoking and very encouraging commentary! Your reviews have been such a joy to read. :)
Response from grangerous (Reviewer)
Another thought (that I had in the shower): When Bellatrix died, she didn't have her own wand. Hermione Granger had it. (Yes, this is a thought based on *my own* HG obsession!) Canon doesn't tell us which wand Bellatrix uses--presumably it's Hermione's, Ron's or the short, stubby extra one Ron had taken from the snatchers who grabbed him when he walked out on the other two. I've always assumed she had Hermione's wand--if we follow the canon rules about wands submitting to new owners, then though Bella didn't technically take any of the left-behind wands from their owners, she did torture Hermione, and thus might have gained control of it that way. The trio took three wands from the Manon--Bellatrix's, Draco's and Wormtail's--and they left three behind. Since Wormtail was dead, there should have been an extra wand--two extras, really, because Draco took his mothers. Who do you reckon used the spare ones? You don't think the Malfoys might have managed to commandeer one of them? Now that I think about it, the snatchers should have had Dean's wand, too.
Response from diabolica (Author of Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping)
Isn't it funny how these ideas come to you in the shower? That happens to me a lot, too. lolAnd why am I not surprised that you would be totally on top of the finest possible points of canon? *g* You're absolutely right that there must have been a few extra wands floating around the house after the trio escaped; I considered it, but then I figured that Bella would likely make sure that Lucius wouldn't get hold of one, and that Narcissa wouldn't get a replacement when she gave hers to Draco (though I don't think she'd go so far as to take her sister's own wand, I do think she'd be vindictive enough to prevent Narcissa from getting an extra). I would also guess the wand Bella was using at the time of her death (and thus the wand Narcissa summoned in the first scene of Part V) was Hermione's, but I admit it didn't suit my plot-purposes to dwell on it too much. Remind me to turn to you, dear, whenever I need someone to bounce canon-compliance ideas around with. :)
Response from grangerous (Reviewer)
Well, as you know, I became very, very aquainted with canonical events in book 6, and I've recently been delving into book 7 in a similar fashion . . . :)Bounce anything you want off me; I look forward to it.xo
Lovely. Narcissa proves herself to be the consumate Slytherin, by doing as she pleased while letting others think they were forcing her into it. Great use of language, too. The story casts a spell that keeps a person reading.
Response from diabolica (Author of Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping)
Your comments have been so thoughtful and so generous. Thank you! Part of my idea for this piece was to explore the Slytherin conception of loyalty: looking out for those closest to you and remaining true to them even in difficulty. It's what I like about canon!Narcissa. She'd do anything for her family--I just took the liberty of extending that loyalty to Snape in this case. ;)I'm also grateful for your comment about the language; it's wonderful to know that you found the story so compelling. Thank you very much!
A lot can happen in a year. Whatever I feel about Narcissa's politics, I have to admire her strength and tenacity.
Response from diabolica (Author of Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping)
I'm glad you found something admirable in Narcissa here, despite all her flaws and all her mistakes. Thanks so much for your feedback!
Oh, and at the end there she betrays her sister a little bit. The Black family thinks it's somehow outside of the little war going on and uses the sides to play out their own battles. Brilliant!
Response from diabolica (Author of Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping)
Thank you! It's so true--Bella has always used her position as a Death Eater to settle old scores (at least in my mind), and she habours so much resentment towards Narcissa and Lucius, who were free the whole time Bella was locked away. In this part Narcissa finally feels pushed into using the same tactic.
I always had the feeling that Narcissa was holding her family together with her bare hands. You've described that beautifully in this chapter.
Response from diabolica (Author of Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping)
Thanks! That's a really excellent way to phrase it: Narcissa did hold her family together with her bare hands. I'm so happy you liked this chapter!
I like the way this Narcissa is so unapologetic about her life and sympathies. She is what she is. I also love her passion for her family and her love for her husband and son.
Response from diabolica (Author of Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping)
Thank you for your comments! Yes, Narcissa's social and political views are questionable, but that's just who she is. Regardless, she does love her family, and that's her motivation throughout the story. So nice to know that came through. :)