New Chapter for Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping
Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping
diabolica34 Reviews | 3.24/10 (34 Ratings, 0 Likes, 19 Favorites )
The most convincing lies come dressed in layers of truth; the best-kept secrets hide themselves in a thicket of public knowledge, blending in so well as to become invisible. Caught between the Ministry and the Dark Lord, Narcissa Malfoy must choose her alliances carefully.
Start ReadingChapters (5)
About diabolica
Author
diabolica
Member Since 2009 | 11 Stories | Favorited by 18 | 28 Reviews Written | 90 Review Responses
Malfoy fangirl. Sometime fanwriter. Slytherclaw.
Reviews for Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping
I just read the whole story in one sitting and enjoyed it very much. It was nice to see a sympathetic Narcissa. She was a mother who loved her son and feared for his life, that was why she made the Unbreakable Vow with Severus. I think anybody should be able to see that.In this story she also has real intelligence, a conscience, and a moral compass; otherwise she wouldn't have saved Harry's life. She loved Lucius, but I understand her one time thing with Severus. It didn't make her or Severus evil or bad, it just made them feel a burden of guilt. He cared about all three Malfoys and they cared about him. That's why he gave Lucius the 3 vials of antivenin and why Narcissa gave him the bolt holr. If they didn't all care for each other, Severus would be dead, Lucius would be back in Azkaban, and Narcissa and Draco would be at loose ends instead of all of them being somewhere on the Mediterranean (I'm guessing) Coast.
Response from diabolica (Author of Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping)
Thank you! I'm thrilled to read that the story was compelling enough that you wanted to read it all in one go. I'm very much in love with Narcissa, for all the reasons you mentioned: she may be an elitist and have questionable political leanings, but she loves her family and would do anything for them. That's the bit most people can relate to, I think.I also wanted to explore the ways in which Snape and the Malfoys worked together, supported each other, and helped each other survive. As for where exactly they all ended up, I leave that to the reader's imagination... ;)Thanks again for your lovely review!
Another fabulous chapter. I particularly like the way you follow metaphors through after a line or so, for example the hope as blood welling under skin, drying in the air above. Plus, I like how you've taken such time to craft an image that's as dark as the fic itself, and yet still beautiful.(I'm still commenting here, so that people will see the reviews!)
Response from diabolica (Author of Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping)
Thank you!!! It makes me so squeeful that you noticed the metaphors; I thought long and hard about them, trying to keep them consistent without making them repetetive, and I also made an effort to fit the metaphors to the POV character. That is a part of writing that I want to explore further: a strong command of imagery is one of the differences between good writing and great writing imo, so it's an area where I want to develop.And you know what makes me squee even more? Your thoughtfulness. ;) Feel free to comment wherever you like, hon. I'm always happy to get comments from you!
Excellently good. Rather disturbing, in fact.
Response from diabolica (Author of Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping)
Thanks! Disturbing in a thought-provoking way, I hope?
Response from grangerous (Reviewer)
Oh, absolutely. Your Narcissa is incredibly believable, and you have done a fabulous job of underscoring the horrifying tendency of the Ministry of Magic to over ride due process no matter what side of the war it is on at any given time. I'm a pretty consistent HGSS fan and I've always through SS too principled to contemplate adultery, and Narcissa (viewed mostly through her rather hysterical appearances in HBP and DH) as not his type; you have constructed a scenario where both those assumptions no-longer ring true--not that I'm converted from my OTP, don't get me wrong :), but I will follow the rest of the story with interest.
Response from diabolica (Author of Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping)
I'm thrilled to bits to know this fic has given you a new perspective (though I certainly don't ask that you convert). ;) Thank you for your comments! I actually thought Narcissa held it together pretty well through DH, which is what gave me the idea that her behaviour at the beginning of HBP was not normal for her. It made me wonder: What happened at Malfoy Manor during that year and how did she deal with it? As for Snape, I once read some interesting meta on his possible attitude re infidelity, and that further germinated ideas in my evil little mind. So I was of a different opinion than yourself from the outset, but the challenge was creating the scenario you mentioned. Thus, your review was such a compliment, and I thank you for it. :)
Wow. Excellent story. You've done an incredible job of voiceing Narcissa's POV and the ways in which she feels conspired against. Good work.
Response from diabolica (Author of Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping)
Thanks so much for your review! This story took a long time in writing; it's nice to know the effort paid off. :)
Okay, I'm feeling a *lot* more sympathetic to her with this chapter. Really good work :)
Response from diabolica (Author of Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping)
Yay, you kept reading! Thanks for the review. I appreciate the feedback. :)
Response from slasher454 (Reviewer)
Of course I kept reading! You hooked me pretty good with the first chapter, and the second has not disappointed at all.I like how you're building her character without dismissing any of the things we know about her in canon. She can be a bigot and a snob and still be human and a wife and a mother and worthy of some empathy for the shit situation she's in, and worthy of some respect and praise for navigating herself and her loved ones through it.I also really love the way you have drawn Bella. She's such a cartoon in canon, but I see her fleshing out into something more real in your story.Looking forward to the next chapter :)
Response from diabolica (Author of Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping)
I just now saw your comment and it made me ever so squeeful. Thank you! Bella was such fun to write; she'll say anything, and she just doesn't care what other people think.You encapsulated Narcissa perfectly: She can be a bigot and a snob and still be human and a wife and a mother and worthy of some empathy for the shit situation she's in, and worthy of some respect and praise for navigating herself and her loved ones through it. That's it. Exactly. I should have used that as my summary. :) Thanks!
This is an amazing chapter. The image of "Narcissa’s unmarked arm, cradling their infant son," is very emotionally powerful. My favorite part is Severus teasing about having been hatched.
Response from diabolica (Author of Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping)
Thanks so much! I knew that Snape + humour was a very big risk, so it's nice to hear that it paid off for you. ;)
WOW! I love Narcissa, and this is a beautiful and well-written prologue. I can't wait to see what happens next. I love the detail, the thought you've so obviously put into this story. Brava, and I look forward to more!
Response from diabolica (Author of Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping)
Thank you! I also love Narcissa, which is why this story was so much fun to write. She's a fascinating character. Part II, including some more of the events of HBP told from her perspective (and Snape's), is in the queue and coming soon. I hope you'll enjoy it!
Response from floorcoaster (Reviewer)
SQUEE! I'm sure I will. I like your Draco too, the little bits I've seen. He's one of my favorite characters to read and write, so I look forward to him too.
Wow, very detailed and facinating. You've given us a sympatheic eye into Narcissa's life that I don't think I'd really considered before. Of course, she's still a nasty bigot, but even as such, she's got feelings. Her sense of injustice is both moving and laughable at the same time. How bitterly she feels the loss of her own rights while still salivating at the prospect of denying the same and more to others.What a challenge you have taken on! I think you could actually make me like her, even with as flawed and terrible as her mean little mind works.I greatly look forward to more :)
Response from diabolica (Author of Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping)
Thanks for your very thoughtful review! Despite the fact that Narcissa only appears in canon on a handful of occasions, there has to be more to a woman who holds her family together throughout the events of HBP & DH. With this piece, I wanted to explore the costs of that, as well as what might have led the Malfoys to support Voldemort (e.g., a Ministry rife with corruption and a complete disregard for civil rights). She is certainly flawed, but those flaws, mixed with her intelligence and her love for and loyalty to her family, make her quite interesting (and challenging, true) to write. Part II is in the queue, and I hope you'll keep reading! If you can feel at least some sympathy for her position, I'll feel like I've done my job. :) Thanks again for reviewing!
Brilliant Writing.
Response from diabolica (Author of Scylla, Charybdis and the Delicate Art of Secret-Keeping)
Thanks! I hope you'll enjoy the next part.