Pensieves and Possibilities
Chapter 19 of 22
sweetflagOld secrets come back to haunt Maud and Agnes. Snape has an interesting run in with Randall.
ReviewedStoke's visit had shaken Cross. It was undeniable, but he still couldn't discern the exact reason why. His role hadn't been threatened, his professionalism not questioned, but something lingered, like an unpleasant aftertaste. Combined with Burke's impatience, he was beginning to feel pressured. Snape was close to breaking, but to rush its conclusion would only destroy his mind. Cross still harboured the desire to crush Snape utterly. Burke could pluck all the Unforgivables and Unspeakables from Snape's mind as he wanted, but Snape belonged to him until he was a gibbering, broken wreck, begging at his feet, mewling and bawling, accepting his guilt. No Deatheater was innocent; no Deatheater was worthy of forgiveness.
Snape was stronger than he'd given him credit for, and his friends and allies were confounded to a degree he'd never seen before. The Dark Lord had obviously taught him some exceptional spells to befuddle and bewitch, but everyone cracked. The professors would be hurt for a while, betrayal always hurt, but in time, they'd be thankful for having Snape's veil lifted from their eyes. Perhaps when Snape was finally punished, RID would be suitably lauded and Cross could rest easy in the department's future. Then he could cast off such leeches as Burke.
As in if answer to his thoughts, a soft chime rang out. A potion had been used. There were still quite a few Deatheaters left who required the potion, so his heart didn't flicker at the cue, but his breath caught and his heart lurched when he saw the patient number: one six nine. His thin lips cracked into a smile. Maybe soon, he could try some of the new tactics he'd researched. An automatic response was prepared. All that was required was a signature, and then Snape would be his. He settled back in his chair with a smile, his concern melting away as he planned the next session.
ooOoo
Agnes and Maud knew Norbert had lived a long and lonely life, but it still cut to the quick that they mourned alone and no one seemed to notice he was no longer around. They comforted each other with the knowledge that they were the best at their jobs, which is exactly why no one knew or remembered them. It was a bittersweet solace. And because they were good, they were now barely making a ripple, even though their insides squirmed unpleasantly, and the very walls of the Ministry seemed to drip with old and vile secrets. Today was different though. Agnes had done the dishes.
Norbert had been a sly one...a clever one. His plans and tactics had saved their lives on many occasions, and now his death had done the same. The uneaten bowls of soup that he'd placed so carefully in the floo grate had contained more than just cold chicken broth. When the investigation had closed and his property opened to family and friends, Agnes had been to the dingy house and collected what was hers: odd cups, cutlery, a few bits of crockery, the good teapot and the dirty bowls. Preservation spells cast at the time of discovery meant that nothing had altered since that night, and it had snatched her breath that the last bowl had still been warm.
Angry and hurt at his death...possible murder...she'd found the uneaten food an insult to her care and diligence. A bowl had met a messy end when it connected with a wall. As the contents had slid down, she'd caught sight of something glimmering. Curious, she had stepped over to see what was hidden within the broth. Norbert had bequeathed them what he'd seen...and more.
Acting quickly, she'd saved the silvery gifts and then sifted through the other bowls. In total, she'd found twelve distinct memories. Baffled, proud, anxious and determined, she'd contacted Maud, and they'd visited the Lamb to discuss their next move. After a shandy and stout, they'd planned to meet up again at the weekend, to give them time to see if anyone else was interested in cold chicken soup.
Now, almost two weeks after his death, they sat at Maud's kitchen table, staring at the pensieve and the swirling memories within. The old wall clock ticked away, and the house creaked as it settled. Within the small stone bowl swam demons and devils, and they were afraid to dive in, but they were Norbert's, and they knew they couldn't ignore it. Glancing at each, dread etched in their faces, they reached in and let the memories swirl around their trembling fingers. Within moments, they were drawn into darkness and things long past.
It wasn't pleasant. To convey his conviction, he'd drawn out the memories from his time at Grindelwald's side, where he had worked on refining the concept of Black Memories, so that Maud and Agnes could find no escape in denial. Every evil thing he'd done was laid before them. In hindsight, his behaviour, evasiveness, loneliness and pain made more sense, became more pertinent and poignant. They were torn between a sense of keen betrayal and an intense longing to let him know he'd earned forgiveness.
There had been only one memory of immediate interest, and that had been when he'd first drawn a Black Memory. Despite what was displayed before them, they still found it impossible to believe that something so evil could exist. After the shock had dimmed to a dull ache, they returned to the memory to review it dispassionately, to learn all its secrets.
Norbert...young and wild-eyed...was bent over a corpse: it's skin dry and shrunken, the hair thin and wispy, lips shrivelled and pulled back. It was clearly long dead. It was laid out on a table, surrounded by stubby flickering candles and bunches of strange herbs and burning stalks sending oily curls of blue smoke into the air. In the flickering light, they saw him mutter a spell while moving the wand in a complicated sigil, air currents catching the smoke and directing it into swirls and odd shapes. Behind him, they saw the shadowy outline of another wizard, his face hidden but his stance tense and alert. Norbert continued muttering and swaying for several minutes, sweat beading his brow and his face contorting with effort. Contrary to the natural order of things, the corpse twitched, then the jaw moved. Fingers jerked and the scrawny feet kicked feebly. The stranger let out a rasping sigh, reaching out to clasp Norbert's shoulder. He leaned forwards to study the animated cadaver, and his face came into the light. It was Grindelwald.
Despite the shock, they continued, dreading the rest of the memory, but eager to learn all that Norbert wanted to teach them. Their gazes were drawn back to the desiccated face. The tongue had long since wasted away, as had the eyes, so it mouthed silent words while eyeless sockets drew them towards unfathomable depths. Wasted hands began to claw at the air and the legs spasmed.
"Quickly!" Grindelwald demanded. "You know what I need."
Norbert nodded and placed his wand at the thing's temple and began to tug. To their horror, they saw him spool out thin, viscous black strands. It clung to the wand like bitumen, glistening revoltingly in the candlelight. He lifted a bottle and eased the mass from the tip, watching it slide slowly down the glass like a fat slug. He returned to his task, each time pulling out the Black Memories, ignoring the plaintive struggles of the thing on the table. The reluctant witnesses were transfixed as he worked, pulling hours, then days worth of memories out of the corpse's empty skull.
Their minds couldn't quite fathom the mechanics of how it was working, the answers too abhorrent and sickening to contemplate, but they were forming an unsettling conclusion. Somehow, the soul's very memories were being pulled back into the decaying remains and Norbert was siphoning off what Grindelwald wanted. It was too much to take in, and they opted to leave delving too deeply into what was happening, otherwise they'd fear for their sanity. It was clear that whoever was on the table was suffering, and an intense pity burnt through them to the point where tears spilled down their cheeks. They couldn't help but wonder if the soul would come to look unknowingly upon their forgotten loved ones. The only succour in death was that it was supposed to be an end to suffering...and yet here that boon was rendered moot...it was cruel! It was hideous.
Grindelwald leant in closer and studied the bottle and the tar-like substance within. "Do you have it all?"
Norbert shook his head. "I cannot draw out what isn't there," he answered in a strained voice.
"Death restores everything," Grindelwald stated coldly. "You assured me that this method would bypass all attempts to keep secrets from me."
"If it was Obliviated, forgotten or extracted in life, then I can draw it out now in death." He paused and took several steadying breaths. "I cannot take what was never there," he repeated with as much frustration as he dared to show. "Rest assured that everything he knew in life regarding your need will be in this jar."
Maud clasped Agnes's hand and they cleaved together. The corpse seemed terrified, desperate to stop what was happening, its clawed hands trying to stop the tip from touching it. Grindelwald was laughing and urging Norbert on until half the bottle was full and the corpse had stopped moving.
"He's dry!" Norbert rasped, collapsing sideways, his face pale and clammy, and the bottle held up precariously.
Grindelwald caught the bottle and stepped away, his eyes fixed solely on the contents.
"Very well," he mumbled. "You've done very well, Norbert...very well." He placed the bottle in his pocket and looked back at the corpse. "The grave is no longer silent," he said softly before letting out a jubilant laugh. He then pulled out his wand and immolated the cadaver until nothing but powdery ash remained. The memory began to fade, and they saw Norbert, hauling himself back to his feet, his face wet with tears, trying to gather together the ash before it blew away. Maud felt Agnes' fingers bite into the back of her hand.
The kitchen was cold and dark when they emerged. Their hearts were beating fast and nausea clung thickly to their throats. Black Memories had always been thought of as terrible fancy...as the dream of a madman, but Norbert had cracked it. He'd pulled them out! They ran shaking hands over their faces, wiping away the dried tears.
"'Ave you got anythin' to drink?" Agnes asked hoarsely.
Maud nodded and magicked a bottle and two glasses from the sideboard. With a shaking hand, she poured two shots. They drank the lot in one gulp.
"Sweet Mother of..." Agnes said hotly. "What 'ave I just 'ad?"
"Homemade peach schnapps," Maud offered wheezily. "My man used to make it. He said it could cure anything."
Agnes snorted and put down her glass. "Bet it takes paint off an' all!"
Despite that, they both had another glass, their minds too muddled to latch onto anything other than the sting and heat of alcohol. Slowly, they incorporated the memory into their own. What was done was done. They couldn't change that, and they knew how he'd suffered during the war. It seemed to them that in some way, perhaps it had happened the way it was supposed to happen. Norbert wasn't that infirm that he couldn't have defended himself, and he'd been canny enough to protect himself. Maybe he'd allowed his past to catch up. If they were honest, a deep and dark part of them...the part that still hurt and snarled from the war...felt satisfied. Norbert had desecrated the mysteries beyond death, raped the minds of the dead and damaged the soul. It didn't ease the sting of his death, though.
"Silly sod," Agnes muttered sadly, putting into words what they both felt.
Maud sighed and relaxed, turning her mind over the memory objectively. "How long would you say it took him to get those memories out?"
Agnes stiffened and pursed her lips. "I reckon twenty minutes...and he got about seven fluid ounces." Maud frowned and glanced at Agnes sceptically. At her look Agnes bristled. "I make a lot of jam," she snapped defensively.
"Okay," Maud retorted. "We know now he saw eight jars in that room."
Agnes' eyes fluttered a moment as she worked out her measurements. "About one hundred and twenty fluid ounces," she declared. "Give or take."
"So, that's about...five hours worth of work."
"If you say so," demurred Agnes.
"And it looked pretty exhausting."
"Not to mention that exhuming a body ain't exactly quick an' easy."
"And where would you set such a ritual up?"
"Need to be well ventilated," Agnes said thoughtfully. "All that incest stuff would have knocked 'im out."
Maud paused and then sighed. "You mean incense."
"Whatever..." Agnes mumbled dismissively. "An'..." her brow furrowed as she went back over the memory and her own. "Sandalwood, mugwort an' ...hmm...Solomon's seal." She drummed her nails on the table, as if the sharp tattoo would help her thinking. "An' lavender. Somethin' else..."
Maud was momentarily exhausted: her mind unfocused. She'd seen the flowers but Agnes seemed to have seen something else, some deeper significance. She knew better than to interrupt, so made tea while her friend was lost in thought. She stood by the window, filling the kettle, and saw her reflection in the dark glass, a ghostly face merging with the twisted branches and black, swirling clouds. The nights were drawing in fast as they approached December. Normally, despite the cold nibbling at her bones, she liked the cosiness that winter forced her to adopt. The fire would be burning in the grate, and the smell of stews or soups would greet her nose on coming home. She'd be baking shortbread soon for the local schools, and the robins would come and sing in her garden, This time, however, the outside was bitter and cruel. The clouds were heavy and threatening and the branches like talons, seeking to slash her.
The kettle, heavy in her hand, brought her back to herself and she shook off the gloom. She lit the gas, and rested the kettle on the ring gently. Behind her, she could still hear Agnes muttering, and she smiled warmly. It was nice to have the company; loneliness creeps up so softly that sometimes you don't even realise it's there with you until it's forced to leave.
"Bloody Althaea root!" Maud turned and saw the satisfied grin spread across Agnes' wrinkled and worn face. "I knew I knew it!" she said triumphantly.
The kettle began to whistle, intent on being dealt with first. Hastily filling the teapot, Maud sat back down across from Agnes. "Does that mean anything?"
Agnes' smile faltered. "I'm not sure," she said softly, reaching out to pat the back of Maud's hand.
The tea soothed them and they took rapid gentle sips while it was hot. They went over the memories they'd experienced. It was clear that the pensieve had acted as a teacher and a protection. He'd drawn out everything linking him to them. He'd known someone would go rummaging around in his head...and that meant...
"Someone else knows 'ow to get Black 'uns," Agnes said hollowly. "'E bloody well knew that someone were comin' for 'im!"
Maud shared Agnes' bitter frustration, but it softened as she thought deeper. "He didn't know who though." Her brow furrowed and the teacup paused en route to her quivering lips; something nagged at her mind. "His owl was killed," she whispered, her lips slightly ahead of her thinking.
Agnes caught on quickly and tutted. "Ye can get 'em from beasts, too?" She moaned, but then a vicious, victorious smile split her face. "That explains that scream!"
"What do you mean?"
"I'm bettin' he couldn't get anythin' outta that owl...or Norbert," she said gleefully. "All that an' he got diddly-squat!"
Maud smiled. "Norbert was good at frustrating people."
"And helpin' us," Agnes added. "I think we're lookin' for someone as old as us...or thereabouts, who may 'ave 'ad somethin' to do with Grindlegums."
"And someone who can duplicate Norbert's ritual and spells."
"And 'as access to the Ministry," Agnes offered.
Both of them sipped tea and let their minds drift over strategies and plans. Several cups later and when the clock chimed out ten, they had settled on their plan of action. It helped ease their confusion and agitation. Despite Norbert's actions, there was still someone out there doing these vile things, and they needed to be stopped. Perhaps by the end of it, Norbert's last actions would be deemed purifying and grant his soul peace.
Over the next few days, they organised themselves to start the investigation armed with the knowledge from the pensieve. Agnes had taken over many of Norbert's duties in a bid to learn what made him investigate the room in the first place and who potentially could have trailed and killed him. Maud was going through the books, old accounts, anything to find something rotten in RID. There had to be a link between the processes involved in memory work and Black Memories. They both hoped to find something because the alternative was dredging up all their old memories and allegiances, and that was almost unthinkable. Sometimes, to catch devils, you had to become one.
Agnes mopped her way through most of the old storage rooms and long abandoned holding cells, and her duster poked into every nook and cranny in the dingy offices, but nothing had come to light. Cobwebs had faced her frustration, and a colony of Doxys had fled in the face of her consternation. She knew something had to be down here. No one was that careful. She'd wracked her brains trying to think who was still around, but as far as she knew, everyone was either too old or too dead. Norbert must have known them, though.
While clearing out the bins in Dispatch and Procurement, she casually had a good rummage around in the desk. Collecting such memories was a hefty task, requiring particular skills, reagents, materials and resources. Firstly, it required a corpse. Dispatch and Procurement was a rather strange name, but the department dealt with the collection and appropriate and respectful disposal of wizards residing outside normal conditions: those in Azkaban and disowned; the unknowns living in the Muggle world; the dark creatures; and for those where spells had rendered it...difficult for traditional funerary rites. Following a hunch, she wondered if there were any...stray corpses.
For her part, Maud was busy with her task and looking after Peters. The lad had promise. When he'd returned the notes, she knew he'd found something, and he'd had the good sense to keep it to himself. She tutted softly. Aurors just weren't trained to the same standards anymore, she groused. In her day, Aurors would have seen him and his suspicions a mile away. She saw it as a mixed blessing, though. It was vital that he finished what he started: Severus Snape was important to Minerva and she felt he was the key to cracking the Ministry open. However, Peters needed a little guidance before he put a target on his back and perhaps a push in the right direction. It was time to start calling in a few favours from the other secretaries. Firstly, she needed clarity on just how memory extraction and investigation worked. An unpleasant idea was forming in the back of her mind. Luckily for her, the Offices for Magical Research were just down the hallway, and a certain young secretary was about to repay a favour. Unfortunately, she felt that time wasn't on their side. This time, things would get...messy.
ooOoo
Snape slept slightly longer than usual, and as such woke past the dinner bell. Minerva wouldn't mind his absence, but it rankled him slightly that he'd missed a duty. Trying to disperse his frustration, he inhaled deeply, relishing the fact that he could do so without his ribs aching, and stretched, letting the tension out of his muscles. It wouldn't last. On Monday, he'd receive another summons from the Ministry, and then he'd have to face them before experiencing the rapid decline until his next potion. He was its slave.
Realising that he was on the way to despairing and self-pity, he got up and lit all the lamps. Next, he put his mind to a task. Neville's potion leapt into mind like an eager puppy. Guilt settled on his shoulders, and he slumped a little. The potion had been so important at the start, but the few meetings had only confirmed his initial suspicions: it just wasn't feasible. Neville had shown great skill and dedication, and as such had travelled all available avenues. There simply wasn't anywhere else to go.
He summoned a coffee from the kitchen and returned to his desk, where he pulled out his pen and paper. Something had caught his imagination back in Wales. Something had tugged at his interest. Neville! Snape snorted at the suggestion, but couldn't quite reject the notion. Unbidden, he recalled with excruciating detail the moment his anger and fear had bested him and pressed Neville up against the rock. He'd been so close to him, smelt him, seen his pupils flare as adrenaline coursed through his veins, felt the pulse beneath his fingers on the boy's throat. His mouth went dry when he remembered how Neville had wrapped his arm around him for support...and then that gasp when his wand had pressed a little harder. He could still feel the warmth of his body.
With effort, Snape cleared his mind. It wouldn't do well to dwell on things beyond him. However, it did give him an idea. Up until now, Neville had focused on reviving the memories lost or trapped behind the madness. Snape had to agree the memories were there, as nothing had been done at the time to eradicate or remove them. He would never disclose to Neville how he knew this to be true; only Dumbledore knew the truth of that night. No one else needed to know. Of course, that begged the question of what the Longbottoms would do when and if they regained their minds. It was a sobering thought, and one he cared not to ponder.
Returning to his original idea, he considered the possibility of withdrawing the memories of the event that had spawned the Longbottoms' mental decay in the hopes that the trauma could be excised. Would that give them the chance to gather themselves together and restore their sanity? It was an intriguing idea. It had been that one event that had shattered them. He'd witnessed how the Cruciatus could break memory charms, so could breaking the memories of the curse reverse the damage?
He knew from bitter experience how disorientating it was to lose vast chunks of memory, but if he'd learnt anything, it was the fact that you could recall nothing, it was a void, empty of thought and feeling...until it was force-fed back to you. The Ministry adopted a modified method for withdrawing memories. Normally, there was an echo of the memory left behind...a dim awareness of it. This meant that you were still familiar with it, like an instinct or emotional response. He'd used the memory charm often enough in the past to diminish their presence, such as when teaching Potter Legilimency or hiding them from Voldemort. In the case of his interrogations, every last trace of the memory was cut out. Associated memories collapsed away into confused snippets, like discordant harmonics in a song, or took on different aspects, sometimes scary, funny or strange.
Nausea crept up his gullet. He was surprised he could even contemplate doing to Neville's parents what was being done to him, but the idea was in his head, and it was germinating quickly. He had to at least investigate the possibility. If the consequences of his past were to catch him up, then he felt it better and apt that Neville should benefit.
ooOoo
Randall had had enough. Neville's parting words had been sweet and generous and completely infuriating! What was Cupid to do? If he thought they'd really help, he'd make a love potion and force feed them both. It was getting to the point where he was thinking about writing a 'How to...' guide...with illustrations. He'd caught up with Neville at lunch. but the seating meant that he hadn't had the chance to talk to the man, and by the end of the meal, fatigue had crept up on him. He was just too tired to attempt anything.
Flashing Neville a peeved glance, he sauntered off, ushering a few stragglers off to their dorms as he went. He was in two minds to finish marking homework or relax with a bit of Arithmancy...it had been a while since he'd actually applied his art. He could, if he focused, attempt to divine the future for Snape and Neville, but from experience, he knew it was a dubious thing. No, if he were going to do it, then he'd let himself become lost in the purity of the numbers. However, his mind drifted back towards the Neville and Snape dilemma. He was sure that should anyone else become aware of the situation, then they'd be as frustrated as he was. There again, why was he so wrapped up in this?
Neville was a lovely man, and he certainly deserved to be happy and loved...and Randal was almost positive that Snape could make that so...and Snape was just desperate for someone like Neville. It was so ridiculously simple! It wasn't just that though. Randal wanted those things too. Perhaps his efforts were more to help himself than either of his friends. If he couldn't be happy with Neville, then maybe being happy for Neville would be the next best thing.
To relax, he'd completed a basic chart, and was now sitting back, admiring the numbers and lines upon the page. A sudden thought gripped him, and he decided to complete such a chart for Sinastra, as a gift. It wouldn't be a prediction, but rather an arithmantic representation or history of her impact upon the school and him. The older styles of charts were now considered too florid and archaic, but Randall had always been partial to how artistic they looked. He could do one with numbers and linking lines in gold and reds and then frame it in a case, like they used to do when the study was relatively new and only secretive lords could afford the Arithmancer's rates. It wouldn't be too garish, as it would only be about twenty by fifteen centimetres; and he already had a gold-filigreed case to slip the chart into. He grinned at the thought, feeling pleased with himself. All he needed was a few details from the library to link in her birth date with events of the day to create a start point and then figure out where she'd been born. Simple. It would also distract him from Snape and Neville. Between the two of them, he was being driven slowly mad.
His research meant that he failed to hear the gong for dinner and worked late into the evening. The librarian walked around, ousting students, and when she met Randall, she nodded by way of greeting and left him to his work. So it came as a surprise when he finally stretched and checked the time. It was well past ten o'clock. He banished the books back to their places and carefully rolled up the scroll containing his rough calculations. The next step was to get some decent paper and brush off his best quills.
Sighing softly, he stood, pushed his chair under and pulled on his jacket. As he was leaving, he heard something coming from the shadowed aisles. Thinking a student was out past bedtime, he crept over, hoping to catch them unawares. It would be useful if he could cultivate the same skills as the teachers: stealth being one of them. He homed in on the furtive rustles of paper and cloth. His heart fluttered a little, and he couldn't help but smile at the role reversal. How many times had he been the kid out past curfew?
At the next aisle, he caught sight of shadows shifting over the bookcases, so he paused, took a deep breath and bolted round the corner with a snarled greeting. He wasn't sure who was more alarmed: him or Snape. Judging by the wand aimed at his face, Randal assumed Snape was.
"I'm really sorry," Randal professed hastily, his hands up. A trickle of cold sweat ran down his spine, and his heart hammered uncomfortably. "I thought you were a student." He swallowed, his throat unnaturally dry.
Snape merely raised an eyebrow, the wand still aimed.
"If I'd have known..." he trailed off. He wasn't sure how to finish. Several options sprang to mind. They ranged from the purely lascivious to simple survival. "Look," he added, "I'm not about to run off or deface the books, so could you lower the wand?"
Snape had been caught off guard. He knew Madam Westin had cleared the library and had assumed he was alone. His reading had been all consuming, enticing him, and rekindling the desire to work, to fight. When Randall had leapt round the corner, he'd reacted defensively. Initially, his heart had lurched from dread, but upon seeing Randal, it thumped for another reason. The delicious flicker of fear on Randal's face was delightful, and he was torn between guilt and pleasure. The beads of sweat glistening on Randal's upper lip, the dilated pupils, his tongue peeping out to moisten dry lips were very...distracting.
Snape was wiser than Neville. He knew what he liked, and he knew what Randal liked...hadn't he confessed his wants to Neville by the lake? And whereas Neville was confused and unsure of things, Randal was not. It was so tempting! It would have been easy. All Snape had to do was take one step closer, lean in, let his wand-tip slide slowly down the man's cheek, and Randal would whimper and beg. Yes, it was so incredibly tempting. He felt muscles bunching in his thighs, ready to move, but he knew this was just the potion, and he knew it could make him reckless. Tonight would be glorious, but tomorrow would be full of regret.
Randal had had time to see beyond the wand, and like Snape, he was keen enough to see what others tried to hide. He was no Legilimens, but he could read people well enough to hazard a guess at their thoughts and needs. Snape radiated something that snatched his breath. He shuddered at the prospect. It just wasn't fair. Randall knew all he had to do to push Snape was to gasp a little, or put a little pleading into his expression. To make Snape moan, all he had to do was mewl a little. Part of him was willing to fall down on his knees and beg Snape for everything he had to offer, but another knew it would be out of line. Another part wondered if Neville could cope with what Snape might offer. Besides, it would scupper his plans for Neville if he and Snape were to...Hell! It was so godsdamned tempting!
Snape was the stronger man and lowered the wand, sheathing it smoothly within his sleeve. "I should apologise, too," he responded smoothly, impressing Randal, who had lost the ability to even formulate words. "That was unprofessional of me."
"No problem," Randal croaked. "Guess I should make more noise next time."
"Indeed."
"Well," Randal concluded. "I'll leave you to your study."
But he just couldn't leave it. The seconds caught in Snape's gaze had burnt, and he wanted Snape to feel as branded as he. He just had to give him something to mull over, some hint of what could have been...and maybe what still could be. "I just need..." he said, stepping closer and reaching out for a book. He subtly tilted his jaw, exposing his throat, biting his lower lip at the effort of stretching. Former lovers had always found his neck alluring. As he walked away, he swore he heard Snape moan.
Story Actions
To follow, favorite, like, and more either log in or create an account.
Leave a Review
Log in to leave a review.
Latest 25 Reviews for A Fine Divide
103 Reviews | 7.22/10 Average
Wonderful if heartbreaking chapter, thank you.
Response from sweetflag (Author of A Fine Divide)
Thank you for sticking with the story. I am so glad you liked it. Yes, this was quite a hard chapter to write.
This chapter is just wow! I fear for Peters and for Maud but I am glad Severus got them on his side.
I guess Pomona and Minerva sense something before the two men.
I hope your hands get better soon, best wishes!
Poor Severus. Thank you for this chapter!
Oh dear! Thank you for a very funny chapter.
Response from sweetflag (Author of A Fine Divide)
Glad you liked it. :)
I am happy that he has
Response from sweetflag (Author of A Fine Divide)
as a friend. Thank you for a wonderful story!
Response from sweetflag (Author of A Fine Divide)
I've always thought that they would get on. I like having the opportunity to eplore that.
Thank you for this wonderful story!
Response from sweetflag (Author of A Fine Divide)
Thank you :)
Hoping for an update soon. I find this story intriguing.
Response from sweetflag (Author of A Fine Divide)
Hello and thank you for the lovely review. Apologies for the late response, but I only got a notification today :s I will update soon...just need another good read through. :D
Apologies for the late review! Loved the chapter. From the marvellous opening in the pub as Agnes and Maud determine to investigate fully... to Randle's frustrated introspection... to Severus' confusion of feelings... to Neville. Neville, Neville, Neville, Neville!!! Aaaargh!!! I think the only thing you can do is to lock them in that cupboard! I am agog for what is going to happen next.... Can't wait! Pxxx
I'm so glad for the update - this has to be one of the best (but most sad) fics in the archive. I love everything about it, but here's a short list for specifics: Severus himself and his strength, the care that Minerva and the old Hogwards stalwarts have for him, the blossoming 'friendship' between Severus and Neville, the intrigue in the Ministry as well as the fantastic writing which almost requires the reader not to need any imagination, it is so vivid. I don't mind waiting ages for another update - just as long as there is one!
Response from sweetflag (Author of A Fine Divide)
Aww... thank you! The updates have been slow (very upset about that). If I'd have known at the start that things here would become so messy, I'd have kept it back until it was done. Saying that you don't mind the wait (even though there shouldn't be one) is a real balm. It has depressed me no end to sit and not be able to type. Oh well... I'm in a good spell, so I shall make hay while the sun shines :D Next one is up, and the one after that on the go. oops... better not jinx it! Thank you so much for the review *big hugs* It was a nice boost. Oh... and so sorry about not responding sooner. Take care.
Response from sweetflag (Author of A Fine Divide)
Aww... thank you! The updates have been slow (very upset about that). If I'd have known at the start that things here would become so messy, I'd have kept it back until it was done. Saying that you don't mind the wait (even though there shouldn't be one) is a real balm. It has depressed me no end to sit and not be able to type. Oh well... I'm in a good spell, so I shall make hay while the sun shines :D Next one is up, and the one after that on the go. oops... better not jinx it! Thank you so much for the review *big hugs* It was a nice boost. Oh... and so sorry about not responding sooner. Take care.
Just found this story and WOW. Read it all the way through and can't wait for the next chapter. Good emotive writing...you've had me on the edge of my seat a few times. Keep up the good work!
Response from sweetflag (Author of A Fine Divide)
Hello and thank you! So long as I don't push you off the edge, then I'm happy :) So glad that you liked it and thanks for the compliment. Take care.
Response from sweetflag (Author of A Fine Divide)
Hello and thank you! So long as I don't push you off the edge, then I'm happy :) So glad that you liked it and thanks for the compliment. Take care.
Brilliant! A wonderfully intense two way chapter. Loved the atmospheric exchange between the two men and loved, loved the sense of threat and anticipation that you developed here. Of course, I can't wait to see how Severus is coping and whether Neville can discover the ghastly secret... Not to mention Minerva's and Pomona's plans to save Severus from the Ministry. Biting nails in anticipation for the next chapter. Love, love, love this story. Please update sooooooooooon!!! Pxx
Response from sweetflag (Author of A Fine Divide)
Thank you :) I'm doing my very best to catch up with things. I have every one in place *evil laugh*. My only dilemma at the moment is just exactly what Minerva will do to the Aurors whe she finds out.... mwahaha!
Response from sweetflag (Author of A Fine Divide)
Thank you :) I'm doing my very best to catch up with things. I have every one in place *evil laugh*. My only dilemma at the moment is just exactly what Minerva will do to the Aurors whe she finds out.... mwahaha!
Love the tension as Minerva comes to terms with sharing Severus. Love the description of Neville waking up and also Snape's increasing interest in him. I can't tell you how much I enjoy this story, sweetflag. It is simply excellent. Still think Minerva should be doing more to try to save Severus from the Ministry. And now he has taken another dose - there will be another visit to his tormentors....
Response from sweetflag (Author of A Fine Divide)
I have little imagination when it comes to developing romance. I have to go with very simple. Never fear... Minerva has adopted Severus and therefore taken on all that entails.
Response from Proulxes (Reviewer)
*Cue big soppy grin*. You're doing fine by my book Pxx *Waiting happily for the next update!*
Response from sweetflag (Author of A Fine Divide)
I have little imagination when it comes to developing romance. I have to go with very simple. Never fear... Minerva has adopted Severus and therefore taken on all that entails.
Response from Proulxes (Reviewer)
*Cue big soppy grin*. You're doing fine by my book Pxx *Waiting happily for the next update!*
A humdinger of a chapter - we feel concern for the first year Gryffindor, but that concern is rapidly subsumed into greater concern for Severus who is suffering one of his attacks. Superbly written -as Neville deals with the conflicting feelings he is experiencing in caring for Snape, the empathy he feels, and the awkward protectiveness he experiences towards him. Just great writing - thanks!
Response from sweetflag (Author of A Fine Divide)
I felt that I needed to be reminded about duty. Teaching is more than just nerves and playful hostas. Interestingly, I'm reading this with a different mind-set and wondering why I wrote about Neville's flagging sense of duty when in the forest suddenly flaring when he saw Snape. Hmmmm...
Response from sweetflag (Author of A Fine Divide)
I felt that I needed to be reminded about duty. Teaching is more than just nerves and playful hostas. Interestingly, I'm reading this with a different mind-set and wondering why I wrote about Neville's flagging sense of duty when in the forest suddenly flaring when he saw Snape. Hmmmm...
Another great chapter - building the tension between the two men and continuing to toy with the central mysteries of the story. What's in the phial? Why isn't it in the Penseive? Or are all the memories buried inside the garden? If that is the case - how is it so easy for them to be taken away? Shouldn't they all be alarmed or protected from removal - or is everyone on the staff in on the real purpase behind the little healing garden - apart form Neville and presumeably Randal too. Oh, and Snape? Does he know about it? Intriguing! And I loved the last paragraph. "Grab him and haul him off to the potions lab", eh? Nowhere else? *Waggles eyebrows*
Response from sweetflag (Author of A Fine Divide)
I think the next update will answer some of your questions. I've hit a fulcrum in the story, and as I'm answering your review, I'm feeling a little less confident than when I finished it. But, as with all things, there must come a change or things would just moulder. *nibbles nails nervously*
Response from Proulxes (Reviewer)
Don't you dare! No nibbling! That's what happens when you release a story - as you said in an earlier response - readers take things from it that writers might not have intended or even mean!! Don't worry on my acount. This is great writing and I am hooked - I have no idea how you are going to resolve the situation but I can't wait to read it! Pxx
Response from sweetflag (Author of A Fine Divide)
I think the next update will answer some of your questions. I've hit a fulcrum in the story, and as I'm answering your review, I'm feeling a little less confident than when I finished it. But, as with all things, there must come a change or things would just moulder. *nibbles nails nervously*
Response from Proulxes (Reviewer)
Don't you dare! No nibbling! That's what happens when you release a story - as you said in an earlier response - readers take things from it that writers might not have intended or even mean!! Don't worry on my acount. This is great writing and I am hooked - I have no idea how you are going to resolve the situation but I can't wait to read it! Pxx
Funny and thoughtful - loved your dscription of the Herbology lesson! "It's just gone down his trousers, sir" is a great way to end this chapter. Important to see Neville's confidence and abilities here, and to counter any latent prejudices in your readers, too!!
Response from sweetflag (Author of A Fine Divide)
:D Glad you liked it.
Response from sweetflag (Author of A Fine Divide)
:D Glad you liked it.
Oh I do love the tenderness that you have drawn in Minerva's relationship with Severus. Loved Neville's quiet moment in the garden, strokign the sage leaves, and Severus' version of the "Welcome to Hogwarts" speech. I also smirked quietly at the two checking each other out. As oblivious as both of them are to what is growing between them, it is a real pleasure to see how well you are drawing out these two characters. Brava.
Response from sweetflag (Author of A Fine Divide)
You know, I read your review and it struck me just how impossible it is for me to write short stories *sigh* I'm too... wordy. Not my fault! I'm a woman and Gemini... it's almost mandatory to use more words than necessary.
Response from sweetflag (Author of A Fine Divide)
You know, I read your review and it struck me just how impossible it is for me to write short stories *sigh* I'm too... wordy. Not my fault! I'm a woman and Gemini... it's almost mandatory to use more words than necessary.
Oh bloody hell (sorry!) - this chapter is wonderful. Loved the intereaction between Neville and Randal - it was beautifully written and I look forward to more of the same as the story goes on. Minerva's concern over what Neville might do if he discovers the Pensieve in the garden - and the Penseive itself - what a fantastic idea to hide such a thing in plain sight (and so symbolically too!). I can't help but think that she should insist more formally that the Ministry investigate what is happening to Severus - but understand that without the man himself complaining she would find it harder to do so. COme on Severus! Have some self-regard! When Neville finds out the full story, I hope that he takes more direct action. With a sword. Or a hammer. Or some sort of similar implement...
Response from sweetflag (Author of A Fine Divide)
Thank you for that! I worry when writing such scenes. I struggle with anything bordering on... assignations. I feel happier writing about doom and gloom :D Thank you again.
Response from sweetflag (Author of A Fine Divide)
Thank you for that! I worry when writing such scenes. I struggle with anything bordering on... assignations. I feel happier writing about doom and gloom :D Thank you again.
The decaf potion - lol! Brilliant! Oooops - didn't mention RHine in the last review - he is going ot be an interesting character and I like hte way that you have described him thus far. OCs are always tricky to do, aren't they? I have a feelign that he will be important. Oh, Gods, the lighthearted scene at hte start of the chapter bleeds into the horrors of the Ministry. You describe this interrogation superbly. The thought that Severus might lose his mind due to this horrific sustained abuse is sickening and terrible - attacking the thing that makes him, him. I can see how Hogwarts represents a sanctuary for him in a way that is even more important for him now. Urgh! This story is amazing.
Response from sweetflag (Author of A Fine Divide)
Since becoming a bit under the weather, I've become more tolerant of physical issues and pain, but losing my mind is something that scares the bejeebus out of me. I use my mind to overcome aches and pains, so to have it wither would end me. I can think of nothing worse to inflict upon an individual and those they care about than the destruction of personality and strength of mind. I despise diseases and other agents that work to destroy the brain and mind.
Response from sweetflag (Author of A Fine Divide)
Since becoming a bit under the weather, I've become more tolerant of physical issues and pain, but losing my mind is something that scares the bejeebus out of me. I use my mind to overcome aches and pains, so to have it wither would end me. I can think of nothing worse to inflict upon an individual and those they care about than the destruction of personality and strength of mind. I despise diseases and other agents that work to destroy the brain and mind.
So much to comment on in this chapter. the new garden - with its symbolism of unity and caring between the Houses. Clematis is a beautiful idea - and fascinating to see how Severus had helped Pomona to cultivate it. This makes me think about the possibilities of collaboration between Snape and Longbottom for the two cures that they will seek (I hope). I love the way you described the new stone growing out of the old - emphasising the organic nature of the castle. The staff meeting was lovely - and we see again Minerva's friendship for Severus and how he responds to it. Brilliant writing.
Response from sweetflag (Author of A Fine Divide)
To be honest, I couldn't see Snape wallowing. Not that I could see him being all altruistic either. Pomona, although not featured in the books to a great extent, always struck me as a resolute and determined person. It seemed natural that Snape and Pomona would gravitate to each other, even if it started out as a simple request for better fertiliser. The two subjects--Herbology and Potions--seem too connected for the teachers not to have some overlapping interests. I wanted to unite the Houses. There was a tendency to an excess of over-competitiveness (I say this after considering my daughter who screamed out in frustration during her 'friendly' football match with another school--nothing rude, by the way).
Response from sweetflag (Author of A Fine Divide)
To be honest, I couldn't see Snape wallowing. Not that I could see him being all altruistic either. Pomona, although not featured in the books to a great extent, always struck me as a resolute and determined person. It seemed natural that Snape and Pomona would gravitate to each other, even if it started out as a simple request for better fertiliser. The two subjects--Herbology and Potions--seem too connected for the teachers not to have some overlapping interests. I wanted to unite the Houses. There was a tendency to an excess of over-competitiveness (I say this after considering my daughter who screamed out in frustration during her 'friendly' football match with another school--nothing rude, by the way).
Love this chapter - the particular way that you are drawing our their shared experiences and shared attitudes. Even thought they are quite different people, there is definitly a connection between them. The mystery of Neville's parents' condition shadows the other mystery of why Snape can't brew his own version of the blue potion - I am hoping that together they will be able to solve both mysteries.
Response from sweetflag (Author of A Fine Divide)
Shared purpose is a great unifier. The enemy of my enemy and all that. I guess the phrase 'misery loves company' springs to mind for me, but we often do seek like-minded individuals because nothing will ever beat that feeling of connection and understanding between people.
Response from sweetflag (Author of A Fine Divide)
Shared purpose is a great unifier. The enemy of my enemy and all that. I guess the phrase 'misery loves company' springs to mind for me, but we often do seek like-minded individuals because nothing will ever beat that feeling of connection and understanding between people.
Loving the teasing relationship between the Receptionist and her coworker - well drawn! Also the horror of Snape's binding to the Ministry is becoming clearer - this is a terrific idea, sweetflag. He is under a yoke every bit as horrible as Voldemort's - made even more so by the fact that the Ministry are supposed ot be the good guys.... Loving this story.
Response from sweetflag (Author of A Fine Divide)
Thank you. I like old biddies. I was taken with the notion of how easily we place these yokes upon ourselves, thinking that we're doing something for the best. There are these immense ideas we use to burden either ourselves or others. You're right with the Ministry... they place burdens that are accepted solely because they come from such a place. I'm not wise enough to see which burdens should be given or accepted... I think this is a wisdom we have to learn the hard way.
Response from sweetflag (Author of A Fine Divide)
Thank you. I like old biddies. I was taken with the notion of how easily we place these yokes upon ourselves, thinking that we're doing something for the best. There are these immense ideas we use to burden either ourselves or others. You're right with the Ministry... they place burdens that are accepted solely because they come from such a place. I'm not wise enough to see which burdens should be given or accepted... I think this is a wisdom we have to learn the hard way.
Neville to the rescue - and what a rescue! Stil lsmiling at the idea of Snape as damsel in distress (on a rock for goodness sakes!) - and yet you undercut the humour with such bitter gall. I'm as intrigued by Neville's anger - as Snape is. It is hard sometimes to meet someone in later life that you knew (and dismissed pretty much) as a child. Loving Snape's insecurities and weakness - which somehow does not leave him soft - only damaged. Really excellent writing.
Response from sweetflag (Author of A Fine Divide)
I enjoyed writing this chapter. I'm smiling now as I'm recalling it. It is interesting when--as adults--we meet people from our childhood; giants of men seem smaller and those who, as you say, we dismissed, suddenly impact upon us. Thank you for the lovely compliment.
Response from sweetflag (Author of A Fine Divide)
I enjoyed writing this chapter. I'm smiling now as I'm recalling it. It is interesting when--as adults--we meet people from our childhood; giants of men seem smaller and those who, as you say, we dismissed, suddenly impact upon us. Thank you for the lovely compliment.
I realised with great embarassment that I have not reviewed all your chapters. Time ot put that right! I think the premise of this story is intriguing. Love the fact that the Ministry have such a creepy hold over Severus - it is abusive and horrible, but he is still finding little ways to exert his independence. Neville's character is beautifully drawn.
Response from sweetflag (Author of A Fine Divide)
Dear
Response from sweetflag (Author of A Fine Divide)
, do not fret. Thank you for your kind words and your time. I enjoy this feedback, as it helps me refine my own ideas. More often than not, a reader will see something that I hadn't.
Response from sweetflag (Author of A Fine Divide)
Dear
Response from sweetflag (Author of A Fine Divide)
, do not fret. Thank you for your kind words and your time. I enjoy this feedback, as it helps me refine my own ideas. More often than not, a reader will see something that I hadn't.