I'm embarassed to admit I'm teary eyed. It's beatiful, and sad. And yet, happy as well. I don't know, I don't think I'm explaining myself well. Anyway, it's definitely something worth reading over again. Wonderful job!

Very nice-bittersweet and with just enough detail to present a lovely story. I liked how it was told from McGonagal's perspective.

Simply beautiful.

**Applauds**So sad, and yet a form of happy ending.

Nifty.... neat approach... I like the narrative!

Oh, how sad!  It is so very bittersweet.  Considering McGonagall calls them the Yule ghosts, does that mean that they are only together for the waltz after each year's ball? I would hate to think that they could only be together once a year.

Very sweet. And almost a happy ending!  Look forward to more from you.  Thank you for this story.

My dear Sun suggested me to come and take a look because she was sure I'd love this one, and she was right. I simply love this kind of angst that gives the hope of eternal love beyond death and you handled it perfectly. I think the concept is like the epitome of love because it survives everything, and I have used it in my fics a couple of times with good results IMO. Well done. Definitely I have to check the rest of your fics.

Oh, wow! That is heart-wrenching and happy at the same time! Lovely!

Of course you know, I adore this. I really like the way McGonagall tells the story. Nicely done.