New Chapter for In the Valley of the Lily
In the Valley of the Lily
Amita8 Reviews | 7.5/10 (8 Ratings, 0 Likes, 6 Favorites )
Chapters (2)
About Amita
Author
Amita
Member Since 2009 | 55 Stories | Favorited by 15 | 186 Reviews Written | 438 Review Responses
Reviews for In the Valley of the Lily
Enjoyed her discovery of his Dark books and the different point of views, Tom keeping mum and letting her own conclusions--loved the Scarlet Pimpernel reference--HA! So fitting! And the almost conflicting feelings, his being drawn to Lily, his appreciation of Bellatrix, his ultimate goals winning out over a fleeting second of vulnerability with Lily, and the poignancy of her thoughts, his, and the ending. Thrilled that one of my favourite Georgian Poets was included--unsettlingly appropriate here, even in a parody form, as both relating to his feeling towards Lily and revealing another deeper look into a part of Tom. Intriguing and engaging!
Response from Amita (Author of In the Valley of the Lily)
If things were slightly different, they would be a good couple. The good girl Lily would have an endless project in Tom, and Tom is one of the few who could survive her goodness. But Tom is a badder boy than she realizes, and Tom, like Giovanni, like Mozart, can do naught else. The canon dictum, 'Love, the emotion the Dark Lord knows not,' is cast into doubt as being a construction of a chronicler who believes the world is saved through the magic of motherly love. If this relationship had developed, Harry would find himself in the position of Hamlet or Luke Skywalker, but that would be an even darker tale.Thank you for all the choice comments.
There is a wonderful, insidious pleasure building between these two--Tom seems in control at present, stealthy and observant--his cynicism deliciously palpable; the green-eyed one oblivious, except for her compelling energy and need to be 'good' and helpful and assertive to preoccupy herself with beyond her own domestic obligations--intriguing scenario between these two!
Response from Amita (Author of In the Valley of the Lily)
I think this qualifies as a rare pair. Lily is attracted to a harmless old man who needs improvement, but she may be even more attracted when she discovers how powerful he is. Tom is concluding that one can take only so much goodness and improvement. Thanks for reading this.
Absolutely brilliant! Fabulously original. Wow! I am so impressed by this twisted little tale of friendship, perhaps even love on some level.
Response from Amita (Author of In the Valley of the Lily)
Thanks. It wasn't easy to write two light-hearted chapters while knowing what is going to happen.
And the next time he saw her he said, "Stand aside, you silly girl..." You outdid yourself. I imagine this chapter will stand out as one of the best you've ever written. It's one of the best I've ever read.
Response from Amita (Author of In the Valley of the Lily)
Ah, yes, they will meet again two months from this story's end. Outdid myself? Gee, I hope not. Something in this chapter must have resonated with you. Hope it's not a spoiler to say that the early chapters of 'Perseus' have romance-at-a-distance with the heroine somewhat clueless.
Response from Rose of the West (Reviewer)
I didn't review a lot, because it's hard to pick out any one thing, but it's one of those perfect chapters. You have us right in there with sweet mundane things and a little humor. Then you take us out into a wider view to show how this fits into the whole of his master plan, then we go back narrow again to passion and UST and bittersweet what-ifs and as it finished, the horror of what their next meeting will be just grabbed me. There's such a mingling of a lot of flavors there, in just the right proportions.I hope you're enjoying Perseus. It's such a contrast to your view of that witch but some of the same forces at play. She's been brought up to see the business end of marriage and the whole other part of the transaction will take some getting used to. She's a quick learner, though.
Hrmmm, interesting. Naughty Tom, bad boy. Stop hitting on younger women!
Response from Amita (Author of In the Valley of the Lily)
Thanks. Somehow, in this one, he is both a bad boy and the innocent party.
Anonymous
That was a well crafted and intriguing piece!
Well done!
Author's Response:
Thanks. A fellow author finding a piece well-crafted is a welcome compliment.
EdgeOfDark's response: You're quite welcome! Feel free to reciprocate!
Mwahaha indeed. This is a very interesting take on that question brought up by the otoher story. It appears that the tables are turned. This is quite charming, in its creepy way.
Response from Amita (Author of In the Valley of the Lily)
Is Lily turning the tables on him, or is she, like the Black sisters, finding what she wants in him? Would Lily be attracted to someone full of good intentions?
Response from Rose of the West (Reviewer)
I hadn't thought of that, but you're right. Her greatest need is to be a better person than those around her. He's discovering that he has needs, too, though, so this relationship fulfills a mutual need. There was some movie or TV show that described love/romance as two mutually compatable psychoses finding each other. It seems apt, here.
Interesting. I hope you update soon! I like the way that they are interacting.
Response from Amita (Author of In the Valley of the Lily)
Thanks. I planned a one shot. I wrote part of a second chapter, but the story would have to go AU or spiral into doom.