Also beautiful, I think.  I look forward to more of your work.   Thank you.

that was beautifully done.  thanks so much

What about Colin Creevy? and Professor Quirrel (Moldyvort killed him too) and Doby !?!

*wipes tears* This is so beautiful. Each one of them deserves the recognition of the public. I was holding back tears but Tonks and little orphan Teddy were the final blow.

Wow! I love the "old reel" flicker and the "presumably dead" Snape. Fantastic job!

On my goodness, that was so heart wrenching! Fantastic!

Very touching memorial to the fallen. Nicely done.

Such a lovely tribute. Simple, but very effective.

I loved this, very creative. Thank you.

hmm, what of all the others who died.? and i would think a video of that purpose would refrain from usingthe word "killed" .

this is well done - but Dobby!!!  no Dobby?  (snifs)Dobby is a very under-rated character, full of goodness and sweetness and virtue.  Still it was well done, and being done by Muggle-borns, maybe they are mostly unaware of house-elves.  (there's your out!)  So that way Dobby's absence becomes a typical instance of the repression house-elves suffer from every day.  In this case, the Muggle-borns do not even know about them and all their service to humans.

Wow, that was so excellent.  Simple and elegant - just as a memorial should be.

An excellent idea and very nice and thoughtful execution. Only, as far as I know, it should be spelled "in memoriam", not "in memorium"

Very nicely done. Good choice of music as well. :)

Very understated and very moving.

Nice music selection.  Very reflective.  I liked what you said about Fred. 

What a lovely tribute.

Very nicely done! The "old film" quality, as well as the music (with the out-of-tune piano music) really add a lot to the ethereal quality of this piece.

I thought the video was very creative! The music choice helped to pull at the heartstrings. I was curious though, where was Dobby? Also, I liked how you wrote about Snape "presumably dead!" The hope lives on :)Livvy

Simple, but effective! :)

This is powerful in its very simplicity. Nicely done!

A very touching tribute.  Thank you.

Very moving in its simplicity. Thank you for "presumably dead" for Snape. I needed that little bit of hope today.

Very touching, and I liked the scratchy quality of the film and the understated music.  And I loved that you stated that Severus Snape was presumed to have died during the Battle of Hogwarts, but that when his body was not found and no portrait appeared, some believed that he still lived.  I believe that, too!

Well done!
Beth

This was a lovely piece. I thought the concept was quite good. There were some minor flaws in its execution, but all in all, you did a fine job.