I must say Slughorn could have been impressed by their brewing skills and not report detention. It's Polyjuice Potion after all.

Prats! Creative but I'm tickled they were busted. Thanks for the laughs as I imagined them kissing each toad as part of the charm to remove their warts. ;D

So I take it they got Remus and Peter to go instead?  No wonder they couldn't act the parts well enough. 

Good try, boys! :)

Just like them to send someone in their stead. =)

Very cute, and very creative!  And I hope they get busted again. AV

LOL oh that was a good one!  I especially kike that they got caught!

I'm glad Slughorn saw through it! I hope he thinks of something nastier for them to do than pulling warts off toads! Poor Severus.

Bwahahahaha!  That's a good one, Hermione!  Too bad they couldn't pull the wool over Sluggy's eyes! ;)

Great idea.  I'm surprised more students don't do it.