The Petulant Poetess
  • Stories
  • Browse By
    • Category
    • Character
    • Genre
    • Author
  • Info
      Useful Info
    • General Information
    • Message Board
    • Membership & Story Ratings
    • Submission Rules
    • Important Links
    • Support The Petulant Poetess
    • Writers' Resources
    • Punctuation Guide
    • Writing Fan Fiction
    • Harry Potter Resources
    • Dictionaries
    • Beta Resources
  • Create an Account
    • Create an Account
    • Sign In
Hogwarts Castle A Long Vernal Season
Chapters Menu
Download PDF Version

New Chapter for A Long Vernal Season

A Long Vernal Season

1: Prologue: Return

2: Chapter One: Hermione’s News

3: Chapter Two: An Unusual Invitation

4: Chapter Three: St. Giles Clinic for Magical Maladies

5: Chapter Four: Through the Looking-Glass

6: Chapter Five: Alternative Treatment

7: Chapter Six: Race Cars Go “Vroom”

8: Chapter Seven: Waxing

9: Chapter Eight: Business as Usual

10: Chapter Nine: A Delicate Phase

11: Chapter Ten: Jam Tarts

12: Chapter Eleven: Don’t Frighten the Firsties

13: Chapter Twelve: The Stages of Brewing

14: Chapter Thirteen: Breakfire

15: Chapter Fourteen: Of Ice Cream, Kittens, and Jet Planes

16: Chapter Fifteen: Bacon Butties and Baked Beans

17: Chapter Sixteen: A Sympathetic New Start

18: Chapter Seventeen: An Ambush for Minerva

19: Chapter Eighteen: A New Man

20: Chapter Nineteen: Of Scotch, Choices, and Ambiguity

21: Chapter Twenty: A Ghostly Halloween

22: Chapter Twenty-One: Fancy Dress

23: Chapter Twenty-Two: Not Onerous or Dreary

24: Chapter Twenty-Three: Collegiality

25: Chapter Twenty-Four: Dawn Light Reflected

26: Chapter Twenty-Five: Preoccupation

27: Chapter Twenty-Six: Laid to Rest

28: Chapter Twenty-Seven: ’Twas the Night Before the Night Before Christmas

29: Chapter Twenty-Eight: A Happy Birthday?

30: Chapter Twenty-Nine: A Tear Shed

31: Chapter Thirty: A Tour of the Past

32: Chapter Thirty-One: A Date with Hermione

33: Chapter Thirty-Two: Disquiet

34: Chapter Thirty-Three: At Spinner’s End

35: Chapter Thirty-Four: Uncertainty

36: Chapter Thirty-Five: Friendship

37: Chapter Thirty-Six: A Darkly Smouldering Magnetism

38: Chapter Thirty-Seven: An Exercise in Harmless Flirting

39: Chapter Thirty-Eight: Playing with Fire

40: Chapter Thirty-Nine: The Morning After

41: Chapter Forty: A Matter of Timing

42: Chapter Forty-One: A Fast Learner

43: Chapter Forty-Two: Confessions

44: Chapter Forty-Three: Distractions

45: Chapter Forty-Four: No Unmixed Pleasures

46: Chapter Forty-Five: An Esoteric Spell

47: Chapter Forty-Six: A Complicated Life

48: Chapter Forty-Seven: Exotic Concoctions

49: Chapter Forty-Eight: A Wager with the Headmistress

50: Chapter Forty-Nine: Normal Life

51: Chapter Fifty: A New Project

52: Chapter Fifty-One: Just a Fling?

53: Chapter Fifty-Two: Technique

54: Chapter Fifty-Three: Dinner at Delancie’s

55: Chapter Fifty-Four: Dangerous Consequences

56: Chapter Fifty-Five: Not Falling in Love

57: Chapter Fifty-Six: Out-of-Sorts

58: Chapter Fifty-Seven: Making it Through the Week

59: Chapter Fifty-Eight: The Barghest’s Howl

60: Chapter Fifty-Nine: Skimming the Lake

61: Chapter Sixty: Perfect Timing

62: Chapter Sixty-One: Late Night Advice

63: Chapter Sixty-Two: For Old Times’ Sake

64: Chapter Sixty-Three: A Little White Lie

65: Chapter Sixty-Four: The Goblin’s Knee

66: Chapter Sixty-Five: Test Flight

67: Chapter Sixty-Six: Broomstick Rodeo

68: Chapter Sixty-Seven: Some Muggle Business

69: Chapter Sixty-Eight: Bad Timing

70: Chapter Sixty-Nine: Moulting

71: Chapter Seventy: To Persist and Pursue

72: Chapter Seventy-One: Descent into Hades

73: Chapter Seventy-Two: Home

74: Chapter Seventy-Three: Renovation

75: Chapter Seventy-Four: Glimpse the Snape Family Past

76: Chapter Seventy-Five: A Wizard Not to be Crossed

77: Chapter Seventy-Six: Present Danger

78: Chapter Seventy-Seven: Paying Court

79: Chapter Seventy-Eight: Sifting the Past

80: Chapter Seventy-Nine: Atmosphere

81: Chapter Eighty: Finding Flowers and Family

82: Chapter Eighty-One: Lighting

83: Chapter Eighty-Two: An End to a Perfect Evening

84: Chapter Eighty-Three: Attack in a Blur

85: Chapter Eighty-Four: Suspicion

86: Chapter Eighty-Five: Jumping at Shadows

87: Chapter Eighty-Six: Remedying Magical Misfortune

88: Chapter Eighty-Seven: Brewing with the Master

89: Chapter Eighty-Eight: Back to Brewing

90: Chapter Eighty-Nine: A Cryptic Missive

91: Chapter Ninety: A Happy Decision

92: Chapter Ninety-One: A Proposal

93: Chapter Ninety-Two: Promising Start to a Holiday

94: Chapter Ninety-Three: Whetting the Appetite

95: Chapter Ninety-Four: The Rewards of Patience

96: Chapter Ninety-Five: Afternoon Games

97: Chapter Ninety-Six: An Unexpected Encounter

98: Chapter Ninety-Seven: Another Splash of Whiskey

99: Chapter Ninety-Eight: Confidences and Promises

100: Chapter Ninety-Nine: Memory Lane

101: Chapter One Hundred: Some Truth

102: Chapter One-Hundred One: Simply Severus

103: Chapter One-Hundred Two: Meeting Max

104: Chapter One Hundred-Three: Of Lilacs, of Love, and of Danger

105: Chapter One Hundred-Four: Party Games

106: Chapter One Hundred-Five: An Assignation

107: Chapter One Hundred-Six: Refuge

108: Chapter One Hundred-Seven: Reparation

109: Chapter One Hundred-Eight: The Greatest Slytherin

110: Chapter One Hundred-Nine: Vita Furtiva

111: Chapter One Hundred-Ten: Journey to Dun Torc

112: Chapter One Hundred-Eleven: An Accident Foretold

113: Chapter One Hundred-Twelve: Association

114: Chapter One Hundred-Thirteen: The Past Follows

115: Chapter One Hundred-Fourteen: Arithmantic Charms

116: Chapter One Hundred-Fifteen: Dead … or Alive?

117: Chapter One Hundred-Sixteen: The Tyree Estate

118: Chapter One Hundred-Seventeen: From the Primrose Cottage to the Shell Folly

A Long Vernal Season

MMADfan

1,058 Reviews   |   1,058 Ratings, 0 Likes, 88 Favorites )

Mystery/Suspense Drama Romance Alternate Universe Hogwarts Castle 652,726 Words 136 Chapters WIP
Albus Dumbledore Filius Flitwick Hermione Granger Minerva McGonagall Poppy Pomfrey Severus Snape Lucius Malfoy Pomona Sprout Original Character Other Canon Witch/Wizard Narcissa Malfoy Rubeus Hagrid Hogwarts Eileen (Prince) Snape Tobias Snape Draco Malfoy Professor Vector The Fat Friar Madam Rosmerta Alastor (Mad-Eye) Moody Firenze (Centaur) Professor Sinistra Name Withheld (surprise) Ginevra Weasley Arthur Weasley Wilhelmina Grubbly-Plank Harry Potter Fawkes Bellatrix Lestrange Peter Pettigrew Nymphadora Tonks Remus Lupin Sorting Hat

Severus Snape had believed that, for him, life after the Dark Lord was an impossibility, that his death was not merely justice, but necessity. He has survived, though, and now he must learn to live his new, unexpected life, and to find something beyond the narrow existence to which he was once bound. A Snape-centric post-war fic.

A Death’s Dominion sequel, but may stand alone. Not DH-compliant. DH-disregarded. Rated M for overall content. Much of it is "T," but the ratings rise to MA later for a reason, hence the switch to an M-rating for the earlier chapters. Watch the individual chapter summaries and author’s notes for ratings, warnings, and the characters appearing in that chapter.


Part One finds Severus dealing with some very immediate and dangerous consequences of his final confrontation with the Dark Lord more than three months before.

Start Reading

Chapters (118)

Chapter 1: Prologue: Return

Chapter 2: Chapter One: Hermione’s News

Chapter 3: Chapter Two: An Unusual Invitation

Chapter 4: Chapter Three: St. Giles Clinic for Magical Maladies

Chapter 5: Chapter Four: Through the Looking-Glass

Chapter 6: Chapter Five: Alternative Treatment

Chapter 7: Chapter Six: Race Cars Go “Vroom”

Chapter 8: Chapter Seven: Waxing

Chapter 9: Chapter Eight: Business as Usual

Chapter 10: Chapter Nine: A Delicate Phase

Chapter 11: Chapter Ten: Jam Tarts

Chapter 12: Chapter Eleven: Don’t Frighten the Firsties

Chapter 13: Chapter Twelve: The Stages of Brewing

Chapter 14: Chapter Thirteen: Breakfire

Chapter 15: Chapter Fourteen: Of Ice Cream, Kittens, and Jet Planes

Chapter 16: Chapter Fifteen: Bacon Butties and Baked Beans

Chapter 17: Chapter Sixteen: A Sympathetic New Start

Chapter 18: Chapter Seventeen: An Ambush for Minerva

Chapter 19: Chapter Eighteen: A New Man

Chapter 20: Chapter Nineteen: Of Scotch, Choices, and Ambiguity

Chapter 21: Chapter Twenty: A Ghostly Halloween

Chapter 22: Chapter Twenty-One: Fancy Dress

Chapter 23: Chapter Twenty-Two: Not Onerous or Dreary

Chapter 24: Chapter Twenty-Three: Collegiality

Chapter 25: Chapter Twenty-Four: Dawn Light Reflected

Chapter 26: Chapter Twenty-Five: Preoccupation

Chapter 27: Chapter Twenty-Six: Laid to Rest

Chapter 28: Chapter Twenty-Seven: ’Twas the Night Before the Night Before Christmas

Chapter 29: Chapter Twenty-Eight: A Happy Birthday?

Chapter 30: Chapter Twenty-Nine: A Tear Shed

Chapter 31: Chapter Thirty: A Tour of the Past

Chapter 32: Chapter Thirty-One: A Date with Hermione

Chapter 33: Chapter Thirty-Two: Disquiet

Chapter 34: Chapter Thirty-Three: At Spinner’s End

Chapter 35: Chapter Thirty-Four: Uncertainty

Chapter 36: Chapter Thirty-Five: Friendship

Chapter 37: Chapter Thirty-Six: A Darkly Smouldering Magnetism

Chapter 38: Chapter Thirty-Seven: An Exercise in Harmless Flirting

Chapter 39: Chapter Thirty-Eight: Playing with Fire

Chapter 40: Chapter Thirty-Nine: The Morning After

Chapter 41: Chapter Forty: A Matter of Timing

Chapter 42: Chapter Forty-One: A Fast Learner

Chapter 43: Chapter Forty-Two: Confessions

Chapter 44: Chapter Forty-Three: Distractions

Chapter 45: Chapter Forty-Four: No Unmixed Pleasures

Chapter 46: Chapter Forty-Five: An Esoteric Spell

Chapter 47: Chapter Forty-Six: A Complicated Life

Chapter 48: Chapter Forty-Seven: Exotic Concoctions

Chapter 49: Chapter Forty-Eight: A Wager with the Headmistress

Chapter 50: Chapter Forty-Nine: Normal Life

Chapter 51: Chapter Fifty: A New Project

Chapter 52: Chapter Fifty-One: Just a Fling?

Chapter 53: Chapter Fifty-Two: Technique

Chapter 54: Chapter Fifty-Three: Dinner at Delancie’s

Chapter 55: Chapter Fifty-Four: Dangerous Consequences

Chapter 56: Chapter Fifty-Five: Not Falling in Love

Chapter 57: Chapter Fifty-Six: Out-of-Sorts

Chapter 58: Chapter Fifty-Seven: Making it Through the Week

Chapter 59: Chapter Fifty-Eight: The Barghest’s Howl

Chapter 60: Chapter Fifty-Nine: Skimming the Lake

Chapter 61: Chapter Sixty: Perfect Timing

Chapter 62: Chapter Sixty-One: Late Night Advice

Chapter 63: Chapter Sixty-Two: For Old Times’ Sake

Chapter 64: Chapter Sixty-Three: A Little White Lie

Chapter 65: Chapter Sixty-Four: The Goblin’s Knee

Chapter 66: Chapter Sixty-Five: Test Flight

Chapter 67: Chapter Sixty-Six: Broomstick Rodeo

Chapter 68: Chapter Sixty-Seven: Some Muggle Business

Chapter 69: Chapter Sixty-Eight: Bad Timing

Chapter 70: Chapter Sixty-Nine: Moulting

Chapter 71: Chapter Seventy: To Persist and Pursue

Chapter 72: Chapter Seventy-One: Descent into Hades

Chapter 73: Chapter Seventy-Two: Home

Chapter 74: Chapter Seventy-Three: Renovation

Chapter 75: Chapter Seventy-Four: Glimpse the Snape Family Past

Chapter 76: Chapter Seventy-Five: A Wizard Not to be Crossed

Chapter 77: Chapter Seventy-Six: Present Danger

Chapter 78: Chapter Seventy-Seven: Paying Court

Chapter 79: Chapter Seventy-Eight: Sifting the Past

Chapter 80: Chapter Seventy-Nine: Atmosphere

Chapter 81: Chapter Eighty: Finding Flowers and Family

Chapter 82: Chapter Eighty-One: Lighting

Chapter 83: Chapter Eighty-Two: An End to a Perfect Evening

Chapter 84: Chapter Eighty-Three: Attack in a Blur

Chapter 85: Chapter Eighty-Four: Suspicion

Chapter 86: Chapter Eighty-Five: Jumping at Shadows

Chapter 87: Chapter Eighty-Six: Remedying Magical Misfortune

Chapter 88: Chapter Eighty-Seven: Brewing with the Master

Chapter 89: Chapter Eighty-Eight: Back to Brewing

Chapter 90: Chapter Eighty-Nine: A Cryptic Missive

Chapter 91: Chapter Ninety: A Happy Decision

Chapter 92: Chapter Ninety-One: A Proposal

Chapter 93: Chapter Ninety-Two: Promising Start to a Holiday

Chapter 94: Chapter Ninety-Three: Whetting the Appetite

Chapter 95: Chapter Ninety-Four: The Rewards of Patience

Chapter 96: Chapter Ninety-Five: Afternoon Games

Chapter 97: Chapter Ninety-Six: An Unexpected Encounter

Chapter 98: Chapter Ninety-Seven: Another Splash of Whiskey

Chapter 99: Chapter Ninety-Eight: Confidences and Promises

Chapter 100: Chapter Ninety-Nine: Memory Lane

Chapter 101: Chapter One Hundred: Some Truth

Chapter 102: Chapter One-Hundred One: Simply Severus

Chapter 103: Chapter One-Hundred Two: Meeting Max

Chapter 104: Chapter One Hundred-Three: Of Lilacs, of Love, and of Danger

Chapter 105: Chapter One Hundred-Four: Party Games

Chapter 106: Chapter One Hundred-Five: An Assignation

Chapter 107: Chapter One Hundred-Six: Refuge

Chapter 108: Chapter One Hundred-Seven: Reparation

Chapter 109: Chapter One Hundred-Eight: The Greatest Slytherin

Chapter 110: Chapter One Hundred-Nine: Vita Furtiva

Chapter 111: Chapter One Hundred-Ten: Journey to Dun Torc

Chapter 112: Chapter One Hundred-Eleven: An Accident Foretold

Chapter 113: Chapter One Hundred-Twelve: Association

Chapter 114: Chapter One Hundred-Thirteen: The Past Follows

Chapter 115: Chapter One Hundred-Fourteen: Arithmantic Charms

Chapter 116: Chapter One Hundred-Fifteen: Dead … or Alive?

Chapter 117: Chapter One Hundred-Sixteen: The Tyree Estate

Chapter 118: Chapter One Hundred-Seventeen: From the Primrose Cottage to the Shell Folly


About MMADfan

Validated
Author

MMADfan

41 Stories  |  Favorited by 312  |  127 Reviews Written  |  4,741 Review Responses

Note 10 December 2015: I've been unable to write fanfic the last couple years, but I haven't abandoned my works-in-progress!

Many of my completed fics are available for download in ebook format through my blog and LJ.

Perfect Imagination accredited beta. PI:7311261659.

More about me here.

Author Website
http://mmadfan.com/
Also Archived At
<a href="http://archiveofourown.org/users/MMADfan/works" target="_blank">An Archive of Our Own</a>; <a href="http://mmadfan.com/read-fanfic/" target="_blank">MMADfan's Fanfic Hub</a>; and <a href = "http://www.fanfiction.net/u/1216581/" target = "_blank">FanFiction.net</a>. Some older fics also on the Sycophant Hex archives.

Reviews for A Long Vernal Season

Displaying Review 1051 - 1058 of 1058 in total
← Previous 1 2 … 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 Next →
10/10

makaem

So in this one Snape's  a replacement for Krum. Nice switch.

Response from MMADfan (Author of A Long Vernal Season)

Thanks -- I hadn't thought of that until I reread the chapter recently, myself, how people use Krum as a Snape-like guy for Hermione, etc. (Wasn't the movie version of Krum a surprise? He looked nothing at all like my particular mental image of him from the books, anyway.) I actually did the Krum/Benetti pairing in DD in order to bring Helena into the RaMverse.Thanks for the review. :-) Glad you enjoyed it!

0/10

oenthusiast

That was a lovely flight. And I think Severus is beginning to develop some ability to read people in social situations.

Response from MMADfan (Author of A Long Vernal Season)

I'm gla you liked the flight! :-) Thanks for the review!

10/10

mimmom

Interesting.  I like seeing Severus trying to get out and do things even though he's feeling quite negative.  I can't wait to see how things work out.  Malcolm's Song was a cool thing.

Response from MMADfan (Author of A Long Vernal Season)

Thanks! I'm glad you enjoyed it!

10/10

mimmom

Lots of Snapes thoughts here, which I love.  He is well aware of the things on which he needs to work but knowing isn't always helpful in practice even to pretty well-adjusted people, poor Severus.  He is a good person and he just wants a nice life without so much turmoil but inner turmoil is impossible for him to avoid.  He will improve, he seems very motivated to improve.  I enjoy reading all these internal battles he has with himself.

Response from MMADfan (Author of A Long Vernal Season)

I'm glad you're enjoying the Snape-introspection in these chapters. As you say, even for a well-adjusted person, it can be tough to make changes even when we know what it is we need to work on and what our weaknesses are. For someone who's had as strange and abnormal a background as Severus, and no truly normal relationships with people during his adult life (and, as far as we know, precious few when he was a kid), it's even tougher. He's an ambitious Slytherin, though, and his ambition has become to have as "normal" and basically rewarding a life as he can. He won't find that easy, though, and lifetime habits can be hard to break.Thanks for the review!

10/10

mimmom

I like the way this worked out.  They do need to step back.  Poor Severus is working so hard and wrestling with all the things he never felt, never could afford to feel, while he was a spy.  These kinds of conflicts come up a lot with people who haven't had a lot of misery in their lives.  So it makes sense it would happen with Poppy and Severus.  I like when I can read about what Snape is thinking.  Like when he says that his apology made no difference.  Poor thing.  I wish I could give him a hug. 

Response from MMADfan (Author of A Long Vernal Season)

He does feel as though somehow, now that he is trying harder and apologizing, and so forth, that it should somehow change things for him, but he's still as outcast as he used to be -- in his own mind. I'm glad you liked the chapter. Thanks for reviewing! Happy New Year!

10/10

esmelle

Oh I loved Malcolm's Song.  As I was reading it I guessed that it referred to Malcolm McGonagall (any chance of bringing him back from the dead? - just kidding).  What a nice tribute.  Glad to see Wilhelmina back and making Hagrid happy.  How exciting that Hagrid gets to finish his education.  I never thought that it was fair in the books that that subject wasn't addressed after it was revealed that Hagrid wasn't responsible for the crime he was accused of.  Although Severus wasn't having the best of times, I think he'll find it was worth his while to join his colleagues.  Sometimes attending informal work functions pay off in improved collegial relationships.  I wonder if he is going to move on to Helena now.  Poor Poppy.  BTW-what's with Pomona and the prejudice against Slytherin?  I think Gertrude needs to straighten her out.   

Response from MMADfan (Author of A Long Vernal Season)

Oh, (RaMverse) Pomona's always had a bit of a knee-jerk grumbly reaction to Slytherin, which doesn't (usually) translate into a direct prejudice against individual Slytherins -- it just got worse over the previous 20-or-so years! (Don't know if you read "Now is Perfect," but we get a glimpse of that when she learns that Filius is going out w/ Minerva's Slytherin cousin . . . ;-))If the RaM sequel ever gets written, we'll see more of Malcolm -- I have kind of skipped over that fic, although I have notes and a partial outline for it, and have had for a couple years, at least -- and we'll see that Malcolm actually wrote that song and it is one of the ones that he sang for Gertrude on that day they met at Minerva's party. So it was fun for me to work that into this chapter. Thanks for the review! Happy New Year!

Response from esmelle (Reviewer)

Happy New Year to you too!  I like Malcom's Song even more now knowing its history.  I'll have to go back and re-read Now is Perfect.  Its been awhile.  I'll keep my fingers crossed for the RaM sequel, but no pressure.  I'm thoroughly enjoying A Long Vernal Season.     

10/10

Riposto

Well, Severus is improving somewhat with casual social interaction. He managed an entire evening without deliberately insulting or provoking anyone, and even managed a bit of chivalry. Helena better be careful, walking home with a wizard who's miserable, jealous, and horny-as-hell. He really does need an Easter vacation, to get out of that castle and stop feeling so put-upon. Or is Albus planning to send him to a wizarding resort in the North Sea??I seem to remember that Grubbly-Plank and Hagrid had a thing with each other back when he was very young. Was that in the RAM-verse or am I mixing up my stories?The last few encounters Severus has had with Hermione have been very interesting. And enlightening. I suppose she's still hurt and angry, and I'm guessing from the way she has twice accused Severus of trying to rig the Quidditch outcomes that she's no longer seeing him through the hero-worship lenses, but I'm really surprised that he's not more hurt and angry than he is by her attitude. It is good to know that she is still subject to adolescent tempers of her own, though. Makes her more interesting, you know?

Response from MMADfan (Author of A Long Vernal Season)

Yes, Hermione's mature and extremely intelligent, but she's still got her adolescent temper -- though she's not sending birds to attack Severus, a la Wonnie-kins! LOL! -- and she is not seeing him in quite the same light as she did. She's also got other stuff in her life now -- out of Hogwarts, in an apprenticeship, making new, non-Hogwarts friends -- so she's affected by that as well as the fact that the war's over. I'm glad you find it makes her a bit more interesting!Yep, you're remembering correctly -- that's RaM-verse. Grubbly-Plank was at Hogwarts teaching CoMC for a while, then she got a job at a dragon preserve and left, with Hagrid somewhat broken-hearted.Helena has a light-hearted approach to life, although she's had a lot of pain recently, so she might be a bit of a leavening influence on Severus. We'll see . . .  Thanks very much for the review!

10/10

mimmom

Oh Severus, so quict to jump to conclusions.  So many years of disappointment and sadness, it's hard to break the old pattern of thoughts.  Poor thing.

Response from MMADfan (Author of A Long Vernal Season)

So many hurts and disappointments have conditioned him to be prepared for it. It is sad!Thanks for the review!

Response from mimmom (Reviewer)

That's why he needs fanfic writers who love him and understand him and want to make it all better.  LOL.  I don't think I'd want to meet JKR for fear I'd tell her just how annoyed I am with her.  LOL.  Not that I didn't EXPECT things to end the way they did, he's a tragic character and that's how it goes.  Still, to write him in ways that make people feel a certain empathy for him and then claim we like bad boys....sorry, I've said that before.  It's like she's oblivious to what she's written about him.  Of course she could have done that just to throw us off to keep us wondering about the character.  Whatever.  She also discusses the sexuality of characters in a kid book where that sort of thing isn't really appropriate and I can only think it was to stir up controversy.  She should have left it up to people's imaginations IMHO.  Maybe I should just shut up now.  ROFL.

Response from MMADfan (Author of A Long Vernal Season)

I wouldn't have minded if there had been a gay couple in the HP series, for example -- and it wouldn't have to be explicitly discussed, just obvious to adults and older kids -- but coming out after the books have been published and saying AD's gay or whatever, that's just a publicity thing, IMO. The books do have people falling in love (e.g., Remus & Tonks), and they have tons of married couples, so it's not as though she was trying to completely avoid adult romantic relationships in general. And having a fixation/adulation for a person of the same sex (particularly for teens) doesn't make a lifetime choice, either. And I think she made Snape a really pathetic character, and it bothered me that it seemed that after over 15 years, Snape's motivation for remaining on the right side was the same -- his betrayal of Lily. It seemed to me that he would still be a DE if he hadn't inadvertantly betrayed her. And yet other things about the character showed a person with hurts that went deeply, and someone who was capable of reflecting on own his actions, too. I could say more on that topic, but . . . I think probably Death's Dominion expresses my preferences on how Snape might have better been treated -- don't ignore the evil he did, or the nasty side to his personality & character, but allow him an opportunity for real redemption, and not just some kind of payback. I also hated his manner of death in DH.Anyway, that's a very scattered response to your point -- better that I should be succinct: I agree with you! LOL!

Response from mimmom (Reviewer)

It's nice to share scattered thoughts.  It's also nice to have someone to talk to about this.  Yeah, it's all fiction but when you fall in love with a book you do invest some emotion in it.  I don't like Hermione with Ron and I don't like that Snape has only his betrayal of Lily as motivation.  I can see how he'd still be extremely remorseful and haunted by what happened and his role in it, but to never find anything else for motivation in all those years, well it's surprising he didn't just kill himself.  I agree about the death.  OMG, stupid stupid stupid.  But, not unlike moldywart to be so ridiculous.  Though he's portrayed as being rather intelligent so why he didn't THINK about the wand problem a bit more carefully is beyond me.  Anyway, this is all why I love your stories so much.  It explores a lot of things about Snape that I want to know.  He's so complicated and yet we never get any sort of satisfying answers in DH.

Response from MMADfan (Author of A Long Vernal Season)

I agree completely, including about the wands & moldy voldy. But I also think that there are inconsistencies in her magical theory -- things that just aren't very well thought-out. I think, for example, that the way the Fidelius works -- and the way it would seem to have to work -- in the first several books and the way she had it "work" in the last one wasn't consistent or even sensible. I basically ignore DH for the magical theory as well as for the events/content. I could go on and on about what I think is flawed about the wand theory, too, but I don't want to bore you! LOL!

Response from mimmom (Reviewer)

I remember feeling like I needed to suspend disbelief more in the last book.  "Hang on a minute, that's not how that's supposed to work."  She seems to forget about the rules she set up so that it doesn't work within it's own logic.Not sure I'd be bored, but I do have a rather limited attention span.  LOL.  Amazing I even managed to get through the books but when I get hyperfocused on something I really like then I last much longer.  Hyperfocused Snape obsession.  LOL.

Response from MMADfan (Author of A Long Vernal Season)

"Hyperfocused Snape obsession."I can appreciate that! :-D

Displaying Review 1051 - 1058 of 1058 in total
← Previous 1 2 … 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 Next →

The Petulant Poetess

A moderated archive, hosting stories by authors who enjoy dabbling in the wonderful world of Harry Potter fanfiction.

More About The Petulant Poetess

© Copyrights. All rights reserved. ThePetulantPoetess.com

Explore

  • All Stories
  • by Author
  • by Category
  • by Character
  • by Genre

Links

  • General Information
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Message Board
  • Writers' Resources
  • Submission Rules