Confessions, Questions and Quandaries
Chapter 2 of 4
Lady WhitehartEven Severus Snape was once pure and innocent and, according to JK Rowling, greatly loved. A look at Snape's early life told from Eileen's POV. No, it's not another abuse/domestic violence fic.
ReviewedDisclaimer and legal stuff:
All things Potterverse do not belong to me.
They belong to J K Rowling, as you can plainly see.
She has a team of lawyers, who work both night and day.
Their only mission in this life is to keep plagiarists at bay.
So I write my disclaimer, to say I mean no harm.
Followed with a smile, as I turn on the charm.
I make not a single Euro or Yen, no Galleon, Sickle or Knut,
Not a dime or dollar, pound or quid, so please don't sue my butt!
A/N: No, poetry isn't one of my gifts, but at least one chapter must contain a poetic disclaimer. Anyway, thank you to Verity, my ever-loyal beta, for making sure this was fit for human eyes.
WARNING: There is a large amount of religious content in this chapter. If you think that you might find such content offensive, feel free to skip to the page break.
Chapter 2: Confessions, Questions and Quandaries
Snow blew around the solitary figure that tramped down the narrow street towards the chapel. Eileen Snape held on tightly to the basket containing her well-bundled son. Once or twice, she slipped the thick woolen mitten off of her hand to touch his face beneath the thin silk veil. His face was comfortably warm, and he turned his head to suck on her finger.
"Hungry again, little man?" she asked. "I'll feed you soon. I just need to stop at the chapel for a moment."
The young woman hurried up the wooden steps into the vestibule of the tiny church. Quietly, she closed the door behind her, slipping the black lace veil from her pocket and covering her hair with it. Making as little noise as possible, she walked to one of the pews near the back, setting her basket on the seat. Wearily Eileen sank to her knees, going over the words of the prayers in her mind.
Each time she went to the chapel, the same questions plagued her. What would she say? What could she say? She could hardly go in and say: "By the way, Father, I'm a witch." Keeping it a secret was wrong; she knew that. However, to bring her abilities out in the open would almost certainly spell disaster. A feeling of helplessness drifted over her. She sighed at her sad situation, hoping and praying that somehow, some way, she would be able to untangle herself from these tendrils of deception.
Off to her right, an old woman coughed. Severus stirred in his basket, making little smacking noises with his lips. Eileen smiled softly and helped him find his thumb. Maybe he would be content with that for a moment or two. No, for his sake she would keep her secret just a little while longer. Severus was dependent on her, and she was not about to let anything happen to him.
A rustle of velvet drape behind her signaled that the confessional was now vacated. Another young matron staggered exhaustedly to the front of the church to pray her penance. Eileen stood up and hefted the little basket. Proper or not, she didn't feel right leaving Severus in the pew all alone. Straightening her veil, she slipped behind the thick drape.
"Bless me, Father..." Eileen began as usual. She continued with the usual litany of human failings, adding a few new ones that had come about through the course of motherhood. The old priest, Father Carrington, listened patiently, offering words of advice and comfort.
Father Carrington gave her a penance and granted her absolution. "I absolve you of your sins: In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit."
She gracefully made the Sign of the Cross. "Thank you, Father."
"One more thing before you go, Eileen."
Eileen whispered in surprise, "How did you know it was me, Father?"
"I recognized your voice, my child." She could almost hear the smile in his warm tone.
Eileen nodded and smiled in return, even though her confessor could not see her.
"You will be having your son baptized this Sunday after Mass? He is over two weeks old now." There was a touch of sternness in the kindly voice.
Eileen frowned. She had known from the day she had discovered that she was pregnant that this would be inevitable. She herself had been raised on the fringe of the Church, attending services only on rare occasions. Many families had, from time to time, intermarried with Muggle-borns, who continued to follow the traditions of whatever faith they had grown up with. Witches and wizards learning to reconcile their abilities with religious upbringing was nothing new, and Eileen was no exception.
When she had married Tobias Snape, she had married his religion as well. Making the transition from someone who attended services mainly at Christmas and Easter to being much more devout had been difficult at first. Her magical abilities had to be kept a secret. Besides, she had then...and still did...sincerely doubt that Tobias would have believed her anyway. As a result, he was blissfully oblivious to the fact that she was a witch, and she was hoping to keep it that way. If he ever found out, she was afraid that he would abandon her. Then she would be forced to return to her father's house with her infant son in tow. A thought she couldn't bear to even consider.
"Eileen?"
"Forgive me, Father, my mind was wandering," she said hurriedly.
"Will you be having him baptized this Sunday?"
"Yes, Father, we will."
"Good, good. And have you selected godparents?"
"Yes, Tobias's oldest sister and her husband will be his godparents. They are very excited about it." Severus began shifting about in his basket, making his presence known at last with tentative whimper. Eileen reached down to comfort her son, helping him find his thumb once again.
Eileen thanked the priest. As she exited the confessional, Severus gave a loud, frustrated wail, making it quite clear that he was truly hungry and not just bored. With a tired sigh, Eileen exited the chapel; she would pray while she fed her son.
Once home, Eileen shook the snow from her coat. She went straight to the kitchen, set the baby's basket gently on the table and began to add wood to the fire in the cook stove. The swaying movement of the basket on the walk home had soothed the baby, and Severus had fallen asleep under his warm blankets. Pulling the old rocking chair closer to the warmth of the fire, the young mother settled down to rest. The baby apparently noticed the changes in his surroundings, and he began stirring once again.
His mother settled him comfortably in the crook of her arm as she nursed him. Once or twice, he paused to look at her with his dark eyes. Unnatural. That was how Tobias had described the baby's intense gaze. Eileen knew better. She smoothed his hair. "You're magic just like me, my wee laddie. I was hoping you wouldn't be, then maybe, just maybe we could live in peace. But never you mind. I love you all the same."
As she rocked her son, she remembered that she had yet to say her penance. The words flowed in time with the rocking of the chair. "Our Father..."
Later that evening, Eileen was awakened by the rattling of the front door. Tobias was home from work. She had fallen asleep in the rocking chair while feeding the baby! She didn't have any dinner made, not even hot water for tea.
"Eileen?" her husband called as he entered the kitchen. The sight of his dirt-smudged face and mussed dark hair caused her to guiltily bite her lip. He looked at her, and a concerned look crossed his face. "Is everything all right?"
"I fell asleep in the chair," she admitted, carefully placing the sleeping baby in his basket. "There isn't a hot meal for you. I'm so sorry. Please don't be angry."
His face clearly showed his disappointment. Eileen waited to see if he would raise his voice in anger, but he refrained from commenting. Instead, he shuffled over to the basket where Severus was sleeping, staring down in wonder at the small being that had intruded on his quiet existence. The baby squirmed for a moment as he settled more comfortably under his blanket. Tobias shook his head. He whispered, "I see you've kept your mam busy today. Just from now on, try not to wear her out until after she has supper on the table."
"Shh... Tobias, you'll wake him," Eileen warned softly, smiling in spite of herself. She was heating water in the kettle for tea. Luckily there was some leftover ham in the cold cupboard, tinned tomatoes, a loaf of bread... She set the table as her husband took his spot. She started to heat the ham on the cook stove before she set about slicing the bread and opening the tin of tomatoes.
When the simple meal was ready, they bowed their heads and gave thanks before tucking in. Eileen had hardly touched her meal when the baby demanded her attention again. At first, she decided to let him fuss to see if he would settle back down on his own. When his demands were not immediately met, he wailed louder, squirming uncomfortably. With a sigh and a quick glance at her husband, Eileen quickly moved to pick him up.
No sooner had she lifted him to her shoulder then he left out huge belch, settling immediately back against her shoulder. Eileen flopped into her chair and tried to eat with one hand.
"Hearty little man, isn't he?" her husband asked as he continued to shovel food into his mouth.
"I've nothing to make a comparison." Eileen shrugged. "I spoke with Father Carrington today; he wanted to make sure we were having Severus baptized this Sunday."
"I spoke with my brother-in-law, he and my sister will be sure to attend this weekend." He frowned deeply. "Will your family be there?"
Eileen's pale face turned even paler. Tobias knew little about her family, save that her father and brother were overbearing. The few times he had met her family, he had understood that they were more than a little 'odd,' and that she really didn't want much to do with them. Her mother, father and two of her four brothers had attended the nuptial Mass and had placed the announcement in the Daily Prophet. They had only been around to the house when she first told them that she was pregnant and then again after she told them that the baby had been born. Other than that, they had-- thankfully -- left her alone. "I suppose I should tell them. Severus is their only grandson and all."
"Mind your brother, William, behaves himself. I would not like to give him a thrashing on the Sabbath," Tobias grumbled between mouthfuls, his fist clenching his fork tightly, "and especially not at my son's Baptism."
Eileen cringed at the memory of when her brother had first met Tobias. The two had hated each other instantly. She knew that her husband was a strong man, but her brother could make Tobias suffer or even kill him with a word or two and a wave of the wand. The last thing she wanted was to lose the first person who had cared about her. She absently patted the baby's bottom, praying that she was strong enough to protect them both--Tobias and Severus, the only two people that mattered to her.
"I'll make sure they mind their manners," she promised, reaching across the table to stroke the back of his long-fingered, rough hand.
Later that night, Eileen fell into bed utterly exhausted. Tobias made a halfhearted overture that Eileen quickly turned down, reminding him that the midwife had told her to wait at least until the baby was six weeks old. She was thankful for that bit of advice, as she was still quite sore and was not up to suffering that just yet. Well, not suffering exactly, she enjoyed his touch, completely and shamefully. He settled for pulling her more closely to him, stroking her hair and kissing her neck.
Just as they were beginning to drift off, the baby began whimpering in the other room. The whimper changed to a pathetic, pleading cry, before switching to a full-fledged howl. Eileen went to fetch him. Her breath hung in the air like a little cloud. When she picked Severus up, she noticed that his little nose, fingers and toes were terribly cold. She very well could have used a Warming Charm on his blankets, but she felt a heart-wrenching need to have him close to her. With a sigh she took him back to the bed.
"What s'matter?" Tobias muttered, half asleep.
"It's too cold. He'll have to sleep with us," she whispered, fumbling with the buttons of her nightgown. The tiny body settled down for a middle of the night feeding.
Tobias rolled over to touch his son with the tips of his fingers, a look of wonder in his sleepy eyes. "Lucky bloke."
Eileen shifted slightly, wincing as the little mouth took a firmer hold on her. Maybe if she kept him in the bed, she would actually be able to get some sleep.
"I love you, Eileen," Tobias said softly.
It wasn't something he normally said, so she opened her eyes wide in surprise. Looking at him as he watched his son, their son, the outward symbol of their love, she felt a rush of warmth that banished the cold of that January night. She reached out to touch his face, whispering, "And I love you, Tobias."
In her heart of hearts, she knew that she had to tell him her secret and hope that the love she saw in his eyes was stronger than any anger he would feel towards her for keeping such a thing from him. For all three of their sakes, she prayed that their love would be enough.
Here's hoping that the Snape household wasn't quite as grim as we have been led to believe. I'm such an optimist. I'm even more of an optimist by thinking I will get reviews.
Story Actions
To follow, favorite, like, and more either log in or create an account.
Leave a Review
Log in to leave a review.
Latest 25 Reviews for Eileen's Hope
29 Reviews | 8.07/10 Average
Not bad! I like this normal parenting plot. What is the main focus/theme here overall?
Not bad! I like this normal parenting plot. What is the main focus/theme here overall?
That was great. A more realistic view of Snape's past than his author would have us believe.
Response from Lady Whitehart (Author of Eileen's Hope)
There had to be some reason Eileen and Tobias got together and stayed together.
Anonymous
She kissed his tiny nose
I just love this little detail, considering how most of us now thing of Sev's nose! I can actually see EPS being the religious sort, too, now that I think about it. :-)
Author's Response: Would you believe someone once corrected me that 'in canon Snape's nose is large and hooked?' I guess that person had never seen a newborn.
Catholics are in the minority, but it's still possible. Thanks for enjoying! ~LW
I could swear I wrote a review on the first chapter, but obviously didn't. I love this story. I am sad to read that it will only be 4 chapters long though. I'll take what I can get . Only 4 chapters?
Response from Lady Whitehart (Author of Eileen's Hope)
If it makes you feel better there will be a sequel about the rise and fall of the Half-Blood Prince... well at least my version of it. I'll be submitting the next chapter very soon. Thanks!
It's not a good thing if she has not shared her heritage with Tobias. That does not bode well for either her or Severus when he finds out. Trust, truth two mainstays in any marriage. He's already angry at her family... This is a very good story. I'm looking forward to the chapters.
Well I have seen *SCANT* few others about Severus' infancy - maybe two or three? But most of them follow the fandom cliche of Tobias being a beast. I prefer your version of it, where Tobias isn't a bad guy, for all that he's working class and undereducated.
I, too, think he was probably unaware that Eileen was a witch, at least at first, and I think this is due to a Ministry edict.
Response from Lady Whitehart (Author of Eileen's Hope)
AbusiveSpouse!Tobias doesn't make much sense when you think about it anyway. Why would she have married him in the first place if he was a total monster? Here's to being working class and still being a decent person.
Thank you for reading and reviewing.
Response from cmwinters (Reviewer)
Well, most abusive guys are really charming and whatever at first, and THEN they turn into jerks after they've got the woman feeling like she's trapped, but yeah.
I come from a long line of working class people, myself!
Well, I can't let an optimist lose her faith in readers, can I? Your Tobias is much nicer than he's usually depicted -- sad that that seems to change. Looking forward to the next installment. Thanks for your work!
Response from Lady Whitehart (Author of Eileen's Hope)
Tobias will soon learn the truth. and... well, you'll see.
Thanks for reviewing and helping me keep the faith!
Whoa. That was especially nice, especially that bit about the history of Severus' name. So Tobias in this story is a Catholic/Christian?Anyway, I'm really glad I saw this story. I've started developing a liking for Eileen Prince stories. Haha. :) I'll definitely look out for this. :)
Response from Lady Whitehart (Author of Eileen's Hope)
On a whim I looked up the name and didn't really think much of the weaver patronage, but it did plant the seed for Snape's father to have been Catholic. Naming your child after a saint was a common practice up until fairly recently in the Catholic Church. Once we found out about Snape's connection to Spinner's End, I decided to run with it.
The fic is 80% complete--only four chapters. I'll submit as quickly as my beta and I can make it presentable. Hope to hear from you soon!
I have to admit, I never thought of what Severus Snape was like as a baby. Makes you feel all protective of the sweet little darling, knowing what happens later, huh? I'm interested to see where this goes. Thanks for your work!
Response from Lady Whitehart (Author of Eileen's Hope)
This is actually a preface to another story I'll be posting. I wrote a Young!Sanpe/Lily story and had a ton of backstory that I didn't want to toss. I hope you will keep reading... and reviewing too. Thanks for reviewing; I really appreciate it.
I like the back-story you have created for Severus. I also enjoy reading your writing, and always feel like I’m there watching these people. I’m also glad that Eileen gave up her magic because of love and not fear or because she was very depressed.
Severus seeing his uncle and thinking he was wearing a dress but learning that is how wizards dress goes with how some of us interpret the scene in DH when Severus first meets Lily. That he had dressed himself as a wizard and not because of his mother did not care.
I always enjoy when authors take something from canon and go against popular interpretation: the idea that the man that Harry saw was Snape’s uncle and not his father.
Great fic. One of my favorites. Thanks for writing this.
Response from Lady Whitehart (Author of Eileen's Hope)
Going against popular canon interpretation (and making it plausible) is much more challenging than going with the obvious. I'm so glad you enjoyed this and made it one of your favorites. My young!Snape fic Meant to Be... Enemies? is a continuation of this. Hope to see you there as well.
Response from tedebear (Reviewer)
I plan on reading it. I might be a bit slower. I tend to read a lot of stuff at the same time.
Response from Lady Whitehart (Author of Eileen's Hope)
Take your time; it will be there. I read several things at the same time too. Too many fic not enough time.
Response from Lady Whitehart (Author of Eileen's Hope)
Going against popular canon interpretation (and making it plausible) is much more challenging than going with the obvious. I'm so glad you enjoyed this and made it one of your favorites. My young!Snape fic Meant to Be... Enemies? is a continuation of this. Hope to see you there as well.
Response from tedebear (Reviewer)
I plan on reading it. I might be a bit slower. I tend to read a lot of stuff at the same time.
Response from Lady Whitehart (Author of Eileen's Hope)
Take your time; it will be there. I read several things at the same time too. Too many fic not enough time.
So many things I like about this story that it goes into my personal canon. Many Eileen and Tobias stories have a weak Eileen and a monster Tobias. This story also connects with a couple of my other favorite stories where there is a Catholic theme.
Response from Lady Whitehart (Author of Eileen's Hope)
One of the things I was determined not to write was yet another domestic abuse story. I wanted to come up with something more creative than drunk abusive Tobias beating his wife. No offense intended towards those who write those stories. The woman was a witch, and IMO, even a relatively underpowered witch armed with PMS and a wand would be able to take on a Muggle man and prevail. If the situation was that bad, why stay?
Response from Lady Whitehart (Author of Eileen's Hope)
One of the things I was determined not to write was yet another domestic abuse story. I wanted to come up with something more creative than drunk abusive Tobias beating his wife. No offense intended towards those who write those stories. The woman was a witch, and IMO, even a relatively underpowered witch armed with PMS and a wand would be able to take on a Muggle man and prevail. If the situation was that bad, why stay?
I’m with you. I like to think there were some good times at the Snape house hold. Great chapter.
Response from Lady Whitehart (Author of Eileen's Hope)
Thanks! I can't imagine why she would marry and stay with a Muggle otherwise.
Response from Lady Whitehart (Author of Eileen's Hope)
Thanks! I can't imagine why she would marry and stay with a Muggle otherwise.
It’s me bemoan. I was remembering this story and wanted to reread it. This was one of the first fan fics I read and one I enjoy dearly. I’ve read many fan fics since then, and some I have forgotten, but not this one. I have come across a few other fics that have Tobias as a Catholic. Also it was discussed on Snapedom that the chances of him being Catholic were pretty good.
Response from Lady Whitehart (Author of Eileen's Hope)
Hey, bemoan! Thank you for wanting to reread (and review!) my story. I remember taking part in those old Catholic!Snape discussions; they were definitely some of the more interesting ones. Thanks for commenting. LW
Response from tedebear (Reviewer)
The topic came up in July, so it might be another discussion.
Response from Lady Whitehart (Author of Eileen's Hope)
There were some going back as far as just prior to the release of OotP. It must be one of those topics that crops up over and over.
Response from Lady Whitehart (Author of Eileen's Hope)
Hey, bemoan! Thank you for wanting to reread (and review!) my story. I remember taking part in those old Catholic!Snape discussions; they were definitely some of the more interesting ones. Thanks for commenting. LW
Response from tedebear (Reviewer)
The topic came up in July, so it might be another discussion.
Response from Lady Whitehart (Author of Eileen's Hope)
There were some going back as far as just prior to the release of OotP. It must be one of those topics that crops up over and over.
While I can appreciate your desire to finish the story before "Deathly Hallows" comes out, the fact remains that after DH, fanfiction will carry on regardless of what happens in the final book.
I don't understand the general reasoning behind writing a storyline before Ms Rowling does just so one can pretend it is 'canon'. When it comes right down to it, anything written in fanfiction is a deviation from what JKR intended. Alternate Universe is a wondrous place to play and it lets the fanfiction author's imaginations free. One does not have to color within the lines to make a beautiful picture.
Your last chapter reads like a story that has a lot more to tell. You've created a brother to Eileen and this whole possibility of story development. By having this brother who is upset at having to borrow his sister's half-blood son to have a Prince heir would indicate to me the potential for Severus having learned advanced magic, the manner/attitude of the pureblood, the possibility to meet other magical children [and not like them!] You shown that being honorable and the intrinsic goodness that I feel that is Severus Snape as coming from Tobius rather than learning to hate from an abusive muggle father is interesting. While the possibility of not being treated well at the hands of the tyrannical uncle, yet learning that duty to family as an important lesson, too. You've started to show that Severus was torn between two worlds right from his childhood and had to learn to balance between them to exist. That maybe he returns to Spinner's End, not because he's too poor to have better, but because it is the home he knew love in. Frankly, I think it's a shame if you are letting Deathly Hallows shorten the life of a good story that could easily continue without being deterred by what is considered to be 'canon'. I feel that way about any author that has quit their stories just because that which they chose to write about, prior to whichever book was published, ended up not being the route that JKR took. But, it is your story and if you feel as if that is all there should be to it, so be it.
I've enjoyed your writting, just wish you would develop your story out more.
Response from Lady Whitehart (Author of Eileen's Hope)
What JKR writes is canon—pure and simple. Getting this finished was more of a deadline I had set for myself for reasons of personal satisfaction. Unfortunately Real Life often impedes my writing goals.
Eileen's Hope was meant to be a short prequel to another story I'm working on callled Meant to Be...Enemies?, which covers Severus's years at Hogwarts. There is an obvious shift in POV, making them two separate stories. In short, the story will continue under another title. MtBE has 6 completed chapters and several chapters in various stages of ready-ish. My beta team has read what I've written so far and told me to post new canon be damned. Depending on how she writes Snape, people may like my story better anyway.May fanfiction enjoy a long and exciting life.
An excellent take on that scene Harry witnessed. It's nice to see Eileen and Tobias struggling together, both wanting the best for little Severus, rather than Tobias cast as the bad guy.
Response from Lady Whitehart (Author of Eileen's Hope)
The fact that Harry so frequently misinterperated things about Snape gives us hope that maybe Snape's life wasn't as bad as Harry thought it was. Besides, it also makes for a nice connection between Harry and Snape. I'll soon be posting a new story that is the continuation of this one. Hope to keep hearing from you.
Good story I always thought there were issues between Severus's parents, but I think it's fandom not cannon impressions.
Response from Lady Whitehart (Author of Eileen's Hope)
Rowling herslef said in an interview that Snape knew love and that made him in some ways worse that Voldemort, who was never loved. Of course, I could be completely wrong, and fandom could be right.
Response from sinbad (Reviewer)
After reading Deathly Hallows (which I found disapointing on a few levels) I suspect the love he found was Lilly's. Parents are stiil up for grabs lol. Will there be more to this story?
Response from Lady Whitehart (Author of Eileen's Hope)
I'm toying with writing an epilogue for this as a way to bridge it into Meant to Be...Enemies, which will tell the story of Snape's seven years at Hogwarts and his involvement with the DE's. It's not going to be very DH compliant, but we will hear from Eileen and Tobias. Thanks for reviewing.
This was a extremely good story and for once a nice Tobias. Thank you
<3 <3 <3 Tobias' premonitions!!!! *swoon*
Response from Lady Whitehart (Author of Eileen's Hope)
I just couldn't resist putting that in there.
Response from cmwinters (Reviewer)
Well I'm VERY glad you *didn't* resist!
I really like that you gave her an out, to have the Ministry come and Obliviate Tobias, and that she chose not to take it. Looking forward to chapter 4.
Eileen really has gotten herself caught between the two worlds, hasn't she? I think you're portraying her very realistically.
This is off to a lovely start. I'm enjoying your portrayal of Eileen and the whole family dynamic Severus was born into.
It's quite intresting getting to knowSeverus's parents. A good job so far
I was expecting Tobias to leave Eileen alone, but I figured yes, he would want to honor his vows. It's the Catholic thing to do. I'm glad you spared us the cliche of him abandoning his family. :)
Great chapter! Keep it up. :)
Response from Lady Whitehart (Author of Eileen's Hope)
Thanks for enjoying what I had hoped to would be a fresh approach to Snape's background. I'm a volunteer at a women's shelter, and I would avoid E/T stories becuase that's what so many of them turned out to be. My solution to not finding many stories about the pairing that didn't resemble the issues I dealt with? Write my own and hope some people like them. And, yes, that was a very Catholic thing to do especially in the late 50's/early 60's.