The Petulant Poetess
  • Stories
  • Browse By
    • Category
    • Character
    • Genre
    • Author
  • Info
      Useful Info
    • General Information
    • Message Board
    • Membership & Story Ratings
    • Submission Rules
    • Important Links
    • Support The Petulant Poetess
    • Writers' Resources
    • Punctuation Guide
    • Writing Fan Fiction
    • Harry Potter Resources
    • Dictionaries
    • Beta Resources
  • Create an Account
    • Create an Account
    • Sign In
Hogwarts Castle Resolving a Misunderstanding
Chapters Menu
Download PDF Version

New Chapter for Resolving a Misunderstanding

Resolving a Misunderstanding

1: I: Minerva’s Grievance

2: II: Minerva’s Mortification

3: III: Albus Reflects

4: IV: More McGonagalls

5: V: Madam Puddifoot’s and a Complicated Situation

6: VI: Spero et Expecto

7: VII: Chez Albus

8: VIII: Minerva’s Project

9: IX: A Father Worried, A Father Reassured

10: X: A Smooth Apparater

11: XI: The Special Project

12: XII: An Unexpected Arrival

13: XIII: Lunch in the Great Hall

14: XIV: To Train a House-Elf

15: XV: A Success

16: XVI: Preparations

17: XVII: Minerva’s Mission

18: XVIII: A Sudden Change of Circumstance

19: XIX: Waiting

20: XX: Hiding

21: XXI: Seeking

22: XXII: Finding

23: XXIII: Escaping

24: XXIV: A Missent Missive

25: XXV: Meeting

26: XXVI: A Lovely Sight to Behold

27: XXVII: Pleasurable Anticipation

28: XXVIII: A Bright Morning

29: XXIX: Breakfast with Albus, Breakfast with Minerva

30: XXX: Speculation and Facing Oneself

31: XXXI: Curiosity Piqued

32: XXXII: The Attacks

33: XXXIII: A Difficult Conversation

34: XXXIV: Professor Gamp’s Suggestion

35: XXXV: Hagrid

36: XXXVI: Dinner and Dessert

37: XXXVII: A Morning Constitutional

38: XXXVIII: Requests

39: XXXIX: A Startling Revelation

40: XL: Horrid Relatives

41: XLI: Down the Garden Path

42: XLII: Dalliance and Deception

43: XLIII: Doubt and Comfort

44: XLIV: An Early Breakfast and an Owl

45: XLV: A Quiet Afternoon at the Gamp Estate

46: XLVI: More Relatives

47: XLVII: Dinner and Divination

48: XLVIII: Lessons in Letter-Writing

49: XLIX: Games at the Gamps

50: L: Curious Conversation

51: LI: The Lovely Couple

52: LII: Shall We Dance?

53: LIII: The End of the Party

54: LIV: Breakfast al Fresco

55: LV: Return to Hogwarts

56: LVI: A Conspiracy of Witches

57: LVII: Hot, Cold, and Tepid

58: LVIII: The Comforts of Home

59: LIX: Mistakes and Misunderstandings

60: LX: The Magic of Memory

61: LXI: An Owl from St. Mungo’s

62: LXII: To Be of Assistance

63: LXIII: Tasseomancy

64: LXIV: Debate and Dissension

65: LXV: Hagrid’s Hut

66: LXVI: Many Meetings

67: LXVII: An Escort in Dark Places

68: LXVIII: A Date for Minerva

69: LXIX: None But the Two

70: LXX: Forever in the Sun

71: LXXI: If This Were a Date . . .

72: LXXII: Not a Date

73: LXXIII: A Tale of Two Wands

74: LXXIV: Ever Green

75: LXXV: Collision

76: LXXVI: A Most Pleasant Disturbance

77: LXXVII: Impulse

78: LXXVIII: Meeting Morag

79: LXXIX: Jeremiah Was a Jarvey

80: LXXX: An Evening in Hogsmeade

81: LXXXI: Disarming Minerva

82: LXXXII: Silly Wizard

83: LXXXIII: Family Time

84: LXXXIV: Mates

85: LXXXV: Plans

86: LXXXVI: A Mother’s Trust

87: LXXXVII: Of Altruism and Magical Accidents

88: LXXXVIII: From Albus, Sincerely

89: LXXXIX: A Perfect Flat

90: XC: A Confidant

91: XCI: Hope, Suspect

92: XCII: Expectations and Arrivals

93: XCIII: Tea Party on the Ceiling

94: XCIV: Poppy and Potions

95: XCV: Home Again

96: XCVI: Not to Be Tolerated

97: XCVII: Happy Birthday, Albus

98: XCVIII: Warding

99: XCIX: Head of Gryffindor

100: C: Touring Hogwarts

101: CI: The Tale of a Young Wizard

102: CII: The Sorrows of a Young Wizard

103: CIII: Defeating Darkness

104: CIV: Gifts

105: CV: A Werewolf's End

106: CVI: Reverberations

107: CVII: Unsolicited Advice

108: CVIII: In Memoriam

109: CIX: Holiday from Hogwarts

110: CX: Seduction

111: CXI: Headmaster’s Holiday

112: CXII: Unexpected Arrivals

113: CXIII: Seeking Counsel

114: CXIV: His Lady’s Servant

115: CXV: Questionable Intentions

116: CXVI: Seeking Solace

117: CXVII: Comfort and Consolation

118: CXVIII: Confronting Albus

119: CXIX: Love Unceasing

120: CXX: The Morning Beyond Never

121: CXXI: The MacAirt Pledge

122: CXXII: Another Date for Minerva

123: CXXIII: Love Beyond Disbelief

124: CXXIV: Courting Minerva

125: CXXV: Rematch

126: CXXVI: Age Cannot Wither

127: CXXVII: An Interesting Idea

128: CXXVIII: Romance Interrupted

129: CXXIX: A Mercurial McGonagall

130: CXXX: The McGonagall Cliffs

131: CXXXI: Realising Love

132: CXXXII: Melina Marries Her Muggle

133: CXXXIII: Abiding Love

134: CXXXIV: Sweet Delight

135: CXXXV: A Spree

136: CXXXVI: Aprés Spree

137: CXXXVII: The Silent Knight’s Tale

138: CXXXVIII: Back to Hogwarts

139: CXXXIX: Lagniappe

140: CXL: Sorted

141: Epilogue: . . . and his stupid beard too!

Resolving a Misunderstanding

MMADfan

954 Reviews   |   954 Ratings, 0 Likes, 108 Favorites )

Humor Drama Romance Alternate Universe Hogwarts Castle 887,445 Words 157 Chapters Complete
Albus Dumbledore Minerva McGonagall Poppy Pomfrey Armando Dippet Rubeus Hagrid Wilhelmina Grubbly-Plank Rufus Scrimgeour Alastor (Mad-Eye) Moody Tom Riddle (Voldemort) Moaning Myrtle Aragog Bellatrix Lestrange Druella (Rosier) Black Bartimus Crouch Filius Flitwick Horace Slughorn Professor Binns Mr. Ollivander Gellert Grindelwald Nicolas Flamel Cornelius Fudge Professor Kettleburn

Minerva has just finished her first term teaching. A series of misunderstandings leads to an embarrassing moment, injured feelings, regret, growing understanding, then resolution. A Minerva McGonagall fic set in 1957, with forays into the past. More than a Romance; stories within stories. Features Minerva, Albus, and Poppy, with appearances by Slughorn, Grubbly-Plank, Hagrid, Flitwick, Moody, Riddle, Grindelwald, and other canon characters. Not DH-compliant. Disregards DH.
Nineteen Parts.
Most content T-rated, but ratings rise to M and MA for several later chapters. Overall M rating reflects later content.
Pertinent warnings in individual chapter summaries.

Voted First Place, Minerva McGonagall: Legacy Fic, in the HP Fanfiction Fan Poll Awards Spring/Summer 2013.

Start Reading

Chapters (141)

Chapter 1: I: Minerva’s Grievance

Chapter 2: II: Minerva’s Mortification

Chapter 3: III: Albus Reflects

Chapter 4: IV: More McGonagalls

Chapter 5: V: Madam Puddifoot’s and a Complicated Situation

Chapter 6: VI: Spero et Expecto

Chapter 7: VII: Chez Albus

Chapter 8: VIII: Minerva’s Project

Chapter 9: IX: A Father Worried, A Father Reassured

Chapter 10: X: A Smooth Apparater

Chapter 11: XI: The Special Project

Chapter 12: XII: An Unexpected Arrival

Chapter 13: XIII: Lunch in the Great Hall

Chapter 14: XIV: To Train a House-Elf

Chapter 15: XV: A Success

Chapter 16: XVI: Preparations

Chapter 17: XVII: Minerva’s Mission

Chapter 18: XVIII: A Sudden Change of Circumstance

Chapter 19: XIX: Waiting

Chapter 20: XX: Hiding

Chapter 21: XXI: Seeking

Chapter 22: XXII: Finding

Chapter 23: XXIII: Escaping

Chapter 24: XXIV: A Missent Missive

Chapter 25: XXV: Meeting

Chapter 26: XXVI: A Lovely Sight to Behold

Chapter 27: XXVII: Pleasurable Anticipation

Chapter 28: XXVIII: A Bright Morning

Chapter 29: XXIX: Breakfast with Albus, Breakfast with Minerva

Chapter 30: XXX: Speculation and Facing Oneself

Chapter 31: XXXI: Curiosity Piqued

Chapter 32: XXXII: The Attacks

Chapter 33: XXXIII: A Difficult Conversation

Chapter 34: XXXIV: Professor Gamp’s Suggestion

Chapter 35: XXXV: Hagrid

Chapter 36: XXXVI: Dinner and Dessert

Chapter 37: XXXVII: A Morning Constitutional

Chapter 38: XXXVIII: Requests

Chapter 39: XXXIX: A Startling Revelation

Chapter 40: XL: Horrid Relatives

Chapter 41: XLI: Down the Garden Path

Chapter 42: XLII: Dalliance and Deception

Chapter 43: XLIII: Doubt and Comfort

Chapter 44: XLIV: An Early Breakfast and an Owl

Chapter 45: XLV: A Quiet Afternoon at the Gamp Estate

Chapter 46: XLVI: More Relatives

Chapter 47: XLVII: Dinner and Divination

Chapter 48: XLVIII: Lessons in Letter-Writing

Chapter 49: XLIX: Games at the Gamps

Chapter 50: L: Curious Conversation

Chapter 51: LI: The Lovely Couple

Chapter 52: LII: Shall We Dance?

Chapter 53: LIII: The End of the Party

Chapter 54: LIV: Breakfast al Fresco

Chapter 55: LV: Return to Hogwarts

Chapter 56: LVI: A Conspiracy of Witches

Chapter 57: LVII: Hot, Cold, and Tepid

Chapter 58: LVIII: The Comforts of Home

Chapter 59: LIX: Mistakes and Misunderstandings

Chapter 60: LX: The Magic of Memory

Chapter 61: LXI: An Owl from St. Mungo’s

Chapter 62: LXII: To Be of Assistance

Chapter 63: LXIII: Tasseomancy

Chapter 64: LXIV: Debate and Dissension

Chapter 65: LXV: Hagrid’s Hut

Chapter 66: LXVI: Many Meetings

Chapter 67: LXVII: An Escort in Dark Places

Chapter 68: LXVIII: A Date for Minerva

Chapter 69: LXIX: None But the Two

Chapter 70: LXX: Forever in the Sun

Chapter 71: LXXI: If This Were a Date . . .

Chapter 72: LXXII: Not a Date

Chapter 73: LXXIII: A Tale of Two Wands

Chapter 74: LXXIV: Ever Green

Chapter 75: LXXV: Collision

Chapter 76: LXXVI: A Most Pleasant Disturbance

Chapter 77: LXXVII: Impulse

Chapter 78: LXXVIII: Meeting Morag

Chapter 79: LXXIX: Jeremiah Was a Jarvey

Chapter 80: LXXX: An Evening in Hogsmeade

Chapter 81: LXXXI: Disarming Minerva

Chapter 82: LXXXII: Silly Wizard

Chapter 83: LXXXIII: Family Time

Chapter 84: LXXXIV: Mates

Chapter 85: LXXXV: Plans

Chapter 86: LXXXVI: A Mother’s Trust

Chapter 87: LXXXVII: Of Altruism and Magical Accidents

Chapter 88: LXXXVIII: From Albus, Sincerely

Chapter 89: LXXXIX: A Perfect Flat

Chapter 90: XC: A Confidant

Chapter 91: XCI: Hope, Suspect

Chapter 92: XCII: Expectations and Arrivals

Chapter 93: XCIII: Tea Party on the Ceiling

Chapter 94: XCIV: Poppy and Potions

Chapter 95: XCV: Home Again

Chapter 96: XCVI: Not to Be Tolerated

Chapter 97: XCVII: Happy Birthday, Albus

Chapter 98: XCVIII: Warding

Chapter 99: XCIX: Head of Gryffindor

Chapter 100: C: Touring Hogwarts

Chapter 101: CI: The Tale of a Young Wizard

Chapter 102: CII: The Sorrows of a Young Wizard

Chapter 103: CIII: Defeating Darkness

Chapter 104: CIV: Gifts

Chapter 105: CV: A Werewolf's End

Chapter 106: CVI: Reverberations

Chapter 107: CVII: Unsolicited Advice

Chapter 108: CVIII: In Memoriam

Chapter 109: CIX: Holiday from Hogwarts

Chapter 110: CX: Seduction

Chapter 111: CXI: Headmaster’s Holiday

Chapter 112: CXII: Unexpected Arrivals

Chapter 113: CXIII: Seeking Counsel

Chapter 114: CXIV: His Lady’s Servant

Chapter 115: CXV: Questionable Intentions

Chapter 116: CXVI: Seeking Solace

Chapter 117: CXVII: Comfort and Consolation

Chapter 118: CXVIII: Confronting Albus

Chapter 119: CXIX: Love Unceasing

Chapter 120: CXX: The Morning Beyond Never

Chapter 121: CXXI: The MacAirt Pledge

Chapter 122: CXXII: Another Date for Minerva

Chapter 123: CXXIII: Love Beyond Disbelief

Chapter 124: CXXIV: Courting Minerva

Chapter 125: CXXV: Rematch

Chapter 126: CXXVI: Age Cannot Wither

Chapter 127: CXXVII: An Interesting Idea

Chapter 128: CXXVIII: Romance Interrupted

Chapter 129: CXXIX: A Mercurial McGonagall

Chapter 130: CXXX: The McGonagall Cliffs

Chapter 131: CXXXI: Realising Love

Chapter 132: CXXXII: Melina Marries Her Muggle

Chapter 133: CXXXIII: Abiding Love

Chapter 134: CXXXIV: Sweet Delight

Chapter 135: CXXXV: A Spree

Chapter 136: CXXXVI: Aprés Spree

Chapter 137: CXXXVII: The Silent Knight’s Tale

Chapter 138: CXXXVIII: Back to Hogwarts

Chapter 139: CXXXIX: Lagniappe

Chapter 140: CXL: Sorted

Chapter 141: Epilogue: . . . and his stupid beard too!


About MMADfan

Validated
Author

MMADfan

41 Stories  |  Favorited by 312  |  127 Reviews Written  |  4,741 Review Responses

Note 10 December 2015: I've been unable to write fanfic the last couple years, but I haven't abandoned my works-in-progress!

Many of my completed fics are available for download in ebook format through my blog and LJ.

Perfect Imagination accredited beta. PI:7311261659.

More about me here.

Author Website
http://mmadfan.com/
Also Archived At
<a href="http://archiveofourown.org/users/MMADfan/works" target="_blank">An Archive of Our Own</a>; <a href="http://mmadfan.com/read-fanfic/" target="_blank">MMADfan's Fanfic Hub</a>; and <a href = "http://www.fanfiction.net/u/1216581/" target = "_blank">FanFiction.net</a>. Some older fics also on the Sycophant Hex archives.

Reviews for Resolving a Misunderstanding

Displaying Review 451 - 475 of 954 in total
← Previous 1 2 … 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 … 38 39 Next →
10/10

Hypnobarb

Aaargh!  We know what they're doing wrong.  At least Minerva is thinking about what Quin said to her.  She's rather like a moth to a flame.  She can't stay away from Albus and refrain from letting affection slip through.  As it is, she is trying too hard to be someone different than she truly is.Besides, Albus probably would have slept better with her next to him anyway.  After a bit of, erm, exertion? 

Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)

Yes, some, um, exertion would have helped them both sleep quite well! But . . .

We'll see Albus's point-of-view soon. And it evolves some, too.

Thanks for reviewing!

10/10

alina612

Poor Minerva! If she keeps going at this rate, IT won't be a secret for much longer. I hope one of the slips up somehow! I am really enjoying this story still! Can't wait for the next chapter.

Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)

I'm very glad that you're still enjoying the story! It is very encouraging to hear.

There are a few bumps before the big slip -- and don't forget that when one slips, one usually falls, and falls often hurt . . .

However, there are lots of nice, warm, and even fluffy moments between now and then, and I do believe in happy endings, so the fall will not be fatal!

The next chapter will be up in a day or two.

Thanks for reviewing! I really appreciate it!

10/10

Hypnobarb

Oh my stars and garters!  This is the first time I've read anything of the sort featuring Hagrid.  I'm glad he's had the opportunity to know that he is loveable.Talk about being the fly on the wall.  Poor Minerva!You certainly have some interesting stuff rolling around in your head.

Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)

Yes, well, rolling around and waiting for me to get rid of it somehow -- so I write it down for you folks! Aren't you lucky! LOL! I've known what Hagrid's "problem" was since the beginning (hee!), but wasn't entirely sure how I was going to present it -- then it came to me when I wrote the previous Wilhelmina/Hagrid scene exactly how to do it. I think it worked in a way it wouldn't have if done from a different p.o.v. For me, anyway.

Glad you liked it! Hope it doesn't give you nightmares, though. *grin*

Thanks for reviewing! 

10/10

Hypnobarb

Well, Albus isn't going to win any popularity awards with the Hogwarts Caretaker's union.  No shackles, iron maidens, branding irons or other fun stuff.  On top of that, a werewolf on the staff.  What other notions might that man have in his head?

Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)

Silly wizard, wanting to do away with proper discipline! What's the world coming to! *grin* Of course, Pringle will have a right little acolyte in Filch, so I don't know if Albus's idea of getting him an assistant will do what he hope it will. . . .

Thanks for reviewing!

9/10

Fallen_Angel_Mione

Poor Hagrid and his broken heart. At least it's another cue for Minnie, with Hagrid being sad because he didn't know if his Meena-bird loved him or not, that she should tell Albus and let him decide.

Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)

Well, it may take a while for all the various hints to sink in for Minerva. The next chapter is called "Many Meetings," and Minerva meets with Wilhelmina, among others, and discusses the older witch's relationship with Hagrid. Rather an awkward conversation!

9/10

Fallen_Angel_Mione

Good to know DH!Albus won't be making an appearance: he's very different from RaM!Albus after all.

Hehe, awkward staff meeting and afters. Is Dustern part Seer? "Soon he'll be hiring...a centaur for Divination" Lol.

Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)

Naw, Dustern's not a Seer, that's just The Author's Weird Sense of Humor!

Actually, there are some parallels between DH!Albus and RaM!Albus, but I'm ignoring DH and just going by my timeline and outline. Essentially, I'm putting it out of my mind entirely. Besides, as I've said elsewhere, I've grown rather fond of this story and the characters as they're developing, so I don't really want to try to twist it around and force it into a mould that it wasn't intended for. I'm just glad that my Muse didn't flee into the wild blue yonder never to be seen again!

Thanks very much for reviewing! 

10/10

Fallen_Angel_Mione

The Hogwarts teachers sure are an interesting bunch!

Hopefully Minnie see more points that prove Quin's prophecy before it's too late.

Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)

I'm glad you enjoyed the chapter. And aren't they just! As for Minerva . . . you'll have to wait and see, but you may like to know that I'm a big fan of happy endings! Thanks for reviewing.

10/10

HermioneDancr

Well, here's an interesting chapter!  I love looking at the relationships between all the characters indivudual, but the politics of the group dynamic are fascinating.  Great job capturing them!

Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)

Thanks! I'm glad you enjoyed it. It's a peculiar group to have working together, too.

10/10

Hypnobarb

Minerva finally blurted when she called Albus "dearest"!  Perhaps at some future time, Albus will remember?  She kissed him, even if it was on the cheek.With the restrained way these two act around each other, that's the equivalent of slamming him against the wall with intentions of having her wicked way with him.Now, if Albus will just take off the blinders we could have some very happy moments, soon.Good luck to us all with Deathly Hallows and have a good trip.

Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)

"With the restrained way these two act around each other, that's the equivalent of slamming him against the wall with intentions of having her wicked way with him."

LOL! I love it! You're so right!

I'm crossing my fingers about Deathly Hallows! One thing's for sure, I won't be starting my trip back home until after I've finished the very last sentence!!! I can't imagine having the book half read sitting in my car -- it would be screaming out at me to read it! *grin*

There's always AU! Have a good week! 

10/10

Hypnobarb

What torment!  Minerva almost blurted.  I wonder what Albus was thinking, beyond the looks he couldn't quite keep off his face.Perhaps the castle could cooperate and lock them in a room together overnight?And what's upsetting Hagrid?

Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)

Yes, Minerva will almost blurt a few times until she finally does blurt! Albus . . . poor fellow was thinking how beautiful/wonderful/lovable Minerva is and how he'll never be able to be any closer to her.

And you will all soon learn what's up with Hagrid! Very soon!

Thank you for reviewing! :D 

10/10

Hypnobarb

Since JKR hasn't really told us much of anything about Minerva and Albus personal lives, your version might not be AU.  Who cares if it is anyway?  She can make the money as long as we get to hijack the characters.It's clear that Minerva's parents understand what is going on and are willing to facilitate.  Good!

Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)

That's right! I agree! There's no way we are diverting any profit away from her! How many gazillions does she have now? LOL!

Yep, now that Albus showed up at their doorstep with his flimsy excuse to see their daughter, they think he might feel the same as she . . . and they certainly aren't unhappy about it!

Thanks for the review! 

10/10

Hypnobarb

So this is where Albus' willingness to allow Remus Lupin into Hogwarts began.  I look forward to seeing how you have him handle this humanitarian issue and Minerva's response.

Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)

Yes -- and it helped him learn to deal with the issue differently, as well. Well, you'll see the various effects this may have on Albus (and on Minerva, of course). Thanks for the review!

9/10

Fallen_Angel_Mione

Ooh, a mini break-through! Good chapter. Have fun on your vacay!

Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)

Thanks very much! I need a bit of a holiday! Thank you for the review -- glad you liked the chapter!

0/10

meaculpa909

Delightful! Valerianna made a fool of herself and Minerva kept her cool. I'll be waiting (sort of) patiently for the next chapter.

Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)

Glad you liked it! The chapters will come fairly quickly for the next week or two, after which I'll likely be updating once a week or so.

Thanks for the review!

10/10

hermione278

oooh, yay!  Pick on Valerianna time xDI really liked this chapter =DOh, and I figured out where “‘Almost entirely’ is not entirely, though, Gertrude,” Minerva replied somewhat sternly. is from!It was Keira Knightly who said it, but it was in the 2005 version of Pride & Prejudice.  She was talking to Mr. Darcy and his sister about her character (Elizabeth Bennet)'s piano playing.  The conversation was something like this:Elizabeth Bennet: "Your unfortunate brother once had to put up with my playing for a whole evening."Georgianna Darcy: "Why he said you played very well."Elizabeth Bennet: "Well he is mistaken."Fitzwilliam Darcy: "No, I said you played quite well."Elizabeth Bennet: "Quite well is not very well; I am satisfied."It was something like that *shrugs*  and it was similar to what you had it your story.  I was sitting on the train, on my way home after seeing the third Pirates of the Caribbean movie again, and suddenly a bulb went off in my head EUREKA! It's from Pride & Prejudice!  hehe, I knew Keira Knightly said it :P

Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)

Thanks! Glad you liked the chapter.

Now that you've heard that phrase once, you'll likely hear many variations on it now for the rest of your life! Like those annoying jingles that don't leave you! haha! It's a classic kinda line to use, particularly when someone is being censorious and maybe a bit overly prudish and hypercritical about something. It sounds like an original Pride and Prejudice kind of line -- very Jane Austen-y. I should re-read Pride and Prejudice -- it's been at least 30 years since I last read it. It's a great read for a teenager, I think. I wonder if I would still like it . . . . I have to pick up Anthony Trollope again, too -- talk about funny! His characters are a riot! Glad you remembered the scene it reminded you of -- I hate that -- it's like having the name of a person or a song on the tip of your tongue and you just can't remember it. It's always such a relief when you finally do!

But I digress rather widely from the topic! -- Thank you for your review! I am very glad you are still enjoying the story. There will be another chapter up later today, I believe. 

10/10

HermioneDancr

Oooh, it continues!  I really liked the character exposition with Minerva offering transfiguration tutoring to her fellow students without ever mentioning it to Albus.  I can't wait for the ball and to see what Valerianna is planning!  And... it's ocurred to me that Mmad alliterates with Mmore.  *cough*

Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)

Hey, there! Thank you for your review! Glad you liked that detail. There should be another chapter up today or tomorrow.

10/10

Fallen_Angel_Mione

Minnie doesn't really have a sneaky, suspicious and subtle portion to her mind, does she? Because she can't seem to think through Valerianna's scheme, or why the warnings matter. Of course, knowing a bit more about polite society might help her in unravelling the plot and feeling more grateful for her friends' concern. Delciously sneaky chapter.

Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)

She does have a sneaky, suspicious portion of her mind, I think, she's just engaging it in the wrong way and focussing on the wrong things. She is somewhat distracted by her own preconceptions, unfortunately. However, it gives us a story!

I'm glad you like the chapter. There will be another one up later today or tomorrow!

Thank you for your review! 

0/10

meaculpa909

The big five-oh!  I'm highly impressed with your vast knowledge of Roman numerals. Anyway, great chapter and I'm looking forward to the next one!

Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)

LOL! I hope that's not the most impressive thing about my writing! There are really only a handful of Roman numerals, too, fewer thatn the ten we have (i.,e., 0 - 9); you just have to combine them. (M, C, L, X, V, and I.) There will be another chapter up this weekend.

10/10

Hypnobarb

What a lovely reminisce of the scene in Gertie's classroom.  Gertie seems to have a better sense of what is going on between Albus and Minerva than the two of them do.Valeriana....Livia.....Same difference?

Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)

Those old Roman aristocrats certainly harbored a lot of nasty women among them, didn't they?

However, when I came up with the name "Valerianna," I was thinking more of valerian root -- you want to hold your nose when you're around it, and Valerianna inspires the same reaction in some of those unlucky enough to know her!

Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)

I suddenly realized that you were likely referring to Sian Phillips' portrayal of Livia in "I, Claudius" -- that was so long ago! I remember being hooked on it when I was a teenager and it first aired on PBS -- and my mention somewhere that I see Valerianna as looking somewhat like Sian Phillips. She was beautiful . . . still is, I think.

Response from Hypnobarb (Reviewer)

Hi, MMADfanYou had mentioned Sian Phillips as an inspiration for Valerianna in an earlier review response when I mentioned thinking of Bette Davis in the role.  Both women could do her well.  Sian Phillips has played some really exotic manipulator roles - Livia in I, Claudius and and the Bene Geserit Reverend Mother Helen Somethingorother in Dune.She did bald really well in Dune.  Maybe somebody she offends could snatch her head bald in Resolving a Misunderstanding?  Just a suggestion.  Have a good weekend!Barb

Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)

LOL! I love your suggestion! She did look surprisingly good in Dune, didn't she? (Was that a slow-moving movie, or what?)

She's been in some recent TV stuff, too, I think, though blessed if I can remember any of them. I think she was recently in one of those Midsommer Murders episodes, or maybe it was some other mystery.

But snatching her head bald -- that still has me chuckling!

10/10

Hypnobarb

Quidditch sounds like a game for the young.Period.Minerva/Albus romance takes another half step backwards.  Aaargh!

Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)

Like hocky and rugby, but you still see uber-competitive middle-aged people out there bloodying themselves up like weekend warriors! But I think maybe Gertie won't be playing any more Quidditch!

Thanks for the review!

Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)

I mean "hockey," of course!

10/10

Hypnobarb

Now, we have the two steps back.  Albus is being all honorable and Minerva is having second thoughts.  They are both being so darn cerebral when one of them just needs to blurt it out.Dang.

Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)

Yes, it's a two-steps-forward-one-back kind of dance they're doing, but eventually, they'll run right into each other! Thanks for the review!

10/10

Hypnobarb

Quin is pretty good at giving readings.  Now, there's a man who uses his skills in divination in a practical way.  He applies it to business, uses it to get to know people better....He took the news of Minerva's heart having a prior commitment pretty calmly.  Part of me wonders if he's thinking he could be the one to help her get over it?Minerva's letter could be a "one step forward" in her relationship with Albus.  Give the man a little prodding and he might just take the next move.

Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)

Quin and Minerva have known each other a very short time, but they are fast becoming friends. Quin will continue to play a role in the story. And Minerva's letter was rather revealing, at least to those who aren't willfully blind!

Thanks for the review! 

9/10

Fallen_Angel_Mione

Interesting similarities between Minnie and Gertie: stubborn, loyal, nit-picky and subtly caring. Good chapter.

Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)

Thanks!

9/10

Fallen_Angel_Mione

Haha. I guessed right about the elf mailing the lettter. Seems liks Albus needs help in letter interpretation. Trying to get Quin and Minnie set up indeed! She and Albus were both up and drinking tea at the same time, for goodness sake. They definitely need more unpolite interference from friends to open their eyes. Good work!

Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)

They'll get some more hints and nudges, but it will take a while yet, and various other events will intervene. Thanks for reviewing!

10/10

Fallen_Angel_Mione

Ooh, natural divination is a handy thing. If only Minnie would listen to everyone's good advice. I hope a house-elf comes and mails her letter while she sleeps. Excellent chapter.

Response from MMADfan (Author of Resolving a Misunderstanding)

Thank you! Glad you enjoyed it.

Displaying Review 451 - 475 of 954 in total
← Previous 1 2 … 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 … 38 39 Next →

The Petulant Poetess

A moderated archive, hosting stories by authors who enjoy dabbling in the wonderful world of Harry Potter fanfiction.

More About The Petulant Poetess

© Copyrights. All rights reserved. ThePetulantPoetess.com

Explore

  • All Stories
  • by Author
  • by Category
  • by Character
  • by Genre

Links

  • General Information
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Message Board
  • Writers' Resources
  • Submission Rules